News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by shrugger on Saturday May 28, 2016 @07:56AM (#11791337)
I know it's one of those 'tabs or spaces' questions, but are there any decent alternatives to Reddit?

I've tried Voat, but it's literally just Reddit.

The world needs a p2p, anonymity-first, censorship resistant link-sharing and discussion site/app/thing.

If anyone could point in some such direction, I sure would appreciate it.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by rsync on Saturday May 28, 2016 @12:21PM (#11792185)
"but are there any decent alternatives to Reddit?"

You're on it. You're using it right now. This is it.

I've been an active user and contributor to (in order) local BBS, Fidonet, Usenet, Slashdot, Kuro5hin, digg/reddit, HN, and in my opinion, HN is the best, most interesting and functional discussion board that has ever existed.

Enjoy it! It won't last forever.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by nightcracker on Saturday May 28, 2016 @12:31PM (#11792238)
HN is too limited in scope to be compared to reddit.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by dredmorbius on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:00PM (#11794310)
HN is very profoundly limited in scope and capabilities.

Simple stuff like collapsing long comment threads would be a Very Nice Plus, f'rex.

I've been on nearly all the platforms you've mentioned. The early ones (BBSes, Usenet) were tiny in comparison. Slashdot always kinda sucked for moderation, though its editorial curation was more useful than people today appreciate. Kuro5hin had some good ideas but ultimately never gained traction. I actually skipped digg. I use reddit, and like it for some elements, but it also frustrates me.

My interests are more toward a bloggy-oriented discussion platform, and the mix of capabilities, community, and hosting (free is unfortunately where I'm at for now), is hard to find.

I'm actually warming back on blogs, with self-hosted static-site systems being particularly attractive.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by wodenokoto on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:06PM (#11793199)
I really like hn, but it is more like a subreddit, than an actual reddit alternative.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by shrugger on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:45PM (#11792521)
HN censoring is terrifyingly rampant, dang is an extremely egotistic, and objectively biased moderator. I don't disagree that HN is capable of producing interesting conversations, but it's a very limited window imo. HN suffers greatly from one of the major problems that plagues Reddit, and that's the hivemind effect that threads seem to have. I was a great fan of Slashdot because it was possible to see multiple threads with different opinions from a parent topic, but on HN, whatever the hivemind agrees with floats the top and the rest sinks like a rock. That people think HN is even close to a balanced platform is somewhat concerning.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by CaptSpify on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:14PM (#11793265)
The difference though, is that HN clearly does not claim to be an uncensored free for all. HN has a very strong focus, and strong rules. They want a very limited window, and that's not a bad thing. I think that will help them stick around for a long time.

But that makes reddit and HN an apples to oranges comparison. They aren't even trying to be the same thing.

My personal concern, is that there is no reddit replacement that has a broad focus. All of the alternatives seem to be racist shit-holes, or fluffy, clearly manufactured facebook-feed alternatives.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by dsacco on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:06PM (#11793201)
>> HN censoring is terrifyingly rampant, dang is an extremely egotistic, and objectively biased moderator.

Sigh...alright, I'll bite. Can you give a concrete example of HN censoring in effect?

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by gedrap on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:48PM (#11793412)
One of the cases was banning of michaelochurch ( https://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/ ), who was heavily criticizing YC, Paul Graham, and VCs in general and was relatively popular, banned for swearing or something like that. While many of his posts are extremely negative, some of them have ideas worth considering.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by said on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:46PM (#11793407)
I don't have any concrete examples, so this answer likely won't satisfy you.

Also, I must mention that dang has been significantly more fair the past year or so. It's been a long while since I've really noticed any of the issues I'm about to list.

From least to most concerning:

1. A couple of years ago, dang would regularly wade into gender arguments. And he'd apologize publicly and profusely to women who had unspecific complaints about Hacker News making them feel "unsafe", assuring those women that he felt their pain and would fix the problem.

2. Rules about tone were enforced unevenly. (Again, to be clear, they're now enforced far more fairly.)

Cruel, over-the-top, mean-spirited, Shanley-style [1] derogatory posts from feminist activists would routinely be allowed to stand. People would respond asking why this tone was being allowed on HN, and others would respond with "it's oppressive to tone-police women in tech". Despite all the attention drawn to these posts, they would not be moderated.

At the same time, the slightest acerbic replies against feminist activism were either "deaded" or publicly admonished by dang.

3. This last point is the most difficult to prove, but regular lurkers will know exactly what I'm talking about. Flags were enforced unevenly—they were used as an excuse to minimize community exposure to posts that disagreed with dang's politics.

When a controversial submission that ran counter to the feminist narrative quickly disappeared off the front page despite hundreds of comments, people would complain in the thread (because where else would they complain?). He'd respond, "Hey, this submission received a lot of flags. This wasn't my decision. I'm not closing this thread, so you can continue discussion. But I'm listening to the community by taking it off the front page."

However, controversial submissions that promoted the feminist narrative would often stay up for hours. Those posts undoubtably received tons of flags, too. When people would complain, dang would explain that he would disregard flags for controversial posts if they generated important conversations.

[1]: http://www.breitbart.com/london/2014/12/10/the-madness-of-qu...

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by unlinker on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:48PM (#11793414)
If you say something that could be labelled as conservative (something racist, or something about family values vs. homosexuality, or mentioning men and women are not equal in some way, etc) your comment will be killed by dang himself, and he'll say you're being inflammatory.

It's funny how this creates an echo chamber where nobody in real life is racist, or where you believe yourself that something remotely racist is wrong.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by jklinger410 on Saturday May 28, 2016 @05:24PM (#11793599)
being insensitive is now being conflated with being racist/sexist etc etc
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by throwawaymaroon on Saturday May 28, 2016 @03:37PM (#11793074)
I wouldn't describe myself as a dang fan, but egotistic? Sure, he's just a low-ranking enforcer used to shield YC from criticism, but he's just doing his job. It's not exactly his fault, as a pawn, if the overall system is poisoned.

But as to the rest of it, yeah, the HN hivemind is insane in exactly the same way Startup Culture is a sick, greedy mess.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by DanBC on Saturday May 28, 2016 @08:14AM (#11791375)
>The world needs a p2p, anonymity-first, censorship resistant link-sharing and discussion site/app/thing

Every single time that's been tried it tanked because either pathological arseholes overwhelmed everyone else, or no-one wanted to use it.

But since you ask for an example that you can use: The "free" hierarchy of Usenet. It was set up to have no rules.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by visakanv on Saturday May 28, 2016 @08:21AM (#11791391)
> Every single time that's been tried it tanked because either pathological arseholes overwhelmed everyone else, or no-one wanted to use it.

Absolutely. I once ran a community that grew from 5 to 50 to 300+ people, and had this utopian vision that moderation wouldn't be necessary, we were intelligent, enlightened people who would have healthy discussions and hash out our disagreements in civil ways.

Alas.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by intended on Saturday May 28, 2016 @08:39AM (#11791416)
AH, the FIRST dream of any mod.

That said, moderation and moderation tools - especially on reddit, are evolving. To the point that many issues which I thought were fatal, are now manageable (such as permanent noise to signal ratio attenuation).

Unfortunately what keeps me up at night, is that the tools we are developing are straight up censorship bots and their proliferation on various subreddits, and eventually to all social platforms is beyond worrisome.

Theres big brother, and then theres the more agile and nimble little brother.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by davidivadavid on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:10AM (#11791513)
Here's an idea that's probably naive and that's been tried before and failed: what about individual moderation?

Let users decide: "I never want to see anything from that guy ever again" (unless, say, 50 people I've upvoted upvote one of his comments).

I can see why people would want to avoid such solution, with all the "filter bubble" rhetoric, but I can't see why it wouldn't be a viable option?

In fact, I'm pretty sure there's a huge opportunity in that space, for whoever nails the mechanics correctly.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by jonathankoren on Saturday May 28, 2016 @11:51AM (#11792077)
Slashdot has that with their friend-foe feature. You could assign anywhere between a +2 and -2 bonus to anyone you friended or foed. Additionally you could assign bonuses to anyone that friended or foed you. Comments only had a score range of +5 to -2 with -2 being completely hidden. So someone you foed at -2 could only show up for you if his comment got a +3. (Default view threshold is 1.)
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by function_seven on Sunday May 29, 2016 @03:22AM (#11795320)
> Additionally you could assign bonuses to anyone that friended or foed you.

I just some nostalgia for /. from this comment. People who friended or foed you were "fans" and "freaks", respectively.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by sgc on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:27AM (#11791565)
RES etc have this, but there are millions of users; thus I have never used it because the idea of going down that rabbit hole is rather off-putting. I like your basic premise though.

There is a lot of space between reddit's "everything the mods let you see" (whether you want it or not) and facebook's "only what your friends (or Zuck) want you to see", and the two extremes cause a lot of friction. Something much better is certainly possible.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by CamperBob2 on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:23PM (#11792426)
This is tricky because the desirable attributes that we're looking for in a utopian discussion medium all have dark downsides. Privacy and security require impenetrable anonymity... which in turn means that abusive users can simply abandon one troll or sock puppet account and pop up with another.

As with Usenet, you'd end up having to buy a bigger hard drive just to keep your killfile up to date.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by stanmancan on Saturday May 28, 2016 @12:05PM (#11792131)
Sounds like this would be a solution for a small community with a low growth rate. At any scale the chances of you running into a particular user diminishes. "Ignoring" 20% of a 100 member community isn't too difficult. But if that community is >500 suddenly that becomes quite a burden.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by icebraining on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:24AM (#11791555)
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by iza on Saturday May 28, 2016 @12:21PM (#11792189)
That's how Hubski works and it's pretty great. However I'm not sure it would scale well if it had as many users as reddit.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by dublinben on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:59PM (#11793474)
Hubski importantly applies that in a positive sense too. I only get content from users I actively choose to follow. There can be entire subcultures represented on the site that I will never be aware of.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by aptwebapps on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:04AM (#11791494)
At what population level did things start to go noticeably South?
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by sunshiney on Saturday May 28, 2016 @10:36AM (#11791779)
For me, it happened at 325 users of a community group. Pia for sure. I truly wish people were more like cats sometimes -- a quick swipe and then friends again. :-)
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by visakanv on Sunday May 29, 2016 @12:59AM (#11794875)
It would get progressively 'worse' I think from 150, 200, 250, 300. The group eventually 'died' at 300. I should've instituted clearer rules and moderations once we hit about 75, or frankly, from day 1.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by weego on Saturday May 28, 2016 @10:50AM (#11791819)
That's because the people doing it think that decentralisation, privacy and censorship are primary features that will sell any old bullshit facebook clone site instead of being nice secondary or tertiary features underlying some new idiom that are transparent to users.

Even if you managed that and then managed somehow to get funding to grow and scale for a system with no obvious revenue opportunities history shows us you are still likely to fail.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by voidmein on Saturday May 28, 2016 @10:21AM (#11791742)
> pathological arseholes overwhelmed everyone else

How about a system like this.

Something like HN or reddit, but make it read only via online. And the only way to post into it should be by sending a hand written mail, to the admins. These will not be filtered, and will be posted exactly as they are written. People will be able to see the discussions online. The original note can be optionally delivered/forwarded to the recipient (let us snail mail that too)... There will be upvotes and downvotes. But nothing will be sorted or hidden based on that. In other words, take the "instant gratification" out of the discussions, and make them more personal.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by Anon1096 on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:34AM (#11791598)
4chan's been here for a while for anyone looking for anonymity-first minimal moderation forums. Of course, it isn't the most pleasant site and definitely isn't for everyone.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by stanmancan on Saturday May 28, 2016 @11:59AM (#11792109)
Surely how pleasant a site is must correlate to how much moderation and anonymity its users experience.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by shrugger on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:45PM (#11792523)
Yeah, because Reddit has turned out great, hasn't it? /s
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by stanmancan on Saturday May 28, 2016 @03:41PM (#11793095)
I'm sure most would agree Reddit is much more pleasant than 4chan.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by dpc59 on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:20PM (#11793300)
It really depends on the subreddits and their mods.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by unlinker on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:51PM (#11793432)
A huge split is always created: sites for left wingers (usually very moderated) and sites for right wingers (usually more free).
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by tomp on Saturday May 28, 2016 @11:49AM (#11792072)
As much as I would like to see this, censorship-resistant networks don't fare well in today's political climate (because of child porn and copyright). There's always a point of failure; if nothing else, it's the contact between the real world and the virtual world(s).

We can see this today in the case of TOR. The network is censorship-resistant from within, but it's still vulnerable externally - if governments put its users into jail, that's effectively censoring the whole network instead of some specific content.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by _xander on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:18PM (#11792668)
8chan is quite close to what you described. Although the anonymity-first censorship-resistance thing might give you more than you bargained for once you get there.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by frabrunelle on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:59AM (#11791677)
I am closely following Project Decorum (http://www.project-decorum.com), which is built using the SAFE Network.

I am also interested by Yours (https://www.yours.network), which is built using Bitcoin.

And you can see a list of other related projects here: https://github.com/yoursnetwork/yours-core/blob/master/docs/...

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by Pxtl on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:04PM (#11792597)
Moderation is hard especially against bots and spammers. Moderation on a p2p environment would be harder.

Reddit had the advantage that the subreddit is a natural partition point so it's not quite as hard a problem as something more granular, but still: p2p social network is hard.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by shrugger on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:07PM (#11792611)
Moderation of discussion is unethical, imo.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by Pxtl on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:09PM (#11792618)
So are violent threats, doxxing, conspiring to commit horrible crimes, and racism. Which do you want on your site?
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by shrugger on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:44PM (#11792800)
Coercion is criminal. Should I stoop to the level of a common racist by FORCING him/her to speak a certain way? I've no right to tell people what they can and can not say, nor will I hold myself responsible for their thoughts and actions. It's their burden to bear.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by yathern on Saturday May 28, 2016 @06:58PM (#11793949)
> Coercion is criminal.

I'm not sure what you're saying here. Are you suggesting moderation of online discussion is coercion, and therefor criminal? I think the entire legal system (US specifically) would disagree. Or are you suggestion that a user that is using coercion is criminal, and something you would put a stop to?

> Should I stoop to the level of a common racist by FORCING him/her to speak a certain way?

That's a judgement call to make, depending the context of the site. Yes, you can make the argument that censorship of hate speech is as unethical as the speech itself. I'm not sure if I agree or disagree, and it's a bit of a rabbit hole. Or you could make the argument that your site is for particular discussion of certain topics, and if it's well known what the rules are, there's great benefit to the community by enforcing them: eg /b/ vs Hacker News.

> I've no right to tell people what they can and can not say

You absolutely do, if they are using a site which you own or are in some way in charge of. The same way you have the right to tell someone to get off your lawn.

> nor will I hold myself responsible for their thoughts and actions. It's their burden to bear.

You don't have to hold yourself responsible, but your users might. And shrugging that responsibility might result in a bad experience for many users, depending on how the culture and discussion of a site develops.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by Pxtl on Saturday May 28, 2016 @03:15PM (#11792958)
But fora are really a website posting your comment on your behalf. A website shouldn't silence you, but is also under no obligation to give you their megaphone.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by conceit on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:54PM (#11793449)
Coercion is not necessarily criminal. Where does it say otherwise?

> Should I stoop to the level of a common racist by FORCING him/her to speak a certain way?

You are not a Forum. On the other hand, your comment implies you try to convince someone to act (not) a certain way. The difference between the force and conviction might make all the difference, but conviction is one kind of force, isn't it?

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by DanBC on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:12PM (#11793253)
You might want to host it yourself, rather than expose other people to the legal threat that comes with what you ask for.

This is possible with INN. Everything you ask for, I think, is possible with INN.

https://www.eyrie.org/~eagle/software/inn//

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by notduncansmith on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:28PM (#11792718)
Hey, I'm working on something similar to what you're describing (focused on mobile right now) and would love to get your thoughts. My email is in my profile, please reach out and I'll show you what we've got so far.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by zeckalpha on Saturday May 28, 2016 @11:24AM (#11791952)
MetaFilter.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by robbiemitchell on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:02AM (#11791487)
How do you build a P2P site/app? Isn't that by nature hosted somewhere?

As for alternatives, what about The Pirate Bay? Links, comments, anonymity.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by icebraining on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:33AM (#11791594)
It's hosted by the computers of the users running the app. For web apps, see TiddlyWiki, which runs off a single HTML file.

An existing example is Freenet, which has a decentralized messaging system.

Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by Tiquor on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:07AM (#11791505)
Old (some would say current) usenet was decentralized.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by drhodes on Saturday May 28, 2016 @11:38AM (#11792023)
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by unlinker on Saturday May 28, 2016 @07:57AM (#11791339)
A p2p discussion site would even be slower than reddit itself, and that's a lot to say.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by shrugger on Saturday May 28, 2016 @08:06AM (#11791359)
I've never been hindered by Reddit's speed myself. Is this a real issue in other places?
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by unlinker on Saturday May 28, 2016 @08:40AM (#11791420)
If you are logged in (i.e. pages are not cached) and you load a page with lots of comments (or any page, at a peak hour), generation times of over three seconds are not unheard of.
Re:Affiliate links on Reddit by notduncansmith on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:01AM (#11791480)
Working on it.