News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by russnewcomer on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:02AM (#11430873)
This is a pretty disturbing article, and I feel like Talese should have reported Foos to the local authorities. Foos is clearly a serial sexual offender, and should have been reported or at the very least put into treatment. Talese admits that Foos is an unreliable narrator and is pretty clearly a voyeur for sexual purposes, mentally shielding himself by saying, "oh, I'm just a researcher."

Journalism is one thing. This is enabling a predator, just as much as Foos' two wives.

Re:The Voyeur's Motel by knowaveragejoe on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:50AM (#11431350)
Did you read the entire article? It's certainly illegal and distasteful, but the writings contain a lot of poignant commentary on modern life in general, not just sex; about war, eating habits, racial issues, and so on. I found this particularly interesting:

> My voyeurism has contributed immensely to my becoming a futilitarian, and I hate this conditioning of my soul. . . . What is so distasteful is that the majority of subjects are in concert with these individuals in both design and plan. Many different approaches to life would be immediately implemented, if our society would have the opportunity to be Voyeur for a Day.

Also this:

> These experiences prodded Foos to concoct an “honesty test.” He would leave a suitcase, secured with a cheap padlock, in the closet of a motel room. When a guest checked in, he would say to Donna, in the guest’s hearing, that someone had just called to report leaving behind a suitcase with a thousand dollars inside. Foos then watched from the attic as the new guest found the suitcase and deliberated over whether to break the lock and look inside or return the suitcase to the motel office.

> Out of fifteen guests who were subjected to the honesty test, including a minister, a lawyer, and an Army lieutenant colonel, only two returned the suitcase to the office with the padlock intact. The others all opened the suitcase and then tried to dispose of it in different ways. The minister pushed the suitcase out the bathroom window into the bushes.

Re:The Voyeur's Motel by russnewcomer on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:53AM (#11431386)
I did read the entire article. I was very disturbed. The first of your quotes is actually part of what clearly disturbed me and made me think even more that Foos is clearly a sexual offender.

The second of your quotes I found to be just a secularized and romanticized restating of basic Christian doctrine (or just the 'Golden Rule'), which makes me further disturbed that someone would have to wade through years of voyeurism to reach that conclusion.

Re:The Voyeur's Motel by daveguy on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @01:29PM (#11432429)
Just FYI -- the "golden rule" was around for thousands of years before Christianity. It is an essential human rule of empathy.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Rule

(Antiquity section)

Re:The Voyeur's Motel by rootlocus on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @03:28PM (#11433575)
I think this sums up pretty well how important sex was for Mr. Foos:

  But more often Foos found observing his guests depressing. They argued. 
  They watched too much television. (This was especially irksome when the 
  guests were attractive and could have spent their time having sex instead.)
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by jandrese on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @03:37PM (#11433644)
I'm sorry my life isn't spicy enough for your liking Mr. Voyeur...
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by codingdave on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @02:08PM (#11432830)
I just want to make sure I understand your comment... are you saying that illegal and distasteful acts are OK as long as they have interesting / poignant documentation?
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by axlprose on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @07:21PM (#11435380)
How or why does something being "interesting" automatically imply that it's "OK"?

Interest is nothing more than a human behavioral response to a stimulus, it typically has little to do with what people think is "moral" (which itself is usually vague and hard to define). Just think of how many people find watching documentaries about serial killers, crimes, or atrocities like the holocaust or the jonestown massacre, entertaining. Not to mention your typical news channels in the US, which tend to disproportionately showcase negative events as opposed to positive/neutral ones. Does having an interest in that kind of media somehow imply a moral approval of it?

If the documentation is there, people are going to read it, and the more out of the ordinary it is, the more likely it will be that people find it interesting. Uniformly condemning people for having interest in deviant topics is a slippery slope to justifying censorship or thought policing. Accepting that it's natural does have the consequence of possibly giving some people the idea that it's "OK" to do questionable things on the basis that it will grant them some kind of fame/notoriety, but that would arguably only happen with a small minority of people (since the barrier to entry to conduct these sort of depraved acts isn't exactly low), and thus would probably have a smaller negative impact on society than just flat-out condemning everybody for having questionable interests.

Re:The Voyeur's Motel by codingdave on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @07:44PM (#11435505)
The fact that it was interesting is not the part of the comment that implied it was OK. It was the question asked of "Did your read the entire article?", which normally implies disagreement, and the word "but", which sounds to me like a justification.

That is also why I asked what was meant... I didn't want to jump to conclusions in case it was just a miscommunication due to wording.

Re:The Voyeur's Motel by 5ilv3r on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @03:56PM (#11433812)
Interesting regardless of morality.
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by rosser on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @02:36AM (#11437038)
"Interesting" and "moral" are orthogonal.
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by mbrutsch on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:30AM (#11431141)
> Foos is clearly a serial sexual offender

When the "victims" have to be informed, decades later, that they even are victims, it makes you wonder.

Re:The Voyeur's Motel by someone7x on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:45AM (#11431309)
To be fair, one of the victims was murdered because of the what he knew and did with that knowledge.
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by ceejayoz on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:41AM (#11431267)
You can be victimized without being aware of it.

Crimes against an infant, a comatose patient, etc. don't cease to be crimes.

Re:The Voyeur's Motel by bredren on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @12:29PM (#11431796)
Arguably, anyone living in the tax systems of those exposed in the Panama Papers are victims of the accused' possibly illegal, likely unethical tax avoidance.
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by thaumasiotes on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @12:44AM (#11436671)
What would make legal tax avoidance unethical?
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by russnewcomer on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:45AM (#11431313)
Sorry, it doesn't make me[0] wonder. It's still at the very least a moral failing.

If it were encryption keys he was snooping on and not sex, would your response be different?

[0]edit - I used the wrong pronoun (you) here in my initial post.

Re:The Voyeur's Motel by cpncrunch on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @06:33PM (#11435122)
Yes, it's still morally wrong, but only on the level of a white-hat hacker who hacks into a system, snoops around a bit, but doesn't alter anything. I'm sure a lot of us here have done that...
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by ghshephard on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:25AM (#11431075)
What are the odds that the entire story is pure (and well written) fiction, and that Gerald Foos never existed?
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by cwhipasapa on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @04:21PM (#11434023)
There's an item about it in the Denver Post: http://www.denverpost.com/news/ci_29727885/aurora-motel-owne... If the story checks out, I expect (or hope) the fallout will be a lot bigger in the coming weeks - that is assuming ISIS doesn't blow up the White house or Donald Trump commit suicide or something
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by pivo on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:54PM (#11434856)
I actually suspected that this was fiction when I read the part about Mr. Talese's tie accidentally hanging down through the vent above the couple having sex. How could that possibly happen without him or the couple noticing it?
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by qq66 on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @02:57PM (#11433299)
Gay Talese doesn't really write fiction. He may have never written a fiction piece in his life, it would be an odd time in his career to start.
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by partisan on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:03PM (#11434419)
Were you in the vent above him watching the whole time? Maybe he writes fictional pieces and then quietly flushes them down the toilet. Maybe there's a whole stack of fictional stories sitting on his desk waiting to be printed based on the popularity of this story.

If I took one thing from this article, it's that you never know what other people do or don't do. It's the thing you know, but it's jarring when you are reminded of it.

Re:The Voyeur's Motel by qq66 on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @07:20PM (#11435375)
Maybe he's a two-headed space alien.
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by yarou on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @08:56PM (#11435845)
Sure, but we have this nifty thing called Occam's Razor to immediately prune far fetched explanations, like someone secretly being a space lizard from Nibiru.
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by jzwinck on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:46AM (#11431320)
I would expect the purchase and sale of the hotel is a matter of public record, so it should be straightforward to check if the guy really ran the place.
Re:The Voyeur's Motel by saalweachter on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @12:01PM (#11431489)
In the article, it mentions the sale of the hotel was recorded in '69, while the journal starts in '66.

Meanwhile, the local police have no record of the murder, unsolved or otherwise.

It's possible those discrepancies could be explained, but the author left them in there to likely indicate he believes the voyeur's account is a mix of fantasy and reality. Which gives it dubious value as a research document, ignoring the ethics of how it was collected. Which in turn makes it difficult to rationalize the way in which the data was collected, if the data is of no value.

Re:The Voyeur's Motel by pvg on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @10:50PM (#11436266)
Zero. The New Yorker labels its fiction as fiction.