News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by mmastrac on Monday May 23, 2016 @10:41AM (#11754120)
This reads like "I don't eat breakfast, so here's the reasons why I'm right." Studies that support his conclusion, while flawed, are probably right. Studies that oppose it are obviously tainted by various problems.

The fact that research shows that breakfast is actually beneficial for children is hand-waved away because 'reasons'.

This is honestly just a low-quality, cherry-picked opinion piece by someone who really doesn't like breakfast.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by coldtea on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:47AM (#11754603)
>This reads like "I don't eat breakfast, so here's the reasons why I'm right."

Actually he gives very reasoned arguments and comments on meta-studies showing that he is right -- not that breakfast is bad, but in that it doesn't make any difference, and if it does nobody has clearly shown it.

(a) . In a paper published in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition in 2013, researchers reviewed the literature on the effect of breakfast on obesity to look specifically at this issue. They first noted that nutrition researchers love to publish results showing a correlation between skipping breakfast and obesity.

(b) However, they also found major flaws in the reporting of findings. People were consistently biased in interpreting their results in favor of a relationship between skipping breakfast and obesity. They improperly used causal language to describe their results. They misleadingly cited others’ results. And they also improperly used causal language in citing others’ results.

(c) Few randomized controlled trials exist. Those that do, although methodologically weak like most nutrition studies, don’t support the necessity of breakfast.

(d) Further confusing the field is a 2014 study (with more financial conflicts of interest than I thought possible) that found that getting breakfast skippers to eat breakfast, and getting breakfast eaters to skip breakfast, made no difference with respect to weight loss. But a 1992 trial that did the same thing found that both groups lost weight. A balanced perspective would acknowledge that we have no idea what’s going on.

(e) Many of the studies are funded by the food industry, which has a clear bias. Kellogg funded a highly cited article that found that cereal for breakfast is associated with being thinner. The Quaker Oats Center of Excellence (part of PepsiCo) financed a trial that showed that eating oatmeal or frosted cornflakes reduces weight and cholesterol (if you eat it in a highly controlled setting each weekday for four weeks).

Your comment however, reads exactly like you describe his, but for the opposite preference.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by PaulHoule on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:54AM (#11754648)
If anybody is telling you to eat when you are not hungry, check to see if they are selling something.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by raverbashing on Monday May 23, 2016 @02:32PM (#11755814)
This is the kind of thing that sounds right but makes absolutely no sense at all

Exactly because the sense of hunger is not correlated with the exact need to eat is that we have obesity.

Eating only when hungry sounds like a good idea but then you get (usually fat) people complaining they are hungry all the time.

An average adult will spend around 12h (and probably more) physiologically fine without food, until its glycogen reserves are depleted.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by dhimes on Monday May 23, 2016 @03:22PM (#11756164)
First you must distinguish between hunger and appetite. Hunger is usually accompanied by a "growling" stomach. Appetite is simply the desire for food.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by PaulHoule on Monday May 23, 2016 @03:43PM (#11756329)
In the case of "eat" you may be right, if you want to seriously lose weight you should probably adopt a structured eating plan.

In terms of "consume" in general, there is an intense commercial pressure to get you to "consume" more. Oddly you don't see ads pressuring you to eat lunch or eat dinner, although Taco Bell used to advertise "fourthmeal" for a while.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by coldtea on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @04:29AM (#11759794)
>Eating only when hungry sounds like a good idea but then you get (usually fat) people complaining they are hungry all the time.

Those people have no idea what is like to be actually hungry -- in the literal, haven't eater for 2 days sense.

They just have cravings.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by pc2g4d on Monday May 23, 2016 @04:05PM (#11756489)
I think they meant "Don't eat when you aren't hungry" rather than "Always eat when you're hungry". The first seems obviously true, while the second is something that I don't think anybody argues.

The disconnect between hunger and the need to eat may be an artifact of the separation of flavor from nutrition in modern, engineered "foods". To me it seems that hunger must have evolved as a fundamental signal to do or not do exactly what it's about (eat) but that it's been disrupted by modern developments.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by scotty79 on Monday May 23, 2016 @06:10PM (#11757456)
I'd argue both. "Don't eat when you aren't hungry" is very often violated because eating is social activity. I also don't see why would everybody agree on "Always eat when you're hungry". I think it's better to drink a glass of water (or tea) or milk when you are hungry or do something else instead like going somewhere where you should be, doing something you should do or just playing a game.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by pizza on Monday May 23, 2016 @08:37PM (#11758099)
What does depletion of glycogen have to do with hunger/being "physiologically fine"? People who are ketotic after about 1 or 2 days, or people who have just hit "the wall" during an ultra-long workout, don't have much glycogen to go on, but still get hungry just fine.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by Drdrdrq on Monday May 23, 2016 @03:22PM (#11756175)
I think you missed the point - the way I understood parent, he tried to point out that many of the articles about "healthy" food consumption are financed by food industry and should be more or less ignored.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by brianpan on Monday May 23, 2016 @03:13PM (#11756102)
Oh, god, my mom is in on it too?!
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by PaulHoule on Monday May 23, 2016 @04:01PM (#11756453)
Moms learn pretty early on that sugar is a powerful form of social control.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by skrause on Monday May 23, 2016 @02:42PM (#11755877)
I can personally confirm that I used to have a strong correlation between skipping breakfast and obesity. Back when I used to eat a big pizza at 11 pm followed by some beer I could never eat the next morning because I was still full, so I skipped breakfast and didn't eat until lunchtime.

However, the skipped breakfast was not the cause of my overweight, but simply the result of eating far too much in the evening. So maybe there actually is a correlation, but as always: Correlation does not imply causation.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by dhimes on Monday May 23, 2016 @03:19PM (#11756138)
My eating a big pizza and beer for breakfast also correlated with obesity, so there's that.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by mmastrac on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:58AM (#11754672)
(a), (b), (d), and (e) are where he's argued that support for "breakfast is good" is methodologically weak, but then he goes and brings out (c) as an argument for his conclusion, while also being methodologically weak at the same time.

You've also neglected to mention (f), where the author discusses studies that show that breakfast is beneficial to children and then handwaves both of them away:

> What about the argument that children who eat breakfast behave and perform better in school? Systematic reviews find that this is often the case.

and

> It has been found that children who skip breakfast are more likely to be overweight than children who eat two breakfasts.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by ethbro on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:23PM (#11755302)
The quote between your two selected lines

> One of the reasons that breakfast seems to improve children’s learning and progress is that, unfortunately, too many don’t get enough to eat. [...] It’s not hard to imagine that children who are hungry will do better if they are nourished.

Seems a pretty valid point as opposed to handwaving. Nutrition research in general has a pretty studious history of ignoring results in an attempt to support pre-existing conclusions.

For support of last statement, see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11444941 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K-ration (side note: military nutrition has a long and interesting involvement with civilian nutrition guidelines)

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by coldtea on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:35PM (#11755400)
>but then he goes and brings out (c) as an argument for his conclusion, while also being methodologically weak at the same time.

Here's the thing though: he has every scientific and methodological right to do so.

It's those making a claim (that breakfast is good) that have to prove it.

If they fail to provide evidence for their claim, those who like the author merely point out that their research is weak don't have to prove breakfast is neutral.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by jschwartzi on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:29PM (#11755349)
In those studies, they've probably failed to control for children who qualify for Free and Reduced Lunch, which is a good proxy for children who don't get enough to eat for lunch. I suspect the correlation would go away if that were controlled for.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by sathackr on Monday May 23, 2016 @02:59PM (#11755997)
> It has been found that children who skip breakfast are more likely to be overweight than children who eat two breakfasts.

What if overweight children are more likely to skip breakfast?

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by everfree on Monday May 23, 2016 @12:01PM (#11754693)
So it sounds like a more apt name for the article would be "There is no conclusive evidence for or against whether breakfast is magical".
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by PeterisP on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:32PM (#11755372)
Once you have carefully looked in the obvious places, contrary to the proverb, absence of evidence is evidence of absence - not very strong evidence, but still.

With the attention paid to this topic, if no causal relationship has been found, then it does imply (though not conclusively) that in most circumstances breakfast does not have any strong, meaningful beneficial (or magical) effect.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by jonknee on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:21AM (#11754420)
Well there is no shortage of people who like breakfast (or are in charge of selling people breakfast) and hand wave about it being "the most important meal of the day". The truth is probably people have different metabolisms and if you are hungry in the morning you should eat and if you are not you shouldn't.

And that's almost exactly what this post suggests:

> The bottom line is that the evidence for the importance of breakfast is something of a mess. If you’re hungry, eat it. But don’t feel bad if you’d rather skip it, and don’t listen to those who lecture you. Breakfast has no mystical powers.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by thomasahle on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:25AM (#11754447)
And again other people may have metabolisms that need to be "kick started" in the morning by breakfast, to keep a stable bloodsugar level during the day.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by fu9ar on Monday May 23, 2016 @12:07PM (#11754742)
Did you read the article or just head straight into posting this morning?
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by jonknee on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:30AM (#11754481)
No shit:

> people have different metabolisms and if you are hungry in the morning you should eat and if you are not you shouldn't

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by lmm on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:34AM (#11754519)
People with the metabolism the grandparent describes don't feel hungry in the morning, but nevertheless should eat in the morning.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by eeeeeeeeeeeee on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:39PM (#11755436)
It probably depends a lot on when people eat dinner. I sometimes eat dinner at 5-6pm and then I definitely need breakfast. If I eat at 8-9pm, I usually skip breakfast. But I've sort of stopped with the whole "you must have 3 meals per day" at these designated increments and I simply eat when I'm hungry, regardless of the time.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by bgilroy26 on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:26AM (#11754449)
>The truth is probably people have different metabolisms and if you are hungry in the morning you should eat and if you are not you shouldn't.

Bodies don't always cooperate, if you are going to exercise strenuously in a given day you had better eat some kind of breakfast whether your body feels like it or not.

Breakfast is always going to be the opportunity to eat when you have more of the day ahead of you. That's true by definition, and it's the principle behind the chestnut about it being the most important meal of the day. There isn't much more to it than that.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by forgetsusername on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:41AM (#11754557)
>if you are going to exercise strenuously in a given day you had better eat some kind of breakfast whether your body feels like it or not

Or what? As someone who has undertaken week long fasts while participating in competitive sports with no discernible performance difference, I'm skeptical. Your body doesn't "run out of fuel" because you haven't eaten for 12 hours.

Everyone is different. These rules of thumb, including breakfast being extra special, are silly.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by ethbro on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:27PM (#11755339)
Well, it runs out of certain kinds of fuel. But luckily, evolution gifted us with multiple Plan B's to prevent silly malnourished mammals from keeling over the first time they missed a meal!
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by collyw on Monday May 23, 2016 @12:41PM (#11754958)
Meh, I did 4 hours driving followed by 4 or 5 hours of whitewater kayaking on Saturday, with hardly anything to eat until afterwards. (I have been doing a bit of intermittent fasting the last couple of years, and that seems to help in such situations).
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by wildmusings on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:10PM (#11755196)
>Bodies don't always cooperate, if you are going to exercise strenuously in a given day you had better eat some kind of breakfast whether your body feels like it or not.

I've done many multi-day hikes and a 24 mile one-day hike. I can confirm that eating breakfast before setting out in the morning is absolutely crucial. Like the old saying goes, an army marches on its stomach.

I'm normally not hungry in the morning, so this was a challenge. The few times I did skip breakfast on these hikes, I had to stop half-an-hour in to correct my mistake, as I felt completely drained.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by jonknee on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:50PM (#11755507)
> I've done many multi-day hikes, and a 24 mile one-day hike. I can confirm that eating breakfast before setting out in the morning is absolutely crucial. Like the old saying go, an army marches on its stomach.

Shockingly, people are different. I much prefer a snack on the trail to breakfast before.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by Fomite on Monday May 23, 2016 @03:42PM (#11756320)
This is my experience as well.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by SixSigma on Monday May 23, 2016 @03:14PM (#11756108)
Hunger and nutritional need are not the same.

Just like drinking when thirsty is drinking too late.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by ksk on Monday May 23, 2016 @12:44PM (#11754988)
>"I don't eat breakfast, so here's the reasons why I'm right.

Its more like "I don't eat breakfast, because I'm not hungry at that time". In your haste to paint the author as biased, you ended up sounding the same.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by duaneb on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:19PM (#11755264)
I think this is more of a refutation of "Breakfast is the most important meal of the day", not of the meal entirely.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by amelius on Monday May 23, 2016 @02:30PM (#11755805)
> The fact that research shows that breakfast is actually beneficial for children is hand-waved away because 'reasons'.

It seems that your comment is equally handwavy :)

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by bluthru on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:00PM (#11755111)
>The fact that research shows that breakfast is actually beneficial for children is hand-waved away because 'reasons'.

As a casual observer of this topic, it seems like breakfast is necessary for humans who want to grow: kids and people adding muscle mass.

If you want to lose weight or maintain breakfast can probably be skipped.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by a_small_island on Monday May 23, 2016 @03:27PM (#11756211)
>people adding muscle mass.

There is a very large following of Intermittent Fasting in the bodybuilding community. Tens/hundreds of thousands of consistent weightlifters who do not eat breakfast or lunch and put on impressive mass. Your body doesn't care about daily fluctuations, calories in/calories out, count your macros. Fin.

So I disagree with your casual conclusion.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by bluthru on Monday May 23, 2016 @04:22PM (#11756633)
IF is great for reducing body fat percentage while increasing muscle mass, but someone starting the day with protein will increase muscle at a faster rate.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by a_small_island on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @02:35AM (#11759381)
Of course you will be providing a source to this claim, right? right...? oh.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by IIlllIllIIIIlII on Monday May 23, 2016 @10:46AM (#11754161)
.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by mikeash on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:21AM (#11754415)
"X is good for you" is not typically a universal statement, but a probabilistic one. It doesn't have to be good for every single person in every single circumstance in order to be correct. It merely needs to be better for most people.

For example, not being overweight is good for you. The existence of people who survive famine because they started out obese doesn't disprove that.

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by IIlllIllIIIIlII on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:44AM (#11754577)
"Breakfast is good for you" implies that it has some benefit. In some cases, however, the cost of eating breakfast is greater than its benefit.

For instance, if you have to get to work at 5am, are you better off waking up earlier to eat breakfast? In this case, the cost of lost sleep may be greater than the benefit of breakfast.

The NYT article points out that many of the studies that claim breakfast is good may be flawed. If that's true, then we are likely overestimating the benefit of breakfast. And that means that in many cases where we thought

perceived_benefit(breakfast) > cost(breakfast)

it could actually be that

real_benefit(breakfast) < cost(breakfast)

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by mikeash on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:51AM (#11754630)
Yes, of course. I don't disagree with that at all. I'm just saying that "breakfast is good for you" is not disproven merely by showing that it's not always good for you.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by IIlllIllIIIIlII on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:56AM (#11754658)
my original thoughts were wrong. it makes more sense to use a cost/benefit function (ala economics) rather than a logical argument
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by mikeash on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:17PM (#11755249)
Gotcha. I think that's what I'm trying to say as well.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by ethbro on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:29PM (#11755352)
Feel free to leave original comments up. No shame in knowledge or thoughts!
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by de_Selby on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:23AM (#11754430)
I contend that lunch and dinner are also good for you.

Can you apply the same logic there?

Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast by arcticbull on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:08PM (#11755172)
Well, yes, that's why you have people investigating intermittent fasting. Some interesting results there too. It's good to question things.