News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by thoman23 on Saturday July 16, 2016 @01:40PM (#12107156)
I don't care if it's oversimplified. The 10,000 hour rule is brilliant for getting people past the difficult stages of learning a new skill. Can't play guitar? It's not because you were born without musical talent...it's because you haven't put in your time yet. Get to work. People aren't born playing guitar. They learn to play guitar...through practice...lots and lots and lots of practice...10,000 hours of practice!

For me, this realization was life-changing. And yes, I learned to play the guitar at the age of 40 after reading Outliers because I then had faith that with enough hours of hard work that I could do it. And I did. And now playing music is one of my greatest pleasures in life.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by nostromo on Saturday July 16, 2016 @02:29PM (#12107356)
The question is if Malcolm Gladwell wants to be a Tony Robbins type author or a Steven Pinker type author.

Both are fine. One is meant to be motivational, and one is meant to inform the public about science.

Gladwell's reputation is one of a science-based author which brings with it extra scrutiny.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by wmccullough on Saturday July 16, 2016 @03:16PM (#12107522)
To some extent you're right and I see your point, but this is also a false dichotomy. Gladwell can be whatever he wants to be. He may be rooted in science, but let's be honest, 10,000 is a fairly arbitrary number. If the world couldn't figure out that 10,000 hours wasn't scientific, we may have a larger problem.

I'm more mentally exhausted by the endlessness of pure contrarianism on the Internet. It gets worse and worse with each year and I'm losing my enjoyment of social communities.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by argonaut on Saturday July 16, 2016 @07:42PM (#12108321)
I think that perspective of exhaustion with contrarianism is part of the problem. There an excellent quote, which is "the amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than to produce it."

It is really really easy for someone to write some BS (online or in print). Books and newspapers do it routinely. Blogs do it every day. And of course people on online forums do it every second. Unless you just write "You're wrong," it usually takes a lot more effort, volume, and words to refute the BS.

So yes, it is often intellectually easier for people to be contrarian, but only because there is so much BS out there to refute. And it still takes more effort and volume to do so.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by PhantomGremlin on Saturday July 16, 2016 @08:35PM (#12108445)
Sadly, I've found myself doing this https://xkcd.com/386/ more often than I would like.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by Alex3917 on Saturday July 16, 2016 @03:28PM (#12107564)
> I'm more mentally exhausted by the endlessness of pure contrarianism on the Internet.

This is because 'skeptic' content is by far the most cost effective to produce. You're piggy backing off someone else's fame, and the only demand you're making of your readers is that they not read the original source material for themselves, which isn't exactly a difficult sell.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by eyelidlessness on Sunday July 17, 2016 @01:46AM (#12109159)
> I'm more mentally exhausted by the endlessness of pure contrarianism on the Internet. It gets worse and worse with each year and I'm losing my enjoyment of social communities.

Let me be the first to say I agree. And I'm a contrarian!

It just can't be possible that every discrepancy deserves the effort to refute and correct, and we're biologically trained to approximate as a matter of priority.

It took me 9987 hours to learn that.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by pastProlog on Saturday July 16, 2016 @03:24PM (#12107554)
Pinker is not a great example as a popularizer of science. He writes scientific books in layman's terms like The Language Instinct (which itself sometimes drifts off scientific canon into one explanation he favors over another in disputed areas). He also writes books like The Better Angels of Our Nature which are much more loosely connected to science in which he gives his opinion on human nature, politics, society etc.

I agree with the Language Instinct since it sticks with our current scientific understanding of how the brain scientifically and mathematically creates grammar. I disagree with much of The Better Angels book since it contradicts many anthropological and archaeological studies of human societies.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by toasterlovin on Saturday July 16, 2016 @03:39PM (#12107594)
Genuinely curious: in what ways does Better Angels contradict studies of human societies?
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by pastProlog on Saturday July 16, 2016 @10:42PM (#12108812)
You can read Marshall Sahlins, Lewis H. Morgan, Eleanor Leacock or others.

One thing they say is the hunter-gatherer bands of 10,000 years ago (or the small handful which remain in the world's remaining wilderness today) are not as bad as they say.

One thing is - the men in some of these bands work less than 40 hours a week. So in some respects, they are better off than a lot of people here (in some respects worse off).

The basic idea is against the Panglossian idea that Voltaire talks about in Candide - that we're currently living in the best possible economic/political/etc. system. One counterpoint to that is every political system since the dawn of time has held up people like Pinker who say we're living in the best of all possible systems and the other ones are awful, people need a strong government to keep them in check, and so forth.

People didn't need a strong government to keep them in check 10,000 years ago, 20,000, 30,000 when they were painting buffalos in caves and so forth.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by OvidNaso on Sunday July 17, 2016 @12:47AM (#12109057)
>One counterpoint to that is every political system since the dawn of time has held up people like Pinker who say we're living in the best of all possible systems and the other ones are awful, people need a strong government to keep them in check, and so forth.

Pinker never says anything like this I can remember and it doesn't even sound like something like something he talks about. Could you point out something that lead you to this interpretation?

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by maroonblazer on Saturday July 16, 2016 @04:47PM (#12107835)
>I agree with the Language Instinct since it sticks with our current scientific understanding of how the brain scientifically and mathematically creates grammar. I disagree with much of The Better Angels book since it contradicts many anthropological and archaeological studies of human societies.

So you agree with "The Language Instinct" because it supports the prevailing view and you disagree with "The Better Angels..." because it doesn't. Why the appeal to authority? Why not judge the books on their arguments and evidence?

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by pastProlog on Saturday July 16, 2016 @10:30PM (#12108787)
> because it supports the prevailing view and you disagree with "The Better Angels..." because it doesn't.

No, I said the Language Instinct talked about science and the brain, and Better Angels talked about political questions. One is scientific, one is polemic.

Pinker refers to Noam Chomsky in his scientific books, and he is an author of similar note. Chomsky writes mathematical formulas to describe human and computer languages, which are widely used - so there is no argument to their validity (unless you have some logical proof that Chomsky normal form can not describe context-free grammars). Chomsky also writes in other books about what he thinks about Israeli foreign policy - which is political and polemic.

I don't know how much more I can explain how there is a difference between an error-free mathematical proof and a controversial political opinion. They are apples and oranges.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by maroonblazer on Sunday July 17, 2016 @04:47AM (#12109499)
You're misrepresenting what Pinker is saying in "Better Angels". His claim is that violence globally has declined and he backs that up with quantified data and argument. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and not disagree that there probably are some remote cultures that are less violent but it doesn't detract from his larger point.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by mathattack on Saturday July 16, 2016 @08:58PM (#12108513)
There have been enough criticisms of Gladwell that I put him somewhere inbetween - perhaps closer to James Altucher of James Gleik?
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by dredmorbius on Saturday July 16, 2016 @06:32PM (#12108128)
I see your point, though I don't find your examples particularly compelling.

Stephen Jay Gould, Isaac Asimov, Sir Patrick Moore, or Vaclav Smil strike me as better examples, drawing from personal experience.

I'm actually having a fair bit of trouble coming up with a good example of a contemporary scientific author I'd recommend unhestitatingly. Hrm.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by bharath28 on Sunday July 17, 2016 @12:00AM (#12108976)
Where would you put Richard Dawkins? His science books? I've always found them to be methodical and instructive.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by dredmorbius on Sunday July 17, 2016 @02:07AM (#12109190)
He's in.

A larger part of my confusion is that I'm doing some massive revision -- call it a refactoring -- of my worldview. Not an absolute overturning, but tossing off massive amounts of cruft, teasing out the odd bits of real truth, and digging further for more connections.

Many of the more insightful authors I could name simply aren't very well known. Many aren't in the hard sciences, though some (again, Smil delves there) are. Generally I'd point very hard at many of the folks associated with the Santa Fe Institute (Geoffrey West, W. Brian Arthur, David Krakauer, Sander van der Leuuw, J. Doyne Farmer), and others.

Since I'm reassimilating and assessing, a lot's up in the air.

I'd considered a few other names, mostly older -- Carl Sagan and Isaac Asimov. I'd give slightly stronger cred to Asimov than Sagan, I think Asimov was more grounded in science, while Sagan tended to get a bit fuzzy. Though I also give Sagan serious credit for his attacks on bullshit and pseudo-science.

To a large extent though I'm mining more distant authors -- the past 250-300 years. Adam Smith (though largely revising my "conventional wisdom" assessment of him), Charles Darwin (quite possibly the most significant scientist of all time), Newton, Aldo Leopold, Howard and Eugene Odum, Alfred Lotke, William Ophuls (though more politics).

It's complicated.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by bharath28 on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:58AM (#12129029)
Completely agree on Asimov. I spent a quite a bit of my childhood reading anything that was written by Asimov that i could lay my hands on. I always felt so much in awe at the kinds of things he'd make me think about. I'll have to check out the Sante Fe Institute stuff - thanks for the recommendations!
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by gxs on Saturday July 16, 2016 @02:56PM (#12107457)
Could not have said this better myself.

I've struggled to articulate my dislike of Gladwell, but you've done it accurately here.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by paulpauper on Saturday July 16, 2016 @03:08PM (#12107500)
Upvoted. Its easy to forget, he is a journalist, albeit a very glorified one - not a scientist, although it's easy to see how he is often confused as one.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by ebbv on Saturday July 16, 2016 @07:58PM (#12108360)
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by smt88 on Saturday July 16, 2016 @05:05PM (#12107873)
Journalists have as much responsibility to the truth as scientists. It is possible to entertain people using only the truth.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by js2 on Saturday July 16, 2016 @06:49PM (#12108177)
Sure, but they're limited by not being experts in the subject matter they are reporting while at the same time attempting to distill it down into accessible language for the lay reader.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by iQuercus on Saturday July 16, 2016 @07:58PM (#12108362)
Just because someone is proclaimed "expert" doesn't mean they are good at what they do. This is especially true for the softer fields that Gladwell writes in.

At the end of the day it's up to you to determine if what you are reading is accurate. And if you don't have the tools, resources, or time to do so, you trust in experts at your own risk.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by Tiquor on Sunday July 17, 2016 @06:49AM (#12109704)
Except Gladwell didn't "get us wrong". People who read Gladwell and misinterpreted it "got us wrong". Gladwell has spoken repeatedly and clarified his book statements, Though if you read it closely there isn't much clarification needed.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by threepipeproblm on Sunday July 17, 2016 @08:24AM (#12109954)
I am confused by the comment. You think the researchers whose work Gladwell based his book on are WRONG about Gladwell getting it wrong, even though they explain the problems fairly well and you haven't addressed any of the specific points? Curious to know what qualifies you to know they have the wrong interpretation of their own work... have you even read it, or do you feel qualified to say this based on a reading of Gladwell alone?

Also, Gladwell has repeatedly "clarified", but if he didn't "get it wrong" why would there be a need to do this?

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by Tiquor on Monday July 18, 2016 @07:23AM (#12114407)
"Got us wrong" implies a fundamental inaccuracy in the concept. There is not a fundamental inaccuracy in the concept. Clarification is need to explain the nuance.

In regards to interpretations of their own work. They have largely spoken at arms length from what I'be seen and the book was popular enough to have lots of comments made via reporterst etc. I'm not claiming some coBS piracy, just the nature of these things.

Gladwell addresses this two years ago: http://www.businessinsider.com/malcolm-gladwell-explains-the...

To specifically address criticisms. One of then claim that deliberate practice is only 1/3 of the result. Gladwell, in his clarification, and original statements did not claim that deliberate practice was the only component. That was the misunderstanding from his book, not his intent.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by swiftisthebest on Saturday July 16, 2016 @09:38PM (#12108655)
He's a Gladwell type author.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by ebbv on Saturday July 16, 2016 @07:53PM (#12108352)
The 10,000 hour rule does more damage than good. Guitar is a perfect example to illustrate why.

a) It doesn't take 10,000 hours to be halfway decent at guitar. If all you want to do is be able to strum the chords for most popular music, you should be able to do that in way less than 10,000 hours.

b) Even 10,000 hours isn't going to turn you into Stevie Ray Vaughan or Walter Becker. There's lots of guitar players out there with way more than 10,000 hours who are damn good and still aren't those guys. The 10,000 hour rule as Gladwell presents it makes people believe that time investment is key in developing a skill and that's just not true for all skills.

c) 10,000 hours is such an arbitrary number as to be totally meaningless. As guitar perfectly illustrates, it's almost never going to be the right number. For most people who just want to be able to strum some Beatles tunes, that's way too much time. For people who want to be Yngwie Malmsteen, it's not enough.

But it's not just guitar, most skills are like this. The 10,000 hour number is totally meaningless. How much time you need to invest into a skill depends on what your goals are with that skill, and also how good you are at related skills that feed into that ability already.

The 10,000 hour meme needs to be taken out back, hit with a shovel and buried. It's awful.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by kinleyd on Sunday July 17, 2016 @09:49AM (#12110153)
The idea of the 10,000 hour rule has been quite a motivation for me, but you do put your arguments very well.

Like most people I've never taken the 10,000 hours as an absolute yardstick, just that you will be rewarded in proportion to the effort you put in. Of course, it's hard to slap a slick rule name on it when put that way.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by mcguire on Saturday July 16, 2016 @03:46PM (#12107613)
He didn't oversimplify it, he simply misstated it.

10,000 hours will make you an advanced student in a very competitive field, if you are the kind of person who will put in long practice into that field. It might still be a question of musical talent; the students in question would certainly be the ones born with talent.

Further, it's dedicated practice, not noodling around and not performing.

Finally, 10,000 hours isn't any kind of magic number. It wasn't enough to make those students masters, and I would bet that you haven't put in anywhere near that many to achieve a level of skill that satisfies you.

About the only thing that comes out right is that to develop a skill, you need to practice. Which, to quote my own least favorite phrase, we already knew.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by thoman23 on Saturday July 16, 2016 @04:14PM (#12107716)
> About the only thing that comes out right is that to develop a skill, you need to practice. Which, to quote my own least favorite phrase, we already knew.

Everybody knows they need to practice. But at least for me, the 10,000 rule set my expectations properly. Knowing that "practice" means 20 hours a week for 10 years helped me get past the temptation to quit when things aren't so easy in the beginning.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by mcguire on Sunday July 17, 2016 @11:45AM (#12110507)
Or it could have convinced you not to try: 20 hours a week for 10 years? Are you crazy?
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by i2shar on Saturday July 16, 2016 @05:45PM (#12108000)
When I read Outliers, I never took the 10,000 hour rule literally and I don't think Gladwell wanted us to. It put in perspective what we all knew and that's what contributed to it's popularity -- it gave us a common vocabulary to refer to when talking about "lot of practice". To quote from the article "The rule is irresistibly appealing".
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by mcguire on Sunday July 17, 2016 @11:41AM (#12110492)
So, he misappropriated and abused some research, but it's ok because everyone knows it's just a metaphor?
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by chongli on Saturday July 16, 2016 @06:47PM (#12108170)
Music isn't a single skill, it's a big collection of skills, many of which build on others. 10,000 hours may get you to a point where you can play the instrument you've been practising but you might still be a total beginner at music theory, composition, conducting, recording, etc.

When we describe someone as a master or a professional, it's assumed that they've mastered more than just the mechanics of playing an instrument, since all of the most well known names in music have multiple skills developed at a high level.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by thoman23 on Sunday July 17, 2016 @03:50AM (#12109403)
Everyone seems to get hung up on "mastery" or being a professional. Well guess what? You know what made me more receptive to music theory lessons? Thousands of hours of guitar practice. Practice feeds on itself. Once I was proficient with the physical basics of the guitar, I naturally reached out to all of the YouTube lessons on theory. The theory that now seems very straightforward would have been lost on me as a beginner.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by DanBC on Saturday July 16, 2016 @04:19PM (#12107741)
> Which, to quote my own least favorite phrase, we already knew.

There's a bunch of people who say they can't math, or paint, or play instruments, or learn a foreign language, etc etc. They don't seem to know that all they need is better lessons and lots of practice.

And when the (now withdrawn) "Sheep and goats" programmer study gets quoted here it feels right to some people, because we've all seen people who just can't fizzbuzz.

We may have known it, but lots of us don't seem to have taken it to heart.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by rukuu001 on Saturday July 16, 2016 @04:16PM (#12107729)
I think the kicker here is that if you are a born musical genius (and there are such things) those 10K hours will get you on a world stage.

Otherwise, as you say:

> advanced student in a very competitive field...

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by chongli on Saturday July 16, 2016 @06:52PM (#12108184)
That's an unfalsifiable claim. The corollary is "well you didn't make it on the world stage, that proves you aren't a born musical genius".
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by RogerL on Saturday July 16, 2016 @06:41PM (#12108157)
This is not supported by the data. All it says is that the very best practices more than the extremely good. There is no evidence that prolonged practice leads to exceptional performance.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by Tiquor on Sunday July 17, 2016 @07:02AM (#12109737)
You seem to be arguing semantics more than nuance. You aren't trying to say that practice doesn't matter. Right? Instead, it is debatable how much it differentiates the absolute best from those just below?

If so, I think the "No evidence" is a bit strong in this case. We may lack what would commonly be considered "proof" but there are good indications that practice matters.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by matwood on Saturday July 16, 2016 @02:31PM (#12107365)
People may not do it consciously, but it is a defense mechanism used to understand why they cannot do something. I recently had a huge argument with some friends about drawing. They said some innate talent was needed to which I said no, practice is all that is needed. Anyone can take some classes, and spend time to become passable at something like drawing.

Greatness is where practice and innate talent intersect.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scottlocklin on Saturday July 16, 2016 @03:05PM (#12107490)
I've definitely seen counterexamples to this, regarding drawing. Some people are visual thinkers, and some, despite thousands of hours of attempts, aren't.

There is such a thing as innate talent. Do you think anyone can be a world class physicist or mathematician with 10,000 hours practice? What about sprinters, programmers or entrepreneurs? I certainly don't. Not any of the above. I think people who achieve a high level of performance have almost certainly put in a lot of practice, but the reason they keep practicing is they have some natural aptitude for what they're practicing.

Gladwell's myth is comforting to our present elites who claim to have gotten where they are via hard work, and keeps the peace with the rubes.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scott_s on Saturday July 16, 2016 @03:39PM (#12107593)
Do you know anyone who has practiced drawing for, literally, thousands of hours and is not competent at it? I find that difficult to believe. There are people who can't form mental images, but that is considered a neurological condition (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11554894). I believe such people may never be competent at drawing, but that's not usually what people mean by "visual thinker."

Personally, I think people put too much emphasis on "natural talent." There may be such a thing, but yes, I think that dedicated, deliberate practice over long periods of time is what makes the biggest difference, and it can beat out "natural talent" in the long run. But, I'm not entirely convinced "natural talent" is a thing. I'm unsure what is real and what is perceived and cultural myth on this subject.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by asdf1234567890 on Sunday July 17, 2016 @01:38AM (#12109144)
>Personally, I think people put too much emphasis on "natural talent." There may be such a thing...

It's comforting to think that we are all capable of greatness. That doesn't make it so. It seems easier to accept with physical prowess. Do you think any amount of practice will bring me, an average Joe, even remotely close to the sprinting abilities of Usain Bolt? Clearly he was born with a physique that I was not. It's plain to see and so, natural physical talent is not something that is hard to accept. Why would natural mental talent be any different?

btw: i'm a high school teacher. I see the difference between gifted, middle of the road and ... um how to put it kindly, academically challenged individuals all the time. It may not be very PC, but there are loads of dummies among us and there's not much they can do do lift themselves up to even basic levels of intelligence. And just to be clear I'm not talking about the intellectually disabled.

> deliberate practice over long periods of time is what makes the biggest difference, and it can beat out "natural talent"

No. It will only beat out natural talent that never bothered to hone the same skills. Combining natural talent with practice is simply unbeatable and no amount of deliberate practice will allow you to reach the same heights.

This is patently obvious with physical ability. Why so hard to accept the same with mental ability?

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by srtjstjsj on Sunday July 17, 2016 @03:01AM (#12109312)
> there's not much they can do do lift themselves up to even basic levels of intelligence.

> And just to be clear I'm not talking about the intellectually disabled.

below basic levels of intelligence, but not intellectually disable?

Then what are you talking about? Perhaps you are talking about kids who have squandered their potential, or had it squandered by others.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by asdf1234567890 on Sunday July 17, 2016 @03:03AM (#12109319)
you do realise that intelligence, like any other trait has variability among individuals? We don't all magically get the same amount at birth.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scott_s on Sunday July 17, 2016 @01:11PM (#12110833)
My main reservation with these discussions is how much unsubstantiated claims there are, based on anecdotes. You're assuming such a thing called "natural talent" exists, and ascribing success to it. There are other plausible explanations.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by asdf1234567890 on Sunday July 17, 2016 @07:46PM (#12112469)
are you suggesting there is no variability between people with regard to intelligence or ability to learn? if all other human traits show variability (height, strength etc) what makes intelligence special?
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scott_s on Sunday July 17, 2016 @11:06PM (#12113046)
No. I am suggesting that what people call "natural talent" is just general intelligence and learning ability. I think that when people use the term "natural talent", implicit is talent at a particular task, which I suspect is not a real thing.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scottlocklin on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @05:02AM (#12164269)
OK, so you don't believe human abilities are statistically distributed. This is a fashionable political statement these days. It's also been proven completely false.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by asdf1234567890 on Monday July 25, 2016 @12:42AM (#12156506)
This makes even less sense.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by nostrebored on Saturday July 16, 2016 @04:13PM (#12107712)
Right. Programming is also a terrible example. I think anyone who is not mentally handicapped would become an excellent programmer with 10k hours of practice.

That's three and a half years of a 9-5 if you work 7 days a week. 5 years if you work 5 days a week. And I mean work to learn not work to put out a sub par product.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scottlocklin on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @05:00AM (#12164262)
Yes, as a matter of fact, I know a woman who has been trying to be a representational painter for 10 years. The first time I saw a picture in her studio which was decent, it was her husband's first attempt at a portrait (he'd never used a paintbrush before).

You may think natural talent doesn't count; but you can only think this because you've never been exposed to a sport, game or skill where someone had 4 sigma of natural talent on you.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by Fricken on Saturday July 16, 2016 @11:59PM (#12108972)
I was into BMX when I was young, and really wanted to learn how to manual (coasting on the back tire). I practiced this every day for 6 months, I got to being able to manual about 30 feet on a good run. One day, my friend who was a natural athlete but had no particular interest in BMX decided to give it a try. He had it figured out within an hour. It was pretty clear that 10,000 hours would get him a hell of a lot further than it would get me, and that it was time to divorce myself from any aspiration of becoming a professional, or even competent BMX rider. I rage quit. Natural talent is huge.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by srtjstjsj on Sunday July 17, 2016 @03:03AM (#12109317)
Do you know how many hours he put into athleticism before that day? If you are a clutz like me, you probably did an hour less of athletic activity every day of your life than someone with an aptitude. Aptitude plants a seed that grows.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scott_s on Sunday July 17, 2016 @01:48PM (#12110969)
Agreed with your sentiment. What makes Fricken say his friend is a "natural athlete"? Is it just because Fricken did not see his friend practice athletic activities since being very young, or did Fricken's friend really excel at athletics without any practice? There are a lot of examples of athletes crossing over from one sport to another, because their prior sport's skills transfer well. I wouldn't say they are a "natural" at the new sport.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by matwood on Saturday July 16, 2016 @05:41PM (#12107988)
I didn't say anyone can become great, only passable. Greatness requires a huge confluence of variables.

I could argue that having a some innate talent helps to keep people practicing, but it is certainly not required to become okay at something.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by mangodrunk on Saturday July 16, 2016 @11:33PM (#12108914)
What about the many people who are passionate and who do practice quite a lot but don't really take it that much further. For example, in track and field there are people who are really into it and who run all the time. Or any of the other hobbies that people are into but they never get better than certain levels.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by nostrebored on Saturday July 16, 2016 @04:20PM (#12107742)
Outright denying Gladwell's theory is comforting to pseudo-intellectuals in fields like programming who like to think that they're special or hyper logical.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by grkvlt on Saturday July 16, 2016 @07:44PM (#12108325)
The human brain is an amazing thing, and the particularly amazing thing about it is that it's a very general-purpose thinking and learning machine. It's this generality and the ability to learn that allows people to become programmers, entrepreneurs, physicists or mathematicians, and large amounts of time spent practicing is what enables the specialisation.

But the interesting part is they all started out with essentially the same hardware, and I don't believe there is any part of the brain where you will find a 'natural' aptitude for entrepreneurship, or programming or whatever. Evolution just gave us a general purpose tool that can be moulded to whatever purpose.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by srtjstjsj on Sunday July 17, 2016 @03:05AM (#12109323)
> I don't believe there is any part of the brain where you will find a 'natural' aptitude for entrepreneurship, or programming or whateve

Maybe, maybe not. https://en.wikipedia.aorg/wiki/Empathizing–systemizing_theor...

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by paulpauper on Saturday July 16, 2016 @03:02PM (#12107476)
IMHO there are certain tasks where the rule is more applicable, and others were it isn't. I think music and athleticism involve flow states and muscle memory, whereas math and writing tend to be more cognitively demanding and involve more structure and rules, and you either have the talent to do well or you don't, and such talent tends to manifest at a very early age. The 10000 hours is the amount of practice that allows an already talented person to possibly compete at the world-class.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by nashadelic on Saturday July 16, 2016 @02:21PM (#12107339)
While I understand your point, the danger in this over simplification is that it encourages brute forcification. If 10k hours were only enough, our typing speed would keep increasing. But that's not the case; to improve you need to be challenged with a higher skill level requirement. For example, if you're at 100 WPM, use a typing tutor that requires 110. Otherwise you'll just stargnate.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by matwood on Saturday July 16, 2016 @02:32PM (#12107370)
I believe Gladwell does say 'deliberate practice' so he agrees that time alone is not enough. It must be time well spent.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by 50CNT on Saturday July 16, 2016 @02:40PM (#12107396)
First, congratulations on learning the guitar, I'm really happy that it brings joy to your life.

However, research in the area of expert performance shows that when it comes to this practice, not just the amount, but the type of practice matters tremendously. How practice is done is such a major factor in improvement that taking the 10,000 hour rule by itself is like solving physics problems with the formula F = a instead of F = ma.

Research in the area shows that performers usually plateau after reaching competence, which is the point they no longer struggle with regular operations. At this point, automaticity takes over, which for example is the reason that whilst most people can walk, few get consistently better at it despite walking a lot. This means, that out of the 10,000 hours put into learning the task, 9,000 are potentially wasted.

In order to leave plateaus, one needs engage in "deliberate practice", a term coined by the cognitive psychologist Anders Ericsson. It's presence, or lack thereof has been shown across a wide variety of disciplines between masters and people who are merely good after having spent similar amounts of time on practice.

Deliberate practice is practice where you consciously strain for a point that is just outside your current skill level. In the case of musicians for example, it can manifest as slowing down a song to a crawl until every note is hit in the right way, and then slowly speeding up or slowing down again at the line where one starts making mistakes.

My point is that whilst the 10,000 hour rule is useful for setting time expectations to become a master at a task and helps illustrate how expertise is attainable for all of us if we put in the time and work, it lacks predictive power for whether you will become great at something after spending this amount of time.

For a hobby, this may only result in some wasted practice time getting to competence(I've eyeballed this at about a factor of 2 doing some testing learning the piano, unscientific, I know), which is perfectly fine. You're doing it for fun. Pain periods and all.

For an occupation, however, it can lead to endless grief. You've read about the 10,000 hour rule, you want to become very good, but after a year of work, you don't ever become significantly better. You sit there, grasping at the problem, but it's elusive, like you're wildly tweaking screen settings things to fix a kernel bug.

I am also oversimplifying a bit for brevity here, but there's some books on the topic. For an in depth review, there's the "Cambridge Handbook of Expertise and Expert Performance"[0].

For a lighter book more along the lines of Outliers, theres "The Talent Code"[1] by Daniel Coyle. AFAIK, both draw from the Cambridge book.

Both of them are worth a look, the 10,000 hour rule might tell you "I can do it", but these will tell you "How to do it".

[0][https://www.amazon.com/Cambridge-Expertise-Performance-Handb...] [1][https://www.amazon.com/Talent-Code-Greatness-Born-Grown/dp/0...]

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by kinleyd on Sunday July 17, 2016 @02:54AM (#12109297)
Thank you for the reference to the Cambridge Handbook. Having read The Talent Code and Talent Is Overrated, both of which I recommend, I look forward to this one as well.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by 50CNT on Sunday July 17, 2016 @08:01AM (#12109894)
It takes a bit of time to go through, the chapters take me about a day if I take notes, and it's 40 chapters, so I'm personally only up to chapter 15 right now.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scott_s on Saturday July 16, 2016 @03:41PM (#12107596)
Good post, but one nitpick: the author of the submitted piece made a point that the 10,000 hour was for music students at about 20 years old who were not yet masters.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by 50CNT on Sunday July 17, 2016 @08:28AM (#12109967)
I like the 10,000 hour rule as an order of magnitude estimation. Somewhere between hour 5001 and 49999, you become very good, given the right kind of practice. It's an acceptable heuristic for that, and research throws up similar numbers in a range of fields.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by kinleyd on Sunday July 17, 2016 @09:23AM (#12110091)
With focused, deliberate practice, I'm hoping I crack the electric guitar in 5001. :) But seriously, I know it's the journey that's more important - the heuristic really does give me confidence when I look at where I am and where I want to be.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by 50CNT on Monday July 18, 2016 @03:54PM (#12117677)
One thing I found with psycho-motor skills like the guitar or piano is that slowing it down significantly at the start is really helpful. I downloaded a metronome app onto my phone and I'd start out at a rate of 10 BPM (which is agonizingly slow), and then bump it up in 10 BPM, and then 5 BPM increments. The other thing I'm thinking about is getting a skilled spotter, because early on your error correcting feedback mechanisms aren't all that great. Whilst I could focus on hitting the right keys at the right time, things like posture and how I hit the keys were things where I couldn't differentiate between good and bad. Might as well start out with good form.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by kinleyd on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @05:50AM (#12127825)
Yes, from everything I've read, the key to grasping a new motor skill is to break it up in chunks and then to really slow it down. This has worked for me, and the interesting thing I noticed is that if I don't break it down and do it slowly, the level of frustration from doing it even for a short while tempts me to end the session right there.

If you can get a skilled spotter, or a coach who knows his/her stuff, nothing like it! I have to rely on myself unfortunately, and am very grateful for the super materials that I've found for learning the guitar. Like you, I am focusing on the fundamentals and patiently letting my skills build up. 2 years into it I am happy to say that it's looking good!

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by thetruthseeker1 on Sunday July 17, 2016 @12:30PM (#12110678)
The author agrees with Gladwell that to become pretty "good" at anything you will need to work hard at it(10K hrs). But the theme of the book is 'outliers', and Gladwell over simplifies saying that all it takes to be an outlier is 10000 hrs of work - which is not the case apparently, some people achieved this without as much effort and it is likely some people require a lot more effort than 10K hrs to be "as" good and considering that, it is not really clear what the outlier benchmark cutoff hrs is.

The underlying message which Gladwell conveys that to be outlier at anything, all you need is 10,000 hrs of work does not seem to hold true for all individuals in all fields.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by kinleyd on Sunday July 17, 2016 @04:24AM (#12109467)
I started two years, after I'd crossed 50, with the same conviction. Outliers, The Talent Code and Talent Is Overrated were what inspired me. I believe there is natural talent, but it's much rarer than we like to believe. Perseverance and knowing how to learn are much more accessible to the general population and that's what I'm betting on. Like you I am drawing my greatest happiness playing the guitar. I'm still some ways from mastery, but I am making good and measurable progress.