News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by awinder on Friday September 09, 2016 @10:11AM (#12462341)
Why is Facebook a media outlet as opposed to, say, a private gathering place like a mall or movie theatre?
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by paganel on Friday September 09, 2016 @10:21AM (#12462441)
Facebook has become a de-facto political "agora" for the politicians and high-Government officials from my country (I live in Eastern Europe). More exactly, that's where now they first express their views on current political, social and economics affairs affecting my country. Nowadays I would say that most of the important stuff first gets posted on FB, and only then it gets re-published by the local media (whatever it's left of it at this point).

So, even if I would want to "get off" FB and decide to ignore it completely then I would just have an "inferior" experience as a citizen of my country, i.e. I would not have first-hand account on what's shaping the things around me. It's not that I like what Facebook has become, but there's nothing that I can do to change it at this point.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by wyager on Friday September 09, 2016 @11:26AM (#12463070)
So once your platform gets popular enough, the government can tell you what to do with it? Why? It's not Facebook's fault that politicians started using it.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by jpetso on Friday September 09, 2016 @12:18PM (#12463610)
Because with great power comes great responsibility, and companies like to cherry-pick only one out of two. It's in the interest of society that when something becomes mainstream enough to be considered "infrastructure" - something with so little competition that ignoring or bypassing it is infeasible given the state of the market - that this infrastructure works within frameworks that we've built and refined over centuries.

Rent-seeking is bad, it's facilitated by ownership of too large a share of the market. In return for allowing Facebook to leverage its size and influence for rent-seeking behavior, we as a society, a.k.a. the government representing us, have the right and responsibility to set the ground rules for what we get in return.

That's not about fault or entitlement, it's about how we can continue to uphold the values that are important to us. Free speech and the ability to publicly disagree are a crucial part of that. If your platform gets popular enough that strengthening or suppressing your voice has a material impact, profit and shareholder interests can't be the only thing that decides how things are supposed to work. There's a lot more at stake here.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by curried_haskell on Friday September 09, 2016 @12:21PM (#12463636)
Exactly yes. Once your platform becomes this popular, you wield real power over human society. And society should absolutely start to dictate to Facebook what it can and cannot do to prevent it from abusing its power. How many times do we need to go over this?

Any organization, when it becomes sufficiently large, essentially becomes a government.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by wonder_er on Friday September 09, 2016 @02:23PM (#12464792)
>And society should absolutely start to dictate to Facebook what it can and cannot do to prevent it from abusing its power.

We have no good mechanism to prevent the government from abusing its power.

Those here defending FB are not arguing that FB can do no wrong, they are arguing that fixing a problem _with another broken system_ is not an improvement, and is, in fact, a step backwards.

I can opt out of FB, and I have. Facebook exerts no influence over me, compared to the influence the government exerts over me.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by dredmorbius on Friday September 09, 2016 @05:04PM (#12466035)
The problems of power abuse and effective communications are ancient ones. There's nothing that prevents private individuals or corporations from abusing power either, and there's a very long history of them having done just that.

Government, for better or worse, is a vehicle for channeling and aggregating power, in a way that at best benefits society as a whole, expresses the preferences of the majority, and respects the rights of the minority. It's far from perfect. But it's better than most alternatives.

Facebook is granted rights by governments, ultimately also to benefit the public at large. Facebook is not itself a government, though it transacts the online communications of a population larger than all but the very largest countries.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by wyager on Friday September 09, 2016 @12:49PM (#12463929)
> Any organization, when it becomes sufficiently large, essentially becomes a government.

Remind me when Facebook used violence to enforce laws or take taxes?

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by wonder_er on Friday September 09, 2016 @02:20PM (#12464767)
Along these lines, the argument says "Facebook is large, and should therefore be subjected to regulation".

Government is far larger than Facebook, and far more insulated from the people than is Facebook. I can't imagine why we extend trust to the government to fix a situation where we don't trust facebook.

It's all run by people, with their own competing goals.

And lets not forget that facebook could collapse overnight if enough people decided to stop using it. I don't think a population could exert that level of influence over a government.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by dTal on Saturday September 10, 2016 @02:43PM (#12470400)
>Government is... far more insulated from the people than is Facebook

Is it? Facebook doesn't hold elections. It seems entirely unaccountable to me, with no system of checks and balances to reign it in.

>facebook could collapse overnight if enough people decided to stop using it. I don't think a population could exert that level of influence over a government

They could and do, all the time. See: any successful rebellion ever. See also: the collapse of the Soviet Union.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by dredmorbius on Friday September 09, 2016 @05:06PM (#12466051)
Any given API change, content promotion or censorship, freebooting support (or restrictions), represents a taking of usefruct or allocation amongst various parties. With little or no recourse to them.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by wyager on Friday September 09, 2016 @10:36PM (#12467368)
> With little or no recourse to them.

Did those parties enter into a contract with Facebook that said that Facebook owed recourse if they changed or censored something? Evidently not.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by dredmorbius on Saturday September 10, 2016 @05:13PM (#12470902)
Does the victim of pollution, or of a highway rerouting, or a relocation of a major traffic draw for brick-and-mortar foot traffic, have any contractual claim to their previously-enjoyed benefit?

Power and rights are far more about the ability to effectively press a claim than specifically detailed binding pacts.

The matter was whether or not Facebook could effect a taking. Not the rights of recourse of others. You're dragging goalposts.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by Daishiman on Friday September 09, 2016 @12:18PM (#12463604)
Yes. You become a medium of public discourse with network effects. That seems perfectly fine to regulate.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by wyager on Friday September 09, 2016 @12:48PM (#12463917)
I disagree that anything on Facebook is "public" in the sense of "public ownership". Facebook is a private platform. Just because things are (maybe) publicly visible doesn't mean they're public property. Should the government be able to force people to put up or take down posters in public-facing Windows?
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by joelberman on Friday September 09, 2016 @02:50PM (#12465041)
If I buy or rent space for a billboard I am not allowed to put anything I wish on it. That is no different than putting a poster in a public-facing window. It gets more interesting when a website in one country is offensive to another country.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by Daishiman on Friday September 09, 2016 @02:56PM (#12465092)
I'm pretty sure that if you put a two-story tall porn image on your property it's not going to last long. I'm pretty sure that if you post a hugely racist message as big, or some other things, not matter how public that space will be, you'll run into some problem with the law whether at local or federal level.

Whether you're a private or public platform here is not as relevant as the fact that is is a public forum, it is practicing certain forms of censorship, and it a medium of information. Other platforms get regulations applied to them in many respects too.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by dredmorbius on Friday September 09, 2016 @05:08PM (#12466061)
Governments do in fact regulate posting of notices, including both commercial and political speech, routinely. This includes both forbidding specific types of notices in some instances, and compelling them in others.

As only one of literally millions of examples: http://ij.org/case/gilliland-et-al-v-city-of-dallas/

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by visarga on Friday September 09, 2016 @12:39PM (#12463820)
> once your platform gets popular enough, the government can tell you what to do with it

I'd say there is considerable public interest, yes. Facebook without the users is nothing, but the users without Facebook are the same society, just using another software.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by dTal on Friday September 09, 2016 @01:37PM (#12464388)
>the users without Facebook are the same society, just using another software

When the software shapes your interactions to the degree that Facebook does, I'm not so sure. You don't think Facebook has changed society?

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by awinder on Friday September 09, 2016 @02:07PM (#12464657)
I don't think Facebook has changed society in a way that isn't repeatable. It's a low risk to the system when google+, or any other competitor, could meaningfully take its place given enough pressure.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by zdkl on Friday September 09, 2016 @12:04PM (#12463470)
It's astounding so many people defend variants of 'power to the mighty'. Are you so naive you believe you are one of the mighty?
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by wyager on Friday September 09, 2016 @12:44PM (#12463877)
Huh? What are you talking about? I'm defending the right of everyone to be free of excessive government interference, whether it's an individual or a popular company.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by PhasmaFelis on Friday September 09, 2016 @03:06PM (#12465176)
It's never clear, with these arguments, why being oppressed by a corporation is better than being oppressed by a government.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by rm_-rf_slash on Friday September 09, 2016 @02:10PM (#12464677)
But you're totally ok with people having no right to be free of corporate interference?
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by lostlogin on Friday September 09, 2016 @12:04PM (#12463472)
They can tell you what to do with it and not use it too. This is the way it should be. Think of the harm that can be done in all sorts of abusive ways if there was no regulation of sites and services.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by sitkack on Friday September 09, 2016 @11:30AM (#12463116)
Yes.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by red_admiral on Friday September 09, 2016 @10:42AM (#12462660)
Facebook arguably has a monopoly position in the way that your local mall, movie theatre or newspaper does not.

If I don't like the Times, I can read the Guardian instead. If I don't like what's on at one cinema, I can go to another (granted this may be harder in a small town with only one).

Of course I can close my facebook account and move to diaspora, but then I'd lose everything from keeping in touch with my friends' latest accomplishments to the schedule of my local hiking club.

I already find if I'm away hiking for a weekend without internet access and couldn't be bothered to catch up on facebook on Monday morning because there's already a pile of e-mails to deal with, at coffee break it's like I've missed some important social information that everyone else knows, because team member A has done something and posted about it on facebook and everyone else has been liking and commenting on it, and everyone expects you to be up to date with this. Without a facebook account you may as well wear a badge that says "antisocial".

I personally think governments should regulate media outlets in proportion to their influence on people's lives. FB is the new IE.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by amscanne on Friday September 09, 2016 @11:24AM (#12463050)
TIL that I wear an antisocial badge.

It's perfectly possible to be happy and healthy without a Facebook account. You might lose out on one particular kind of "social" connection, but that doesn't mean you lose actual social connections. You just catch up with people in person, via telephone, via email, via chat, or a million other ways.

Personally, I don't really find the "social" information Facebook has to offer all that valuable. It's just a stream of trivia from extended not-really-friends.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by visarga on Friday September 09, 2016 @12:43PM (#12463867)
The parent poster just said that he felt like he missed on some important communication that he was expected to have been aware of. It's not possible to be happy without FB, it's not possible to be happy with FB either.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by wonder_er on Friday September 09, 2016 @02:28PM (#12464836)
It is so possible to be happy without FB. Just decide your life is fine, despite the occasional time lags in you discovering certain information.

FWIW, I deleted my FB account months ago, and my quality of life has gone up. If someone expects me to be available via FB, I give them my email address.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by red_admiral on Friday September 09, 2016 @04:51PM (#12465950)
Like not replying to urgent work e-mails at weekends, I wish I could do that too.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by wonder_er on Friday September 09, 2016 @02:26PM (#12464819)
>I personally think governments should regulate media outlets in proportion to their influence on people's lives. FB is the new IE.

IE went into a decades-long decline, because superior products came to market. No regulation required.

Who regulates the governments in proportion to their influence on people's lives?

I wish my government didn't bomb other countries. Can I stop paying taxes, so I can stop supporting the murder of people around the world?

You're asking an organization that backs its wishes with the threat of violence and jail to regulate an organization that lets you keep up with your friends hiking accomplishments.

Facebook could be irrelevant in five years. The laws you're asking to be implemented would be in place for another 100. Are you sure this is a good idea?

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by dragonwriter on Friday September 09, 2016 @02:30PM (#12464854)
> IE went into a decades-long decline, because superior products came to market, because superior products came to market. No regulation required.

The decline followed behavioral changes in response to regulatory action and ongoing litigation (even it began before the resolution of the litigation), so I'm not sure you can concluded from it that regulation was unnecessary to the outcome.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by shabda on Friday September 09, 2016 @10:20AM (#12462427)
Because it is becoming the predominant way people consume media. If it were only used by 10% of its current use, it shouldn't be, but it current levels it should.

As Stalin said "quantity has a quality all its own".

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by nine_k on Friday September 09, 2016 @11:01AM (#12462832)
Referencing Stalin in a media freedom context is, well, so liberal.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by throwanem on Friday September 09, 2016 @11:12AM (#12462934)
Stalin was quoting Napoleon. I'm not sure where you're going with this.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by pjc50 on Friday September 09, 2016 @10:24AM (#12462472)
.. both of which are subject to different kinds of government regulation. But Facebook is definitely a medium. In some ways like a telecom or transit operator.
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by kefka on Friday September 09, 2016 @12:12PM (#12463551)
There's a simple path to change things here.

Start criminally charging Facebook for every criminal act they fail to remove. If they're playing the censor, then they need to be punished when they fail in that role.

The other choice, is not to censor anything, other than by the requirements of the law. Like the telephone system does.

Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by awinder on Friday September 09, 2016 @12:11PM (#12463546)
Sure, but they're regulated differently, and the parent seemed to assume it should be regulated as a media outlet
Re:Facebook deletes Norway PM's post as 'napalm girl' row es... by dredmorbius on Friday September 09, 2016 @05:15PM (#12466103)
How might a government or society have an interest in, say, the content carried by a private radio station? What possible interest might there be?

http://rwandanstories.org/genocide/hate_radio.html