News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google+ Redesigned by dredmorbius on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @06:31AM (#12397267)
That just squishes the problem into a new space, and recreates the initial G+ problem. Actually, the original Gmail problem.

Until Gmail existed, there was no reason for the typical user to log in to Google at all. Webmasters and advertisers and a few other categories, yes, but search was just Generic, Unauthenticated Search.

Gmail changed that. Now the general public had a reason to create a Google acccount. And to have their online Google activity accountable to that.

I immediately resisted any temptation to create a personal Gmail account. I may have had several through corporate email (and yes, it was technically far superior to, say, Microsoft Exchange). But man did the idea of mapping my random search activity to my name (and my employer, and my paycheck) not sit well.

Any mandated centralised ID across Google services, without the ability to disown or repudiate services, is simply wrong.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by reitanqild on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @02:40PM (#12400459)
Actually I can agree with you to a certain degree.

From googles and the uncaring users perspective it makes perfect sense though: less hassle for everyone.

Re:Google+ Redesigned by dredmorbius on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:51AM (#12405216)
I agree. I've got a lot of sympathy with Google's problems, and think they've done a good job in many regards.

The fact though that I cannot specifically associate or dissociate specific products across IDs is quite problematic. I've got a "Things I Don't Have" post somewhere ... Here we go:

"Google Shit I Don't Have"

https://ello.co/dredmorbius/post/y0ss_vplsmhsagqvf23fiq

The inability to, once, in once place, for all time, say "no, this shit isn't OK with me" on Google services doesn't sit well with me. It's why my public and personal use of the company's services are so widely separated, and largely minimised.

Using Google mostly to criticise Google has ... a pleasing symmetry.