News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by ihsw on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @01:54PM (#12746025)
This is classic tribalism -- like-minded people will congregate in safe spaces to share ideas and whatnot while denying entry to outsiders. Attributing it to some kind of banal hostility towards all women is nonsense, it is simply indicative of hostility towards outsiders (and in a male-dominated environment, women are outsiders).

Rigid power structures, nepotism, and the like are present everywhere but it wasn't until recently that women have been regarded as partners rather than servants. The trend will inevitably change but attacking "manliness" with silly terms like "mansplaining" and "manspreading" will only get you labelled a nitwit (and rightfully so). The goal should be to empower women, not degrade men.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by tptacek on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @05:04PM (#12747636)
This sounds like a tightly reasoned argument but is in fact just an exercise in the rhetoric of rationalist dismissal. You can see this by simply looking carefully at the words you've chosen. "Classic tribalism", you say. Apart from begging the question of what exactly is "classic" about it, there's the bigger problem of how hard it is to come up with any human conflict that can't be cast and dismissed a "tribal", from the proper border between Kaliningrad and Lithuania to whether and how cities should regulate Uber drivers.

You know the complaint about "mansplaining" is utterly bogus because of the real problem with the term, which is that English already has a universally-accepted word that means literally --- exactly literally --- the same thing: "patronizing". What you object to isn't the term: you object to the people using it, and seek to dismiss and mock them.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by chillingeffect on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @05:35PM (#12747905)
My strawperson-per-minute meter just pegged.

Don't you find it unreflexive and ironic to dismiss their writings as rationalistically dismissive then proceed to nitpick denotative meanings?

And how on Earth do you get that deploying a bigoted version of an existing word means the person who doesn't like getting targeted with it has no right to complain about it?

For example, how do you feel about people who call women "cunts"? By your logic, objecting to that practice would be utterly bogus (not just bogus, mind you, but utterly bogus...), because the jerks doing it have a right to do it. In your logic, the bigoted, offensive term "cunts" is fine. Anyone complaining about getting called a "cunt" doesn't dislike the term, they just want to dismiss and mock the jerks calling them that...

That's ridiculous. People who call women "cunts" are trying to verbally intimidate them through gendered, offensive references. And the same is true with people who label others "mansplainers." They're just offensive namecallers, trying to use sexual imagery to shame someone into shutting up, to demonstrate that they will go further in a conflict, that they have less to lose, and dare them to push back.

Look, I kind of understand where you're coming from, tptacek. I've read a lot of the same social theory as you in grad school. I've read a lot of your writings here and elsewhere. And I object to mainstream society in a big way, too. And I object to a lot of the tech scene as well, from the huge bets on stupid tech to the path of tech from research to military to police to consumer.

But take this from someone who wants to see you succeed: You're flipping out and not being persuasive. You're relying too much on trying to overwhelm people with big words from the literature and failing to communicate. You're letting yourself get triggered and losing the ability to relate to those who disagree with you and see two or more simultaneous perspectives in your mind at once. You're moving into all black and white territory, but you know reality isn't like that.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by tptacek on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @05:41PM (#12747948)
Once again: the word "patronize" means literally the same thing as "mansplain". It doesn't just have the same connotation. "Mansplain" is essentially the Newspeak version of "patronize".

But nobody is infuriated by "patronize", either its meaning or its clear connotation, because "patronize" is mainstream standard written English, and thus presents no good opportunities to use otherization to deflect criticism.

I don't know why you think I've been "triggered", but I assure you that I spent the next 4 minutes after writing that comment drawing a Trogdor-shaped United States to illustrate on Twitter one of Hillary Clinton's proposed campaign slogans, and I remember my emotional state during that effort far better than I do picking apart the dumb comment I replied to. But: I do appreciate the concern.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by diydsp on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @06:27PM (#12748250)
What's this about Newspeak: In my experience Newspeak was a dialect of language dictated by the illegitimate power structure to prevent the accidental communication of truthful expression which could undermine its authority.

When you say "mansplain" is the Newspeak version of "patronize," that would make the gender-less "patronize" the unspeakable, but truthful expression...

...Yet it would upset the illegitimate authority to say "patronize," so the powers require us to use "mansplain" to not reveal the underlying, genderless truth?

I think I relate to Winston Smith simply wanting a peaceful Red Barchetta cabin in the forest!

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by tptacek on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @06:37PM (#12748320)
You may have "Newspeak" confused with "Doublespeak" (or I may have denuded Newspeak of its political goals). Isn't the word "doublespeak" itself an instance of Newspeak (or Basic English)? Replacing a latinization with a pair of simpler words, for instance, is what has happened in the conversion from "patronize" to "mansplain".

At any rate: the two words, patronize and mansplain, mean the same thing, so feigning offense at the gendering of "mansplain" is a pitiful way to build an argument.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by makomk on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:19PM (#12748572)
Newspeak was a political tool that was supposed to limit society's freedom of though by making ideas that went against the ruling power's goals literally impossible to express. Think about how that might apply here - by replacing the genderless "patronize" with the gendered "mansplain"[1], we embed the idea that this is something only men do to women into the language itself. (Obviously this doesn't make it impossible to criticize other kinds of patronizing behaviour, just harder than with this kind - Newspeak was a fictional conceit.)

[1] And yes, one is clearly gendered while the other one isn't. If someone claimed that you couldn't describe a woman as "patronizing" because that term only applied to men, this would seem like nonsense to any English speaker, whereas "mansplaining" was explicitly coined as something only men could do to women.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by tptacek on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:29PM (#12748633)
"Patronize" is not genderless.
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by jimmywanger on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:34PM (#12749007)
How is that?

Currently is it. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/patronize

Nowhere in there is patronize used in a gender based way at all.

A patron is simply somebody who supports you and bankrolls you. Christopher Columbus had a female patron.

Or are you grasping at straws here? Even m-w lists a male gendered meaning for the root word patron at the eighth definition. From m-w (http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/patron): 8: the chief male officer in some fraternal lodges having both men and women members

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by oska on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:46PM (#12749071)
The ultimate root of patronize is the Latin pater meaning ‘father’.
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by jimmywanger on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:36PM (#12749277)
Yes. Words change meanings over time/society. Why are you debating etymology? Patronize no longer has a gendered meaning. You would ask a women whether or not she patronized a store, for instance.

If you're a small business owner, you'd equally thank a woman or a man for their patronage, or yell at them equally for them to stop patronizing your employees.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by tptacek on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:20AM (#12751909)
The word has two meanings, and the one you invoke in your latter example is gendered. You would be yelling at your women customers for talking down to your employees as if from a father to a child. Which is fine; women can act like obnoxious men, too.

Not only is Latin mostly gendered and the Latin root of this word clearly male, but the female root "matron" is also a common root for English words.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by mzw_mzw on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:12PM (#12757924)
>The word has two meanings, and the one you invoke in your latter example is gendered.

Oh, tptacek, maybe you need to go outside and get some air. You really think that people are leafing through unabridged Latin dictionaries looking for ways to be subtly sexist?

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by tptacek on Friday October 21, 2016 @08:03AM (#12759661)
No, that is not at all what I am saying. I am not criticizing the word "patronizing".
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by diydsp on Thursday October 20, 2016 @09:56AM (#12752188)
Well I found this at wikipedia:

Newspeak is the fictional language in the novel Nineteen Eighty-Four, written by George Orwell. It is a controlled language created by the totalitarian state Oceania as a tool to limit freedom of thought, and concepts that pose a threat to the regime such as freedom, self-expression, individuality, and peace. [1]

It matches my definition very well:

"In my experience Newspeak was a dialect of language dictated by the illegitimate power structure to prevent the accidental communication of truthful expression which could undermine its authority."

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by dubyah on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:16PM (#12748907)
I thought the problem was that in the current usage(or misusage), it's a quick, snappy, gendered means of shutting someone up.

Even in the original intended usage of the term, patronizing and mansplaining aren't quite the same; despite roughly analogous root words, mansplaining includes a degree of gender essentialism that patronizing lacks.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by eropple on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @02:01PM (#12746103)
I am a man. "Mansplaining" isn't degrading. It's the recognition of a common facet in Western society where men assume that women aren't competent in mathematical and technical fields at first glance and presume without cause that they need it explained to them by those men. And that first glance is because they're women. It is not, unless you get shitty when called on it, some deep character flaw. Societal inculcation is a thing and it's hard to shake without being confronted with it.

I've seen plenty of people apologize when called on it and avoid making that assumption a second time. Recognize it, do better, move on.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by jimmywanger on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @07:35PM (#12748674)
> men assume that women aren't competent in mathematical and technical fields at first glance and presume without cause that they need it explained to them by those men.

Wow, what a minefield.

I don't expect anybody to be competent in mathematical or technical fields, so I generally start from the beginning until somebody says "Oh, I already worked with this particular tech stack this is the problem I can't figure out."

Immediately attributing that to the fact that they're women and the main thing they need is explanation, by a man, that's a huge leap.

Calling it Mansplaining is horrible. Like somebody else pointed out, condescending is the gender neutral way to say it, and calling it mansplaing indicates it's problem exclusive to men. Can Caitlyn Jenner mansplain? Can Oprah mansplain?

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by ihsw on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @02:22PM (#12746295)
Just call it condescension, making it into a gendered term is bigotry. Tolerating the usage of that term is acknowledgement that bigotry towards men is acceptable.

The fact that you are a man is irrelevant, I'm also a man and I find the acceptance of bigotry towards men to be abhorrent.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @03:56PM (#12747143)
Recognizing and calling out a particular common gendered pattern of condescension isn't bigotry toward anyone.
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by chillingeffect on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @05:14PM (#12747731)
...Implying women don't also talk for long streams wherein men are expected to listen to them.

Any socially astute man knows that women benefit from being listened to in sustained streams-of-thought speech. It's commonly called "processing." And if you're not doing it currently, then all the women in your life, from your family to friends to lovers, will be happy when you start. It's a way of showing women respect and demonstrating that you're listening to them and take them seriously.

So both men and women will talk for long paragraphs. It's only recently that a small, vocal subset of women decided to genderize it with the term "mansplaining" to mock and dismiss men. It was kind of funny when it was just a joke, but now that it's used to shout down men and these women are forgetting their own propensity for endured, one-sided conversation, it's not funny anymore.

But secretly, I'm happy when I hear a woman use the phrase "mansplaining." It's a signal that helps me decisively eliminate her from my social life. Anyone using that term as anything more than a small side joke doesn't deserve my attention.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @05:27PM (#12747833)
No, not implying that at all; thats not even rationally connected to what you are responding to.
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by chillingeffect on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @05:45PM (#12747974)
Yes, it is. Please set aside your need to be right and think about it:

Women talk for long streams. If men were to refer to it as "womensplaining," it would be condescending.

Men talk for long streams. When the small, vocal subset of women refer to it as "mansplaining," it is condescending.

The error in logic is to say that it's a gendered pattern of condescension. Because both genders do it, it only becomes gendered when you forget that women do it, too.

Who is the Zen master who makes the grass green? It is you. You make the grass green.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by eropple on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @05:51PM (#12748014)
Mansplaining has nothing to do with "talk[ing] for long streams". It has to do with what is being said and why. Mansplaining is when there is an assumption of ignorance on the part of a woman that can only be rectified (and must be rectified) by a man educating her on a topic, where that assumption of ignorance stems from gendered biases. And it does happen. And the reverse does not happen in any serious proportion--in no small part because of the social conditioning where women would be considered pushy and bitchy for doing so, but where men are considered leaders and experts for it.

You've failed to even grasp the topic, and yet you would condescend towards dragonwriter (one of the wisest, most insightful posters around here on a wide variety of topics) about his "need to be right" while inventing an argument out of whole cloth. Tremendous.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by smallnamespace on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:00PM (#12749142)
> Mansplaining is when there is an assumption of ignorance on the part of a woman that can only be rectified (and must be rectified) by a man educating her on a topic, where that assumption of ignorance stems from gendered biases

So 'mansplaining' goes beyond simply noting a man's condescending behavior, but suggests that the only motivation is sexism. Is the evidence sufficient to prove the charge?

Maybe the man is simply rude towards everyone; maybe the woman is ignorant on the topic; maybe the guy was having a bad day.

The problem with the word is the logic that it implies. Soon we'll be finding that if a man is ever rude to a woman in public for any reason, he is automatically labeled a sexist. I'm not sure that's a very useful, or fair heuristic.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by hephaistos on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @06:38PM (#12748327)
On topics that were traditionally feminine, like housework, childcare or cooking, women can be really condescending.

I still remember the tone used by the nurse when she "taught" to my brother how to change the diapers of his newborn. I've never seen someone that condescending.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by mzw_mzw on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:08PM (#12757915)
It's unfortunate that you have such a strong desire to use clearly sexist language, to the extent that you'll write at such length defending it. This is your right, of course, but please keep it off HN, which is an inclusive site.
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by adrienne on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:18AM (#12758303)
Speaking as a woman in tech, HN is PRETTY FUCKING FAR from an "inclusive site". It's repulsive, which is why i mostly stay the fuck away from it. 4chan is at least honest about being a cesspool.
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by mzw_mzw on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:30AM (#12758344)
What makes you think it's not inclusive?
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by eropple on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @03:54PM (#12747125)
Please define "bigotry" and explain, in very if-A-then-B form, exactly how "mansplain" is either an example of bigotry or encourages such.

If you believe that words mean things--which, even in today's climate, is a generally accepted position--this might be a difficult one for you.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by jimmywanger on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @08:18PM (#12748925)
Mansplain means taking a neutral world, "explain", and associating it with both gender and a negative connotation. It also implies that only men can be condescending in this way, and that it's impossible for a woman to do the same.

Would it be all right to say that somebody is "whitesplaining" or "gooksplaining" or "blacksplaining"?

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @03:57PM (#12747160)
The usual use of "mansplaining" isn't limited to scientific and technical fields, in fact, I'd argue that is neither the original nor most common domain in which "mansplaining" was and is called out.
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by eropple on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @04:52PM (#12747564)
Oh, sure--they're just where people I know have most egregiously run into it.
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by RangerScience on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @02:05PM (#12746151)
Mansplaining = commisseration + condescension

Ironically, I learned valuable psychological hacks from manspreading: When you feel down, spread yourself out and take up a bunch of space. It's really empowering!

> The goal should be to empower women, not degrade men. Yes, but - Mansplaining is meant to point out situations when men are degrading women. So it's not about degrading men, it's about degrading assholes, although yeah, the term is inherently gender'd.

Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women? by ihsw on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @02:24PM (#12746314)
Then call it what it is -- condescension.

Do we label Asians that cheat on tests in college as "chinks"? No! That's awful and bald-faced racism, we just call them cheaters with low moral standards.