You can listen to the explosion here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I6isMuPfxcI
I hear birds chirping. No rifles.
update: yes, I know Elon mentioned the 'quieter bang' sound and it could well be related, but it doesn't sound anything like the crack of a rifle round.
Surely sensors would have picked up the impact a .50 makes. Although I don't know why one would need a .50. It's a heavy round with lots of drop and it's not like the rocket is armored. From what I've read of the relative fragility of rockets you could get by with a very small round in just the right spot.
Also "just the right spot" could be huge on a rocket. The thing is as wide as a barn.
Although I also think sabotage such a weak theory.
https://youtu.be/maRTEzlSBLk?t=1m8s
You can hear a distinct and odd metallic noise just before the explosion.
Which would be very consistent with a bursting tank within the rocket.
There's a very audible boom-like sound at 0:06.
I've not heard of subsonic rounds being used at distances over five hundred yards, and even that is a very difficult shot for that low velocity.
The engines were built just as the USSR was collapsing. The engines use a better grade materials and it uses a more efficient combined pumping system 20% better.
The engines were supposed to be scrapped but one of the guys in management diverted them to a warehouse.
The RD-180 in question, by contrast, is newly manufactured specifically for the Atlas rockets.
Thanks.
We have one baby (she is almost 7 months old now) and my brain feels completely useless. I can't even imagine twins.
Being a Pershing crewman was actually quite high-risk.
Leaving before anyone could notice you would be a bit more of a problem.
A place like the Cape is tough because you have many, many contractors and commercial users along with multiple civilian and military fed personnel and even academics. It's likely full of people trying to get their work done, not playing "if you see something say something."
How secure is the Cape? Anyone got any experience?
So you sit. Hope they don't have dogs, wait for dark, then exfiltrate. Hell, there are even ways to counteract dogs.
How many former snipers do you think there are in civilian life? How many smart rednecks who can shoot well enough to hit a rocket-sized target at 300 yards? (hell, I'm in that category...)
Somewhere in the union of those two sets, there may exist somebody with sufficient motivation to pull something like this, and enough spare time to prepare well enough to succeed.
I'm not saying that this is what happened, but I am saying that it's far from impossible.
A bullet hitting the rocket would cause ripples in the sheet metal that ought to be visible.
What a job that would be--Elon tells you to get a slo-mo camera and start target shooting LOX at sniper distances "for research".
All you would really have to do is get fuel dripping out along the surface to a point where it would ignite from heat from the engine exhaust.
Thanks for replying--I would have gone to my grave not even considering the fact that rocket fuel has oxidizers mixed in, but the search you just sent me on set me straight.
Before they started supercooling the LOX, it was even easier because heat transfer into LOX tanks is conventionally managed by boil-off (in launchers without supercooled propellants, latent heat keeps the liquid at a stable temperature and a trickle refills the tank continuously until a minute or two before launch).
If you hit the rocket at all, something will fail, very possibly in a manner that will either be noticed before launch or discovered by a subsequent investigation. A .50 caliber bullet hole with its edges facing inward will not be missed by investigators, if there's anything left to investigate at all.
So, no. Nobody shot the rocket with a sniper rifle, because that would be stupid. They would be very likely to get caught, or to cause detectable damage that would obviously not be SpaceX's fault.
Also black ops would never do the same trick twice :)
"A large stationary target like a rocket is a simple shot for a sniper with a 50 cal rifle from a mile away. . . It was something discussed 30+ years ago: to have Special Forces snipers punch holes in the missiles on mobile launchers that would not be discovered until preparing for launch. Instead of destroying the system the enemy would have wasted time and effort moving to a launch location only to find out that they were incapable of launching."
and
"What the article doesn't mention is that ULA buys its engines from Russia and is a vital part of the Russian rocket program. As a part of ULA's activities, there are Russian engineers with military training in the country legally right now. "