News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by aravindet on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @02:28PM (#12175347)
This is good news for a healthy Node.js ecosystem, but I can't see what’s in it for Microsoft. V8-based Node.js works fine on Windows and Azure, so they don’t need this to attract Node.js developers and the npm ecosystem to their platform.

Are there any theories about how this (presumably substantial) investment makes business sense for MS?

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by niftich on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @02:53PM (#12175561)
It's a hedge against Google.

Google, through V8, Chromium, Chrome, Chrome OS, Android, and Dart, has a large say in the future of the web platform, browsers, apps, the future of Javascript, etc.

Time and time again, Google has used their substantial influence and market share to make unilateral decisions affecting the web platform [1][2][3][4][5][6]; the individual merits of each decision notwithstanding, Google can do just about anything and it will affect enough of the userbase that others must compensate or follow suit.

By offering an alternative to V8 monoculture, they can protect against Google using its influence to drive the Javascript platform in its own direction.

[1] SHA1 sunset: https://security.googleblog.com/2014/09/gradually-sunsetting...

[2] NPAPI discontinuation: https://blog.chromium.org/2014/11/the-final-countdown-for-np...

[3] Block Flash by default: https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/forum/#!searchin/ch...

[4] Chrome ignoring autocomplete=off: https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=468153...

[5] VP9 available in WebRTC: https://developers.google.com/web/updates/2016/01/vp9-webrtc...

[6] H.264 in WebRTC still gated behind a flag: https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=500605

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by SBArbeit on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @03:56PM (#12176015)
This. As much as I personally don't like JavaScript, it's not up to me whether it exists and is used, and having an advertising company de facto in charge of how people perceive its implementation simply isn't a Good Thing for the web in general.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by hochchristoph on Thursday July 28, 2016 @04:25AM (#12179034)
> Google, through V8, Chromium, Chrome, Chrome OS, Android, and Dart, has a large say in the future of the web platform, browsers, apps, the future of Javascript, etc.

> Time and time again, Google has used their substantial influence and market share to make unilateral decisions affecting the web platform [1][2][3][4][5][6]; the individual merits of each decision notwithstanding, Google can do just about anything and it will affect enough of the userbase that others must compensate or follow suit.

Funny, that 15 years ago you could say the exact same thing about Microsoft. Google's increasingly like the old Microsoft.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by pjmlp on Thursday July 28, 2016 @08:13AM (#12179702)
And before Microsoft maybe IBM or DEC.

What is strange is that many still don't get these cycles. :)

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by devsquid on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @08:13PM (#12177509)
I think all 6 of those examples are good decisions on Google's part. Google has a heavy stake in making sure the web runs great. Chrome holds a large share of the browser market, but it doesn't control a controlling share.

I'm all for MS releasing a competing open source JS engine. Personally I have been burned so many times by MS in the past when they had "substantial influence" I have no interest in using it.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by stephenr on Thursday July 28, 2016 @01:05AM (#12178410)
> Google has a heavy stake in making sure the web runs great.

Google has a heavy stake in making sure people keep using Google.com and it's associated services.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by devsquid on Thursday July 28, 2016 @02:08AM (#12178639)
Yes they also have that, however Google.com is a search engine for the web. If users stop using the web, they stop using their search engine.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by pjmlp on Thursday July 28, 2016 @03:25AM (#12178851)
Not if they use Android or ChromeOS, they will just use the G App instead.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by devsquid on Thursday July 28, 2016 @07:39AM (#12179616)
Then this isn't really about V8 anymore and the web and as far as that's concerned MS is already extremely dominant.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by pjmlp on Thursday July 28, 2016 @07:59AM (#12179664)
Depends on what one understands for web.

For me, the network protocols are what actually matters.

An on the mobile space for the time being, Apple and Google rule.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by pjmlp on Thursday July 28, 2016 @03:24AM (#12178846)
The whole "do no evil" mantra was only a thing while they were a small startup looking for geek credo across SV Starbucks.

After GMail, Web Search, Chrome and Android, they are just like any other corporation out there.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by kuschku on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @04:30PM (#12176262)
#5 and #6 are even worse, because it basically means Google can dictate whatever terms onto you, if you develop a competing browser.

As VP9 is heavily patented, and the license only allows you to use it if you don't ever sue Google, you're out of luck if Google ever fucks you over somewhere else.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by themihai on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @05:31PM (#12176665)
The alternative is worse(H.264)
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by kuschku on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @09:48PM (#12177818)
H.264 is worse, but at least it's available with pretty straightforward license terms (just pay).

VP.9's license might actually violate antitrust laws.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by vetinari on Thursday July 28, 2016 @06:18AM (#12179402)
> H.264 is worse, but at least it's available with pretty straightforward license terms (just pay).

That's pretty much discriminating against a wide range of software - namely Free and Open Source. VP9 on the other hand, is compatible with a such development model.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by kuschku on Thursday July 28, 2016 @06:42AM (#12179465)
Sure, yet VP9 is discriminating against about every startup with innovative patented algorithms that also wants to support VP.9

At the example of Pied Piper from SiliconValley: If they used VP.9 for video encoding before compressing and sending it, Google/hooli would now have the right to use their (potentially) patented algorithm for whatever they want, without ever getting sued.

Now that's great, eh?

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by vetinari on Thursday July 28, 2016 @06:56AM (#12179504)
The VPx cross-license does not work that way.

You are granted patents to use VPx (you can not use these patents outside VPx scope) and you are granting patents necessary to use VPx[1]. If you have some other patents that are not necessary for the VPx, they are not subject of the cross-license.

[1] - "that must necessarily be infringed by the act of Exploiting Licensed Products in the Licensed Field of Use"

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by themihai on Thursday July 28, 2016 @05:02AM (#12179156)
VP9 is a open and royalty free video coding format. You are safe as long as you don't sue Google for VP9 patent infringements. It seems to target MPEG so that if they sue Google their license is revoked and Google can claim patents infringements as well. That being said I take VP9 anytime over h.264. It's not only about the payment to MPEG but your license can also be revoked or not granted in the first place. How f is that compared to VP9?
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by kuschku on Thursday July 28, 2016 @06:40AM (#12179458)
Yes, but imagine you're a startup which has developed a bunch of awesome new algorithms, and patented them.

And now you want to use them in combination with VP.9.

As soon as you do, Google can use your algorithms and patents without ever paying you, and you can't sue them for it, or your product can't use VP.9 anymore.

How fucked up is that? That's a huge cost there for startups that's always treated as "free" while in reality it can be selling out your entire product for a video codec.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by themihai on Thursday July 28, 2016 @07:38AM (#12179613)
Something tells me that you are wrong. Just because Edge is shipped with VP9 support that doesn't mean the MS grants all the windows patents to Google, right? Of course if you want to develop a VP9++ and patent it that could be an issue but I don't think that's necessary a bad thing for the codecs industry. Last thing I want is another proprietary codec to lock the content on specific players.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by Already__Taken on Thursday July 28, 2016 @06:12AM (#12179381)
Surely is only so long as you don't sue google over VP9 codec issues. It can't be a blanket "Never be sue'd" statement.

These patents are all about a corporate cold war esque standoff and a licence term like that to me sounds like a dead hand.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by kuschku on Thursday July 28, 2016 @06:38AM (#12179451)
It is a blanket "Never be sued over any patents" statement.

That makes it quite problematic, because if you, as a company, want to implement WebRTC compatible with Chrome, Google can now use all your patents for free, and you can't do anything about it.

It heavily surpresses innovation in the sector - existing big players can easily make a patent deal, but a new startup?

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by jamescostian on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @02:36PM (#12175427)
I think Microsoft knows how bad of a rap they got back in the days of IE6, and they know that people don't really change their opinions very easily. So they're hoping to change the minds of devs (which is why they've open sourced so much - they're trying to look better and nicer, and now they're taking it further by putting in a lot of work into languages/ecosystems that aren't their own).

Through their charitable work, they look like the "good guys". The great thing about getting devs to like MS is that those devs might praise MS when talking to their non-developer friends, and their non-developer friends might ascribe a lot of value to that praise simply because they know that devs probably know more about tech companies.

In other words, by getting devs to like/trust MS more, non-devs will also like/trust MS more

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by avar on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @02:55PM (#12175568)
These recent moves aren't making me trust Microsoft anymore than before.

It's fantastic that they're open sourcing some stuff these days, but the things they're open sourcing and external projects they're contributing to are all either cost centers (nobody makes money on browser engines these days), or areas where they've lost the battle for cloud hosting, and are hoping to get a leg in on Linux-based hosting.

Now if they were to open source something like MSSQL, Exchange server, truly open up the office format, or pretty much anything where they haven't utterly been defeated by existing open source products I'd be impressed and might think their company culture is truly changing.

As it stands I don't see any reason to think that this isn't just all part of an experimental marketing strategy to bring already lost markets back under the Microsoft umbrella, and once they can achieve lock-in again; goodbye open source.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by edgyswingset on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @03:43PM (#12175913)
With .NET Core, all .NET languages, and ASP.NET Core being open source I'd say they've made that jump. It's literally millions of developers who use .NET and pay for Visual Studio (not to mention, this is what an incredible amount of Microsoft's products are built with), which last I checked is a billon-dollar business for MSFT. The open source stuff is where they're taking that business strategically, or at least it certainly seems that way.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by avar on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @04:00PM (#12176049)
All the things you've listed fall squarely in the category of "we've lost the hosting war, and nobody's going to ship proprietary .NET binaries on Linux distros".

The further you go from that sort of thing where they've already lost the market and either have nothing to lose or the writing is on the wall (how long can paid-for languages truly compete with free ones?), the less they have open sourced.

E.g. even Visual Studio which would be the next logical step is still for sale starting at $500 on their website[1], maybe that'll be fully open one day. After all how long can the paid-for editor wars persist?

What I was pointing out is that there's no sign of them opening up anything that would truly make them an open source company. I.e. things they make real money on, or would threaten their established lock-in.

1. https://www.visualstudio.com/products/how-to-buy-vs

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by int_19h on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @04:55PM (#12176459)
Note that, while VS is still proprietary, VSCode is open source.

Keep in mind that there's a considerable overhead in open sourcing large products with very old codebases that evolved over many years, sometimes decades (this describes Windows, Office and VS, among many others). For example, they may incorporate code and components from other sources, and the license that permitted their use and redistribution may not permit opening the source. Worse yet, in many cases, you won't even be sure if they do or do not before you do an expensive code audit.

Open sourcing something mostly brand new, like ASP.NET Core or Roslyn, is much easier in comparison, because you architecture for that from the get go.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by pritambaral on Thursday July 28, 2016 @06:42AM (#12179466)
> while VS is still proprietary, VSCode is open source

And the two are completely different products

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by int_19h on Thursday July 28, 2016 @07:35PM (#12184002)
Yes, of course. But they're products in a similar area, with the main difference being that one is a brand-new, from-scratch codebase, while another one is ~20 years old, and in places, might be based on code going even further back. Which reinforces my point that it's much easier to open source new stuff.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by oblio on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @04:11PM (#12176134)
Both Visual Studio and the Jetbrains IDEs are commercial and they're considered some of the best tools available on the market. Quality tools can still command a decent price.

To put things into perspective, IntelliJ has been battling both Eclipse and Netbeans for ages and it is (slowly) winning.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by avar on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @04:25PM (#12176234)
Yes it makes perfect sense that they're selling it. I'm not saying it doesn't.

What I'm saying is that the comments here to the effect of "Microsoft has changed their stance" don't seem to be in touch with reality.

Microsoft has just realized relatively late that there's certain things that they can't make money on yet are still strategically important, such as core .NET technology, or JS engines.

That doesn't mean that they'll keep open sourcing stuff, or that they're not likely to pull back the second they think it services their commercial aims.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by pyre on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @05:44PM (#12176735)
> "Microsoft has changed their stance" don't seem to be in touch with reality

I would say that porting MSSQL to Linux, open-sourcing .NET and ChakraCore (amongst other things) is definitely a change from the "Linux / OpenSource is a cancer" days, no?

Microsoft is in no way going to become the next Red Hat in running a service-only model onto of Open Source products. It doesn't make sense for them to do that. But the fact that they have accepted Open Source as a possibility for some of their products, and put that into action is a step in the right direction.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by cyphar on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @07:58PM (#12177432)
The fact that they are happy to ship proprietary products that are known to have backdoors doesn't make me believe they've changed their views on user freedom. It's a relevance ploy, nothing more.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by oblio on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @04:50PM (#12176423)
You're probably right. The thing is, Microsoft is right now in existential danger, at least if it wants to grow, and I think it has to grow, because it's a public company.

Their core market (desktop/enterprise desktop) is basically saturated. Almost their secondary efforts have failed from a financial standpoint or are only second in their niche (Bing, Edge, Azure, Xbox, etc.).

Unless they pull off some sort of a miraculous switch:

* they'll continue to be perennial underdogs

* they'll opening things up in order to gain allies, through genuine community building

From my point of view, in a sort of twisted way, that basically means that they're safe from a open source point of view.

They'll have to develop communities in almost every area they want to compete in (which means that there will be stewards available if they back down) and they'll invest quite heavily in their open source contribution.

It might not be done for the purest reasons, but I think that their new contributions will be here with us for the long term.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by KirinDave on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @07:43PM (#12177353)
The open sourcing of .NET core is incredibly significant. As much as people here like to pretend no one uses C#, it's a massive and profitable ecosystem.

The license you're buying for VS is a support seat with some special integrations. It's not like IntelliJ doesn't do that too. The community edition is entirely serviceable and free.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by pjmlp on Thursday July 28, 2016 @03:27AM (#12178857)
> how long can paid-for languages truly compete with free ones?

This is why we cannot have nice things, and FOSS community keeps rediscovering features that were already common in the 90's in commercial tools.

Common Lisp IDEs is just one example out of many.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by xorcist on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @04:36PM (#12176318)
> they're trying to look better and nicer,

I think that's a misleading picture of where things are going. Seeing these releases as charitable work misses the point. They haven't open sourced any of their core many makers. Nothing of the Office suite got open sourced, and you still can't code for your game console without special permission.

They do as many others, they open source what's already lost in an effort to stay relevant. It has been .net stuff (which was supposed to out-compete Java, but captured exactly zero mindshare outside the Windows ecosystem which is necessary to grow it at this stage), other developer stuff (not Visual Studio, mind you, but things like git and ssh where they tried to compete but lost), cloud (they need Linux on Azure to stay relevant) and web development. Much like Apple when they started out with OS X and released networking, printing and X11 stuff to get back developers. That worked out well for them but we haven't seen any more releases since then.

Don't be tempted to view this in terms of good and evil, but in terms of where these products are in their life cycle. Time will tell if it's successful. I would guess they lost web development long ago and there won't be any mass exodus from PHP or Rails to .net, but they still have a fighting chance against Java, especially if Oracle continues to bodge it.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by vegabook on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @02:43PM (#12175475)
It's less about an explicit positive for MS than a necessary rearguard against a trend negative in the form of the encroachment of Linux. If they don't do (things like) this, they'll be shut out of the server-side ecosystem altogether. MS needs to hedge its bets and ensure that if Linux achieves total domination, they still have a very good technical offering on that platform that does not rely on their arch enemy. So put as much stuff onto Linux as possible, then sell services/support etc IBM-style. And of course they also hope to bring in dev resources for free!
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by jaxondu on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @02:50PM (#12175536)
MS is using Electron for Visual Studio Code, so I can see them using NodeChakraCore instead down the road. They might push it as the way to develop cross platform app, with WebAssembly coming, making it the preferred platform is probably what MS wants. They are planning for Web 4.0.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by pjmlp on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @02:33PM (#12175387)
Oracle is also making JavaScript having first class support on the JVM since Java 8.

JavaScript has just reach the same status as many other languages in having the freedom of multiple implementations.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by nojvek on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @07:11PM (#12177187)
Browsers send queries to search engines. Search engines have ads. Ads shit gold.

It makes sense for Microsoft to not loose too much market share to v8 or chrome. What if node running on chakra on azure vms performs amazingly well?

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by madmax96 on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @02:35PM (#12175411)
Easy: embrace, extend, and extinguish.

If Microsoft behaves as they have done in the past, this is what will happen:

1. Make Node run on top of Chakra [x]

2. Give Chakra non-standard features and sell communities on them while pointing out to dissenters that the extensions are open source []

3. Gradually allow open source work on the product to die and commercialize it []

Microsoft has lost a lot of people's trust. My grandfather used to tell me that trust is hard to earn and easy to lose. Once trust is lost, it's even tougher to earn back. It's going to take some convincing on their end if they want developers to trust them. It doesn't __matter__ if they appear to act more ethically than their competitors, that's not how trust works, and it won't convince a lot of people that have watched Microsoft for a while that they've suddenly changed their ways.

EDIT: funny this is being downvoted considering eee was an actual strategy Microsoft has historically employed according to the US Justice Department. This isn't even conspiracy theory stuff -- this is real life. Those who don't study history are doomed to repeat it.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by addicted on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @02:41PM (#12175461)
This makes no sense at all when Chakra core is open source.

If MS creates a closed source branch, then the most likely result will be for someone to fork the ChakraCore code and continue NodeJS dev based on the open source fork.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by madmax96 on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @03:10PM (#12175675)
Being "open source" is meaningless if there isn't a community actively building the software and no one understands (or very few) understand the code outside the organization.

Open source is luring developers into a false sense of security -- it's possible to implement features that could not be ported easily into competitor's products and have no formal specification provided anywhere. Even if they have a specification, there is no guarantee that the specification will remain up-to-date as time progresses.

Also, I even said:

    > while pointing out to dissenters that the extensions 
    > are open source
Open source doesn't mean anything.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by addicted on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @07:01PM (#12177123)
I simply cannot foresee a scenario where the Node community is active enough to put in the effort to make Node work with ChakraCore, anode continues to remain popular and widely used, but after adopting ChakraCore the community does down to the point where they are incapable of replacing ChakraCore if MS turns hostile.

In addition, if ChakraCore is adopted, it's almost certain there will be a major fork that continues running on V8. The most likely scenario will be that Node will continue to run both in parallel, and soon enough the JS engine bindings will be abstracted enough that it may even become a bring your own JS Engine type software.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by madmax96 on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @08:33PM (#12177593)
I'm not concerned about Node on Chakra necessarily -- its developers are probably smart enough to avoid this issue; I'm concerned about applications running on Node on Chakra. Unless you avoid using __any__ non-standard behavior, Microsoft owns you.

Using Chakra is risky. There is a very real possibility that Microsoft will make developers regret trusting them. The only possible payoff is that maybe you need one less app instance. Maybe.

It's foolish to put you, your codebase, and your organization at risk for this.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by chii on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @09:16PM (#12177729)
Why can't you say the same for v8?
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by KirinDave on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @09:56PM (#12177851)
Because Google is a company of unceasing virtue and "Don't be evil?"

Or perhaps because many people have been conditioned to dislike anything Microsoft does without actually analyzing it's impact or relevance. Certainly it seems like there aren't many rational facts to thia person's argument.

I very much agree that "non-standard behavior" in an open source product exists that could be directly replicated. One of the major benefits of open source licensing is to hedge against that behavior.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by madmax96 on Thursday July 28, 2016 @07:59AM (#12179667)
So your counter-argument is this:

    > Or perhaps because many people have been conditioned to 
    > dislike anything Microsoft does without actually 
    > analyzing it's impact or relevance.


    > Certainly it seems like there aren't many rational facts 
    > to thia person's argument.
I could say the same thing about this comment.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by KirinDave on Thursday July 28, 2016 @11:20AM (#12180755)
So tell me, why is it bad for the industry? Why wasn't it bad when V8 came out and enabled node?

Why is there a different standard you apply to Microsoft's open source efforts? Please, tell me.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by madmax96 on Thursday July 28, 2016 @01:24PM (#12181631)

    > why is it bad for the industry?
I already explained how Microsoft has a history of violating people's trusts, and how an investment in Microsoft's technologies is therefore risky.

    >  Why wasn't it bad when V8 came out and enabled node?
This is off-topic: you don't know my opinion of V8 or Google. My opinion on V8, good or bad, also does not change the validity of my criticisms.

    > Why is there a different standard you apply to 
    > Microsoft's open source efforts?
You don't know me personally, so it's presumptive of you to assume I'm applying a standard unevenly.

You have done nothing to address the criticisms of Microsoft, instead you have resorted to cheap red herrings -- a tell-tale sign of a lost argument. Until you decide to actually provide an argument of substance against what I've said, rather than arrogant name-calling and presumptive assumptions regarding my standards for open source, this conversation cannot serve any constructive purpose.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by KirinDave on Thursday July 28, 2016 @02:29PM (#12182107)
Corporations are not people. Holding grudges against them as if they are people and not a social construct that changes over time makes 0 sense.

They have new management that is doing a lot of great things. The number of bad things they do is going down. Many of their products are genuinely good now. They're oing out of their way to improve their support for the broader developer ecosystem.

At this point, I "like" them a lot more than I like Apple or any of the hapless desktop Linux Distribution corporate governance bodies.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by madmax96 on Thursday July 28, 2016 @07:54AM (#12179653)
That's not related to the conversation at hand. Who said I like using v8?
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by KirinDave on Thursday July 28, 2016 @11:43AM (#12180912)
Who asked what you like? That's irrelevant.

You talk about "organizational risk"as if we don't live in a post-Sun world where Oracle genuinely believes APIs are patentable and the number of successful major open source projects without corporate sponsorships is vanishingly low. It's a world where a single assinine node developer with a trivial package on npm shut down the entire damn industry for days.

A relationship with a fairly stable and increasingly developer friendly company like Microsoft seems very reasonable by comparison.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by madmax96 on Thursday July 28, 2016 @01:39PM (#12181762)

    > Who asked what you like? That's irrelevant.
Parent did, when they asked:

    > Why can't you say the same for v8?
My point was they did not know my opinion on the subject and to make an argument about my personal consistency in analysis (although this is off-topic) is impossible.

Oracle's actions do change the validity of the criticisms against Microsoft. That conversation isn't directly related to this thread and is a weak distraction from Microsoft's history, a history that many reasonable people could claim is shameful. If that's the best that can be done to defend Microsoft, then it seems that it isn't trustworthy.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by KirinDave on Thursday July 28, 2016 @02:30PM (#12182118)
That's an odd reading. It looked to me like they were asking you why Chakra doesn't represent a risk similar to V8.

And it does. But it's not a very high risk.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by castratikron on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @04:24PM (#12176223)
If you alone hold the copyright to a piece of software you can change the license at any time.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by benaiah on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @04:44PM (#12176381)
But that doesn't apply to versions that already had an open license. You can't retroactivally revoke a license, you can only add it to new versions.
Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by castratikron on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @08:09PM (#12177485)
That's not true, and it's happened before:

http://www.cnet.com/news/nessus-security-tool-closes-its-sou...

A project like Linux couldn't do this, since it has thousands of authors, and each author would have to agree to the change. But if the author is a single person, or a corporation, then only one person has to make the decision.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by KirinDave on Wednesday July 27, 2016 @09:59PM (#12177864)
You're misreading the article, I think. They didn't release a new version under the GPL. They didn't retroactively undo licensing for older versions.

It is not at all clear that you can snap your fingers and renegotiate an existing license arbitrarily like that. You need to do it in advance of the agreement.

Re:Bringing ChakraCore to Linux and OS X by frik on Thursday July 28, 2016 @12:45AM (#12178354)
Probably Microsoft want to take over NodeJS ecosystem. They are lobbying to replace v8 engine with their chakra engine for Win32 builds. Read up about the history of the company, it can be very bad if the official NodeJS project switches to chakra for one or all platforms. So it's in probably bad news that Microsoft targets NodeJS even more. And their TypeScript adventure and how they steer/lobby the ES6/7 development in their interest isn't great for JS and WebAssembly. They have a vast interest to port their class based old C++/C# codebase of Office tools and Monaco editor to the web. They could stick with their new delayed lacklustre rather unfinished DotNetCore 1.0 ecosystem. Let's hope Google and others cone to the rescue to help NodeJS. On the other side I really wonder why Google switched to TypeScript for one of their project. Maybe the choose between Facebook and Microsoft and favoured the later because he former is an even bigger competitor in WebFrameworks (React), because they were late to the game?