Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women?
by smallnamespace on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @09:00PM
(#12749142)
> Mansplaining is when there is an assumption of ignorance on the part of a woman that can only be rectified (and must be rectified) by a man educating her on a topic, where that assumption of ignorance stems from gendered biases
So 'mansplaining' goes beyond simply noting a man's condescending behavior, but suggests that the only motivation is sexism. Is the evidence sufficient to prove the charge?
Maybe the man is simply rude towards everyone; maybe the woman is ignorant on the topic; maybe the guy was having a bad day.
The problem with the word is the logic that it implies. Soon we'll be finding that if a man is ever rude to a woman in public for any reason, he is automatically labeled a sexist. I'm not sure that's a very useful, or fair heuristic.
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women?
by hephaistos on Wednesday October 19, 2016 @06:38PM
(#12748327)
On topics that were traditionally feminine, like housework, childcare or cooking, women can be really condescending.
I still remember the tone used by the nurse when she "taught" to my brother how to change the diapers of his newborn. I've never seen someone that condescending.
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women?
by mzw_mzw on Thursday October 20, 2016 @11:08PM
(#12757915)
It's unfortunate that you have such a strong desire to use clearly sexist language, to the extent that you'll write at such length defending it. This is your right, of course, but please keep it off HN, which is an inclusive site.
Re:Why Do These Straight Men Want Nothing to Do with Women?
by adrienne on Friday October 21, 2016 @01:18AM
(#12758303)
Speaking as a woman in tech, HN is PRETTY FUCKING FAR from an "inclusive site". It's repulsive, which is why i mostly stay the fuck away from it. 4chan is at least honest about being a cesspool.
You've failed to even grasp the topic, and yet you would condescend towards dragonwriter (one of the wisest, most insightful posters around here on a wide variety of topics) about his "need to be right" while inventing an argument out of whole cloth. Tremendous.