News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by ihsw on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:01AM (#12968175)
The article rightly points at readers having embraced their cognitive dissonance in the face of unrelenting media bias but unfairly singles out the alt-right movement -- one can't say that they are wrong in their dogmatic mistrust of the media. We saw non-stop coverage of the election where they talked up Clinton at every fifteen-minute segment, parroting statistics like her 98% guaranteed victory.

Through Wikileaks, we can plainly see that they were very much in bed with the Clinton campaign and frankly anyone with an ounce of sensibility should see that as plain as day.

That said, I would posit that the MSM orgs need to do a lot of soul-searching to restore their credibility lest they continue to drift into irrelevance. The Fourth Estate has fallen into disrepair due to their close adherence to progressive extremist ideology and their objectivity is rightly attacked.

It's not that people are looking for somebody to pick on, but instead the media are agitators rather than reporters of fact. There is a clear desire to steer society rather than simply disseminate information, much like how cable companies have zero interest in operating as communications conduits and instead strive to provide content experiences.

IMO there must be structural reform for the Fourth Estate to be restored to its previous stature -- to wit, mainstream media must be made great again.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by jaynos on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:14AM (#12968351)
>The Fourth Estate has fallen into disrepair due to their close adherence to progressive extremist ideology and their objectivity is rightly attacked.

[citation needed].

The MSM needs some repair, but I'd say that repair should be moving away from the "both sides do it" and "two sides to every argument" mentality and delivering the truth. On issues like climate change, equal weight does not need to be given to the "it's a hoax" crowd.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by yolesaber on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:25AM (#12968479)
Glenn Greenwald has a great essay on the false notion of "neutrality" in MSM - https://theintercept.com/2016/03/14/the-rise-of-trump-shows-...
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by andrewingram on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @12:09PM (#12969036)
(Slight tangent alert)

Sadly, Glenn Greenwald's interactions with Sam Harris have severely tarnished his credibility as a champion of objectivity in my eyes. Harris has a weakness in that he's very good at putting out content that's easy to cherry-pick in an uncharitable way, and this is what Greenwald seems to do every single time.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by ihsw on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:40AM (#12968669)
Lying by omission is still technically truthful, how can you reconcile your proposition with the fact that the MSM clearly downplayed Clinton's shortcomings while highlighting Trump's at every moment?
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by matt4077 on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:46AM (#12968749)
Maybe Clinton's shortcoming was her choice of E-Mail provider while Trump is, indisputably, a proto-fascist?

I mean, it's now admitted fact the Russian government tried to influence the election with the leaks, other hacks and a myriad other ways that must have had a significant effect.

Can you imagine what Breitbart et al would have written if Obama 2012 had been elected with help from Russia?

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by MK999 on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @12:03PM (#12968945)
Hillary's shortcoming was 40 years of corruption
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by james0001 on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:21AM (#12968434)
Why not? The science is far from settled. In much the same way that the media leans left, so does academia. Academia is not immune from corruption, and dare I say, academia is a worse swamp than Washington.
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by 1024core on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:34AM (#12968601)
When 99% of the academics agree on something, you could say the science is more-or-less settled. If you disagree, the onus is on you to come up with the evidence/theory to challenge it. Just claiming that "science is far from settled" doesn't make it so; you might as well claim that the "science is far from settled" on the Earth not being flat.
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by refurb on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:50AM (#12968805)
When 99% of the academics agree on something, you could say the science is more-or-less settled.

Go back 50 years and 100% of doctors thought stress and diet caused stomach ulcers. We now know that's not true.

I'm not using this fact as a knock against climate change. I'm just saying consensus across academics doesn't mean they are right.

If you had said "There is consensus across academics that humans activity is mostly likely the cause of global warming" than I wouldn't disagree.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by 1024core on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @12:08PM (#12969005)
I said nothing. I was just saying that if you want to go against scientific consensus, the onus is on you to provide proof! You can't just say "I disagree with them, so they must be wrong". It doesn't work that way.

This is how science works: there's a current understanding of the world; and if you want to change that, you have to come up with the counterexamples or other scientific evidence to back up your claim. You can't just stick your head in the sand and say that since I don't believe these guys, they must be wrong.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by ihsw on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:57AM (#12968886)
You are correct that appeal-to-authority arguments are inherently weak but it doesn't change the fact that his hand-wavy "it's not settled!" argument is even weaker.

To take your remark about doctor's a century earlier, germ theory was met with derision[1] :

> [...] Some doctors, for instance, were offended at the suggestion that they should wash their hands, feeling that their social status as gentlemen was inconsistent with the idea that their hands could be unclean.

Sometimes prevailing wisdom is discountable but sometimes it's not.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis#Discovery_of_...

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by soundwave106 on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @12:20PM (#12969155)
On the other hand, I think there are some facts on climate change that are hard to deny. We have actual data points of past weather patterns from various weather stations. We have observed various climate effects (glaciers disappearing, ice fields thinning, etc.).

I think it could be said that it is a fact that the Earth has warmed significantly over the past century. I think the evidence suggests that the trendline is atypical of normal patterns. I wouldn't call the trendline abnormality a fact at this point, but I think the evidence is very strong.

If someone had a conclusion was "the Earth is warming but I'm not sure humans are the cause", I would say that's fine. It recognizes the facts and strong trendlines above. It goes against consensus, but if they had some interesting data to go with their doubt, I would hope this analysis would be welcome.

"Global warming is a hoax!" type statements on the other hand tends to be completely dismissive sometimes of even the facts we have.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by emp_zealoth on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:53AM (#12968843)
When any sign of disagreement with the agw cult results in swift, abrupt and pretty much permament death of ones career then it is no wonder that not many people do that.

Ive had a few chances to personally speak with some scientists and they were not 99% sure what is happening

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by titzer on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @12:26PM (#12969216)
Yeah, well, the General Theory of Relativity doesn't predict the motions of galaxies very well (without dark matter), and is not compatible with quantum mechanics. But try getting GPS to work without it.

You think 2016 wasn't hot? (surprise answer, it really freaking was, and it's getting worse: http://www.nasa-usa.de/feature/goddard/2016/climate-trends-c...)

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by raattgift on Thursday November 17, 2016 @04:58PM (#12982111)
The incompatibility of QFT and GR is a theoretical incompatibility. Practically, however, GR is perfectly compatible with quantum mechanics right to the limit of strong gravity, which can only find inside black hole event horizons (and in particular at and very near the singularity), and in the very early universe.

In GR terms, strong gravity is where the uncertainty in position of field quanta sources an impossible gravitational field; this is only measurable when the energy-density is non-negligible and that requires enormous quantum numbers. In quantum field theory terms, the (general, not just electromagnetic) charge of a particle and its energy are separate quantities except for the gravitational charge of a particle, which is its energy. Because the gravitational interaction is so weak, this only matters when particle energies are very high (on Feynman diagrams, this means more than one loop of gravitons; while gravitons are massless they do carry momentum, and thus have energy, and thus gravitational charge).

The clocks in GPS satellites all rely on quantum effects, and those effects that run faster further from the Earth than they did closer to the Earth prior to launch. GNSS applications, as well as atomic clocks on spacecraft scattered around the solar system, are ongoing tests of the validity of this prediction of GR.

It is precisely because General Relativity is an effective field theory (in the Kenneth G Wilson sense of effective) in all presently accessible regimes, and has so far survived every test -- direct and indirect -- that it is extremely hard to arrive at an explanation for the effects of gravity pointing the wrong way other than non-luminous, transparent matter rather than a different theory of gravity.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by ihsw on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:44AM (#12968718)
It's sad to see that climate-deniers are still pushing their agenda when the facts so plainly speak for themselves.

As mentioned elsewhere in this thread, science is rarely settled. That is what makes it science, evidence is provided and notions are challenged -- indisputable axioms are very rare. Nevertheless we can still point to the results of rigorous studies and accept that their weight is enough to arrive at a reasonable assumption that global warming is real and it's not going away.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by james0001 on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:26AM (#12968494)
Oof, I must've offended a couple academics
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by yolesaber on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:31AM (#12968558)
I think it's because you denied climate change or rather hand-waved it away with "the science is far from settled" ~ as if science is EVER settled.

Humans are undeniably accelerating climate change for the worse. Species are dying off left and right from it. Why is this controversial?

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by Jimbob12 on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @12:05PM (#12968971)
Yes we are in a mass-extinction event, but no that is not because of climate change. Rather it is because we are destroying habitats left and right through deforestation, pollution, etc. Climate change is happening at such a slow glacial pace; I haven't seen any good data to suggest that the Climate is changing fast enough to produce harm.
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by mcphage on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:30AM (#12968541)
> but unfairly singles out the alt-right movement

Did you miss the part of the article where they pointed out a series of left-leaning false claims?

"No, delayed military absentee ballots would not have swung the election. No, Melania Trump has not filed for divorce, nor was her husband born in Pakistan. No, Mike Pence definitely did not tell Fox News that gay conversion therapy saved his marriage."

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by 1024core on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:33AM (#12968577)
It's called cognitive dissonance. :)
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by ihsw on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:59AM (#12968906)
I don't see SJWs being regarded as a threat to American democracy but they are agitators and proud-idiots just the same.
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by psychometry on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:18AM (#12968400)
You know when you're talking to a Trump supporter when they think that a preference for facts over lies amounts to a "close adherence to progressive extremist ideology". What a load of bullshit.
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by ihsw on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:38AM (#12968652)
Trump can go die in a hole for all I care, the MSM on the other hand glossed over the continuous revelations about the Clinton campaign. Time after time they refused to even cover the rampant corruption in the DNC, from how the Democratic nomination race was one-sided against Sanders, to how Clinton's very close relationship with Wall Street and her handling of Benghazi deeply damaged her credibility.

I do have a preference for facts but what I do not have a preference for is a Fourth Estate that has been infiltrated and manipulated to support an elite cadre intent on pushing a certain agenda.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by drabiega on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:53AM (#12968837)
I don't exactly follow what people would call the mainstream media closely, but what I was exposed to mentioned all of these things (or at least the fact that she was accused of them), while their coverage of Trump that I saw consisted solely of unedited airing of him speaking.

I sincerely don't understand the claims that the coverage was biased against Trump. If anything, it seemed to me that they were personally against him but in response to that they overcompensated and skewed the coverage too far in his direction.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by titzer on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @12:30PM (#12969249)
+1

The media bent themselves into some really odd shapes to make Trump's continuous string of gaffes appear somehow "normal".

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by dmode on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @02:25PM (#12970498)
MSM gave ample coverage to the most important story of all - Comey's political move on emails a week before election. It was pasted in huge headlines across all mainstream media outlets. And that turned out to be a dud at the end, but the damage was done. So not sure what you are expecting.
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by bubbleRefuge on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @12:02PM (#12968928)
Sanders supporter who voted for Trump because of disdain for the Democrats and party corruption. For example, super delegates flipping states for HRC. Donna Brazile's shenanigans, Debbie Wasserman-Schultz, Wall Street speeches, Clinton Foundation. Trump(and Bernie) created a consciousness/awakening in the country about the how the political system has been captured by the donor class and corporate interests. Hopefully, the Democratic party will purge itself and return to being the peoples party. If not we need a third party direct democracy organization driven by open source software and forums like HN which hold online debates and crowd source the decisions made by politicians.
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by psychometry on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @12:35PM (#12969292)
> Sanders supporter who voted for Trump

There's an undeniable indicator of an unsound mind right there. The correlation in policy goals between Sanders and Clinton was probably about 0.8, but you went with the guy at 0.1.

The only noticeable commonality between Sanders and Trump is that they're both white males, which I suspect is a significant reason for your absurd trajectory of political preference (whether you'll admit that to yourself or not).

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by bubbleRefuge on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @02:50PM (#12970778)
whats the correlation between any policy goal during a campaign and what actually happens? Insiders from both political parties didn't want Trump and didn't want Bernie. Trump has kind of upended both political parties. A good thing.
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by james0001 on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:23AM (#12968458)
You know you're talking to a person with "close adherence to progressive extremist ideology" when they assume the facts are on their side and the other side is just lies. Real scientific integrity eh?
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by taeric on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:28AM (#12968525)
My personal backlash against this is from experience. I have been wrong. I will be wrong more in the future. Ignorance is normal. Nobody knows everything.

However, ignorance is not to be embraced. Fact checking is not a liberal agenda. It is a general path to improvement.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by yolesaber on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:28AM (#12968528)
Yes, because only progressive extremists believe the facts are on their side. Say that out loud again, it sounds ridiculous.
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by james0001 on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:33AM (#12968590)
They have a greater tendency to do so, yes.

Probably stems from the implicit assumption that since academia leans left, that these progressives will have the needed scientific support for their policy proposals.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by yolesaber on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:38AM (#12968643)
You know that it was two Republicans who started the bipartisan committee on climate change in the House, right? It's not a liberal issue. It's a reality that is happening NOW

Your generalizations are laughable and are only indicative of the toxic thinking that has characterized this election.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by jjuel on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:43AM (#12968713)
Right now you are only believing your side and think the other side is lies. Do you not realize how dense you are being right now?
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by matt4077 on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:28AM (#12968518)
Much like the US today is a better country than it ever was, "the media" today is better than its critics say. People have a fantasy of how it supposedly was, how objectivity works (or doesn't) in journalism, and how much we still rely on a small handful of traditional publications.

Journalism has always had, and always will, a part to play in shaping public opinion. "Simply disseminating information" is something a phone book may do. Publishing a newspaper starts being subjective when you decide on what to write about.

The ecosystem of hanger-ons garnishing news with left-wing (Mother Jones, HuffPost) or right-wing (breitbart, FOX) slant adds exactly nothing but vitriol.

Wikileaks has shown exactly nothing except that in a million internal e-mails you're bound to find a few embarrassing ones. And that the American right has absolutely no problem that they won an election with the proven and admitted help of the Russian government.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by drewrv on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @12:20PM (#12969158)
What annoys me is how people treat ideology as the only type of bias. People will accuse a news source of being biased in favor of the left or right and that's it. The reality is that ideology is not even the most interesting or influential type of bias.

For example, news organizations heavily favor sensationalism over stories that are important but boring. News organizations will pander, reporting stories that their audience will enjoy rather than what will educate them. There's a "pre existing narrative" bias, for example Al Gore was a dorky know it all so of course he claimed to invent the internet, regardless of reality.

Maybe the New York Times or CNN slightly favors the right or the left, but give them a story that is sensational and fits the narrative and they won't shut up about it no matter which ideology it harms.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by chrisbennet on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:30AM (#12968552)
>The Fourth Estate has fallen into disrepair due to their close adherence to progressive extremist ideology and their objectivity is rightly attacked.

The Fourth Estate has fallen into disrepair because it's funding model was disrupted. No income source = less (real) reporters.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by gaur on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @12:15PM (#12969102)
> unfairly singles out the alt-right movement -- one can't say that they are wrong in their dogmatic mistrust of the media

A lot of alt-righters distrust the media because they think it's controlled by Jews. That's a regular theme on alt-right websites.

So yes, you can say they are wrong in their dogmatic mistrust of the media.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by nickpsecurity on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:16AM (#12968367)
"but unfairly singles out the alt-right movement "

The left version would be the passive-aggressive, censorship-prone bullies we call Social Justice Warriors (SJW's). You'll rarely see sites call them out despite them often being a minority within a minority acting like they speak for everyone where issues are often more nuanced.

Far as media reporting, corporate media work for advertisers. People hearing what they want to hear and hating who they want to hate keeps their attention. Those outlets will then selectively present information to maintain that feedback loop. Business is booming. Groups actually trying to inform people with the facts or present balanced information to let people decide themselves are rare. Often small.

My old approach was to identify the bias and reliability of various outlets then read them all. These days, I read second-hand info more often as I've found reliable, biased individuals or groups that pre-filter such sites to I can get to the meat of what they're saying. I still follow-up on raw data where it matters. The election cycle this year was the biggest pile of bullshit-producing, echo chambers I've seen in a long time. That Facebook, etc have algorithms preventing opposing sides from seeing each other as often as they would in the past is the reason imho.

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by yuncun on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:08AM (#12968263)
>Through Wikileaks, we can plainly see that they were very much in bed with the Clinton campaign and frankly anyone with an ounce of sensibility should see that as plain as day.

Thought they were pro-Trump?

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by gingerrr on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:12AM (#12968330)
The general argument I've heard that synthesizes both: They gave Trump too much credibility by treating him as an equal while attacking Clinton (were "pro-Trump"), but endorsed Clinton and crowed triumphantly at every step that she had it in the bag (were "pro-Clinton").

We should probably stop making absolute claims about anything regarding this election, as there are so many moving parts it is impossible to conclusively place responsibility at any one group's feet.

Then again, that may have been the point you were making :)

Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by ralmeida on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:13AM (#12968343)
I believe 'they' in the sentence refers to the media. As in, info from Wikileaks suggests that "[the media] is in bed with the Clinton campaign".
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by welanes on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:13AM (#12968338)
'They' being the media in that sentence.
Re:According to Snopes, Fake News Is Not the Problem by bbctol on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:37AM (#12968632)
It's more complicated than either one.