News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by danielrm26 on Sunday September 11, 2016 @06:13PM (#12476015)
This will surprise nobody on Hacker News.

The allure of startups isn't a guaranteed 20% more than a regular company's salary; it's the possibility of 1000% more.

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by swampthinker on Sunday September 11, 2016 @06:24PM (#12476049)
It's like the lottery, except you can influence your odds a bit more.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by isoos on Sunday September 11, 2016 @06:29PM (#12476066)
It would be interesting to see what the expected outcome's distribution is with buying lottery tickets for $X/month vs. doing a startup (and potentially earn less by $X/month than one could have had at a larger corporation).
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by elliotec on Sunday September 11, 2016 @07:03PM (#12476173)
Interesting. If I spent 20% of my salary on lottery tickets, how good would my chances be of winning vs cashing in my stock at a startup that goes public in which I made 20% less salary? And what would the payout differences be?
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by mbesto on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:45AM (#12477245)
More interesting would be to take the delta between a startup salary and a Google salary and invest it in SV real estate. I'd easily bet real estate would net higher returns.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by vasilipupkin on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:28PM (#12476627)
The startup deal is a much better deal than lottery tickets. If you can get a 1% ownership stake and we assume a 10% chance of a 100 million dollar startup, the expected value of that grant is 100k. The expected value of buying lottery tickets with 20% of your salary is close to zero You should also consider the fact that if you are an early employee in a startup, your future expected payout is at least in part a function of your efforts
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by msandford on Sunday September 11, 2016 @11:16PM (#12476970)
You don't get to say that the EV is close to zero in one case, but not in the other. 20k/year (dollars spent) * 1/100mm (odds of winning) * 100mm (jackpot) = 20k/year

If you get a 1% ownership stake for a 20% salary reduction (per year) and you have to stay there for say, 4-5 years in order to get that 100k payout then you're looking at numbers on very similar terms.

I understand why people need to be convinced that their odds are much better in startups than in the lottery. But wanting to believe something to be true and it being true aren't the same thing.

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by bendbro on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:49PM (#12476707)
Even given the generous 10% success rate, and 1% equity comp, you need to factor in dilution, time till maturity, whether the company even goes public, and below market salary/benefits.

After that, I'll bet that in the vast majority of cases your maximum upside is significantly less than what you'd have with the standard bigco package.

Edit: not to day there isn't legitimate reason for joining a startup: it's just if the work isn't super interesting, you're getting tricked

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by sidlls on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:08AM (#12477544)
Is 10% a reasonable value for that chance? Is 1% a reasonable value for the ownership stake? What about dilution and payout rights?

A reasonable expected value of a lottery ticket is directly computable: jackpot times probability of a winning set. I'm not so sure the same is true for the value of startup employment.

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by dragonwriter on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:13AM (#12477566)
Lottery tickets' jackpot is usually determined in part by sales of tickets for that drawing, and a winning combination wins a divided pot in the case of multiple winners (the probability of which depends again on sales of tickets for that drawing.)

So, no, you can't, at the time of buying a ticket, actually calculate more than a guess of they parameters you cite for determining its expected value.

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by sidlls on Monday September 12, 2016 @02:50AM (#12477699)
The published jackpot is a very accurate value to use, and the probability of being the sole winner is a very reasonable probability to use. The actual expected value is not going to differ from that product by enough to matter most of the time.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by gdilla on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:56PM (#12476735)
and accelerate your learning/career path a bit. Big companies with big company politics tend not to reward talented 20y/rs like they should with promotion, raises, and bonuses. But being promoted or growing in a startup has a return when you job hop, at least when you're starting your career.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by nommm-nommm on Sunday September 11, 2016 @11:50PM (#12477065)
Not my experience at all!
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by vollmond on Sunday September 11, 2016 @07:45PM (#12476301)
And you're (hopefully) working on something more interesting and more self-directed than you might at a typical job.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by tdb7893 on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:09PM (#12476569)
How many engineers get 1000% more? I thought it was the founders and investors that got more.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by Hytosys on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:48AM (#12477253)
Yep, you're right. There's a belligerent, Randian dream behind that 1000% nonsense that always seems to be accompanied by some far-fetched narrative of climbing the ladder.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by susan_hall on Sunday September 11, 2016 @06:25PM (#12476055)
"not 20% more but possibly 1000% more" -- you are implying that the median startup employee makes less but it is worth it because of the big payoff for the lucky ones. That is, you imply that the median might be lower, but the average pay is higher. But that is not what the article is saying. The article is saying that average payoff is lower. In other words, being a startup employee is irrational the same way the lottery is irrational -- total payouts are lower overall.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by fsaneq2 on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:55PM (#12476523)
This entirely depends on what utility you assign to a given amount of money.

For many people who are well-enough off to consider having a good risk floor, the utility of a non-life-changing amount of extra money is nearly zero. It is only once you get into the high jackpots that it gets interesting.

Depending on your situation it can be completely rational to play the lottery or be a startup employee.

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by thoman23 on Sunday September 11, 2016 @06:32PM (#12476073)
Both the lottery and working at a startup are rational bets if you believe the value of money is non linear.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by rlanday on Sunday September 11, 2016 @06:41PM (#12476100)
No, many people believe the value of money in non-linear but most of those people believe that the marginal utility of each additional dollars diminishes as your wealth increases, rather than increasing. I.e. even if you might earn more money on average at a startup (which the article claims isn’t the case), it still wouldn’t be worth it because it’s better to earn a decent salary from a big company with high probability. Who seriously believes that the marginal value of money increases as you have more?
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by zachsnow on Sunday September 11, 2016 @07:10PM (#12476190)
Interesting that while I agree that the marginal value decreases I also feel (literally feel) that somehow having say an order of magnitude more would somehow be qualitatively different (and better). Funny to see my own biases play tricks (?) on me!
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by djur on Sunday September 11, 2016 @07:28PM (#12476236)
Paradoxically, I think that you feel that way _because_ of the decreasing marginal value of money. Superfluous income is disposable income, and spending money in a way entirely of your choosing is pleasurable.

Especially if you're already making enough to get by, the value of the money you're already making is "priced in" to your subconscious analysis. Thus, the next order of magnitude of income really is qualitatively different.

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by superuser2 on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:29PM (#12476437)
> Superfluous income is disposable income

Only if you don't rent a nicer/closer apartment. (OTOH, lower commute times are associated with happiness).

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by zachsnow on Sunday September 11, 2016 @10:36PM (#12476846)
Of course, this is a good interpretation! Cheers.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by phamilton on Sunday September 11, 2016 @07:38PM (#12476269)
I think one could define a metric in which average result is higher for startup employees than for BigCo employees.

Someone with $100M has access to politics/investments/etc that most people earning $250k/yr don't. So while the average monetary payout is smaller (1% chance at $100M is equal to a 50% chance at 2M), average social currency is much higher. (1% chance at the social power that comes with $100M vs 0% chance in the BigCo job).

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by jwatte on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:42AM (#12477236)
You'll only make $100M of you're a founder of one of the very few really large, successful companies. It's a 1 in 10,000 chance or worse, not 1 in 10. (And mean value of $100M at 0.01% right now is only $10k)
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by arcticfox on Sunday September 11, 2016 @07:51PM (#12476326)
Unless you think that marginal value decreases at quite an exponential rate, an order of magnitude more would probably be noticeably better. That's a huge difference (e.g. the difference between minimum wage and well-to-do, between well-to-do and rich).

Until maybe ~$100M net worth, for me personally, I think an order of magnitude difference would indeed be qualitatively different / better.

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by orangecat on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:42PM (#12476481)
Who seriously believes that the marginal value of money increases as you have more?

There are plausible arguments that money can often have increasing marginal utility for poor people. Google "bee sting theory of poverty".

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by ojbyrne on Sunday September 11, 2016 @08:53PM (#12476516)
That's not really the relevant range for this discussion.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by jwatte on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:39AM (#12477228)
With $1M net worth (expect $40k/year annuity,) you'd have to live frugally to be truly independent, especially of you have a family. With $5M net worth, you could live well, independently.

A 9-5 is unlikely to let you save $1M, much less $5M, unless you're high level in a big company. If you're very early in a big success, you can get there.

However, in many ways, employee 15 and up is the worst of both worlds. Small stock grant, sub market salary and benefits.

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by AstralStorm on Monday September 12, 2016 @01:44PM (#12481865)
Caveat lector: author is talking about USA.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by arcticfox on Sunday September 11, 2016 @07:46PM (#12476304)
I also believe that the marginal utility of additional dollars decreases, but I prefer the startup value prop for me. My personal calculation is something like this, where "value" is some personal average of marginal utility:

Big co: $50k extra from $100k -> $150k = $50k * 1 value / dollar * 100% = 50k value

Startup: $10M extra from $100k -> $10M = $10M * 0.25 value / dollar = 2.5M value * 5% chance of success = 125k value

There's also the intangible value of having hope for big success.

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by thedufer on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:12PM (#12476587)
The entire point of the article in question is that startup employees make less on average, so forgive me if I'm a bit skeptical of your claim that the startup job will pay on average a full order of magnitude more.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by ddlatham on Sunday September 11, 2016 @06:44PM (#12476112)
That depends on whether you believe it is sub-linear or super-linear. Many people treat the value of money as sub-linear (e.g. better to go from $0 to $50k, than to go from $100k to $150k). If that's the case, then the riskier, lottery style model would not be rational if money is the only value in working for a startup.

However, most startup employees I know make the choice for more than just the direct monetary rewards. There's the culture, the potential influence and impact, and several other potential reasons.

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by Retric on Sunday September 11, 2016 @07:23PM (#12476224)
The idea is once your making ~80k extra money does not make a big difference assuming your single. Until you hit an extra ~2,000k which let's you stop working.

I take the opposite approach where a low stress 40 hour a week job can be pleasant. I have a minimal commute and spend less than 1/3 of my waking life at work or getting there. Further I mostly enjoy my time there. I did the high pay high stress job and it's just not worth it, but taking a year off showed that's not so interesting either.

Live to be 70 and a 40 hour week to a normal retirement is ~19% of your time. As long as it's not bad there are just other thing to focus on.

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by ux-app on Sunday September 11, 2016 @09:08PM (#12476567)
> is ~19% of your time.

Let's not count the 8 hours you sleep. That gives us 8 hours out of 16 spent working. Also your employer isn't paying you for your commute let's count that at 1 hour per day this comes out to 9 hours /16 @ 5 days per week

45 hours out of 112 waking hours in a week spent working (and commuting). That's if you're lucky enough to work at a place that allows you to leave after "only" 8 hours worked without raising eyebrows.

That's 40% of your premium waking hours devoted to earning those precious clams.

Let's not kid ourselves. Your employer gets the best hours of the day and the best years of your life.

Work sucks.

Re:Startup employees don't earn more by brianwawok on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:00AM (#12477100)
Hah but what is the flip side? You can give no hours to work and be stuck in a park bench. You get more prime hours, but is your quality of life better?
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by toomuchtodo on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:21AM (#12477166)
A good used sail boat is about $60k. You can live very well on it for about $15k/year. That's not a park bench; that's freedom, which is priceless.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by brianwawok on Monday September 12, 2016 @03:30PM (#12482883)
Not sure my dogs would like that.
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by toomuchtodo on Tuesday September 13, 2016 @12:35AM (#12485648)
Liveaboards have dogs onboard without much issue, unless they're frequently transiting other countries and having to clear customs (ie your pet needs to be quarantined for 30 days).
Re:Startup employees don't earn more by jwatte on Monday September 12, 2016 @12:35AM (#12477215)
Or if you're looking for variance rather than mean. You can't beat the beta of a lottery ticket!