We need to reverse the trend. Otherwise, eventually, it will lead to violence, as many observers have predicted over the years (and it did lead to revolutions in many countries years ago, and even the Arab spring more recently).
Ways to do it:
- Stop restricting competition through laws that limit entry into various sectors (there's an absurd amount of laws which serve no use other than protecting big business interests)
- Heavy taxes on rent-seeking. There's an absurd amount of rent seeking in our economy, especially when it comes to commercial real estate in urban areas, patents, and many other behaviours (the tab above can be considered 'rent-seeking' since it introduces inefficiencies that favour incumbents)
- Estate taxes. While we love antidotes of the middle-class entrepreneur becoming a billionaire, it's the exception to the rule. While there is a lot of churn and mobility amongst the billionaire class, when you take the top 1% as a whole, they, as a group, are increasing their lead over the rest of society. Yes someone who has $50 million in the family can turn it into a billion. And someone with a billion can lose enough to go back to being a multi-millionaire. But the upper classes in general, due to their large real estate holdings and ability to seek rents, generally stay rich. If one family falls, those assets are likely incorporated into another family. Dynastic wealth doesn't always last, but the 1% generally stays the 1%, due to various dynamics.
- Real progressive taxation. While the lower classes pay lower percentages of income tax, it's stacked against them because their current rates still make up a larger percentage of their cost of living allowances. Not to mention, upper classes have more investment vehicles and tax avoidance vehicles at their disposal.
Anyhow, there's much more to say about it, but what it comes down to is, unless we stop the trend, nothing's going to get better, no matter how much we wish it.
Seems more accurate that dynastic wealth doesn't usually last[1][2][3]
[1] http://time.com/money/3925308/rich-families-lose-wealth/
[2] http://www.fa-mag.com/news/why-wealth-disappears-8227.html
So, the 62 richest own as much as the poorest 3,652,500,000. Gates and Buffet are interesting, with the philosophy of, give your kids enough to make something of themselves, but not so much they make nothing of themselves. The waltons on the other hand, are definitely shooting for dynastic wealth.
There's a (very) rare chance of getting super rich. There's a possibility of being the kind of person that wants dynastic wealth, so some percent of those super rich are going to have super rich families. Kennedy, Rockefeller, Mellon. But it tends to be dilluting after a while, there are thousands of DuPonts as far as i can tell.
I guess the point i'm making, some superrich will be effective in creating dynastic wealth (they have so far anyway) That, in and of itself isn't a big deal. All the wealth in the world is around $240 trillion. How much of that are we ok with being locked up in a dynasty or 10? How tall can that spike be and have a working economy? In the US the dynasts only control 500 billion or so, so maybe not a big deal, it's not that big of a slice of the pie.
I dunno. It'll be interesting.
i guess it's more like $550,000,000,000 but it was just a casual observation. The rest of the list probably averages around $3,000,000,000 , so another $550 billion there.
What holds true for families who have > $1 million, doesn't necessarily hold true for families who have > $500 million. Dynastic wealth in Europe usually means owning private banks, wineries, châteaux, lands, etc... In the US, I'd be thinking of families who are large landowners, and have massive amounts of private wealth.
We're not talking about people who gained wealth from a single business in the patriarch/matriarch's lifetime, but rather people whose entire wealth derives from rent-seeking/inheritance.
The 1% is more of a euphemism for the top 0.01%. We're not talking about anyone who, at any point, was ever 'working class'. Steve Jobs' and Bill Gates' wealth probably will disappear; the Rockefellers, Mellons and Rothschilds of this world have done a comparatively good job at holding on to wealth. And there's far more of them than there are rich entrepreneurs... When you talk about inherited wealth, there's plenty of families who aren't on the Forbes' list, still worth billions.
And one note - as many economists have stated, dynastic wealth is still rather young in the US. Historically, in Europe the upper classes derived much of their wealth from land and property, which in Europe is comparatively very expensive because of its scarcity relative to population. For most of the US' history, land has been comparatively cheap. Also, the US has at various times broken up monopolies and redistributed wealth much more radically than western Europe. The US' relative equality is due to its socialist tendencies at various points in history.
There's so many structural issues which serve to increase inequality right now...
Not that that makes them wrong.
Seriously though, during dinner last night my wife and I (and my parents in their late 50s/early 60s) watched the Fox News Town Hall with Sanders and Clinton. They could not fathom how worse off people our age (early 30s/late 20s) have it compared to them. Even after rattling off college costs, inability to secure a home, stagnant wages, poor job prospects, it was incredulous to them. "It can't possibly be that bad!"
Is it an education issue? Perhaps. I think it'll get fixed the hard way though: one obituary at a time. Until then, we'll need a whole lot more social activism out there.
Are people like, forgetting the great Dust Bowl or something?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dust_Bowl
An entire generation of Americans left the Farms and went for the cities, only to learn that the Cities have entered the Great Depression.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Depression
And the cities had no help for the entire generation of farmers who lost everything. This time stands in contrast to the "Roaring Twenties", a time of plenty and a booming economy that the US has almost never seen before.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roaring_Twenties
Someone here has been drinking too much of that Rubio Kool-aid. Americans have had plenty of generation-defining tough times in our history. We are strong because of surviving through it, learning about the problems, and working to make the country better afterwards. But that "economical reset" button has been pushed several times in our history.
---------
In "Game of Thrones" terms, the Baby Boomers were born in the "great long spring", and have only known prosperity their whole life. They were born in a great time, a world rebuilt by the Greatest Generation (who grew up through the Dust Bowl AND Great Depression, then left to fight WW2 and then set the economic conditions for the post-war economic miracle).
But now fall is upon us, and the historians are remembering that yes, Winter is coming. And it is the millennials who have to now work through the winter that our parents don't remember ever existing... but our grandparents may remember the tougher times they had.
Then 2008 happens and everyone is right AND everyone is wrong. A unique blend of too-much regulation AND not-enough regulation hits the nation and everything goes to crap. Republicans continue to point at the too much regulation (US Government encouraging loans, which helped fuel the sub-crime mortgages which created the bubble in the first place), while Democrats continue to point at too little regulation (AIG creating Credit Default Swaps on the "dark market", hidden away from regulators, which insured CDOs of CDOs of Mortgaged backed securities which fueled the housing bubble).
When in fact, both Republicans and Democrats are correct here. Government probably shouldn't have been doing some things, and the government probably should have been doing other things instead. But the parties are so locked into the mindset of "Government should do things" vs "Government shouldn't do things" that its hard to actually get any agreement anymore.
Anyway, that's how I see things: the two factions of US Politics are focused on creating arguments for the two primary stances on virtually any issue that occurs in politics: whether government should do something about a particular issue, or whether government should NOT do something about a particular issue.
That's good, and in fact, its great that people disagree because that's how we learn as a country. The problem is now the political wheels and deals have died off, because people have lost faith in the system. People need to start agreeing and creating consensus across the aisle so that the government can start doing stuff (be it rolling back poorly-implemented government programs, or pushing forward key beneficial government programs)
Also the Great Depression only lasted 10 years to begin with meaning that it didn't even affect a majority of that generations prime earning years. Coupled with the fact that it was immediately preceded and succeeded by periods of incredible growth and you see why you're point isn't really accurate.
Did you not read my post? I started with the Great Dust Bowl, which completely eradicated an entire generation of farmers. Eight years of drought was a natural disaster on an unfathomable scale.
Look, if you were born in 1915, you'd have finished high school right in time for the Dust Bowl. Your entire family's profession of "Farming" or "Ranching" is utterly destroyed. Then, you'd move to the city to look for a job, only to learn that the Great Depression started and there was no hope for you here.
You're 20 years old who only knows how to farm. Its 1935. Current networth: $0. Good luck finding a job during the Great Depression.
If you're not a farmer and were a city-folk for those years... well now its 1935 and all these dumb homeless, jobless farmers are taking the jobs in the city, leaving no jobs for you. Of course, its the Great Depression and nobody has a job, so maybe you shouldn't be blaming the farmers.
In either case, you'd now spend several years homeless, moving between Hoover-villes and shanty towns across the nation, until Pearl Harbor happened and everyone was drafted into the military. You were then forced to fight against either Hitler or the Japs in the bloodiest war the world has ever known.
You're now 30 years old, and its 1945. Current networth: $0. That's if you're a lucky one and you weren't killed or maimed during WW2.
Now you've come home from the war, and the postwar economic boom is beginning to start finally, but the country now raises taxes all the way to 90%+ to pay off the WW2 Debt. Good luck building a networth with that kind of tax.
You're now 35 years old and its 1950. Taxes are high, but you finally have a networth. You finally feel what prosperity feels like, after a pretty tough life, and then father a naive generation that we now call "The Baby Boomers". A group of kids who are so naive that even today in their 60s, they believe in "Get a college education, you'll get a job" and ideals like "children always grow up in better times than their parents".
Facts which are pretty much exclusively true for only the Boomers.... and only because the Greatest Generation planted the seeds for their prosperity.
Anyone who ever recommended or used consumer credit forgot everything important about it.
Nothing is wrong with consumers using credit. But when banks use credit (far above and beyond the arbitrary 20% number that the Fed has set), then a failure at one bank can cascade against the rest of the banks in the country.
People have forgotten that the massive decentralization and massive deflation of the 1930s created the conditions of the Great Depression. Tiny banks were far more correlated with each other due to shoddy lending practices.
-------------
People calling for the Gold Standard have forgotten the lessons of the Great Depression. Banning Gold from US Citizens was a major step towards curing the Great Depression: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102
Once Gold was no longer in circulation, the Fed was able to expand the money supply by printing more dollars than there was Gold to back it. In the coming years, the US would start pulling itself out of the depression caused by Gold Hoarding and loose fiscal policy.
Honestly, it was a similar strategy as QE or dropping interest rates that was employed in 2008: the goal was to expand the monetary supply to pump us out of a potential Depression.
If anything, its credit that allows us to get out of economic shocks like that. All the Libertarian Gold Bugs seem to forget the lesson of the 1930s however...
Progress is supposed to continue, and we should have higher hopes than comparing our current lot to ages which were objectively pretty horrible... We've literally undone the progress made since 1950, and you're arguing that's OK because at least it's better than the 1800s or whatever.
The meme of Keynesian economic theory created this concept of "in the long run, we're all dead". So effectively, the baby boomer generation leveraged future generations' well being. You can't borrow now without giving something up in the future, there will always be an equivalent exchange.
> We are in unprecedented territory right now.
We are but we aren't. Regression in equality is unprecedented, but inequality isn't. We fixed the problem of inequality, then subsequently politicians convinced us to let them unfix it, to our own detriment.
We know the solutions, people just don't want to implement them. Money controls media, which tells people what they want. 'Establishment' politicians buy votes with handouts and shiny objects, all the while dismantling the welfare state and passing laws which increase inequality. I guarantee if people voted on every bill that went through Congress, the US would look far, far different...
(Note that with population growth, the boondocks have inevitably moved further out.)
Most of my ancestors had none of these. Most also lived relatively stress free lives, owned property, didn't work particularly long hours, and most lived into their 90's.
For most of my 'career', I've worked 60-80 hour weeks. Been stressed out as hell. Own no property. My wife and I's 'dream' involves retiring to a stress free place and yes, doesn't really involve technology. Even that is looking like a pipe dream. Recent studies state that retirement may not be possible for millenials, period. Most of my ancestors were able to stop working in their 60's, and still maintain their quality of life (which, as I stated before, lasted into their 90's).
Technological progress is not dependant on inequality. America and Europe were at one point more egalitarian. And society saw its fastest technological progress ever. Heck, most technology today is still built on the exact same foundations that were developed in the 1950s to 1970s.
The problem of inequality isn't necessarily a market-based economy. But rather the current set of laws that enable incumbents to make higher returns on capital than the rest of society. The problem really is - how do we properly allocate resources while also distributing wealth in a way that is most beneficial to all.
It's not a problem of capitalism vs. socialism vs. communism, or technological progress vs. no progress.
I was disputing the idea that we are worse off than some past period, not that we are worse than some hypothetical alternate reality where every single thing is better. So again, are you willing to give up technology and live in that past? Is your wife willing to accept a 1/1,000 risk of maternal mortality rather than a 2 or 3/100,000 risk?
Also, I have no idea why you are bringing up inequality. None of the things mentioned in mcphage's comment have anything to do with inequality. Neither does your 60-80 hour weeks, your stress, or changing demographic ratios which will make retirement (at future higher standards of living) more difficult.
They say that because the average 'poor' person has access to things rich people didn't have access to 100 years ago, that the poor person should accept that they're rich, and not complain.
I'm calling it what it is, a strawman. One that occurs in every discussion of inequality. One that's existed since time immemorial, when slaveowners claimed that their slaves were better off on the plantations than in primitive Africa.
As for why I brought up points that weren't in the parent post, I was agreeing, and then elaborating on the subject because it's an interesting subject.
And of course, inequality is completely relevant in a discussion about millenials relative wealth vs. previous generations.
That was the only point I was making. Glad we are in agreement.
But more technology.
It's up to you whether or not you think that's better.
Ugh. Unfortunately, it's long past time to deal with this.
On behalf of the HN community: please stop posting about your sex life. We don't want to hear about it.
Talking about means and normal distributions in this context is far too reductive.
Maybe an inevitable fact of human behaviour.
> a result of changing government policies, globalization, and the loss of power of labor, engineers, and professionals.
I completely agree that these are the reasons why we've regressed.
There is a tendency for capital to be more valuable than the results of labour, which should theoretically be offset by diminished returns on capital. However the theoretical natural state of economies is disrupted by the fact that those with means will change the laws and tilt things in their favour. It's this fact (which we could accurately call corruption, which we've institutionalized as 'lobbying') that makes inequality inevitable.
In brief I disagree. More the product of determined coalitions and misinformation. Things we can change, regardless.
> There is a tendency for capital to be more valuable than the results of labour,
Ironically I think capital is far less valuable than labor at the moment, partly because valuable labor is far scarcer. I suspect capital's value is being artificially propped up, but I'm not sure of the cause.
> ...those with means will change the laws.. The citizens of any republic must remain vigilant, but more people need to realize that getting a bigger slice isn't worth it when you're shrinking the pie.
You'd be surprised how many people, even with all the actual data on the subject, refuse to accept that millenials are 'worse off', citing technology advances or whatever.
That being said, we are just returning to the 'normal' state of things. The reduction in inequality after WWII and subsequent economic boom was the exception in human economic history, we're simply reverting to the mean. Thomas Piketty and others point out that inequality is increasing and while that's true, we've been there before.
Since there's not a whole lot more to say, here's a great Piketty related article by Robert Solow (Nobel winning economist, known for the Solow model of economic growth): https://newrepublic.com/article/117429/capital-twenty-first-...