News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by known on Monday July 11, 2016 @02:01AM (#12069161)
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by zby on Monday July 11, 2016 @02:32AM (#12069244)
Money is always a confidence trick. It is only valuable to you because you are confident that it is valuable to other people.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by asciihacker on Monday July 11, 2016 @10:27AM (#12071247)
do you draw a distinction between currency and money?
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by s17tnet on Monday July 11, 2016 @02:19AM (#12069218)
The whole western bank system is a confidence trick. Never head off fractional-reserve ? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by simonh on Monday July 11, 2016 @04:38AM (#12069686)
Can you name a banking or finance system that has ever existed that wasn't? Are there non-western banking systems that are better?
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by s17tnet on Monday July 11, 2016 @05:44AM (#12069924)
I can't because I don't know one. The point is that every transaction, from barter to high frequency trading, is a matter of trust.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by simonh on Monday July 11, 2016 @10:48AM (#12071394)
Then why did you say 'western'?
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by ZenoArrow on Monday July 11, 2016 @02:39AM (#12069265)
It's worse than just fractional reserve banking. The vast majority of the money supply is based off debt.

Would recommend watching the 4 minute introduction on the Positive Money homepage for a quick overview of the current situation with money creation:

http://positivemoney.org/

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Monday July 11, 2016 @03:25AM (#12069402)
The world's population in the 1900 was 1,5B people. By 1970, it was twice that. By the year 2000, it was twice that again! And by 2050 it will be 9B.

Where does the money for all those people would come from if not from borrowing (money from the future)?

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by dredmorbius on Monday July 11, 2016 @07:57AM (#12070400)
Where do cricket points come from?

Money comes from the same place.

It's not substance. It's not energy.

(Though yes, it's exchangeable for both. And time. And space.)

It's information. About obligations and demand rights.

It can be created as fractional reserve. Or simply issued into existence (thogh market ops make pricing more transparent).

While we're at it, I'm not entirely certain of that 9 billion figure either.

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Monday July 11, 2016 @08:35AM (#12070570)
>(Though yes, it's exchangeable for both. And time. And space.)

Yeah, that's kind of a big differentiation though. Isn't it?

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by dredmorbius on Monday July 11, 2016 @05:10PM (#12074660)
Sorry, I don't grasp your point.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by ZenoArrow on Monday July 11, 2016 @03:42AM (#12069469)
Money does not need to be based on debt. Money is just a medium of exchange. There is no requirement for the creation of money to generate profit for the money creators, especially as the cost of creating digital money is near zero.

If you want to look into it more, I'd suggest taking a look at debt-free money.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monetary_reform

http://positivemoney.org/2011/10/debt-free-money/

http://positivemoney.org/2016/03/debt-free-money-brief-reply...

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Monday July 11, 2016 @04:19AM (#12069606)
This requires a perfectly just world. We do not live in such a world and we probably never will.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by ZenoArrow on Monday July 11, 2016 @05:16AM (#12069828)
It doesn't.

There's a few different ways of creating debt-free money.

Government-created debt-free money has existed in the past, and can exist again. Using the UK system as an example, the minimum that would be required would be to update the Bank Charter Act of 1844 to include bank credit, so that private banks couldn't create money:

http://positivemoney.org/how-money-works/how-did-we-end-up-h...

It would then be the sole responsibility of the government to create money and spend it into the economy. In order to prevent hyperinflation, you could create an independent body responsible for setting how much new money could be created, which would be separate from the those who decided what the money was spent on.

As for other forms of debt-free money, cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin also qualify. You do not owe interest to Bitcoin miners, when you own a Bitcoin it is debt-free, and it cannot be destroyed by paying off a debt.

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Monday July 11, 2016 @05:18AM (#12069832)
Oh but it does. Because you will essentially be destroying the wealth of the rich people. They will not agree to that.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by ZenoArrow on Monday July 11, 2016 @05:39AM (#12069910)
All it requires is for people to choose democratic representatives that stick up for the interests of the masses. Even if a few rich people disagree with the policy, it doesn't matter if the masses have decided what they want to happen.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Monday July 11, 2016 @07:18AM (#12070268)
Oh, if that's all that is required then it shouldn't be such a big problem.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by ZenoArrow on Monday July 11, 2016 @07:21AM (#12070287)
Glad you agree.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Monday July 11, 2016 @08:55AM (#12070682)
Have you been involved in any political decision? Even just at a company level?
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by ZenoArrow on Monday July 11, 2016 @09:46AM (#12070981)
Yes. Why?
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Monday July 11, 2016 @10:19AM (#12071193)
You definitely don't sound like you hqve.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by ZenoArrow on Monday July 11, 2016 @10:41AM (#12071343)
Looks like you were mistaken then.

If you want to make a substantial point, you'll need to address the content of the points I raised rather than wasting our time with ad hominems. Why do you find it far fetched that people can choose to vote for those that will represent their best interests?

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Monday July 11, 2016 @02:04PM (#12072966)
I already addressed what needed addressing.

I told you that "people to choose democratic representatives that stick up for the interests of the masses" is an impossible task. You prefer to ignore that and/or pretend that it is not true.

So I told you that your idea cannot be put in practice because we don't live in a perfect world but you don't acknowledge that. What is left there to say?

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by AnimalMuppet on Monday July 11, 2016 @03:18PM (#12073568)
> I told you that "people to choose democratic representatives that stick up for the interests of the masses" is an impossible task. You prefer to ignore that and/or pretend that it is not true.

You made a large claim that was completely unsubstantiated. ZenoArrow didn't ignore the claim; he/she didn't believe it. On HN, that's your cue to provide some evidence to back up your claim. That's what's left to say. Provide some evidence that "people to choose democratic representatives that stick up for the interests of the masses" is an impossible task.

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @07:39AM (#12078226)
Oh god this is embarrassing to be honest.

There is no one "interest of the people". There is no "people". There are different groups with different interests. Or are you proposing dictatorship of the proletariat? Because we know how that turned out, don't we?

If you want evidence of the above you need to look no further than a couple of weeks back to the Brexit vote. You have it there all.

- There is no disproportionate political influence by the rich. The majority of the rich said "don't do it! PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF GOD DON'T DO IT!".

- There is no rich vs. poor. One of the richest, most influential people on Earth, Rupert Murdoch, used his media influence to sway the vote in favor of leaving.

- People unable or not interested in forming a balanced opinion. The decision was made because of demagoguery and blatantly false claims.

- Power-hungry, opportunistic politicians riding the wave, no matter what the wave is and then back tracking on their promises and claims.

Same thing happened in the Greek elections. A politician came, promised all sort of things, and in the end did exactly the opposite of what he promised.

So in the end people acted against their self-interest. Because they don't know what their interest is and because politicians tricked them. Story as old as mankind itself. There should be no need to "prove it". If it wasn't self-evident, then you are just out of touch with reality. But here you go, I spent 10 minutes explaining things that should be self-evident, to people who claim that they understand the politics and science of reconciling interests and opinions.

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by ZenoArrow on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @03:46PM (#12081807)
> "So in the end people acted against their self-interest. Because they don't know what their interest is and because politicians tricked them."

You fix that by having a more informed population. You can do this in multiple ways, but primarily the fight is in breaking the stranglehold of the mass media by popularising news outlets with more in-depth and clear analyses of the issues we face. It's not an impossible fight, it's one we can make a difference in. If you don't believe things will change, then step back and let people who are willing to make a difference put in the work to do it for you.

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @04:58PM (#12082232)
Oh, so people who pick apart your flawed plans should just shut the fuck up and let you agitate for a global revolution? Because that's what you are doing. You did not argue for better education. You argued for a change in the financial system. One that requires a massive change in people's reasoning abilities in order to work out as advertised.

"Oh hey guys, let's do this very cool thing where we will all live way better. just don't read the fine print which says that everybody needs to be very smart and educated in order for all of this to work." And when they follow you and your idea touches reality and your plan shatters? What then? Because we have it very good now and you want to improve it a bit, but if (when) you fail we will have it A LOT worse. Risk vs. reward is not there at all.

If you want to improve things, go for it. But you are proposing to cure a common cold with a surgery.

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by ZenoArrow on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @09:04PM (#12083338)
> "Oh, so people who pick apart your flawed plans should just shut the fuck up and let you agitate for a global revolution?"

I'm all for debate, but if you were interested in debate before you wouldn't have dismissed it as 'impossible' without explanation. Just because you say something is impossible doesn't make it so, you have to elaborate on why. If you're interested in engaging in the implementation details now I'm all for a debate.

> "You did not argue for better education. You argued for a change in the financial system."

I argued for both. I argued for a change in the financial system, and as I elaborated on how I could see this come to pass, I argued for better education. To me there is no conflict, to have an effective democracy you need an informed populace, otherwise people are too easily swayed by demagoguery. If you think this represents a shift in my argument, I'd invite you to read my comment history, I have been clear with my position on how the mass media plays a big role in influencing the masses. Breaking through the misinformation spread by the mass media is an important prerequisite for societal change that benefits the many. In terms of how to break through media manipulation, I could go into implementation details if you're interested.

> "Because we have it very good now"

Maybe in your world, but economic inequality is an increasingly pressing issue, and one that needs to be addressed. Take a look at this story...

http://www.oxfam.org.uk/media-centre/press-releases/2016/01/...

If that is accurate, 62 people have the same level of wealth as half the population of the world. Do you recognise the types of problems that concentration of power can create?

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @02:29AM (#12084258)
>I argued for both. I argued for a change in the financial system, and as I elaborated on how I could see this come to pass

But see, the education comes first. You don't promise people sunshine and rainbows and then give them a condition. They will not hear about the condition. They heard about the prize and all they hear is the prize. And this is how so many tin-foil hatters are bread, convinced of lizard people puppeteering the whole planet in their spare time. Bullshit like Zeigeist. Concatenations with half the facts missing. Straight to the conclusions. This is the route you take when you want to trick people, not when you want to educate them!

And no, I actually don't see the problem with income inequality. People in general are living better. I don't particularly care that Mark Zuckerberg has a million times more money then me. I will be able to send to send my son to the same university as his. So who cares and why?

Even if there are problems, you are curing a cold with surgery. it's all about risk/reward. And your ratio sucks. Big time.

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by ZenoArrow on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @03:45AM (#12084548)
Education of the masses comes first, but there's no problem in an individual who has researched an issue discussing it before the education of the masses has taken place.

As for your claim that you don't see the problems that come from income inequality, the rich have two main advantages:

1. They can more easily buy influence in government to have legislation passed that favours them over others.

2. They can take greater control of material assets, and alter the power dynamic in a market.

Do you see these as problems?

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @05:17AM (#12084933)
So you ask for evidence about painfully obvious things, but you feel like you can make unsubstantiated claims when there is evidence that directly contradicts those claims? Even when I addressed them already?

All the rich people were against Brexit but it still happened, didn't it? There is no one monolithic lizard people cabal that is out there to get you. There are many, many different groups with competing interests and opinions. This is why capitalism has been so good and has brought us so much prosperity. Real power cannot be usurped. Everybody competes. And this is why I cast doubt on your political acumen. You seem to have 0 consideration for competing interests and opinions. In your head everything happens in a vacuum and all will be OK if everybody was just a little bit more like you. Well, that's not going to happen. You can pout and scream unjustice and agitate people with beautiful promises and at the end of the day you will either have accomplished nothing or you will have crashed the best period in human history.

The kind of change you want requires a gradual improvement, not a revolution. Shift in the generations to come, not asking people to make a massive jump in their reasoning RIGHT NOW. And for all we know, the generations to come have a shift in their thinking. There's evidence for that. Milenials have a very different value chain the generations before them.

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @11:55AM (#12080094)
I just love the downvote.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by mac01021 on Monday July 11, 2016 @04:25AM (#12069633)
Why does additional population require additional money?
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by ZenoArrow on Monday July 11, 2016 @05:36AM (#12069899)
Because deflation is seen as more risky than inflation. In principal prices could drop to stretch the spending power of money, so that the money supply didn't need to increase along with population. In practice this is seen as risky as during the period of transition to lower prices you risk going through a period of economic slowdown and reduced spending power of the population. These problems are especially problematic in a system of globalised trade, as foreign investors can take advantage of the deflationary period to gain further control of local assets.

In other words, inflation is required because the world's economy is based on growth, and inflation and deflation are not equal in this scenario. If the world's economy was based on a steady state economic system, then we wouldn't need to create more money.

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by js8 on Monday July 11, 2016 @06:00AM (#12069981)
To add to your (correct) answer, world's economy has to based on growth for physics reasons. In the real world, almost all things that we produce slowly depreciate due to entropy. So to even maintain the living standard, you need constant production, and thus constant investment. Deflation doesn't incentivize investment (which is an irreversible decision), so the only alternative is, in the face of risk, (small) inflation.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by Dylan16807 on Monday July 11, 2016 @04:11AM (#12069572)
You can just print more money in proportion to population growth. While keeping a stable minimum reserve percent.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by blahi on Monday July 11, 2016 @04:54AM (#12069745)
The rich people will be less rich in that situation. They are in a similar situation now with the current inflation, but growth of money has to be tied to economic growth or otherwise the rich will feel screwed.

I'm not saying it's good, but you cannot screw the rich. The current situation is a compromise and a very sensible at that I might add, despite all the noise from tin-foil hatters.

There are also other, practical consideration which will make what you are proposing impossible to put in practice for a prolong period of time.

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by ZenoArrow on Monday July 11, 2016 @05:26AM (#12069863)
> "The rich people will be less rich in that situation."

> "growth of money has to be tied to economic growth or otherwise the rich will feel screwed."

> "I'm not saying it's good, but you cannot screw the rich."

Two points:

1. Aside from the financial services industry, the rich would be just as capable of getting rich regardless of how new money was put into the system. The pot of available money to grow their businesses would still exist.

2. What is stopping a group from "screwing the rich"? Furthermore, why are you framing addressing economic inequality as "screwing the rich"? Economic inequality will get addressed one way or another, the divide between the rich and the poor shouldn't be allowed to grow unchecked.

> "the noise from tin-foil hatters."

If you're referring to me, I was merely pointing out how the money system works and pointing out that alternatives are available. If you want to refute the accuracy of what I've stated, then please feel free to do so.

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by adventured on Monday July 11, 2016 @05:25AM (#12069857)
The rich do better than everyone else in times of inflation. Their assets are heavily liquid and easily moved. They have very little to fear from higher rates of inflation, it enables them to outperform everyone else that is more income dependent and less asset rich. The poor have the most to fear, by far. That's also why the rich have done so well since the year 2000, the Fed's policies have been heavy on dollar debasement since then, which has eroded the median while the rich have been able to benefit from the Fed's monetary support of asset prices. The Fed's asset inflation policies are a prime driver of the growth in wealth inequality in the US.
Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by naveen99 on Monday July 11, 2016 @08:14AM (#12070471)
I would say it's not a rich vs poor issue. The people who lose money with inflation are the ones who are over exposed to their currency: pensioners close to retirement, forex traders or foreign governments who bet on that currency, black market players who have to hold large amounts of cash without investing it, banks with a lot of fixed 30 year low interest rate mortgages outstanding. Forex players, banks, and foreign governments can be rich, pensioners and black market players can be poor.

Banks actually sell most of the mortgages back to the federal government in the us. Maybe that's the reason us government isn't inflating the dollar too much. They themselves hold most of it through mortgages.

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by riprowan on Monday July 11, 2016 @09:21AM (#12070830)
History shows that you can screw the rich.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/10/Hinricht...

Re:Italy’s teetering banks will be Europe’s next crisis by kybernetikos on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @05:21AM (#12084952)
> The vast majority of the money supply is based off debt.

That's because of the money supply measure you choose, so it's a pretty meaningless thing to complain about.

M0 for example is a measure of the money supply that is not based off debt. Most of the other measures include demand deposits in fractional reserve banks which are primarily debt.