News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by liquidise on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:03PM (#12347051)
> Globo.com only had rights for streaming the content to Brazil... with peak of 433K simultaneous users

This is a neat writeup but the bigger point here is highlighted by the opening statements. While i get the massive revenue channel the olympics provides, i can't help but feel that the media stranglehold over the events has gone too far.

The olympics represent one of the only instances of global unity through competition left in the world. Much the same way the world cup brings small and proud nations into the global stage, the olympics has the same power. Unfortunately, it is easier for me to find 20 year old simpsons clips on youtube than it is for me to find a video of Bolt's 100m heat from last week. Who benefits from this apart from NBC? I can list approx. 7.4B people who don't.

As a lover of capitalism this all leaves me conflicted. But i would point to the olympic coverage as the instance of corporations going too far with their constricting of media sharing.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by edpichler on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @08:04PM (#12348752)
Meanwhile, CBC of Canada broadcasted all olympic games for free. They had peak of 27 simultaneous channels transmitting competitions with excellent quality.

Anyone with a Canadian IP could watch, I personally used a VPN because I don't have TV cable here in Brazil.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by mrb on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @11:11PM (#12349425)
So did the BBC. They broadcasted for free multiple channels of Olympic events to any and all British IP addresses. I also used a VPN because I don't have cable TV.

I have no idea why Olympics events are not freely broadcasted in the US.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by caidh on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @11:28PM (#12349464)
Because the US does not have well funded public television as the UK (the BBC) or Canada (the CBC) do. In the US, sadly, it is to the highest bidder that the broadcast & streaming rights go to. NBC paid $1.23 Billion for rights to the 2016 Summer Olympics, an astronomical amount.

They only provided streaming to those with cable packages above what is considered 'basic'.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by grokavi on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @11:58PM (#12349573)
hotstar.com broadcasted Olympics free of cost in India. They aren't public funded.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by Fuzzwah on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @01:54AM (#12349979)
Channel 7 here in Australia broadcast on 3 channels for free (with ads). They also offered free streaming on mobile devices for a range of sports and had a $20 deal for complete access to all content.

That said, they really annoyed me with the way they handled the time difference. They would open their prime time coverage with spoilers of all the previous day's events and then tell you which replays you could watch on the other channels later....

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by flukus on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @03:33AM (#12350371)
And the whole time the ABC news (Australian one) live stream was constantly being cutoff with "due to licensing restrictions blah blah blah". Sometimes for several minutes, I don't know if that was because of particular segments or just someone forgetting to switch it back on.

I pretty quickly went from casual interest to outright hostility to the olympics.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by JonnieCache on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @04:22AM (#12350552)
My friend once tried to watch a cycle race on BT sport's on-demand web player, to start the stream he literally had to click through a spoiler as to who had won. He was apoplectic, and has not used it since.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by mynewtb on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @03:31AM (#12350366)
Because the free market has no interest in that.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by Gmo on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @05:13AM (#12350706)
Same in France, probably most of Europe actually
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by edpichler on Monday August 29, 2016 @07:58AM (#12381277)
In German it was broadcasted for free too.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by wnevets on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:32PM (#12347314)
>Unfortunately, it is easier for me to find 20 year old simpsons clips on youtube than it is for me to find a video of Bolt's 100m heat from last week.

So glad I wasn't the only one. For whatever reason the nbc link to the video was never on the front of google.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by LanceH on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @12:38AM (#12349711)
The ads streamed just fine. None of the actual events streamed after the ads finished.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by nsxwolf on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @01:48AM (#12349955)
Perverse that ads always work. I feel like I'm owed some kind of monetary compensation every time I watch an ad and then don't get to see the video I wanted to watch.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by cylinder on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:47PM (#12347477)
This was maddening as well. I had to go through nbcsports app and dig deep to find "Michael Phelps wins gold after thrilling final!" Instead of "200m X stroke final"
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by tmptmp on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @06:06PM (#12348141)
Such apps are menace. It seems that these apps cannot even do anything better than simple string search. They should learn a thing: Let Google do the search for them not their app.

A joke for the people who know little bit of programming: Hope they are not using strcmp to find the video file with title "Michael Phelps wins gold after thrilling final!" :(

edit: a typo

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by seanp2k2 on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @06:05AM (#12350872)
Probably untuned MySQL full text search, possibly Solr with all the default settings looking only at titles.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by rakoo on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @06:59PM (#12348451)
> As a lover of capitalism this all leaves me conflicted.

I don't want to go on a tangent but this is the exact contrary of Capitalism, it's a monopoly: as a consumer I can't make a choice, there is no market.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by jaredklewis on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @08:24PM (#12348836)
I feel the word monopoly gets way overused. "There is only one company with a train from Town A to Town B! It's a monopoly!" Probably not, as if there are other viable ways to travel (car, bus, plane, boat), then there are substitutes.

The olympics are no different. As a form of entertainment, there are countless substitutes. If the Olympics are boring, people won't watch. Even as a form of international cooperation, there are many substitutes that compete with the Olympics for the time, money, and attention of nations.

There is a market.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by ppereira on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @10:22PM (#12349233)
Just like public utilities don't have a monopoly on the provision of power, because, hey, every home-owner can buy a diesel generator. With the level of substitution you are describing, you've made the word monopoly meaningless.

The regional broadcasters for the Olympics have a monopoly because of their economic power in setting the price for their good. Other than circumventing copyright or using a VPN, there is no competitor that will provide you with the Olympics for less money. Random youtube videos are not a substitute for watching an Olympics broadcast live.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by rahimnathwani on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @01:53AM (#12349978)
For many routes, planes/trains/coaches are substitutes, so it's meaningful to say that trains are not monopolies. How do we know? Because when train tickets go up in price, there's a measurable effect on the number of coach tickets bought.

Your example (household electricity vs. diesel generators) doesn't work in the same way. If domestic electricity prices in London were to go up by 25℅, the number of diesel generators and amount of diesel fuel sold would not budge. Because diesel isn't a reasonable substitute.

If anyone wants to know more, search the internet for 'cross elasticity of demand' and 'definition of substitute'.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by jaredklewis on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @08:22AM (#12351463)
That's like saying HBO has a monopoly because only they can broadcast game of thrones.

If a product must have a perfectly identical substitute to not be a monopoly, then more or less all companies have monopolies. I feel that position is untenable.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by jamra on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @10:28PM (#12349261)
Public utilities are regulated, which require them to make their case in front of a judge for price changes.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by gre on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @04:10AM (#12350491)
Much of the Olympics wasn't live for the west coast even if you watched on TV.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by jamra on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @10:40PM (#12349316)
So you're saying that the alternative for the Olympics, a international gathering of most countries on the planet, is comparable to let's say... watching a basketball game? I think your analogy is very inaccurate.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by foota on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @07:29PM (#12348610)
Would you go on a tangent with me? Monopoly is completely in-line with capitalism, consumer choice is only guaranteed in a happy capitalist state.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by wlesieutre on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @08:24PM (#12348841)
A lot of the things people like to attribute to capitalism are really aspects of a perfect market. More off a convenient fiction for framing Econ 101 discussions on than something that actually actually exists. In some cases useful as a first order approximation.

It's the economics equivalent of frictionless spherical cows in a vacuum.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by digi_owl on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @06:53AM (#12351049)
Except that while said cow is absurd at the face of it, economics 101 is passed off as gospel.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by johansch on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:12PM (#12347136)
I feel the same. I've been travelling during the past month. Accessing video content from the Olympics has been extremely hard.

I think the IOC might be shooting themselves in both of their feet here. If they don't open open up, they'll some day find that they're suddenly irrelevant.

By the way, during the 2012 London Olympics the IOC and Google struck a deal to stream the like 20+ HD channels live to 64 territories:

"The live-streaming on the IOC’s YouTube channel will provide exclusive digital access to the London 2012 Olympic Games in territories where digital broadcast rights have not already been acquired by the IOC’s broadcast partners"

https://www.olympic.org/news/ioc-to-live-stream-london-2012-...

https://youtube.googleblog.com/2012/06/ioc-to-show-live-cove...

I was in one of those regions at the time. It was awesome.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by rhizome on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @01:07AM (#12349804)
I think the IOC might be shooting themselves in both of their feet here

They might get a piece of the vig kicked back to them, but by the time the games started the IOC already had their payday.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by bdhess on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:21PM (#12347229)
I dunno, I found video of Usain Bolt's 2016 100m in less than a minute of looking around on nbcolympics.com. Though I'd have to imagine that that content is geofiltered, since AFAIK NBC only has streaming rights within the US.

NBC paid the IOC something absurd like $12B for exclusive US media rights for the games through 2032. Territorial broadcast rights agreements are a huge source of funding for the IOC. It's hard to imagine how they'd maintain these revenue streams if they abandoned the exclusivity aspect of their media agreements, which likely implies that the games would suffer in some way.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by Retric on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:50PM (#12347498)
I completely skipped watching the Olympics in large part because of NBC which is terrible. So, I have some doubt that 12B is optimal for the IOC and it clearly sucks for the rest of US.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by aschampion on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @05:52PM (#12348039)
Watching via the BBC is a completely different experience: complete on-demand archives almost every event, time bookmarks for groups/bouts/matches, no annoying commentators unless the event was also being broadcast on a channel, no missing most of the event because we need to watch a manufactured interest piece on the US athlete, and you can go 30 seconds without hearing the name Phelps.

Watching NBC's broadcast, in contrast, made it seem like NBC had no belief that any of the events were interesting in and of themselves.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by maxxxxx on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @07:58PM (#12348732)
I hate those sappy interest pieces! Just show me the event.

You are right. They seem to think that the event is not interesting.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by mikekchar on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @04:55AM (#12350652)
I have historically avoided watching the Olympics because I like to watch sports, not drama ;-). Having said that, NHK in Japan did a pretty good job, I have to say. I watched the entirety of the women's rugby 7's semis and finals. Great sports that I wouldn't ordinarily get to watch, and no Japanese participation at all.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by xur17 on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @05:01PM (#12347611)
I did the same. I tried to find a live stream online, and failed. Everything I tried wanted me to login with cable credentials. Ended up watching it on my broadcast TV for about 10 minutes before giving up, and didn't watch anymore.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by js2 on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @05:28PM (#12347836)
Too late now, but you could have purchased a Playstation Vue subscription for one month ($30, one week free trial) which would have given you full access to the NBC Sports app and nbcolympics.com. You can sign up on the web and don't need a Playstation. That's what I did since I don't have a TV subscription and it worked well. The NBC iOS and tvOS app was pretty awful in forcing ads, but the Roku app let you skip mostly skip through them, which is how I did most of my watching.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by dv_dt on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @07:39PM (#12348652)
I wish I knew that before, tried a Sling Tv sub, and that didn't give one access to nbcolympics streaming content. I kept it for the (poor) live NBC streaming of the Olympics, but cancelled it after. Having to watch shows at a fixed time is crazy in the modern age. I watched much fewer sports and the advertisers probably lost out on quite a bit of exposure too.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by rhizome on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @01:06AM (#12349798)
I wish I knew that before

Which is directly due to NBC being the exclusive licensee for Olympic IP in the US, so the Vue could not advertise itself in terms of providing Olympic coverage. You could have come across one of the many articles and howtos for watching the games without cable, but it never would have been advertised to you.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by dexterdog on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @09:27PM (#12349035)
I watched more this year than ever because of the NBC app on Roku. I could watch any sport live or streamed later. No need to watch the Costas garbage.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by mrb on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @11:19PM (#12349443)
"I found video of Usain Bolt's 2016 100m in less than a minute of looking around on nbcolympics.com"

The GP wanted to find "Bolt's 100m heat" which is a different event from the final (athletic heats take place before semifinals). His point was that it is very hard (in the US) to find footage of Olympic events of secondary importance.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:28PM (#12347286)
If NBC were hosting a fireworks show they'd make the people that didn't pay stay indoors.

Edit: Perhaps the strategy isn't effective, that's all.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by X86BSD on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @07:15PM (#12348532)
And for the Olympics, the ancient games meant to bring people together, I for one couldn't watch 5 minutes of any of it as I am a chord cutter and couldn't stream jack, legally that is.

No one should have a monopoly on the Olympics. I find that rather sad and telling.

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by akerro on Wednesday August 24, 2016 @05:12AM (#12350700)
London 2012:

He said: "You probably wouldn't be walking in with a Pepsi T-shirt because Coca Cola are our sponsors."

Interviewer Evan Davis asked Lord Coe if he would be able to enter the Olympic Park wearing Nike trainers, to which Lord Coe replied: "Let's put some reality in this. You probably would be able to walk through with Nike trainers."

Lord Coe defended the ban on 'objects or clothing bearing political statements or overt commercial identification' outlined in official guidelines for spectators.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/olympics/news/9414178/Londo...

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by robbiep on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @07:05PM (#12348484)
>'The olympics represent one of the only instances of global unity through competition left in the world.'

What were the other ones that have presumably ceased to exist?

Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by mattkrause on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @09:59PM (#12349144)
The World Cup is also probably pretty close too. Maybe Eurovision also (for Europeans under about 35, perhaps).
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by _rpd on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @06:51PM (#12348408)
On the other hand, it did motivate me to find a way to stream NBC Sports. Something I wouldn't have done otherwise.
Re:455 Tb of live streaming were transferred during the Olym... by JustSomeNobody on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @04:36PM (#12347363)
I cannot stand NBC and their selfish Olympic coverage.