News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by Arizhel on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @02:23PM (#13474584)
>You forgot about protecting minorities. What do you do when the majority of the people in a jurisdiction like (eg.) Mississippi consistently vote down land use by black people? Just accept that the people have spoken and that black people are unwelcome in that jurisdiction?

Well, yes. That's how democracy works: there's a vote and the majority wins. Are you opposed to democracy?

Yeah, it sucks if you're a minority, but what can you do? This is a fundamental flaw in democracy. We attempt to mitigate it by having constitutions and laws and representatives who are voted on in multi-year cycles, which in engineering terms has the effect of creating a long feedback loop so that the populace's short term emotions don't create too much instability and chaos, but it only works to a point.

The alternative is a non-democratic system like what they do in China. And they don't seem to be too keen on protecting the rights of minorities either.

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by RUG3Y on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:31PM (#13475181)
The alternative is a republic, which is supposed to protect the inalienable rights of the minority from the whims of the majority.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by Arizhel on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:55PM (#13475361)
Are you one of those people who thinks a modern democratic republic somehow isn't democratic? Did you miss my whole line about constitutions and laws? Those are fundamentals of a modern democratic republic. Why is it that every time someone mentions a democracy, someone like you pops up and claims that a modern democracy isn't a democracy?

Read this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_republic

Line 1: "A democratic republic is both a republic and a democracy."

Furthermore, not all republics are democratic. North Korea and China are both republics, as is Iran. I already mentioned China in my previous post. Do you really think North Korea protects anyone's inalienable rights? Or Iran?

Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by RUG3Y on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:01PM (#13475402)
Maybe if someone always pops up to correct your vision of democracy, you're not communicating very well.
[dead]
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by sctb on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @06:41PM (#13476908)
Please no personal attacks like this on Hacker News.
Re:Hawaiians call Mark Zuckerberg 'the face of neocolonialis... by madgar on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @04:57PM (#13476007)
Your first comment in this thread - in which you mention representatives in passing - suggests that you assume all "democracy" to come in the form of democratic republics. This might be true in a discussion of practical implementations of a scalable democratic governing system.

The thread you responded to, however, was about a theoretical directly democratic system of managing land use rights, without any grounding in a realized system with elements of republicanism. The disconnect between the discussion at hand and the assumptions you brought to it (IMHO) caused the confusion between yourself and Arizhel.

A more constructive comment from yourself might have instead politely pointed out that the scenario I described is a classic "tyranny of the majority" issue, a well understood failure mode of direct democracy that is indeed typically resolved practically through the features of republicanism you listed.