Yes, of course. I don't disagree with that at all. I'm just saying that "breakfast is good for you" is not disproven merely by showing that it's not always good for you.
Re:There’s Nothing Magical About Breakfast
by IIlllIllIIIIlII on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:56AM
(#11754658)
my original thoughts were wrong. it makes more sense to use a cost/benefit function (ala economics) rather than a logical argument
Gotcha. I think that's what I'm trying to say as well.
For instance, if you have to get to work at 5am, are you better off waking up earlier to eat breakfast? In this case, the cost of lost sleep may be greater than the benefit of breakfast.
The NYT article points out that many of the studies that claim breakfast is good may be flawed. If that's true, then we are likely overestimating the benefit of breakfast. And that means that in many cases where we thought
perceived_benefit(breakfast) > cost(breakfast)
it could actually be that
real_benefit(breakfast) < cost(breakfast)