News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by conistonwater on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @02:35PM (#12970609)
I downvoted you because you are repeating the tired old trope about implicit biases and agendas. It's as if once we think we've identified someone's agenda, we can tell whether they're telling the truth. But this is false: the proper way is to assess the quality of reporting first, and if it is low-quality, then we can ask questions about how shoddy work got through, and then the answer might be biases and agendas. If it's good reporting, then biases and agendas are irrelevant. But in any case objective quality always comes first.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by bbctol on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @03:06PM (#12970955)
Is that really true? Good, quality reporting doesn't necessarily make biases irrelevant. If (hypothetically) it's true that both candidates in an election are corrupt, though one is more corrupt and dangerous than the other, a story that carefully exposes and discredits the less-corrupt one may be objective reporting on its own, but still serve a biased agenda.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by jonnathanson on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @03:50PM (#12971355)
I think we need to ask ourselves: when we seek out the news source's agenda first, what are we really trying to accomplish? Are we trying to think critically about what we're about to read? Or are we applying a quick heuristic filter to decide whether to read at all?

Think about it this way: I come across an article on XYZ site. I determine (or guess) that XYZ's agenda is generally conservative, and I consider myself a liberal. What do I do with that assessment? Do I stop reading and move on? Do I preemptively and summarily discount anything the article has to say? Or do I continue to read, perhaps skeptically, but nevertheless with an open mind?

I'd like to think we're doing the latter. But I'm not convinced.

My point is, it's totally fine to consider the source when making assessments of an article. It's totally fine to consider the source's agenda. But if seeking out the agenda becomes a routine, primary step in the process of consuming news, that worries me. That's essentially just seeking out confirmation of one's own biases as a reader.

Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by bbctol on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @04:42PM (#12971851)
That's fair. I think a lot of this depends on the precise definitions of words like "objective" or "biased." The 'best' strategy would be to always read everything incredibly critically and carefully, but we all need to use some cognitive shortcuts to actually get our news, and I think which shortcuts we choose have deep impacts on our perception of the world.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by ori_b on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:37PM (#12974320)
Yes, and the person you are replying to is suggesting 'consistently high quality' is a far better heuristic than trying to root out the bias.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by dpc59 on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @02:37PM (#12970632)
You can have objective high quality reporting and still be pushing an agenda. It will show in what you choose to report and what issues you just don't talk about.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by maxerickson on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @03:32PM (#12971197)
It's literally impossible not to have an agenda.

Accurately reporting current events is an agenda.

So for a meaningful criticism, you need to point out how their agenda is pernicious or contrary to their stated purpose, not just complain that they have it.

Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by mtgx on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @03:24PM (#12971105)
The alternative is neutrality, as in the old "we have to give 50-50 time to both sides". So 50% to climate change activists and 50% to climate change deniers, and so on. Is that really better than objective bias? I would think it's not. NYTimes also (publicly) gave up on neutrality in 2012, I believe.

The real problem today is most media today (and I don't include ProPublica in this) isn't even objective anymore. They're just biased, and engage in biased activism, with little objectivity and facts in its way.

Glenn Greenwald did an interview on this issue recently, which I think is worth watching for his perspective on this. Some may see Greenwald as "biased", but I think he's not only less biased than most "journalists" or pro-establishment figureheads on TV, but that more journalists should strive to be like him:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WTC-GvWRlQ8

Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by grzm on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @04:25PM (#12971705)
The 50/50 method is often referred to as "false balance".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_balance

I found the media bias article on Wikipedia to be a good primer on types of bias to keep in mind while reading.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_bias#Types

It's also been useful in identifying which types of bias people refer to when they're talking about bias. I know I personally didn't have a system in place to categorize these things, and generally thought of only a few of them at a time.

Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by rhizome on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @03:17PM (#12971058)
Does "objective" here apply to the reporting or to the assessment that it's high quality?
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by conistonwater on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @02:38PM (#12970653)
In that case, I'd say choosing what to report is itself part of reporting, and if the choices are poor, that's low-quality reporting. So I don't really see an issue.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by athenot on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @02:42PM (#12970687)
Well, there are ways to convey the uncertainty. When there is only one side of a litigious story available, an article should underscore that fact.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by Retric on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @03:46PM (#12971328)
Often one side is objectively wrong, as such you don't always need to cover both sides.

'Balance' is often used as a cover for an agenda.

Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by rokhayakebe on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @04:39PM (#12971824)
I downvoted you because you

If you strongly disagree with someone and care to correct them you should actually UPVOTE them. This way the public gets to learn the correct way/thinking/method. If you bury them many who may have the same wrong notion may not get the chance to be enlightened.

Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by jdormit on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @07:16PM (#12972956)
Your reply lead to a much more productive discussion than your downvote.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by rayiner on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @06:50PM (#12972799)
But "the tired old trope about implicit biases and agendas" the whole content of the Pro Publica piece here? Take away all the facts just there to support that angle, and what's left?
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by maxerickson on Thursday November 17, 2016 @12:35AM (#12974656)
Can you expand or rephrase? I don't follow what you are saying but would like to understand what you are getting at.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by rayiner on Thursday November 17, 2016 @09:10AM (#12977537)
The whole article is about implying pro-merger biases and agendas on the part of the economists on the basis of who they work for and how much they get paid.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by kleigenfreude on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @08:07PM (#12973251)
> I downvoted you because you are repeating the tired old trope about implicit biases and agendas.

Hardly tired- biases and agendas caused the deep political divide in the U.S. and Brexit in England. While it's not news to those in the know, it's certainly not something we should hide or stop talking about.

Here's a study for you:

http://siepr.stanford.edu/highlights/sticking-script-rise-bi...

http://web.stanford.edu/~gentzkow/research/politext.pdf

Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by Chris2048 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:43AM (#12976217)
Political actors are supposed to have an agenda aren't they?
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by kleigenfreude on Thursday November 17, 2016 @09:40PM (#12983887)
My point was that these biases and agendas have more and more driven a wedge, dividing the people of the U.S., Britain, and others.
Re:Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Pedd... by Chris2048 on Friday November 18, 2016 @07:12AM (#12986183)
I'm not sure about this: I think the people were already divided, and this is now being being exploited politically.