News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by dave_sullivan on Thursday August 18, 2016 @02:27PM (#12315106)
Steam has succeeded (I think) because they've managed to walk a thin line w/ drm and not screwing up the user experience too much.

Facebook would be smart to have gaming and social as two separate things with optional integration with Facebook. They'll screw it up because they'll make the optional part super annoying. Because when have they not?

I turned off my Facebook years ago. That works fine for me, but I'm frustrated any time someone uses Facebook to post something I'd like to read (like yann lecun or john carmack) because it's a step backwards. It'd be like Doom being released as an AOL exclusive.

Anyway, my money's on steam and ue4 dominating for years to come, not a new dist platform and not unity.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by mevile on Thursday August 18, 2016 @02:32PM (#12315157)
Facebook's Oculus has already tried to go the way of exclusives and walled gardens so I doubt it will take off. PC gamers are an opinionated noisy bunch and they will cause all kinds of drama for Facebook if they aren't as open as Steam. I don't really get this anyway. Steam works. Origin and Battle.net kinda make sense since those are the publisher's platform, and there's also GoG's Galaxy. There's really not any more room for another competitor.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by eswat on Thursday August 18, 2016 @02:53PM (#12315306)
> Steam works

But does it still provide a great experience for gamers and creators? I'd wager so say they can do a lot better, but they're letting their success stagnate them. Buggy mobile apps, questionable revenue share on Workshop items, no strong answer to the discovery of good games ever since Greenlight came out, IMHO Valve isn't doing enough with their platform on their own. I'd welcome competition to get them to perk up their step a bit.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by mevile on Thursday August 18, 2016 @02:58PM (#12315345)
There already is competition. GoG's Galaxy. It's great. Nobody I know uses it. Not a single streamer on twitch I've ever watch uses it. I'm fine with competition too, but not from Facebook. They've already fucked up with the Oculus store and I don't trust them anyway. Facebook is an unscrupulous advertisement company that turns intimate personal information into pay per click ad dollars.

I'd even go so far as to say Valve not caring is a good thing. They don't try to interfere too much and when they do and it blows up they walk it back.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by serge2k on Thursday August 18, 2016 @04:12PM (#12315996)
> I'd even go so far as to say Valve not caring is a good thing.

Ridiculous statement.

Waiting weeks for a support request is not a good thing.

Waiting weeks then getting response in russian is not a good thing.

The app being a generally slow clunky experience is not a good thing.

Piss poor preview games is not a good thing.

CS Go gambling is not a good thing.

DotA2 is not a good thing. :p

A lot of things were even worse before Origin arrived and Valve started at least a half-assed attempt to make things better.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by n0w on Thursday August 18, 2016 @11:28PM (#12317813)
What's wrong with DotA2??
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by grogenaut on Friday August 19, 2016 @02:30AM (#12318297)
For this person it's likely that it's not League or HOTS... or to make the standard joke... it's actually challenging and for adults instead of an ez mode toy for kids.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by serge2k on Friday August 19, 2016 @02:50AM (#12318358)
It's a MOBA.

Obviously.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by chaostheory on Friday August 19, 2016 @02:56AM (#12318374)
People who don't play multiplayer or don't have a good enough internet connection tend to go with GOG since most if not all games on GOG is DRM free.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by nilkn on Thursday August 18, 2016 @03:12PM (#12315480)
I think Steam's a great experience. It seems leaps and bounds ahead of competition. The coolest thing about it to me is how it keeps expanding in innovative ways. I picked up a Steam Link and Steam Controller last year, and it's really nice to be able to play a PC game in the living room whenever I feel like it. SteamVR is also great.

I guess the mobile app is kind of crappy. I've never really cared as I don't see any reason to use it.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by CaptSpify on Thursday August 18, 2016 @07:31PM (#12316998)
Steam is OK. I agree it's leaps and bounds ahead of competition, but that doesn't make it a "great experience". They can do a lot better, but the lack of real competition isn't pushing them at all.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by maccard on Thursday August 18, 2016 @03:41PM (#12315719)
It's pretty a Awful. I set it up as o was getting nagged about setting up the app as an authenticator, and the next update wouldn't boot. Not a great first experience, considering it's a webview app.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by Freak_NL on Friday August 19, 2016 @04:38AM (#12318703)
Steam's approach to authentication is annoying. You either get their authenticator app for two-factor authentication, or get demoted to a second-class Steam citizen. Without the authenticator you get nagged frequently to get it, and you cannot buy and sell things on the marketplace normally (every action has to be confirmed via email, and any item you want to sell is placed in escrow for two weeks).

I appreciate Valve pushing for better security, but with the authenticator app the only option this really sucks if you don't have a smartphone, or do have a smartphone, just not with Android, IOS, or Windows Phone on it.

Now I understand this for the interim (people were losing their digital items due to poor security), but it is damn near impossible to contact Steam with suggestions or comments (on the Steam forums your voice is drowned in a sea of despair, and I can't seem to get a hold of anyone with a technical background at Steam's help-desk). Perhaps if someone at Valve is reading HN: please consider using Fido U2F as an alternative to a smartphone app!

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by Omniusaspirer on Saturday August 20, 2016 @05:36PM (#12328387)
You'll never get Valve to change a thing, so just use 3rd party libraries like steam-totp to generate the Auth and market confirmation codes. Alternatively code your own program to do so (as I did in Rust) then run it on any device you'd like.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by touristtam on Friday August 19, 2016 @08:39AM (#12319576)
Funny I get this nagging experience (regarding the 2 factor authentication) from facebook, google, and a few others that I don't have in mind.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by ycombinatorMan on Thursday August 18, 2016 @04:35PM (#12316133)
Maybe the app isnt great, but the platform is.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by serge2k on Thursday August 18, 2016 @04:10PM (#12315984)
I'd welcome competition, steam can get a lot better (it's one of the worse apps I use) but I'm not going to use a facebook game thing.

Already have steam, gog galaxy, origin, and uplay for various things. I use only the former 2 as much as I can.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by fellellor on Friday August 19, 2016 @02:24AM (#12318271)
I think of platforms like Steam as an OS. I don't really want to spend a lot of time there. It is just there to help manage my library, keep the software updated and all that, and just get out of my way. I hear about the games I want to play from other channels, so their substandard discovery doesn't bother me so much. I do miss the days when I'd find a cool game to play on the front page, though.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by _puk on Thursday August 18, 2016 @05:52PM (#12316571)
Some must recall the drama that was the launch of Steam.

If I recall, it was optional for CounterStrike1.4, but then required for CS1.6.

The PC bunch were crying that they'd never use this DRM'd buggy POS.

That must have been 16+ years ago. Steam has come a long way since then, and has been credited [0] with helping reduce PC game piracy over the years. Likely because steam just works for the most part, and is as easy if not easier than the alternative.

I just don't see how Facebook can really disrupt this given Steams head start and positive mind share (not to mention the libraries of games that users have likely accrued over the years)

0: http://www.digital-digest.com/news-62904-PC-Gaming-Piracy-On...

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by snake117 on Thursday August 18, 2016 @06:39PM (#12316812)
>...and has been credited [0] with helping reduce PC game piracy over the years.

Their sales definitely had something to do with this as well. Before these kinds of sales, PC games were fixed at a certain price point and would take a long time to see a price drop. Now, I'll see fairly new games that may be marked down anywhere from 10% to 25% and, at least for me, I feel much more inclined to purchase it if I like it.

Granted I have a backlog of games to get through, but still it made purchasing games much more approachable as I know I won't be breaking my wallet over one game.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by thegeekpirate on Friday August 19, 2016 @01:06AM (#12318063)
> If I recall, it was optional for CounterStrike1.4, but then required for CS1.6.

1.6 was the only version on Steam, 1.5 used the WonID servers, which they shut down a few years later.

The largest issue with Steam when it was released was the fact that the client was slow as molasses, and plenty of others had resource issues since you had to also run the client in the background along with whichever game you were playing.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by tech2 on Friday August 19, 2016 @05:28AM (#12318861)
The issue with Steam for CS players was the removal of WoN and needing to re-purchase CS instead of being given a license upon it if you had one on WoN already.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by conradfr on Friday August 19, 2016 @08:11AM (#12319468)
It was kinda a POS back then.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by JimmyM on Friday August 19, 2016 @03:31AM (#12318465)
Looking at Steam, there's a huge undercurrent of games that don't get pushed, don't appeal to the hardcore, but that - in aggregate - sell a very noticeable amount.

Hidden object games, educational games for children, iOS and Android ports.

In the case of the former two - with no real marketing, and with a great deal of competition, these still fly off the digital shelves, and are not expensive to produce. There are people who want these games, and Steam honestly is not doing the best job of getting in touch with these people. Integration with the rest of the Facebook ecosystem would really really help push these games towards the people who want to buy them.

For the last option, people often buy these games when they felt good about playing the iOS/Android game and want to continue the experience (or in rare cases, play a more full-featured version - usually the PC port is incomplete, but sometimes it does contain unique bonuses). I imagine Facebook would have a killer app if it could sync your iOS/Android saved games (or even just achievements) to the PC version of the save game.

TL:DR; I think there's a huge opportunity for a major casual gaming platform, and I think Facebook's pretty well placed to be that platform.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by GlennS on Friday August 19, 2016 @03:29AM (#12318458)
Existing PC gamers are a fussy bunch.

There are plenty of people who play games who've never heard of Steam, and whose friends aren't on Steam, but who are on Facebook.

A lot of those people might be ripe to get sucked into the hobby if Facebook manages to advertise the right game in their feed.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by shostack on Thursday August 18, 2016 @11:56PM (#12317887)
Yeah, you'd think they would at least have the common sense to start completely altruistically and gradually boil the frog once they have lock in and a solid moat.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by stcredzero on Thursday August 18, 2016 @06:44PM (#12316827)
Facebook would be smart to have gaming and social as two separate things with optional integration with Facebook. They'll screw it up because they'll make the optional part super annoying. Because when have they not?

It will be enjoyably ironic when Facebook starts Google-Plussing it's own projects to death!

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by plandis on Thursday August 18, 2016 @04:45PM (#12316196)
Agreed. It's really annoying that others use Facebook for auth as well. Want Spotify? Nowadays you better have a Facebook account because that is how you sign in unless you were lucky enough to have acces to their beta prior to the partnership.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by eslaught on Thursday August 18, 2016 @06:39PM (#12316808)
Spotify switched their policy back to accepting signups via email:

https://www.spotify.com/us/signup/

If you already have an account, I'm not sure there's a way to de-associate it, but you could probably delete the old account and create a new one.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by mitm2mitm on Thursday August 18, 2016 @06:11PM (#12316690)
What do you mean? You can create a new Spotify account with your e-mail.

But I already gave up on Spotify since the web player is buggy and full of memory leaks. But I'm sure their apps are fine.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by ythl on Thursday August 18, 2016 @02:31PM (#12315146)
I hate to break it to you, but Unity already dominates in terms of popularity.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by pjmlp on Thursday August 18, 2016 @03:25PM (#12315617)
Following Unity's growth is like watching again the developers that were trying to create games in "managed languages" (C, Pascal, Modula-2, AMOS,...) slowly wining over the ones writing in pure Assembly.

Yes, there is a lot of of C++ under the hood in Unity, but I also remember the days when writing game engines in C and Pascal dialects actually the majority of the code looked something like:

    procedure MyProc; assembler;
    asm
      (* assembly *)
    end;

Yet 30 years later we seem to have forgotten how bad those compilers were targeting home computers and how much they have improved in all these years.

We need more success stories like Unity to keep driving the industry forward.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by justinhj on Thursday August 18, 2016 @03:58PM (#12315868)
I was one of those developers. I wrote a game in 93 that used mostly c rather than assembly because I didn't want to write it twice for Amiga and PC. At the time games were mostly assembler and it was felt that c compiled code had too much overhead. It was probably true to an extent for another couple of years.

The next fight was to move from C and C++ to Java and C++. This still hasn't happened in console gaming because the overhead needed for gc is not palatable to aaa developers that have to milk every byte of ram in the machine.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by pjmlp on Thursday August 18, 2016 @05:16PM (#12316383)
Yeah, I was one of those early C++ developers being bashed for using a bloated language (vs C), just like C# devs are nowadays.

Regarding GC and consoles, how do the UE 4 developers approach it, just disable the GC related features then?

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by SeanBoocock on Thursday August 18, 2016 @09:28PM (#12317444)
I haven't shipped a game on UE4 yet but in profiling our in-development game I've yet to see Unreal's GC emerge as a performance concern.

The UE4 GC is purpose built, simple (mark and sweep), and limited to only certain objects/allocations. The only time I've seen significant GC times/hitches was related to a bug that resulted in thousands of small allocations every second. I would much prefer if Epic dropped the GC - losing tight control over object lifetimes is as bad or worse than any potential performance overhead issues in my experience - but failing that I don't think its inclusion is a serious concern for shipping on consoles.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by pjmlp on Friday August 19, 2016 @01:12AM (#12318081)
Thanks for clarifying it. Always keen in learning a bit more about the console world.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by justinhj on Friday August 19, 2016 @06:15PM (#12323898)
I don't know much about Unreal but one difference is that a game engine can use a lot of unmanaged memory for the meat of the application and then provide a managed environment on top of that for writing the game. That way a much smaller portion of the ram usage is using gc
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by dave_sullivan on Thursday August 18, 2016 @02:35PM (#12315176)
Yes, hence why everyone that doesn't make games is super excited. UE4 is the superior engine, made by a company that actually makes games. Networking, rendering, UI, lots more -- it all comes built-in to ue4 where unity has built this plugins ecosystem that is sort of a mess.

Also, does Unity still not give you the source code? I assume they'll change this soon enough; you get the source code with ue4.

I kind of see it like blender vs maya or something. Lots of people are using blender, and it's very powerful. But industry is using Maya (because it's more powerful), and that won't change for a bit I think (good for autodesk).

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by babuskov on Thursday August 18, 2016 @04:01PM (#12315896)
> Also, does Unity still not give you the source code?

I believe that the issue isn't that they don't want to share, but that the code is a pile of patchwork that would need to be re-engineered before presenting it to anyone outside the company.

Unity has better marketing. The captured larger audience and thus got more content on their asset market and it has became default engine for beginners (C# seems much easier to learn than C++).

Unity is like Visual Basic of gamedev.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by nucleardog on Thursday August 18, 2016 @07:45PM (#12317050)
'Seems much easier to learn'? I'd attribute the ability to work with it from a managed language with a large part of its success relative to UE4.

Large swathes of even professional programmers have now come into the industry never having had to really deal with manual memory management. (And I happen to think that's fine.)

Given that, and the rising popularity of indie/amateur games, I fail to see how one couldn't count C/C++ as a negative as far as market penetration is concerned.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by babuskov on Monday August 22, 2016 @08:22PM (#12340399)
> Seems much easier to learn

Since I started from Assembler, it's hard for me to estimate how hard is C++ to some beginner. Managing memory came as a natural extension of understanding how the computer works.

> I'd attribute the ability to work with it from a managed language with a large part of its success relative to UE4.

You are probably right, but I simply cannot feel it. Thus "seems".

> Given that, and the rising popularity of indie/amateur games

I believe indie games reached their peak in 2011/2012 and got a huge drop in quality/quantity ratio since.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by niteshade on Thursday August 18, 2016 @11:55PM (#12317882)
I'd go a step further, Unity is the Fisher-Price of games development.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by szatkus on Friday August 19, 2016 @03:43AM (#12318512)
So what is Game Factory or other game makers?
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by jarsin on Thursday August 18, 2016 @03:24PM (#12315614)
> unity has built this plugins ecosystem that is sort of a mess.

I regret every non-art unity asset store purchase I made. Need behavior trees pick one of 10 crappy maintained assets etc etc. Constantly felt like I needed to purchase something to fill some gap in unity or spend tons of time developing my own solution.

I don't feel that way at all in UE4.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by Sleaker on Thursday August 18, 2016 @03:04PM (#12315412)
You don't get source with unity unless you pay a lot, and that's incredibly unlikely to change.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by TAForObvReasons on Thursday August 18, 2016 @02:33PM (#12315163)
> someone uses Facebook to post something I'd like to read (like yann lecun or john carmack) because it's a step backwards. It'd be like Doom being released as an AOL exclusive.

Worth pointing out that both were employed by Facebook (and AFAICT both are still there). I would genuinely be surprised if they used google+ or some other platform for posts

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by funkyy on Thursday August 18, 2016 @03:23PM (#12315599)
Steam might lose fight for players in the future, but for sure it will not be to Facebook. Worthy opponent it seems is GOG, they are superb platform with great values behind their offering.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by jamiesonbecker on Thursday August 18, 2016 @05:32PM (#12316471)
And GOG is committed to DRM-free, too: https://www.gog.com/support/website_help/what_is_gog_com

I've only had great experiences with GOG as a platform.

..and I love Steam, too, and both are committed to Linux as a platform for the future. (When is Portal 3 coming?!)

They each have carved out such a great niche and they're each both gamer and developer friendly.. I'm not so sure that FB has demonstrated being either of those things.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by ekianjo on Thursday August 18, 2016 @09:00PM (#12317348)
> I turned off my Facebook years ago. That works fine for me, but I'm frustrated any time someone uses Facebook to post something I'd like to read (like yann lecun or john carmack) because it's a step backwards. It'd be like Doom being released as an AOL exclusive.

Especially disappointing coming from Carmack who used to be a champion of openness. How has he changed...

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by pjmlp on Friday August 19, 2016 @04:20AM (#12318640)
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by ekianjo on Friday August 19, 2016 @12:12PM (#12321074)
Yup, even though he used to champion OpenGL for his games for a long time. That's why I mentioned he has changed.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by mercer on Sunday August 21, 2016 @03:53AM (#12329912)
Has he ever commented on this? I'd really like to know what changed his mind.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by stcredzero on Thursday August 18, 2016 @06:56PM (#12316884)
Facebook would be smart to have gaming and social as two separate things with optional integration with Facebook.

I don't exactly disagree. Rather, I think the underlying problem is orthogonal to the one you're paying attention to. Facebook's problem is that they let people think of Facebook games as being somehow separate from mobile. The far-seeing move would've been to make Facebook across the desktop, mobile, et al., as views into a single ecosystem.

Anyway, my money's on steam and ue4 dominating for years to come, not a new dist platform and not unity.

I like the sound of this, but what are your reasons for this?

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by 20yrs_no_equity on Thursday August 18, 2016 @03:41PM (#12315716)
Why UE4 over Unity? I have downloaded both and while both have a steep learning curve the one for UE is steeper, and the initial experience is much worse. Seems they never really tested it on the mac much.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by jarsin on Thursday August 18, 2016 @06:05PM (#12316669)
Ya if you are developing for mobile and/or primarily working on a Mac then UE4 is not as good of choice.

I develop on the mac and pc in UE4. On the mac ue4 performance is bad and you need the top of the line mac to deal with it. Personally I just write c++ on the mac and keep the editor closed most of the time until i need to test the code real quick in a very basic level. Then when im on my pc i do the heavy stuff.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by estefan on Thursday August 18, 2016 @04:43PM (#12316177)
I don't know. I did the space shooter tutorial on unity last week and I'm finding it a doddle to make my first 2D game... I'm super impressed, having never done game dev before.
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by busterarm on Thursday August 18, 2016 @05:21PM (#12316412)
People seem forget that the Friends/Community feature on Steam didn't really work at all for _YEARS_ when the platform launched.

I'd love to take the same bet you do, but if you have a killer product that requires the platform, people will use it. Half Life 2 and Counter Strike 1.6 were the killer products for Steam. Mass Effect 3 and The Old Republic are mostly the only reasons anyone I know installed Origin at first (and I'm sure other games now).

If Facebook finds that app, it won't matter how terrible their platform is.

Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by Impossible on Thursday August 18, 2016 @06:32PM (#12316784)
I'm curious why you think UE4 will dominate. I can think of a lot of reasons why, but many of them depend on the definition of "dominate" (raw users in the ecosystem, number of released games, number of successful titles, number of AAA or high-end indie titles, etc.)
Re:Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming p... by nso95 on Thursday August 18, 2016 @09:30PM (#12317451)
They seem to realize that users don't necessarily want to be linked to a Facebook account. For example: you no longer need a Facebook account in order to use messenger. Hopefully they're smart enough and willing enough to apply that same philosophy to this product.