News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scottlocklin on Saturday July 16, 2016 @03:05PM (#12107490)
I've definitely seen counterexamples to this, regarding drawing. Some people are visual thinkers, and some, despite thousands of hours of attempts, aren't.

There is such a thing as innate talent. Do you think anyone can be a world class physicist or mathematician with 10,000 hours practice? What about sprinters, programmers or entrepreneurs? I certainly don't. Not any of the above. I think people who achieve a high level of performance have almost certainly put in a lot of practice, but the reason they keep practicing is they have some natural aptitude for what they're practicing.

Gladwell's myth is comforting to our present elites who claim to have gotten where they are via hard work, and keeps the peace with the rubes.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scott_s on Saturday July 16, 2016 @03:39PM (#12107593)
Do you know anyone who has practiced drawing for, literally, thousands of hours and is not competent at it? I find that difficult to believe. There are people who can't form mental images, but that is considered a neurological condition (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11554894). I believe such people may never be competent at drawing, but that's not usually what people mean by "visual thinker."

Personally, I think people put too much emphasis on "natural talent." There may be such a thing, but yes, I think that dedicated, deliberate practice over long periods of time is what makes the biggest difference, and it can beat out "natural talent" in the long run. But, I'm not entirely convinced "natural talent" is a thing. I'm unsure what is real and what is perceived and cultural myth on this subject.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by asdf1234567890 on Sunday July 17, 2016 @01:38AM (#12109144)
>Personally, I think people put too much emphasis on "natural talent." There may be such a thing...

It's comforting to think that we are all capable of greatness. That doesn't make it so. It seems easier to accept with physical prowess. Do you think any amount of practice will bring me, an average Joe, even remotely close to the sprinting abilities of Usain Bolt? Clearly he was born with a physique that I was not. It's plain to see and so, natural physical talent is not something that is hard to accept. Why would natural mental talent be any different?

btw: i'm a high school teacher. I see the difference between gifted, middle of the road and ... um how to put it kindly, academically challenged individuals all the time. It may not be very PC, but there are loads of dummies among us and there's not much they can do do lift themselves up to even basic levels of intelligence. And just to be clear I'm not talking about the intellectually disabled.

> deliberate practice over long periods of time is what makes the biggest difference, and it can beat out "natural talent"

No. It will only beat out natural talent that never bothered to hone the same skills. Combining natural talent with practice is simply unbeatable and no amount of deliberate practice will allow you to reach the same heights.

This is patently obvious with physical ability. Why so hard to accept the same with mental ability?

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by srtjstjsj on Sunday July 17, 2016 @03:01AM (#12109312)
> there's not much they can do do lift themselves up to even basic levels of intelligence.

> And just to be clear I'm not talking about the intellectually disabled.

below basic levels of intelligence, but not intellectually disable?

Then what are you talking about? Perhaps you are talking about kids who have squandered their potential, or had it squandered by others.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by asdf1234567890 on Sunday July 17, 2016 @03:03AM (#12109319)
you do realise that intelligence, like any other trait has variability among individuals? We don't all magically get the same amount at birth.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scott_s on Sunday July 17, 2016 @01:11PM (#12110833)
My main reservation with these discussions is how much unsubstantiated claims there are, based on anecdotes. You're assuming such a thing called "natural talent" exists, and ascribing success to it. There are other plausible explanations.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by asdf1234567890 on Sunday July 17, 2016 @07:46PM (#12112469)
are you suggesting there is no variability between people with regard to intelligence or ability to learn? if all other human traits show variability (height, strength etc) what makes intelligence special?
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scott_s on Sunday July 17, 2016 @11:06PM (#12113046)
No. I am suggesting that what people call "natural talent" is just general intelligence and learning ability. I think that when people use the term "natural talent", implicit is talent at a particular task, which I suspect is not a real thing.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scottlocklin on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @05:02AM (#12164269)
OK, so you don't believe human abilities are statistically distributed. This is a fashionable political statement these days. It's also been proven completely false.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by asdf1234567890 on Monday July 25, 2016 @12:42AM (#12156506)
This makes even less sense.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by nostrebored on Saturday July 16, 2016 @04:13PM (#12107712)
Right. Programming is also a terrible example. I think anyone who is not mentally handicapped would become an excellent programmer with 10k hours of practice.

That's three and a half years of a 9-5 if you work 7 days a week. 5 years if you work 5 days a week. And I mean work to learn not work to put out a sub par product.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scottlocklin on Tuesday July 26, 2016 @05:00AM (#12164262)
Yes, as a matter of fact, I know a woman who has been trying to be a representational painter for 10 years. The first time I saw a picture in her studio which was decent, it was her husband's first attempt at a portrait (he'd never used a paintbrush before).

You may think natural talent doesn't count; but you can only think this because you've never been exposed to a sport, game or skill where someone had 4 sigma of natural talent on you.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by Fricken on Saturday July 16, 2016 @11:59PM (#12108972)
I was into BMX when I was young, and really wanted to learn how to manual (coasting on the back tire). I practiced this every day for 6 months, I got to being able to manual about 30 feet on a good run. One day, my friend who was a natural athlete but had no particular interest in BMX decided to give it a try. He had it figured out within an hour. It was pretty clear that 10,000 hours would get him a hell of a lot further than it would get me, and that it was time to divorce myself from any aspiration of becoming a professional, or even competent BMX rider. I rage quit. Natural talent is huge.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by srtjstjsj on Sunday July 17, 2016 @03:03AM (#12109317)
Do you know how many hours he put into athleticism before that day? If you are a clutz like me, you probably did an hour less of athletic activity every day of your life than someone with an aptitude. Aptitude plants a seed that grows.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by scott_s on Sunday July 17, 2016 @01:48PM (#12110969)
Agreed with your sentiment. What makes Fricken say his friend is a "natural athlete"? Is it just because Fricken did not see his friend practice athletic activities since being very young, or did Fricken's friend really excel at athletics without any practice? There are a lot of examples of athletes crossing over from one sport to another, because their prior sport's skills transfer well. I wouldn't say they are a "natural" at the new sport.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by matwood on Saturday July 16, 2016 @05:41PM (#12107988)
I didn't say anyone can become great, only passable. Greatness requires a huge confluence of variables.

I could argue that having a some innate talent helps to keep people practicing, but it is certainly not required to become okay at something.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by mangodrunk on Saturday July 16, 2016 @11:33PM (#12108914)
What about the many people who are passionate and who do practice quite a lot but don't really take it that much further. For example, in track and field there are people who are really into it and who run all the time. Or any of the other hobbies that people are into but they never get better than certain levels.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by nostrebored on Saturday July 16, 2016 @04:20PM (#12107742)
Outright denying Gladwell's theory is comforting to pseudo-intellectuals in fields like programming who like to think that they're special or hyper logical.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by grkvlt on Saturday July 16, 2016 @07:44PM (#12108325)
The human brain is an amazing thing, and the particularly amazing thing about it is that it's a very general-purpose thinking and learning machine. It's this generality and the ability to learn that allows people to become programmers, entrepreneurs, physicists or mathematicians, and large amounts of time spent practicing is what enables the specialisation.

But the interesting part is they all started out with essentially the same hardware, and I don't believe there is any part of the brain where you will find a 'natural' aptitude for entrepreneurship, or programming or whatever. Evolution just gave us a general purpose tool that can be moulded to whatever purpose.

Re:Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimpli... by srtjstjsj on Sunday July 17, 2016 @03:05AM (#12109323)
> I don't believe there is any part of the brain where you will find a 'natural' aptitude for entrepreneurship, or programming or whateve

Maybe, maybe not. https://en.wikipedia.aorg/wiki/Empathizing–systemizing_theor...