News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by hellofunk on Saturday November 05, 2016 @10:34AM (#12879911)
I have realized over the years that it is wise to be naturally skeptical of any opinion that is strong, either positive or negative. People who have an appreciation for gray areas, even if they ultimately do have a preference, tend to be a lot more emotionally balanced than those who maintain a very strong stance on something. I have noticed this so consistently over the last 15 years that I now consider it a fundamental benchmark by which I can gauge my ability to work or socialize with someone in general, on any topic, over the long term.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by chucksmash on Saturday November 05, 2016 @11:13AM (#12880069)
Espousing nuanced opinions and making effective arguments are often at odds though. It's very easy for people to lose the thread of an argument if it is chock full of footnotes.

I try to aim for "strong opinions, weakly held" - present a specific, actionable and strong position but be open to changing it if a better argument is made.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by imagist on Saturday November 05, 2016 @02:08PM (#12880998)
There's a parable of a guy who lost his keys in the park at night. Upon realizing he lost his keys, he begins to look for the keys in the street near a street lamp. When his friend asks why he's looking for his keys in the street instead of in the park where he lost them, the guy responds that the light is better in the street.

It's true that espousing nuanced opinions and making effective arguments are often at odds, but the fact is, reality is often nuanced. Glossing over that nuance to make your argument more effective is like searching where there's light. Sure, it's more persuasive, but if you are persuading toward an incorrect idea, what are you really accomplishing?

Of course as Asimov's Relativity of Wrong points out, not all wrongs are equal. It may be worthwhile to persuade someone of a not-very-wrong given limited resources. But this sort of compromise has problems of its own. A social justice movement that ignores the nuance of handling white men's needs is effective until it needs white men's cooperation but instead generates backlash (Trump). The devil is in the details.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by sqeaky on Saturday November 05, 2016 @05:47PM (#12882070)
Ideas are unlike keys in that the details can be glossed over sometimes and you might still go in the right direction.

In an argument about climate change with a denier I might say "Glaciers are shrinking" and until they bring up the the Tibetan glacier is growing I can be content with my intellectual honesty that all other glaciers are shrinking.

I agree with your notion of using details to garner supporters.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by Imagenuity on Saturday November 05, 2016 @09:27PM (#12882933)
The Relativity of Wrong by Isaac Asimov http://chem.tufts.edu/answersinscience/relativityofwrong.htm is one of the essays on this subject.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by yarou on Saturday November 05, 2016 @08:34PM (#12882737)
It's hard to make any true statement when terms are defined by what they aren't, rather than by what they are.

For example, the term "SJW". What is an SJW? I can tell you what it isn't. It is not racist, not misogynistic, etc. But what is it actually defined as?

I've never been a fan of post-structuralism, or any postmodern philosophical theory, but as of late I've been drawn to Jean Baudrillard. At the very least, our political landscape itself has become a simulacra of true political thought, as evidenced by groups defining themselves by the nihil or negation, i.e. there is no Universe where the statement "I am a bigot" can be made true.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by jacobolus on Saturday November 05, 2016 @11:54AM (#12880250)
More to the point, nuanced opinions are at odds with clickbait/flamebait. If you want to get lots of attention and start a big internet fight, say the most outrageous aggressive thing you can, and argue sloppily, with just enough reasoning behind you to get the folks who agree with you to come fight for your side.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by chris_wot on Saturday November 05, 2016 @12:27PM (#12880415)
Sounds like what happens in most diatribes against PHP and systemd I've read lately.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by _greim_ on Saturday November 05, 2016 @05:03PM (#12881875)
Or, make the headline outrageous, but in the body apologize for the clickbait headline and proceed to say a bunch of nuanced and reasonable things.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by ianai on Saturday November 05, 2016 @01:46PM (#12880854)
I don't consider internet "debates" something to seek replication.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by qznc on Saturday November 05, 2016 @01:52PM (#12880896)
It also works in presidential elections.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by brazzledazzle on Saturday November 05, 2016 @09:58PM (#12883038)
I'll take it one step further and say that nuanced opinions are at odds with modern society's increasingly short attention spans.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by rexpop on Saturday November 05, 2016 @01:39PM (#12880820)
Where did you pick up the phrase "strong opinions, weakly held"?
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by sublimino on Saturday November 05, 2016 @03:19PM (#12881392)
Paul Saffo is a potential source:

> Since the mid-1980s, my mantra for this process is “strong opinions, weakly held.” Allow your intuition to guide you to a conclusion, no matter how imperfect — this is the “strong opinion” part. Then –and this is the “weakly held” part– prove yourself wrong. Engage in creative doubt. Look for information that doesn’t fit, or indicators that pointing in an entirely different direction. Eventually your intuition will kick in and a new hypothesis will emerge out of the rubble, ready to be ruthlessly torn apart once again. You will be surprised by how quickly the sequence of faulty forecasts will deliver you to a useful result.

http://www.saffo.com/02008/07/26/strong-opinions-weakly-held...

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by chucksmash on Saturday November 05, 2016 @03:22PM (#12881406)
Lost to the mists of time. A little reconstructive memory spelunking via Google yields a plausible theory though:

A blog post [1] quoting a blog post [2] quoting a guy [3].

[1]: https://blog.codinghorror.com/strong-opinions-weakly-held/

[2]: http://bobsutton.typepad.com/my_weblog/2006/07/strong_opinio...

[3]: http://www.iftf.org/bobjohansen/

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by joeyespo on Saturday November 05, 2016 @03:45PM (#12881513)
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by hiou on Saturday November 05, 2016 @11:10AM (#12880055)
I find that people who sit in the greys tend to be very worried about their public perception or have very little passion beyond maintaining personal comfort.

The people I look for are those that take strong stands but are willing and able to adjust and even quickly reverse those stances.

To me it's the difference between a leader and a worker bee.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by twic on Saturday November 05, 2016 @11:23AM (#12880113)
> The people I look for are those that take strong stands but are willing and able to adjust and even quickly reverse those stances.

Sometimes called "strong opinions, weakly held".

I find this principle to be incoherent - if you understand something well enough to have a strong opinion, you understand it well enough to hold that opinion strongly. Holding strong opinions on things you don't understand that well seems unhelpful.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by oxide on Saturday November 05, 2016 @11:37AM (#12880174)
We all know arguing against a strongly held opinion usually results in the person with the strong opinion digging their heels in even deeper. At that point, things like reason kind of go by the wayside and don't have much effect.

As a poor example, my mother has fully bought into a snake-oil scheme where they sell you concentrated hydrogen peroxide as a cure-all. She won't hear a word against it, she always brings the conversation back to "OTC hydrogen peroxide has stabilizers in it." Asking "what is a stabilizer" gets no response.

The truth is, she doesn't know what a stabilizer is, but it's plausible enough to her that they could be "bad" that she's willing to buy the rest of the farm, along with the cow.

How can you argue against that kind of strongly held opinion? When the other party won't listen because of how strongly held the opinion is, you might as well talk to a wall.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by Animats on Saturday November 05, 2016 @05:00PM (#12881865)
How concentrated? Concentrated hydrogen peroxide (> 90%) is a rocket fuel. Above 8% is considered somewhat hazardous. Above 28%, hazmat precautions (corrosive, burns skin). Above 35%, unstable. Above 50%, even large industrial users usually don't go.[1]

[1] http://www.h2o2.com/technical-library/default.aspx?pid=76&

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by oxide on Saturday November 05, 2016 @07:32PM (#12882496)
I'm not sure, I believe it's 35% or more. She once mentioned that "it's not the legit stuff unless you have to sign a hazardous materials sheet" or something to that affect.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by dredmorbius on Saturday November 05, 2016 @09:30PM (#12882942)
Odds are good that the supplier's lying on both the benefits and qualities (concentration). A fake MSDS/hazmat sheet would be par for the course.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by adrusi on Saturday November 05, 2016 @01:16PM (#12880709)
You don't need to understand something well to be justified in having a strong opinion about it. Your belief should be based on the evidence you have, even if that means a small amount that leads you to an extreme conclusion. Otherwise you will have a bias toward the median belief, and there's no reason to expect, in general, that a median belief is any better than an extreme one. The strength of your evidence should only affect the level of attachment that you have to your belief.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by ball_of_lint on Saturday November 05, 2016 @01:40PM (#12880825)
If you don't understand something well, then any opinion you might claim to have on it is not actually on it, but rather on what you currently understand it to be. In that case, why not just say that you simply don't know enough to have an informed opinion?
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by thwarted on Saturday November 05, 2016 @03:47PM (#12881525)
In that case, why not just say that you simply don't know enough to have an informed opinion?

Up against a dishonest debater, this is exploitable to lessen your influence, even if your position is relatively stronger, against (unsubstantiated) claims of being an expert.

"ball_of_lint claims to be uninformed and doesn't have an opinion. That's okay, listen to me, I'm an expert"

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by Too on Sunday November 06, 2016 @03:47AM (#12884190)
So you'd rather win one debate at the cost of loosing reputation for years?

If someone strongly claims they know something and I later find out that they were wrong, I simply can't trust that person ever again.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by thwarted on Monday November 07, 2016 @05:47PM (#12895954)
If someone strongly claims they know something and I later find out that they were wrong, I simply can't trust that person ever again.

I'm glad you're a critical enough thinker to do that (although it's unfortunate that you don't account for honest conviction or that person obtaining further understanding such that they change their position; after all, not all strong claims revealed to be wrong are meant to deceive). Not everyone is that kind of critical thinker, especially up against a savvy, dishonest debater/character/charlatan. Some people just keep shouting "I know the answer" or "Believe me!" to every question or issue and they end up with a following.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by ythl on Saturday November 05, 2016 @02:20PM (#12881070)
> Your belief should be based on the evidence you have, even if that means a small amount that leads you to an extreme conclusion.

That's one way of thinking, but I reject it. You'll easily be manipulated by political and corporate agendas if you think this way.

Often my own intuition is at odds with the "evidence I have" and I turn out to be right later. If I had jumped to the (extreme) conclusion that smoking was healthy back in the 70s and 80s because of the evidence big tobacco was pushing from the shadows (doctors recommending brands, etc) I might not be here today.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by adrusi on Saturday November 05, 2016 @05:03PM (#12881879)
You won't be easily manipulated by virtue of having strong opinions, as long as they're weakly held, because you'll probably state your strong opinion to someone who knows better than you. If your opinion is actually weakly held, you'll recognize that their opinion is closer to the truth and adjust yours accordingly.

Often my own intuition is at odds with the "evidence I have" and I turn out to be right later.

I mean evidence in a broad sense, encompassing all information available to you for basing your worldview upon, including your intuition. If your intuition has been reliable in the past, and the scientific evidence was being put out by entities with obvious incentives for a certain conclusion, then it's rational to weigh your intuition highly relative to the scientific evidence.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by greenhatman on Saturday November 05, 2016 @08:01PM (#12882606)
What does 'a strong opinion' mean to you? Because I think we have different ideas of what that means.

I think the people who are against forming strong opinions on little data, thinks it essentially means being confident, speaking your mind, and influencing others towards seeing things your way, when you haven't done much research into a topic. Which I think is a bad idea, because it has a high chance of propagating misinformation.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by steveklabnik on Saturday November 05, 2016 @11:31AM (#12880144)
One aspect you're missing here is time; just because something is true today doesn't make it true tomorrow.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by Mathnerd314 on Saturday November 05, 2016 @12:24PM (#12880396)
The end result of knowing a lot about a topic is often that you can't make very strong statements about it; they always end up being something like "you're kind of right because XYZ, but also kind of wrong because XYZ". So the ideal situation is more like "weak opinions, strong actions".

Let's take the example of where someone yells "Duck!". Most likely, you weren't paying attention and you have no clue why they would yell such a thing. There is a high chance that it's some kind of prank. But, I argue, you should still duck anyway, because the potential benefits (not getting a concussion) outweigh the risks (looking stupid).

Similarly, if you are running a startup, you should prepared to pivot at the first sign of customer mismatch, but meanwhile the majority of work will be in one direction, and you should work on it passionately.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by amag on Saturday November 05, 2016 @04:53PM (#12881838)
Often I find the opposite, a better understanding of something means that you have to very clearly understand both its pros and its cons.

So by understanding something you dislike well, you need to appreciate its pros, which will lead to a weaker negative opinion about it. Conversely, understanding something you like well, means you need to come to terms with its cons as well, which should lead to moderation as well.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by macawfish on Saturday November 05, 2016 @12:46PM (#12880538)
I think another way of thinking about this is "being open minded". Life is full of seemingly contradictory truths and perspectives, facets and angles.
[dead]
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by sctb on Saturday November 05, 2016 @05:57PM (#12882128)
> Forgive my vitriol, but after seeing those people flush untold millions down the drain and hurt people and families countless times, they belong flipping burgers or in a mass grave.

We can't, unfortunately. Hacker News is a place for civil discussion; please don't post like this.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by dredmorbius on Saturday November 05, 2016 @09:35PM (#12882963)
The view stated is that positions held in opposition to all fact and experience are exceedingly and manifestly harmful.

History bears this out. There's nothing quite so violently dangerous as wishful thinking.

I'd prefer HN supported that perspective, and do so aggressively.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by rdiddly on Saturday November 05, 2016 @01:12PM (#12880685)
That sounds like something I might've said long ago, but today it seems to me that those at the extremes are the ones concerned about public perception. Like "Hey everybody look at me with my strong opinions!" It's a sales pitch for that person, for you to like and pay attention to them. And it will be necessarily very simplified and won't represent reality per se. A clickbait headline would get no clicks if it said "10 nuanced observations on the subtly complex and contradictory nature of reality, complete with all the exceptions. Number 6 will leave your mind totally blank as you stare out at the foggy hilltops!"

Also look at Trump (if you can stand it). He sells himself by saying extreme stuff. You do want that "extreme" person in a position where they can sell your company! But sales is orthogonal to leadership. A person who appreciates subtleties, if a leader, will quietly lead you to a river of money and not make your life hell on the way there. Or if they're a worker-bee, they'll quietly write bug-free and dependable code at a steady pace.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by BeetleB on Saturday November 05, 2016 @07:45PM (#12882548)
>I find that people who sit in the greys tend to be very worried about their public perception or have very little passion beyond maintaining personal comfort.

Or, you know, the issue is grey. Why take a strong stand when you have plenty of reasons not to?

The funny thing is that I find the opposite. I call it the "cowardice of taking a stand". Being a fence-sitter in this culture is fairly negatively perceived (except out of academia). As such, I notice people are very reluctant to state the nuances - they're afraid of being labeled a fence sitter. Cowards, in harsher words.

>The people I look for are those that take strong stands but are willing and able to adjust and even quickly reverse those stances.

The people I look for are those who ponder over, and see the flaws in their stands before becoming a strong proponent.

Wisdom is usually inversely proportional to posturing.

This is very reminiscent of: "Do you want a fantastic firefighter on your team, or one who prevents fires?" The firefighter is very noticeable because he keeps saving teams from crises. The one who prevents fires doesn't get noticed because there never was a fire. Poor managers reward firefighters.

I remember when I was interviewing for my last job, I would try to pose indirect questions to the potential manager to get an idea on whether they can handle uncertainty from their employees. If not, I would move on to the next interview. Managers who say stuff like "I never accept 'I don't know' for an answer" are to be avoided like the plague. They end up with a team of employees who are pretty adept at BS.

Society wants people who take strong stands, and your comment is a perfect example of it.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by hiou on Saturday November 05, 2016 @08:04PM (#12882619)
I imagine the firefighter that prevents fires has strong opinions about how they start.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by dahart on Sunday November 06, 2016 @09:46AM (#12885277)
I am honestly curious... Do you feel like putting out fires is a matter of opinion? Do you think firefighters are leaders and not worker bees? How does this rhetorical statement speculating vaguely about firefighters support your argument that leaders should have strong opinions about an issue even when they don't fully understand the issue?

FWIW, since you used the word "prevent", firefighters only put out fires that are already burning. The people leading in fire prevention aren't firefighters. Other people think about how to prevent fires. One example is the Forest Service in the US. The Forest Service is having nuanced debates about how to prevent forest fires, and one side of the argument is that many forest fires are natural. Fires have historically always happened, and they are part of our ecosystem. So, some of the thinking goes, we should let them burn. We are actually doing some ecological damage by putting out fires that start natually. We are also doing financial damage spending tax money on a "problem" that will never go away, and isn't a problem if we stop trying to live in the forest.

Other people who have properties & cabins in the woods would prefer that their choice to build a cabin in the woods was protected by firefighters no matter how the fire starts.

What is your opinion about whether naturally occurring forest fires should be fought?

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by snupples on Saturday November 05, 2016 @06:50PM (#12882343)
Sure the leader may have a strong opinion. But most people do, and often about complete BS, which is particularly obvious during election season. So it means nothing. The more important differentiator is the leader is more persuasive in backing the opinion. The nuanced opinion/argument is often more difficult to make persuasive though.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by aswanson on Saturday November 05, 2016 @07:54PM (#12882580)
That sounds to me like a loudmouth versus someone who thinks about what he's saying before saying it.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by lordnacho on Saturday November 05, 2016 @12:53PM (#12880576)
You're right. It's almost instinctive that when I hear some forcefully presented opinion, even if I agree with it, I put a mark next to the person's profile (in my mind).

One quite large issue is that once you've said your opinion, you are held to it. It's often easier to go even more extreme than to backtrack. And the effect is worse the more extreme you've gone.

I've had some sympathies for libertarian opinions lately, but when I see how far some of my friends take it, I wonder whether they're really thinking as clearly as they like to imagine.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by smallnamespace on Saturday November 05, 2016 @12:36PM (#12880467)
"The best lack all conviction, while the worst

Are full of passionate intensity." - Yeats

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by hellofunk on Saturday November 05, 2016 @02:27PM (#12881115)
What an apropos quote! Never seen that one before, good to know it now.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by jessaustin on Saturday November 05, 2016 @07:48PM (#12882557)
My reading of the poem is somewhat at odds with the implication of that quote by itself. Overall Yeats seems to be lamenting a particular situation in which the best and worst have these qualities, rather than simply stating that they have these qualities in general.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by alphapapa on Saturday November 05, 2016 @11:00PM (#12883228)
Yes, along the lines of the quote, "All that is necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing."
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by PerfectElement on Saturday November 05, 2016 @04:27PM (#12881713)
That's only true for opinions that are not generally accepted.

I believe you have strong opinions about all sorts of things, e.g. you probably have a strong stance against slavery. Take this strong stance 300 years back, and you would be seen as an emotionally unbalanced person, by your standard.

I'm glad there are people with strong opinions. The world would be a much darker place if everyone was always on the fence.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by greenhatman on Saturday November 05, 2016 @08:08PM (#12882633)
Yea, Hitler had strong opinions too. This can go either way, I guess.

I think having strong opinions based on a deep understanding is better. And generally a deep understanding means you'll discover both pros and cons to most situations.

This means you can make balanced and calculated efforts, instead of blindly starting a crusade and hope you turn out to actually be right.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by hellofunk on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:16AM (#12898774)
You misread me. I didn't say on the fence, that is something else entirely. I said, an appreciation for gray areas, even if you ultimately do have a preference.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by robertelder on Saturday November 05, 2016 @01:03PM (#12880623)
> I now consider it a fundamental benchmark...

Sorry to be pedantic, but I just wanted to point out the paradox you get by holding such an opinion so strongly.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by hellofunk on Saturday November 05, 2016 @03:28PM (#12881440)
I thought someone might say that. It is possible to have a general opinion on something, or at least some guidance, without maintaining a stubborn perspective on it. I can easily be proven wrong, when someone with strong opinions reveals to be an exception to my experience. I have no problem with that. Doesn't really happen much, though (yet).
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by greenhatman on Saturday November 05, 2016 @08:15PM (#12882668)
I only hold one opinion strongly, and that is that people with strong opinions are full of shit :)
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by user5994461 on Saturday November 05, 2016 @01:43PM (#12880839)
I've found it very difficult to write/argue gray-ish about any topic.

Either it's positive or it's negative.

The way between is full of self-contradictions and footnotes. That makes a difficult read/conversation.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by booleandilemma on Saturday November 05, 2016 @04:21PM (#12881690)
Go not to the Elves for counsel, for they will say both no and yes.

J. R. R. Tolkien

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by benjohnson on Saturday November 05, 2016 @04:44PM (#12881790)
“Ask two Jews, get three opinions.” - a jewish quip given to me by Rabbi Glickman.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by amag on Saturday November 05, 2016 @04:42PM (#12881781)
It seems you have a very strong opinion about who you can work and socialize with... ;P
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by hellofunk on Sunday November 06, 2016 @06:27AM (#12884621)
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by warlox on Saturday November 05, 2016 @05:38PM (#12882031)
There are issues where being unable to take a strong stance is indicative of a weak mind, such as Nazism and genocide. If you can't stand strongly against things like those, you're simply a bad person.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by iheartstartup on Saturday November 05, 2016 @02:30PM (#12881138)
what matters in the end is being right. When opnions have to turn into action, knowing what is the right thing to do (knowing what technology to use, for example), and a careful balance of tradeoffs is always the sign of good leadership. This may include taking very strong stands on various things.

I've found people have tendencies to delude themselves in certain ways, however. Either being too positive or negative. The former is less harmful than the latter, but both are miscalibrations of judgement.

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by crimsonalucard on Saturday November 05, 2016 @01:02PM (#12880617)
This is true, however, I think the people who have strong opinions end up becoming successful entrepreneurs.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by amag on Saturday November 05, 2016 @05:02PM (#12881874)
Or utterly failed ones...
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by jklinger410 on Saturday November 05, 2016 @12:33PM (#12880449)
I'm passionate about how wrong people are to be convinced of everything.

What does that mean?

Re:Be careful about what you dislike by Retra on Saturday November 05, 2016 @12:51PM (#12880571)
It means you've been convinced of something that is wrong.
Re:Be careful about what you dislike by profalseidol on Saturday November 05, 2016 @12:27PM (#12880414)
Understanding of man, the ultimate wisdom- Confucius