> Time and time again, Google has used their substantial influence and market share to make unilateral decisions affecting the web platform [1][2][3][4][5][6]; the individual merits of each decision notwithstanding, Google can do just about anything and it will affect enough of the userbase that others must compensate or follow suit.
Funny, that 15 years ago you could say the exact same thing about Microsoft. Google's increasingly like the old Microsoft.
What is strange is that many still don't get these cycles. :)
I'm all for MS releasing a competing open source JS engine. Personally I have been burned so many times by MS in the past when they had "substantial influence" I have no interest in using it.
Google has a heavy stake in making sure people keep using Google.com and it's associated services.
For me, the network protocols are what actually matters.
An on the mobile space for the time being, Apple and Google rule.
After GMail, Web Search, Chrome and Android, they are just like any other corporation out there.
As VP9 is heavily patented, and the license only allows you to use it if you don't ever sue Google, you're out of luck if Google ever fucks you over somewhere else.
VP.9's license might actually violate antitrust laws.
That's pretty much discriminating against a wide range of software - namely Free and Open Source. VP9 on the other hand, is compatible with a such development model.
At the example of Pied Piper from SiliconValley: If they used VP.9 for video encoding before compressing and sending it, Google/hooli would now have the right to use their (potentially) patented algorithm for whatever they want, without ever getting sued.
Now that's great, eh?
You are granted patents to use VPx (you can not use these patents outside VPx scope) and you are granting patents necessary to use VPx[1]. If you have some other patents that are not necessary for the VPx, they are not subject of the cross-license.
[1] - "that must necessarily be infringed by the act of Exploiting Licensed Products in the Licensed Field of Use"
And now you want to use them in combination with VP.9.
As soon as you do, Google can use your algorithms and patents without ever paying you, and you can't sue them for it, or your product can't use VP.9 anymore.
How fucked up is that? That's a huge cost there for startups that's always treated as "free" while in reality it can be selling out your entire product for a video codec.
These patents are all about a corporate cold war esque standoff and a licence term like that to me sounds like a dead hand.
That makes it quite problematic, because if you, as a company, want to implement WebRTC compatible with Chrome, Google can now use all your patents for free, and you can't do anything about it.
It heavily surpresses innovation in the sector - existing big players can easily make a patent deal, but a new startup?
Google, through V8, Chromium, Chrome, Chrome OS, Android, and Dart, has a large say in the future of the web platform, browsers, apps, the future of Javascript, etc.
Time and time again, Google has used their substantial influence and market share to make unilateral decisions affecting the web platform [1][2][3][4][5][6]; the individual merits of each decision notwithstanding, Google can do just about anything and it will affect enough of the userbase that others must compensate or follow suit.
By offering an alternative to V8 monoculture, they can protect against Google using its influence to drive the Javascript platform in its own direction.
[1] SHA1 sunset: https://security.googleblog.com/2014/09/gradually-sunsetting...
[2] NPAPI discontinuation: https://blog.chromium.org/2014/11/the-final-countdown-for-np...
[3] Block Flash by default: https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/forum/#!searchin/ch...
[4] Chrome ignoring autocomplete=off: https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=468153...
[5] VP9 available in WebRTC: https://developers.google.com/web/updates/2016/01/vp9-webrtc...
[6] H.264 in WebRTC still gated behind a flag: https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=500605