On a totally unrelated note, there are 31 women who have served in the Senate. Ever. And there are zero women who have served as president, though that will change in February. There are a tiny minority of female board members. There is a high of 22 of the fortune 500 with female ceos.
> ....Senate...president...board members...ceos.
A man or a group of men having power is not the same as men, as a class, having power.
You're forgetting about the implied sub-selection (or lack thereof), which then needs to be re-applied to the situation over which the group has power.
Take random small town A containing subgroup B, which holds most seats of power in town A. This is the same as: Subgroup B, as a class, having power, within town A.
So let's rephrase: American men, as a class, have power in America.
Now, what happens if our sub-selection ISN'T a sub-selection, and is just "humanity"? Human men, as a class, have power in humanity.
This is backed up by leadership statistics.
Now, I think what you're trying to say is: Correlation of the "man" attribute with power is the not the same as the "man" attribute causing power".
Again, this kinda makes sense, but, AFAIK/IMHO, so long as the attribute in question is disproportionately shared by the people with power vs the distribution amongst the population, that attribute IS causing some degree of the power held.
Power usually goes to the classes who are most organized and cooperative. If you forbid cooperation, you eventually forbid (equal) power as well.
If we take this to its logical conclusion, should every group of humans should form a stratified sample[1] of the population? What should the variables be -- age, gender orientation, sex, religion, disability status, race, color, national origin, pregnancy, marital status, number of pets, ... ?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratified_sampling
Do you see any downsides to making every group 'representative'?
Here's my thinking:
First, consider that the sample size vs population size of CEOs is goddamn tremendous, and the size of both pools is pretty substantial. It's one thing to try to select a stratified sample of 10 out of 20; it's another to select a stratified sample 500 out of millions. I would expect the transition point to be around when people stop being people, and start being statistics.
Second - It's like dark matter, and then it gets more complicated. Notionally, men and women are equal in capability; given just that, I'd expect to see a sample representative of the population demographics. This is not what is observed, so we can posit a) inequality in capability and/or b) other forces acting on the system.
A isn't born out by other experiments, leaving B. So then it becomes a question of: What are those other forces AND are they ones we want to keep?
Contrast with age, which clearly has a correlation with inequality in capability, so less of the disparity with the theoretical stratified sample must be explained by B.
Of course, shit gets complicated fast; the correlation of skill with age is not only non-linear, but is more like a non-linear probability function of skill given an age; self-selection might at first seem to be a reasonable B force, but then you have to consider what's causing the self-selection, and what effect that should have on the "equally capable" population sizes...
At 55, it looks like CEOs should be equally split down the middle. That this is not the case means there's more forces in play than explained by the "theory".
For example, I think a lot of the hostility coming out of the Gamergate community is partly an attempt to claim 'gaming' as an all-male space. These aren't country-club millionaires figuring out how to buy the next local election.
I thought the whole thing was a rejection of the attempt by members of the gaming media to paint "gaming" as some exclusively male (and explicitly anti-woman) subculture. There was no shortage of women speaking out as "members" of gg.
The example that personally comes to mind is a Daily Show segment a long time back about an all-male retreat, hosted by one Samantha Bee and shot through with mockery of the idea it was needed, condescension, and the general assumption that she understood men better than they did. (This idea that women know men's own needs, desires and experiences better than they do seems pretty commonplace. Think I've even seen men accused of "mansplaining" their own personal experiences.)
Well, a space when you can engage in so called "locker room talk" without getting accused of being sexist or rude.
Basically, at least for me, a lot of the time, when I'm with women in spaces, I feel judged. I can't say things like "son of a bitch" or "asshole" without feeling somewhat watched.
And yes I agree I swear too much, but where's my safe space?
That such things can be so normalized should be proof enough that you don't need a safe space. Your safe space (and, as a white male, mine too) is the entire Western world by default.
No, that's reframing it in the context of the current presidential election.
The sort of thing that I'm talking about is "Hey, what are you doing this weekend? Oh, I'm going out with this Cuban girl I just met. I hear they're supposed to be tigers in the sack".
Notice no sexual assault there, just a conversation females might kick up a big fuss over. "Stop objectifying and stereotyping us."
Or even "What happened to your car? Oh, the transmission guy bent me over and fucked me good for 800 bucks to replace some shitty gears he probably yanked out of a junkyard".
These things should be allowed and have a safe place where you can say them.
The latter--I've used very similar phrasing in conversations with feminist advocates and not gotten a bit of static because the context they were used in was perfectly clear and not avowedly harmful, as per your first example. I think you're misunderstanding the objections that would be raised about your speech.
> feminist advocates and not gotten a bit of static because the context they were used in was perfectly clear and not avowedly harmful
Do they even have the right to complain? You use whatever language you want, and they can choose whether or not to hang out with you. "He's boring to talk to, all he wants to talk about is Yankees baseball". Any allegation of misogyny these days or even worse, sexual misconduct will ruin the life of a man. Even if he managed to clear himself of criminal wrongdoing, his career is over.
Heck, Derrick Rose's accuser didn't even have her name made public whereas Derrick Rose had his name dragged through the mud and had to spend plenty of time and money on lawyers. Whatever happened to the legal system being public record?
That's the best case scenario. The woman was trying to settle, but ended up trying to sue for 21 million. Again, that is the best case scenario, that you have enough time and resources to lawyer up.
If somebody accuses you of something like that when you're at work, there is no due process when it comes to HR. You can sue for wrongful termination, but that's hard to prove and requires expensive lawyers.
You're shitting me. The leap you just made from "locker-room talk" equating to "bragging about sexual assault" is holy-fuck-what-the-hell-wrong-with-you absurd.
I just can't.
That phrase wouldn't be being used if it were not at the forefront of the public consciousness, and that it is being used to moderate bragging about sexual assault is telling.
Those of us who aren't obsessing over this reality TV-show, joke of an election don't think like that.
You're taking a phrase which has existed for, oh, I don't know, probably as long as locker rooms have existed, and re-branding it as "locker room talk now equals bragging about sexual assault" henceforth until the end of time.
Do you realize how dangerous that is?
In the same vein as this article (tangentially): the term "mancave" has been branded forever as offensive to feminists. We're apparently heading down the same road with "locker room talk". Unreal.
Again, I just can't.
He basically said that if you're famous, women let you do things to them. As an example, he just said "I'm automatically attracted to beautiful [women]—I just start kissing them. It's like a magnet. Just kiss. I don't even wait. And when you're a star they let you do it. You can do anything ... Grab them by the pussy. You can do anything."
He didn't sexually assault anybody, they consented. Where are you getting sexual assault from? And his statement is true once you hit a certain level of fame/wealth.
I consent to the groping of my ball sack at the airport because those are the rules, but I'd prefer they didn't do it.
I would rather they not have the sense to "speak their mind in private settings"; I would like to know who I should not trust because of who they have decided to be.
How did you get there exactly?
Rigid power structures, nepotism, and the like are present everywhere but it wasn't until recently that women have been regarded as partners rather than servants. The trend will inevitably change but attacking "manliness" with silly terms like "mansplaining" and "manspreading" will only get you labelled a nitwit (and rightfully so). The goal should be to empower women, not degrade men.
You know the complaint about "mansplaining" is utterly bogus because of the real problem with the term, which is that English already has a universally-accepted word that means literally --- exactly literally --- the same thing: "patronizing". What you object to isn't the term: you object to the people using it, and seek to dismiss and mock them.
Don't you find it unreflexive and ironic to dismiss their writings as rationalistically dismissive then proceed to nitpick denotative meanings?
And how on Earth do you get that deploying a bigoted version of an existing word means the person who doesn't like getting targeted with it has no right to complain about it?
For example, how do you feel about people who call women "cunts"? By your logic, objecting to that practice would be utterly bogus (not just bogus, mind you, but utterly bogus...), because the jerks doing it have a right to do it. In your logic, the bigoted, offensive term "cunts" is fine. Anyone complaining about getting called a "cunt" doesn't dislike the term, they just want to dismiss and mock the jerks calling them that...
That's ridiculous. People who call women "cunts" are trying to verbally intimidate them through gendered, offensive references. And the same is true with people who label others "mansplainers." They're just offensive namecallers, trying to use sexual imagery to shame someone into shutting up, to demonstrate that they will go further in a conflict, that they have less to lose, and dare them to push back.
Look, I kind of understand where you're coming from, tptacek. I've read a lot of the same social theory as you in grad school. I've read a lot of your writings here and elsewhere. And I object to mainstream society in a big way, too. And I object to a lot of the tech scene as well, from the huge bets on stupid tech to the path of tech from research to military to police to consumer.
But take this from someone who wants to see you succeed: You're flipping out and not being persuasive. You're relying too much on trying to overwhelm people with big words from the literature and failing to communicate. You're letting yourself get triggered and losing the ability to relate to those who disagree with you and see two or more simultaneous perspectives in your mind at once. You're moving into all black and white territory, but you know reality isn't like that.
But nobody is infuriated by "patronize", either its meaning or its clear connotation, because "patronize" is mainstream standard written English, and thus presents no good opportunities to use otherization to deflect criticism.
I don't know why you think I've been "triggered", but I assure you that I spent the next 4 minutes after writing that comment drawing a Trogdor-shaped United States to illustrate on Twitter one of Hillary Clinton's proposed campaign slogans, and I remember my emotional state during that effort far better than I do picking apart the dumb comment I replied to. But: I do appreciate the concern.
When you say "mansplain" is the Newspeak version of "patronize," that would make the gender-less "patronize" the unspeakable, but truthful expression...
...Yet it would upset the illegitimate authority to say "patronize," so the powers require us to use "mansplain" to not reveal the underlying, genderless truth?
I think I relate to Winston Smith simply wanting a peaceful Red Barchetta cabin in the forest!
At any rate: the two words, patronize and mansplain, mean the same thing, so feigning offense at the gendering of "mansplain" is a pitiful way to build an argument.
[1] And yes, one is clearly gendered while the other one isn't. If someone claimed that you couldn't describe a woman as "patronizing" because that term only applied to men, this would seem like nonsense to any English speaker, whereas "mansplaining" was explicitly coined as something only men could do to women.
Currently is it. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/patronize
Nowhere in there is patronize used in a gender based way at all.
A patron is simply somebody who supports you and bankrolls you. Christopher Columbus had a female patron.
Or are you grasping at straws here? Even m-w lists a male gendered meaning for the root word patron at the eighth definition. From m-w (http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/patron): 8: the chief male officer in some fraternal lodges having both men and women members
If you're a small business owner, you'd equally thank a woman or a man for their patronage, or yell at them equally for them to stop patronizing your employees.
Not only is Latin mostly gendered and the Latin root of this word clearly male, but the female root "matron" is also a common root for English words.
Oh, tptacek, maybe you need to go outside and get some air. You really think that people are leafing through unabridged Latin dictionaries looking for ways to be subtly sexist?
Newspeak is the fictional language in the novel Nineteen Eighty-Four, written by George Orwell. It is a controlled language created by the totalitarian state Oceania as a tool to limit freedom of thought, and concepts that pose a threat to the regime such as freedom, self-expression, individuality, and peace. [1]
It matches my definition very well:
"In my experience Newspeak was a dialect of language dictated by the illegitimate power structure to prevent the accidental communication of truthful expression which could undermine its authority."
Even in the original intended usage of the term, patronizing and mansplaining aren't quite the same; despite roughly analogous root words, mansplaining includes a degree of gender essentialism that patronizing lacks.
I've seen plenty of people apologize when called on it and avoid making that assumption a second time. Recognize it, do better, move on.
Wow, what a minefield.
I don't expect anybody to be competent in mathematical or technical fields, so I generally start from the beginning until somebody says "Oh, I already worked with this particular tech stack this is the problem I can't figure out."
Immediately attributing that to the fact that they're women and the main thing they need is explanation, by a man, that's a huge leap.
Calling it Mansplaining is horrible. Like somebody else pointed out, condescending is the gender neutral way to say it, and calling it mansplaing indicates it's problem exclusive to men. Can Caitlyn Jenner mansplain? Can Oprah mansplain?
The fact that you are a man is irrelevant, I'm also a man and I find the acceptance of bigotry towards men to be abhorrent.
Any socially astute man knows that women benefit from being listened to in sustained streams-of-thought speech. It's commonly called "processing." And if you're not doing it currently, then all the women in your life, from your family to friends to lovers, will be happy when you start. It's a way of showing women respect and demonstrating that you're listening to them and take them seriously.
So both men and women will talk for long paragraphs. It's only recently that a small, vocal subset of women decided to genderize it with the term "mansplaining" to mock and dismiss men. It was kind of funny when it was just a joke, but now that it's used to shout down men and these women are forgetting their own propensity for endured, one-sided conversation, it's not funny anymore.
But secretly, I'm happy when I hear a woman use the phrase "mansplaining." It's a signal that helps me decisively eliminate her from my social life. Anyone using that term as anything more than a small side joke doesn't deserve my attention.
Women talk for long streams. If men were to refer to it as "womensplaining," it would be condescending.
Men talk for long streams. When the small, vocal subset of women refer to it as "mansplaining," it is condescending.
The error in logic is to say that it's a gendered pattern of condescension. Because both genders do it, it only becomes gendered when you forget that women do it, too.
Who is the Zen master who makes the grass green? It is you. You make the grass green.
You've failed to even grasp the topic, and yet you would condescend towards dragonwriter (one of the wisest, most insightful posters around here on a wide variety of topics) about his "need to be right" while inventing an argument out of whole cloth. Tremendous.
So 'mansplaining' goes beyond simply noting a man's condescending behavior, but suggests that the only motivation is sexism. Is the evidence sufficient to prove the charge?
Maybe the man is simply rude towards everyone; maybe the woman is ignorant on the topic; maybe the guy was having a bad day.
The problem with the word is the logic that it implies. Soon we'll be finding that if a man is ever rude to a woman in public for any reason, he is automatically labeled a sexist. I'm not sure that's a very useful, or fair heuristic.
I still remember the tone used by the nurse when she "taught" to my brother how to change the diapers of his newborn. I've never seen someone that condescending.
If you believe that words mean things--which, even in today's climate, is a generally accepted position--this might be a difficult one for you.
Would it be all right to say that somebody is "whitesplaining" or "gooksplaining" or "blacksplaining"?
Ironically, I learned valuable psychological hacks from manspreading: When you feel down, spread yourself out and take up a bunch of space. It's really empowering!
> The goal should be to empower women, not degrade men. Yes, but - Mansplaining is meant to point out situations when men are degrading women. So it's not about degrading men, it's about degrading assholes, although yeah, the term is inherently gender'd.
Do we label Asians that cheat on tests in college as "chinks"? No! That's awful and bald-faced racism, we just call them cheaters with low moral standards.
Why can't they get their own elk lodge, hmmm?
Money/Control/Power is not a fixed quantity jealously guarded by ragtag formations of men.
It's something generated by an activity of some sort.
Do the activity, reap the rewards.
I'll let Bill Burr explain the simple male brain.
I'm sure I'm exaggerating, but bear with me: A lot of the traditional men's spaces look like avenues for social advancement that are closed to women. This may be incidental because men have historically run things and the politicking and networking naturally occurred in spaces where men congregated, but incidental or not, attempting to bar women from traditionally male spaces today has the effect of locking women out of society, so to speak. In a vacuum, a club where men hang out exclusively is no different than a club where women hang out exclusively, but in reality the sheriff and mayor are rubbing elbows at the elk lodge, not at the women's gym down the road. As long as men hold the reins, locking women out of the spaces where men hobnob is another tool of control.