We have no good mechanism to prevent the government from abusing its power.
Those here defending FB are not arguing that FB can do no wrong, they are arguing that fixing a problem _with another broken system_ is not an improvement, and is, in fact, a step backwards.
I can opt out of FB, and I have. Facebook exerts no influence over me, compared to the influence the government exerts over me.
Government, for better or worse, is a vehicle for channeling and aggregating power, in a way that at best benefits society as a whole, expresses the preferences of the majority, and respects the rights of the minority. It's far from perfect. But it's better than most alternatives.
Facebook is granted rights by governments, ultimately also to benefit the public at large. Facebook is not itself a government, though it transacts the online communications of a population larger than all but the very largest countries.
Remind me when Facebook used violence to enforce laws or take taxes?
Government is far larger than Facebook, and far more insulated from the people than is Facebook. I can't imagine why we extend trust to the government to fix a situation where we don't trust facebook.
It's all run by people, with their own competing goals.
And lets not forget that facebook could collapse overnight if enough people decided to stop using it. I don't think a population could exert that level of influence over a government.
Is it? Facebook doesn't hold elections. It seems entirely unaccountable to me, with no system of checks and balances to reign it in.
>facebook could collapse overnight if enough people decided to stop using it. I don't think a population could exert that level of influence over a government
They could and do, all the time. See: any successful rebellion ever. See also: the collapse of the Soviet Union.
Did those parties enter into a contract with Facebook that said that Facebook owed recourse if they changed or censored something? Evidently not.
Power and rights are far more about the ability to effectively press a claim than specifically detailed binding pacts.
The matter was whether or not Facebook could effect a taking. Not the rights of recourse of others. You're dragging goalposts.
Any organization, when it becomes sufficiently large, essentially becomes a government.