Think about it this way: I come across an article on XYZ site. I determine (or guess) that XYZ's agenda is generally conservative, and I consider myself a liberal. What do I do with that assessment? Do I stop reading and move on? Do I preemptively and summarily discount anything the article has to say? Or do I continue to read, perhaps skeptically, but nevertheless with an open mind?
I'd like to think we're doing the latter. But I'm not convinced.
My point is, it's totally fine to consider the source when making assessments of an article. It's totally fine to consider the source's agenda. But if seeking out the agenda becomes a routine, primary step in the process of consuming news, that worries me. That's essentially just seeking out confirmation of one's own biases as a reader.
Accurately reporting current events is an agenda.
So for a meaningful criticism, you need to point out how their agenda is pernicious or contrary to their stated purpose, not just complain that they have it.
The real problem today is most media today (and I don't include ProPublica in this) isn't even objective anymore. They're just biased, and engage in biased activism, with little objectivity and facts in its way.
Glenn Greenwald did an interview on this issue recently, which I think is worth watching for his perspective on this. Some may see Greenwald as "biased", but I think he's not only less biased than most "journalists" or pro-establishment figureheads on TV, but that more journalists should strive to be like him:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_balance
I found the media bias article on Wikipedia to be a good primer on types of bias to keep in mind while reading.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_bias#Types
It's also been useful in identifying which types of bias people refer to when they're talking about bias. I know I personally didn't have a system in place to categorize these things, and generally thought of only a few of them at a time.
'Balance' is often used as a cover for an agenda.
If you strongly disagree with someone and care to correct them you should actually UPVOTE them. This way the public gets to learn the correct way/thinking/method. If you bury them many who may have the same wrong notion may not get the chance to be enlightened.
Hardly tired- biases and agendas caused the deep political divide in the U.S. and Brexit in England. While it's not news to those in the know, it's certainly not something we should hide or stop talking about.
Here's a study for you:
http://siepr.stanford.edu/highlights/sticking-script-rise-bi...
Why not? You say they did something wrong, but then do not cite to what it was other than saying it involved "trial lawyers and an industry group". Why not provide a link to go along with your opinion and let people read it and decide if they agree with you or not rather than insinuating impropriety?
I'd argue that funding ProPublica and then funding an outfit who takes a contrary position on whatever issue is important to you is a better solution though. We need more journalism not less.
Says who? Not the creator of this site, at least: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171
(Note: I personally don't downvote when I disagree, but I don't think there's an official position by the site)
Even without the cesspool of comments, I won't read Breitbart because the editorial quality is non-existant. Same goes for crapy left-wing blogs like RawStory.
It makes me pretty upset, because that is the study/article that everyone references when discussing that issue.
Sometimes they get involved in issues which seems like it would increase undesirable litigation. (of course people have differing opinions of what is undesirable).
But going further, sometimes laws are setup by congress which essentially 'outsources' enforcement to private parties. You can hold a good or bad opinion of the practice, or specific laws which are enacted, but in those areas, cases going to litigation can be the only way that the law is ever enforced.
On a different matter involving trial lawyers and an industry group, they reported a "scandal" where there was none. I am familiar with that issue (so I have my own biases!). It was my opinion that they were repeating the trial lawyer's argument and calling that an investigative journalism piece. Others may disagree with my assessment. I do not want to link to that story here.
This is one reason why I choose not to financially support ProPublica.
EDIT: I'm getting sick of the downvotes on Hacker News. This is not reddit where a downvote == disagree. Just don't upvote it. It's frustrating to take a few minutes to write a comment and then watch it get nuked because it's "controversial". But please feel free to downvote away because my off-topic rant.