News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google+ Redesigned by awesomerobot on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @12:53PM (#12391734)
What's it like to work on the Google+ team? are they all kind of blindly into it, or is there any sort of "yeah yeah, we know" there? I guess it's an exciting challenge maybe?
Re:Google+ Redesigned by Mahn on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @01:42PM (#12392185)
I mean, engineers are generally pretty smart people, I don't think anybody within the company thinks Google+ is killing it. But the thing is, I would imagine that if you work at Google you are going to work on "unsexy" products too. Working on Google+ today is probably not worse than say working on the Ads Platform or some random internal reporting tool. It's not super mega exciting, but it's a job and you get paid.
Re:Google+ Redesigned by cromwellian on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @07:24PM (#12394765)
Actually, I'd say that the infrastructure and tools work being done on Google+ for the Web are bleeding edge and some of the more exciting stuff being done, so it's not unsexy.

Look at how fast the new + loads, and open up the sources tab in your browser and look at how the JS is split. The way Closure Compiler is slicing up the app into tons of tiny individually loadable, optimized and minified chunks is very awesome. Google+ photos on the Web works the same way.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by ElijahLynn on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @10:27PM (#12395552)
Exactly, the new G+ loads pretty fast. Luke Wroblewski has also been heavily influencing the design of the new G+. Some of you may know him from his A Book Apart book, Mobile First.

Check out his G+ posts to see all the work the G+ team has been doing.

https://plus.google.com/+LukeWroblewski

Re:Google+ Redesigned by awesomerobot on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @01:49PM (#12392245)
Yes, of course I'm sure the actual work is valuable as an employee... and to say you're working on the Google+ team is to say you're working at Google, which is hugely valuable on its own.

I'm more wondering if there's some goal they're all working towards... what's their mission as a team? What's the morale like? Is there a lot of pressure on them to perform better?

Re:Google+ Redesigned by dmead on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @02:01PM (#12392353)
perform better how? the failures are in marketing and brand stuff. after all, google+ is really a me-too product reminiscent of late 90s/early 2000s microsoft. Facebook, for all it's faults pretty much spread word of mouth. everything about google+ seems forced.
Re:Google+ Redesigned by reitanqild on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @04:46PM (#12393751)
Some people around here (not saying you) have been shouting their hate against g+ so loud that many seems to be unaware that for some users, and quite a few it seems, google+ offers a much better experience than anything else.

You say: "everything about google+ seems forced."

I say: less forced than twitter, on g+ I can write my post just the way I want anf share with just the people I want.

Less forced than facebook: on g+ I can (and I do have) multiple personas, keeping my friends away from being bothered by my taste in music, future employers from being bothered by what I do on my spare time etc. Hint: nothing illegal, I would not trust it to protect me against a police investigation, but for the majority of us (I hope) we don't need that.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by user202020 on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @05:32PM (#12394091)
My view is that Google+ is like some smaller social media or messaging apps. If the people you care about are using it, then you'll use it. Some services, like Facebook, are completely dependent on everyone being on it. But others, like GroupMe in my case, are only used for what I like, and I don't care about the people that aren't on it because they aren't what I'm looking for (I know Facebook and GroupMe are different things.) I think Google+ works for the communities that exist on it, and they don't care about seeing the service become insanely popular. Okay, maybe they do, but it doesn't affect the enjoyment they already have.
Re:Google+ Redesigned by nol13 on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @06:11PM (#12394365)
The experience is great I'm sure, the problem is they messed up the launch dooming it probably forever, and that it's owned by google, which already knows enough about me.

Of course I'm also a paranoid who wouldn't use any social media remotely tied to real life anyway.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @09:05PM (#12395181)
Indeed, Google+ is just about the last Google product I still use regularly. Because I have no better options. I'm too wordy for Twitter, and Facebook is too private, it's hard to find new people there.
Re:Google+ Redesigned by dmead on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:45PM (#12409958)
Valid point. I have no use for twitter either.
Re:Google+ Redesigned by kirkdouglas on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @02:14PM (#12392476)
I am sure Google has way more "unsexier" projects than G+.
Re:Google+ Redesigned by sylvinus on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @02:05PM (#12392391)
Depends on your perspective! I think people working on the Ads Platform have much more interesting technical challenges than those working on G+, and that may be more appealing to many developers.
Re:Google+ Redesigned by mason55 on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @03:33PM (#12393170)
> Working on Google+ today is probably not worse than say working on the Ads Platform

Ads funds everything else that Google does. That is where the top engineers are working.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by euyyn on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @03:55PM (#12393337)
It's kind of unrelated. Case in point: Neither Jeff Dean nor Sanjay, the most prominent engineers, work on ads-related things.
Re:Google+ Redesigned by duiker101 on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @04:45PM (#12393740)
Doesn't make it exciting.(in relation to the product at least. Maybe working with them would be exciting just for the hell of it)
Re:Google+ Redesigned by BinaryIdiot on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @01:24PM (#12392024)
Initially Google+ was Google's big foray into social networking and while it gained users it never grew to the size of a Facebook, Twitter or even MySpace. But nowadays it's kept that capability along with bringing in aging Google features such as communities (it seems clear to me that communities will eventually only live in Google+).

From the outside looking in it looks to me like Google+ is going to be the hub in which users can interact with all of Google's properties that have a mechanism to work with and collaborate with other, public users. They likely still have millions of users.

In comparison to Facebook sure it's a massive failure. But I'm of the opinion that isn't an accurate nor useful comparison.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by drusepth on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @10:23AM (#12398496)
>Initially Google+ was Google's big foray into social networking and while it gained users it never grew to the size of a Facebook, Twitter or even MySpace.

It actually surpassed Twitter (and MySpace) pretty quickly after launch in terms of DAUs and MAUs, and remained the #2 network (behind FB) for as long as they released stats for it. I wouldn't be surprised if it still were #2 -- but they haven't released updated MAU counts* for a year or two.

[1] https://qph.ec.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-b597d8be03e46b4bd142d9...

[2] https://qph.ec.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-378c3027e991abd6b078dc...

[3] https://qph.ec.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-28c2654acfc9b8b950de17...

Also, since everyone always asks: their MAU counts separated "users" from "people posting in the G+ stream" -- the numbers above are for the latter.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by awesomerobot on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @01:45PM (#12392208)
> From the outside looking in it looks to me like Google+ is going to be the hub in which users can interact with all of Google's properties that have a mechanism to work with and collaborate with other, public users. They likely still have millions of users.

Yes, but we're talking maybe about .5% of all Google accounts actively use Google+... what's their goal at this point? 1%? is it a "if we build it, eventually they might come" scenario?

Re:Google+ Redesigned by BinaryIdiot on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @01:54PM (#12392292)
> is it a "if we build it, eventually they might come" scenario?

If they're being at all realistic then I think that idea has to be out the window at this point.

Not sure what their ultimate goal is. Since it's Google, even if millions of people are using it I fully expect them to just kill it eventually. I mean they pulled Photos out of Google+, maybe they'll pull out the communities stuff they've been working on and just axe the whole thing.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by reitanqild on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @05:00PM (#12393860)
As someone who likes google+ I think what they do now is smart:

- decouple things from the g+ name since a vocal minority is still throwing a tantrum everytime the name is mentioned.

- g+ identity continues like before only they just call it "your account", not "your google+ account"

- why was photos, maps etc so heavily tied into g+ in the first place? I think it is safe to say now that that portal-like idea was a big nistake in the first place.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by dredmorbius on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @06:31AM (#12397267)
That just squishes the problem into a new space, and recreates the initial G+ problem. Actually, the original Gmail problem.

Until Gmail existed, there was no reason for the typical user to log in to Google at all. Webmasters and advertisers and a few other categories, yes, but search was just Generic, Unauthenticated Search.

Gmail changed that. Now the general public had a reason to create a Google acccount. And to have their online Google activity accountable to that.

I immediately resisted any temptation to create a personal Gmail account. I may have had several through corporate email (and yes, it was technically far superior to, say, Microsoft Exchange). But man did the idea of mapping my random search activity to my name (and my employer, and my paycheck) not sit well.

Any mandated centralised ID across Google services, without the ability to disown or repudiate services, is simply wrong.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by reitanqild on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @02:40PM (#12400459)
Actually I can agree with you to a certain degree.

From googles and the uncaring users perspective it makes perfect sense though: less hassle for everyone.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by dredmorbius on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:51AM (#12405216)
I agree. I've got a lot of sympathy with Google's problems, and think they've done a good job in many regards.

The fact though that I cannot specifically associate or dissociate specific products across IDs is quite problematic. I've got a "Things I Don't Have" post somewhere ... Here we go:

"Google Shit I Don't Have"

https://ello.co/dredmorbius/post/y0ss_vplsmhsagqvf23fiq

The inability to, once, in once place, for all time, say "no, this shit isn't OK with me" on Google services doesn't sit well with me. It's why my public and personal use of the company's services are so widely separated, and largely minimised.

Using Google mostly to criticise Google has ... a pleasing symmetry.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by w1ntermute on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @02:14PM (#12392480)
It's probably a low-stress way to burnish your resume with a couple year Google stint. If you didn't go to a top CS program, working as an engineer at Google (or similar companies) can get you a lot more professional respect. For example, you can get better positions down the line at other companies. Or if you start your own company, investors will be much more willing to invest in you than in someone without any brand names on their resume. If you apply to YC, they'll probably give you the benefit of the doubt.
Re:Google+ Redesigned by dack on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @01:43PM (#12392194)
Not on the team, but know someone who is, and I think it's mostly the latter. I'm sure there are lots of challenges on the project still to keep someone busy, but they're not completely unaware of how it's perceived these days.
Re:Google+ Redesigned by yoodenvranx on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @02:34PM (#12392661)
I am wondering the same thing about the Google HO team. Their product is a horrible piece of garbage (ask any avid Ingress player) and they do _nothing_ to fix it. Who is responsible for this? Is it bad management? Is it bad engineers?
Re:Google+ Redesigned by 1_2__3 on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @02:22PM (#12392551)
Little bit of both.
Re:Google+ Redesigned by znpy on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @01:11PM (#12391920)
it would be fun to know.

I wonder if they perform any actual user testing, when they pick truly random users and ask their feeling about google plus.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by dmoy on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @01:24PM (#12392025)
You can't strongarm a truly random sample. Alas, hah.

For some stuff you have to ask people to come on site, which tends to self select a bit. Sometimes you get... interesting folks.

(Just talking generally about onsite user testing, not involved with G+ in any way)