That's a really STEEP Price to Pay for an "experiment". Anyone know how much the participants were compensated for taking part in the study? No amount of money would make me do something like this. But that's just me.
"Couples enrolled in the efficacy phase were asked to rely only on these injections for contraception."
And there were four pregnancies during the study (from the abstract of the study):
During the efficacy phase of up to 56 weeks, 4 pregnancies occurred among the partners of the 266 male participants, with the rate of 1.57 per 100 continuing users (95% CI, 0.59 – 4.14)
Q: Anyone know how much the participants were compensated for taking part in the study?
A: To answer you question, I do not know what they were compensated.
Yes they did.
It didn't say his sperm count was actually zero.
Generally IVF is still possible when the male is classified as "infertile" by traditional measures (i.e. extremely low sperm count or dysfunctional sperm).
"It was a pretty big study; they gave shots to 320 men every eight weeks, in different countries around the world."
Every eight weeks, but for how long?
In my experience, it would probably be in the neighborhood of a few thousand dollars, but not much more. For the participants, even that much money to take some pills over the course of say a few months would probably be seen as easy money.
But then again, there's those pesky side effects.
FYI: All the drugs I tested were already FDA approved and were not considered in a "trial" phase.
If you are considering a vasectomy anyway then it's not nearly the same problem.
It could be something that would have happened anyway... right? I am not an expert :P.
I know many who would see that as a blessing though: License to have as much unprotected sex as they want without the unfortunate side-effect of an unwanted pregnancy. And they get paid for the experiment in the first place too? Win-win, they would argue.
Right, but I suspect the parent implied that this could be a feature that many would seek out - basically the chemical equivalent of a vasectomy that can't be undone.
Some people, like me, really don't want kids. Taking control of it so that you're not relying on your partner is important as trust (that they haven't forgotten to use contraception or worse - deliberately not take it) isn't a rock-solid security policy. It's also not fair on females to be the only ones in charge of contraception for bare-skin sex.
One thing I've learned as I've collected laps-around-the-sun is that Present Me is a poor judge of what Future Me wants.
I find it much more interesting to ask why somebody wants no kids. That gives much more insight into the person's mind than when you try to persuade them with your own experiences and produces much better followup talk opportunities.
Anyway, I'm curious what you think it might be evolutionary advantageous. On the face of it, if others have less kids, that would seem advantageous to your own kids.
Is the existence of injectable insulin scary just because someone could kill someone just by injecting them with it?
1975 isn't that long ago. If this technology is cheap and available, it will be abused.
What you're really trying to do is make out that somehow sterilisation is a special case of something with a potential negative use case, where if they can easily be used, they will be, without arguing why it's different from all the other things that meet that criteria.
That does not address jamesrcole's argument. He's not saying "it was always possible, therefore being easier is no different".
He's pointing out that there are worse bad things that are just as easy to do, yet they aren't considered scary.
You can't make an argument that the ease matters, because he's asking about things that are equally easy if not easier. Why is easy availability of such a drug different from easy availability of the knife/car/etc.?
You should be focused on access, control and any inappropriate uses. Not on whether the things being used exist or not.
The many people you know that would love to be permanently infertile can get what they want in a matter of minutes, in a proven/well-known way.
Are you sure about that? As far as I know nearly all urologists in the US will refuse to perform a vasectomy on a childless man, especially if they're in their 20s and/or unmarried.
But the doctor didn't ask about any of this (he obviously knew my age). I just had to sign that I was lectured about the potential risks and consequences - similar to the preparations for any medical operation really.
And I had to agree on the price, since this (obviously?) isn't covered by basic health care here.. ;)
So.. No idea. My doctor didn't know about my marriage or kids though.
So I'm guessing they're not too happy with permanent infertility.
Obviously these men signed up for an experimental protocol and presumably were made well aware of the risks. Nonetheless dismissing this as possibly "win-win" is spectacularly tone-deaf at best.
Is it somehow hard to understand the statement that some men (not all men) would be OK with the outcome? I for one am never going to have biological children, so I don't particularly care whether I'm sterile or not.
The fact that there may be men in the first group is totally irrelevant to the experience of the second group.
Regardless of what one feels about children, I'm kind of shocked anyone could see accidental sterilisation as a benefit of any kind.
If permanent inability to produce offspring is what you want, there's always the snip. Of course, you'd still be subject to the risk of STDs if frequent change of partners is what you desire.
I know plenty of heterosexual men who would see this as a license to have unprotected sex with as many women as possible and never be burdened by the responsibility of a child.
I'm not saying I agree with this attitude (furthest from it, actually), but "you'll never have kids" probably won't come to them as a negative.
(I'm not hetero, for what it's worth.)
Sure, as a side effect, it's unfortunate, but if a pill were available that was designed for this effect it would be a blessing.
It takes 20 minutes and you walk out. You'll feel not a thing (you might feel the injections of anesthetics). You 'recover' over a week of mostly nothing. I was riding my bike the day after the procedure.
You don't see a change, you don't feel a change and it is completely painless. Ignoring myself I've talked to a good number of friends who've done the same thing, said the same thing. I haven't heard of one single person that had a vasectomy and complained about pain in any way or form.
Honestly, I wonder why people would even wish for a 'chemical castration' all over this thread. Maybe your first line is something widely 'well known' and often repeated?
> I was riding my bike the day after the procedure.
Please do not spread terrible medical advice which you were surely told not to do. That's great you turned out fine but it is not ethical to promote such behavior.Think of it as someone saying their children turned out fine without immunizations. Your words can become incredibly dangerous once you begin questioning doctors if you are not trained or have added knowledge in the area of specialty.
I asked my doctor if there's _anything_ I shouldn't do and he said 'No'. He told me an anecdote about a patient of his that HAD a bit of pain after flying for most of a day directly after the procedure (being cramped being probably a reason for that), but he explicitly said that there is no reason to hold back. "Be reasonable, be sensible".
But I honestly don't even know what drove you to comment here. I never said 'Ride a bike on the next day' nor am I a doctor or even TRIED to give out medical advice. Instead I explicitly called out (and tried to dispell) the 'OMG it is so painful' FUD.
Your comment is a) irrelevant (I don't give medical advice) and b) assuming things that are completely unrooted in reality and wrong.
http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/contraception-guide/Pages/vasec...
Honestly though? I totally didn't plan for that. I planned the trip, planned the operation. The operation's date was changed by my doctor, I didn't cancel the trip and just .. went along, because I felt fine.
Again: My doctor didn't list any limitations, even when I explicitly asked about it. But I certainly don't claim that people should jump on a saddle as soon as they've left the room. I merely pointed out what I happened to do on the next day to mock the 'the pain is unbearable' FUD.
Feel free to rest for a week. As far as I'm concerned and as far as I'm aware after talking to people that decided to take this step: There's no need to. There's no pain. A feeling ob numbness maybe (think strained ankle, but a week later) and obviously you have cuts that you don't want to strain.
But I had a lot of accidents with a razor or a kitchen knife (mind you, we're talking "face" and "fingers" now, right?) that were far worse than the vasectomy.
Along the same lines, I know several people who have had knee replacement surgery and they all said it was the most painful thing ever. All of them though, are very happy reaping the benefits of that years later. It was only a few months after saying that if he knew it would hurt that much that he wouldn't have had it done that an 80yr old friend of mine was proudly showing me how he could jump down some steps!
My vasectomy was not painful at all. You do get a needle into your scrotum to inject the anaesthetic, and that is not a nice feeling at all. But it's over in two seconds. You don't feel the rest, because, you know, modern medicine.
What part do you think is painful?
For me the only major downside was the cost. If I ever decide I want children, I guess I'll have to adopt.
He said he didn't use to, but then he had a vasectomy himself.
Well if you can't see it, that surely must mean nobody can, right?
We don't know the test subjects or their life goals - I know that I want kids someday, but I also know that I don't want them now.
If I underwent a birth control procedure found out due to an error I couldn't have kids ever, I'd be pretty devastated.
This was a clinical trial, not a procedure. They don't just spring trials on you with no warning.
Also, you definitely can have kids: foster or adopt. :)
The shot's side effects sound significantly more humane.
If you really want solid male birth control with no side effects, bank your gametes for $50/mo and get your vas deferens snipped.
Female birth control may not cause permanent lack of fertility, but it can cause cancer. Breast cancer. Cervical cancer. Liver cancer.
So can dental fillings, breast implants, and artificial sweeteners.
Like female birth control though, most people agree that the risk for developing cancer associated with the activity is well worth the benefits. Saying "boo fucking hoo" about someone who can never reproduce again is pretty cold-hearted, in my opinion.
Do you have some idea of the likelihood here? Are we talking a 10% chance of cancer or a 0.001% chance?
The whole "it can have X side effect" is the same argument anti-vaccine people use without respect to any sort of cost benefit risk analysis.
This study was presenting at around 20% (IIRC, I was reading the outrage version of this stuff a few days ago)
It is also important to note that this is by no means the end of the drug. The people involved consider this to be a very promising study and are going to continue working on it.
It wasn't stopped early "as a failure" to be shelved and never looked at again. It was stopped early because they knew enough about the upside and didn't have to continue on the down.
The next rounds of trials will likely try to alleviate the side effects while preserving the MOA (mechanism of action)
The VOX article was a reasonable balance to the "men are selfish pigs who can't handle side effects" version of this article. http://www.vox.com/2016/11/2/13494126/male-birth-control-stu...
> Eight participants had not recovered to meet the criteria of return to fertility after 52 weeks in recovery phase, the last visit according to the study protocol. These participants were followed on a case by case basis until they regained normal sperm counts (n 5, up to 74 wk of recovery) or declined further follow-up (n 2). One volunteer did not recover within 4 years since his last injections.
http://press.endocrine.org/doi/pdf/10.1210/jc.2016-2141