News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by curiousDog on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:08PM (#11076484)
Why on earth is wall street so hung up on user growth? Don't they still have a ton of monetization opportunities? I see no where near the amount of ads as facebook and I hear their ad targeting is pretty bad right now and despite all this, their revenue isn't bad at all.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by bonaldi on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:15PM (#11076534)
The price reflects the future prospects of Twitter, and a poorly-monetised Twitter with a shrinking user base is worth less than a poorly-monetised Twitter with a booming user base.

Put another way, they used to be hosting a huge party and just had to work out how to turn that into cash. Now people are starting to leave the party, making cash less of a concern at that point.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by diab0lic on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:33PM (#11076688)
I think this pretty much nails the wall street perspective. Interestingly enough I left the party because their attempts to monetize were really invasive; Emails, many notifications on my phone, etc... I think some subset of their users (to which I belonged) appreciated the simplicity of the product. Their attempts to increase engagement decreased it with what appears to be a significant portion of their user base.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by aswanson on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @09:01PM (#11077761)
I never quite got Twitter. It just seemed like a giant celebrity circle jerk. Especially for celebrity tech people. And I just don't give enough of a shit about famous or prominent people for it to matter much.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by colmvp on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:12PM (#11078179)
Honestly, I'm positively perplexed by this comment.

Twitter allows me to follow writers and influencers like Malcolm Gladwell, William Gibson, Edward Snowden, Glenn Greenwald, to niche industry influencers ranging from Rails engineers to industrial designers to photographers in a way that is digestable and at times personal. To me, it's been edifying to read thoughts from them, discover work they've created as it happens, or find out about a book they recommend.

Twitter is literally what you make of it. Follow interesting people, you get interesting content.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by Outdoorsman on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:38PM (#11078276)
It is, indeed, what you make of it....I agree...

I know that the next day, or the day after that, worst case scenario, anything immediately relevant to me, or my community, will appear in my local newspaper, or RSS feed...

I live locally, in the short run, globally in the long run...

That's what devalues Twitter to investors...it's just "entertainment...it can easily be given up, without any real consequences...there are other more refined sources for what it offers...

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by incepted on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:53PM (#11078308)
Your comment is very reasonable but I've found that celebrity or wits or intelligence hardly correlates to interesting Twitter stream. Basically, most people who tweet are a waste of time to read. Even at 140 characters at a time.

It's surprisingly hard to find people who consistently say interesting things in such a restricted space.

Overall, I've decided it was so hard that it just wasn't worth my time, so I no longer read Twitter at all.

Obviously, your mileage may vary.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by MollyR on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:57AM (#11088573)
I too have felt the same way. I occasionally check John Carmack's twitter or some other developers, but that's it. and when he was around I loved https://twitter.com/devops_borat
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by chipsy on Thursday February 11, 2016 @01:24AM (#11078541)
Basic rules

* Never follow accounts with blue checkmarks.

* Take the words of very popular accounts (even if they have no checkmark) with a grain of salt.

* Use your account to converse or pontificate, not to advertise your personal brand.

* Avoid jokey one-upmanship. It is tedious.

* Avoid detailed explanation until prompted. Brevity makes for misunderstandings.

* Follow people you do not know personally.

* Follow artists.

* Follow journalists.

* Follow minorities.

The reason to use Twitter is to get perspectives that have no other outlet - no advertising, no backing, no organization behind them. These are voices that are so faint that they could be tuned out any other way, and they don't get covered in the paper the next day, because they're going outside of the narrative lines. That is why you do better avoiding the blue checkmarks and people who would strive for them.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by rorykoehler on Thursday February 11, 2016 @01:11AM (#11078507)
Last night I engaged an A16Z partner over net neutrality and Free Basics in India. Nothing circle jerk about it. No other platform offers this kind of engagement. I really wish Twitter wasn't public so all this money pressure wouldn't exist. It should be run like Wikipedia.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by justincormack on Thursday February 11, 2016 @12:00AM (#11078333)
Don't follow any celebrities.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by CydeWeys on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @09:16PM (#11077811)
Me neither, and not for lack of trying either. I've posted thousands of tweets. It was most interesting during breaking news events. But it never seemed useful enough to justify my time expenditure in it, so I gave up.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by JeffL on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:16PM (#11078198)
And anything really interesting on Twitter gets liked from Reddit, so no need to follow Twitter independently.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by jeremy_k on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:41PM (#11076741)
Interesting. I receive no emails and rarely any push notifications from Twitter. I use it every day while riding the bus, although I'm mainly a consumer and hardly tweet anymore.

Did you and I fall into different categories or something and somehow that led to you receiving invasive marketing where as all I ever see are a few promoted tweets? Pretty curious about this because you mention that your experience is happening to a large portion of the user base.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by diab0lic on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:58PM (#11076879)
I used to receive multiple push notifications a day at a minimum, which was irritating to me because prior to this a push notification meant that someone was interacting with me, and that didn't hold true anymore. Twitter had broken that implicit contract with me.

As for what I had said in the parent comment, what I was trying to imply was that something has happened recently that has disengaged a significant (different than large portion, specifically meaning not insignificant) portion of its user base as evidenced by the deceleration in user growth. Apologies for any confusion. :)

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by jeremy_k on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:54PM (#11077196)
My mental model jumped from significant to large too easily, sorry about that.

What notifications were you seeing? I'm trying to think what I would receive that wasn't another user interacting with me and all I can recall is something along the lines of 'User1, User2, ..., all liked User3's Tweet' where User1 and User2 were people I followed. But it was very strange because every now and then I get those notifications for high profile accounts and other times it would be like two friends liked a third friends tweet. Those notifications were quite sporadic though and don't bother me in the least.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by amake on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:10PM (#11077271)
> Those notifications were quite sporadic though and don't bother me in the least.

It probably depends on who you follow and how connected they are. I get these notifications sometimes multiple times a day.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by qznc on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:03AM (#11079070)
You can disable them in the settings. No?
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by jsprogrammer on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:47PM (#11076798)
Twitter was pushing text from people I didn't follow to my phone's lock screen.

Only visit occasionally now.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by jonlucc on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:34PM (#11077388)
Their Android widget used to show the latest tweet of a person a follow. Recently (few months, maybe?) it was only the most recent ad. I'll be damned if I dedicate a chunk of my home screen to whatever crappy ad Twitter wants to fling at me.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by Outdoorsman on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:57PM (#11077501)
Some products are chosen, by consumers, because of one thing...simplicity...an easily intuitive UI, use-ability..the product fills a need, just as it is, when introduced to the market...

Scaling up is difficult for such products...

It doesn't matter to consumers that a business needs to monetize...they don't care; they weren't even aware that it needed to...they are satisfied with the product they know, as is...

This is something we in the industry get wrong, so often...

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by RhodesianHunter on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:56PM (#11077203)
Notifications and emails are completely configurable in about 30 seconds. You can get as little or as much as you want.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by ghughes on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:06PM (#11077249)
That's 30 seconds too many because I didn't ask for them in the first place.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by nacs on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:36PM (#11078086)
Exactly. I'm used to unsubscribing from some random newsletter every company inevitably signs you up for but with Twitter it went from occasional emails to suddenly subscribed to 20 different notification-types (on all 3 of my Twitter accounts) delivering everything from daily "summaries" to every random follow I get.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by ZanyProgrammer on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:20PM (#11076578)
Seems like they (and a lot of SV) need to figure out ways to monetize other than ads.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by Grishnakh on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:40PM (#11077421)
I can tell you the easy answer to that problem: micropayments.

Look how much people will spend on Android apps when they're a dollar or three. Make things really cheap, and people will buy them: they'll do a lot of impulse purchases when things are cheap enough.

If news articles only showed you part of the article, and then demanded $0.02 to read the rest, I could see a lot of people paying that. Considering how little they get paid for ad impressions (fractions of a cent), direct payments like that would be more profitable, and readers wouldn't care that much about spending pocket change on it.

But there's no way to make a functioning micropayment system currently. It's not feasible to have credit-card payments for sub-$1 transactions because of the high per-transaction fees, and Visa/MC have a cartel going where you have to use them for any kind of credit/debit payments.

SV needs to figure out how to make easy, low-fee micropayments a reality, and then we'll see some change.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by mistermann on Thursday February 11, 2016 @12:03AM (#11078339)
I would gladly pay a premium if they'd add some fricking features to Twitter and TweetDeck, and I bet I'm not the only one. Just one example, I'd like in TweetDeck to have more visualization options, as well as powerful filtering capability. I get a tweet about every 30 seconds and I would like to have the capability to have some of those go into a "must read later" bucket. That would take a good developer 2 to 8 weeks, lots of people would use it and love it and likely be happy to pay for it, Twitter has all sorts of developers and money, but how often do they release features that are useful? Instead we get some sort of "important" (according to their algorithm if I'm not mistaken) tweets abomination.

Hey I'm not saying these are necessarily awesome ideas, but if your ship is showing signs of starting to sink, doing crazy things like adding features to your product may not be all that crazy.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by LoSboccacc on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @08:48PM (#11077712)
Any intermediary will face the issue of having user deposit an advance payment so micropayments can happen.

Unless one has balls enough to factor in debt in micropayments. You sign up users and make them agree to pay those .02 at a later time and when you're down five dollars the usets need to pay to continue. It's risky but with enough margin to cover the insolvents it could work

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by abraae on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @09:49PM (#11077931)
great plan!

Allegedly a Facebook user is worth $128 (http://www.forbes.com/sites/georgeanders/2014/02/07/youre-wo...).

Paying $5 to acquire a micropayment customer sounds cheap.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by HappyTypist on Thursday February 11, 2016 @03:12AM (#11078888)
No, it's not. Tech companies are values for growth, and while it's applicability is different to different companies, Facebook is still valued for growth.

This logic says a company in beta valued at $1 mil is worth $100k / user for the 10 beta testers. Not at all.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by mistermann on Thursday February 11, 2016 @12:06AM (#11078343)
> Wall Street right now is valuing the average Facebook user at $128 , a touch ahead of Twitter’s $118 — and far above LinkedIn’s skimpy $84.

Wow, I would say Twitter and Linkedin are vastly overvalued compared to Facebook.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by Ntrails on Thursday February 11, 2016 @05:37AM (#11079367)
Really?

I mean, linkedin has a legit monetisation strategy just as a socially connected CV platform for recruiters to find people - and charging recruiters for tools to use it effectively.

That seems far far stronger than what I know of twitter. Facebook - well what I really want to know is more detailed metrics like median time spent on it per user, interactions per user, etc etc. I'd be fascinated to know if the trends are downwards.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by Grishnakh on Thursday February 11, 2016 @11:11AM (#11080975)
Agreed. Facebook's entire monetization strategy seems to be just showing ads to people who waste their time there looking at stupid videos and posting stupid comments to them. That's pretty easily defeated with an ad-blocker.

LinkedIn's strategy is, as you said, a socially-connected CV platform so that recruiters can find people and hook them up with jobs, and make a big commission in the process, so LinkedIn charges recruiters a hefty fee for access to people. Ad-blockers aren't going to have any effect here: the recruiters still have to pay to send messages to people. It seems like a much more sound business strategy, as long as professionals still need jobs and there's recruiters looking to place them in jobs. It might not have the mass appeal of the inanity of Facebook or Twitter (since only a fraction of the population is of the demographic that would find it worthwhile to use LinkedIn; someone working as a barista or a Walmart cashier would not), but it certainly isn't subject to the same fickleness that those two are. All it'll take is some other inane social media platform to rise up for people to share dumb videos on and for FB/Twitter to do something dumb to piss off people, and suddenly they could become the next MySpace. LinkedIn's position is much stronger, as long as they don't screw it up trying to achieve the popularity of those other two.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by LoSboccacc on Sunday February 14, 2016 @03:03AM (#11097549)
Doesn't facebook get a share from facebook app profits?
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by Grishnakh on Friday February 12, 2016 @12:38PM (#11088878)
And who are the assholes who down-modded me anyway? There's nothing controversial or offensive here. People have been wanting micropayments for many, many years now on the internet for the exact reasons I states above. Are there some Visa/MasterCard shills here or something?
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by x0x0 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:32PM (#11076682)
The more users you have the more you can demand advertisers work with you to implement custom ad units or ad types. Since twitter seems to be focusing on promoted tweets and other twitter-only advertising methods, you really need a lot of scale to justify advertisers building custom creative for you.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by devishard on Thursday February 11, 2016 @10:22AM (#11080607)
That's entirely perception with no basis in reality. A million users who make you $10 each are worth the same as 10 users who make you $1 million each. It's worth it for Twitter and its investors to track users so they can see how to monetize them, but if revenue goes up its okay.

If making money ever isn't the main goal of a business, that truly are screwed.

That said, I've long believed that Twitter would be one of the first to fail when the tech bubble pops. They don't have a product people are willing to pay for.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by untog on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:24PM (#11076617)
Quite simple: investors invested in a company that was going to grow exponentially. Now that it is not growing, they want out.

Which, IMO, is fine. I wish we lived in an environment where Twitter could say "we're making money, we're successful enough, invest if you like what you see", but Silicon Valley is frequently hockey stick growth or death.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by harryh on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:56PM (#11076862)
They aren't making money though. They're losing money. They are not successful enough.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by nugget on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:11PM (#11076971)
Keep in mind that the major drag on profitability for many of these companies is labor/compensation costs and specifically the war for talent that Facebook started in 2011-ish. The 22 year old making $150k all in and their 27 year old boss clearing >$300k? That money doesn't come from thin air. Don't underestimate the degree to which the rank and file talent has benefited from the current ''bubble''. If enough downward pressure is exerted to depress salaries broadly across the board then a lot of these companies will benefit. Note that insofar as part of comp is paid in RSUs then this downward pressure is already being felt as public share prices decline.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by ryanSrich on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @08:36PM (#11077665)
Exactly. My only knowledge of Twitter is from a user standpoint, but I've racked my brain for years wondering why Twitter is larger than 100 employees. I can't figure it out.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by majani on Thursday February 11, 2016 @01:41AM (#11078591)
Spreading risk and blame, pressure from investors to spend the big raise money, the diplomatic roles that become necessary at a certain size, R&D employees. Mostly political reasons, but reasons nonetheless
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by rokhayakebe on Thursday February 11, 2016 @12:06AM (#11078342)
Because at X thousands employees: Too Big to Let Fail.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by _cudgel on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @08:50PM (#11077719)
Neither can they ;)
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by throwaway2048 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @08:39PM (#11077682)
However, if things deflate ad revenue is going to go into the toilet, it's largely funded by the same tech companies with huge marketing budgets.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by bonaldi on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:28PM (#11076649)
I think a social network is slightly different from the other companies where that argument applies. The Internet was a fun place with 300m people on it, but growth made it better. Same with Facebook. People bring problems, but in general networks are better with more of them around.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by ethbro on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:32PM (#11078250)
Some crotchety old timers might argue that point.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by _cudgel on Thursday February 11, 2016 @01:29AM (#11078555)
As a crotchety old timer, I agree completely.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by bonaldi on Thursday February 11, 2016 @05:58AM (#11079432)
You'd take Usenet over everything else we got from the growth of the network, from Amazon to MP3s?
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by ethbro on Thursday February 11, 2016 @06:23PM (#11084136)
There's a lot of different distinctions to be made (or argued against) regarding the "who" of the network, rather than the "what".

I think HN comments would be a prime example that simpler-functionality-with-higher-quality-participants is a valued combination.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by _cudgel on Thursday February 11, 2016 @07:00PM (#11084348)
I'd take fewer people online in general. The number of people that are glued to their smartphones because of all this supposed progress frightens me.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by shas3 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:46PM (#11076784)
All companies grow exponentially. Any compounded growth is exponential. The k in e^(kt) can be anything. You perhaps meant to say, investors want way-better-than-S&P-and-in-line-with-APPL/GOOG/FB growth?
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:06PM (#11077252)
> All companies grow exponentially.

No, they don't.

> Any compounded growth is exponential

Not all growth is compounded in a way that fits an exponential curve. Sure, any single interval (two data point) growth will fit some exponential curve, but once you get a second interval, it may or may not fit (or be approximated by) any exponential curve.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by shas3 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:33PM (#11077386)
Unless you specify an error, all growth can be approximated with exponentials. In fact, by your logic, even investors don't desire exponential growth. Why specifically would they want the growth of their investments to follow the rule that the derivative of the revenue is proportional to the revenue? Investors surely wouldn't mind factorial growth :) . It is just that metrics like CAGR are convenient and very rough approximations of the reality, designed to make the concept of growth intuitively year-on-year. In reality companies don't grow exponentially, we use exponential models to define company growth. The exponential model is fully arbitrary, with the k being as small as you please (linear growth is sometimes even defined by low CAGR numbers like 0.1%, etc.)
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by dragonwriter on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:58PM (#11077504)
> Why specifically would they want the growth of their investments to follow the rule that the derivative of the revenue is proportional to the revenue?

Well, I think more precisely they want the growth to be at least exponential; they'd be happy with super-exponential growth (increasing, rather than constant, k over subsequent intervals.)

They also want a minimum value of k.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by jeremyjh on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:03PM (#11077231)
Suppose a company increases their gross revenue by 1MM every year. What do you call that? I'd call it linear, because it will be a straight line on a graph.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by shas3 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:12PM (#11078004)
That would be linear only if the inflation is 0. Inflation adjusted growth rate will not be fully linear.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by baddox on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:37PM (#11077116)
All companies? Surely some companies have linear growth.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by rubyn00bie on Thursday February 11, 2016 @02:24AM (#11078715)
Linear growth is not really growth, in a financial sense, as growth is when the derivative (rate of change) is increasing/decreasing. Linear growth by how I interpret it, would have a derivative of zero, i.e. the rate of change is constant, or geometrically speaking, a straight line.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by shas3 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:34PM (#11077392)
Financial terminology doesn't distinguish between linear and exponential. Linearly growing companies would simply be assigned very low (close to 0 / positive) CAGRs.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by xyzzy4 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @08:52PM (#11077723)
I agree. For example, if you spend exactly $1000 on advertising a day, and have no network effects, you will get linear user growth.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by samfisher83 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:19PM (#11076575)
The way you do valuations is using DCF analysis. They do some projection until a final year at which point they treat is as perpetuity with some growth rate. Here is the basic formula PV = FCF/(r-g). Where r is discount rate and g is growth rate. As you can see g is huge in the way companies are valued. For example for d=10% and FCF value of $10 million a growth rate of 1% would value the company at 111 million whearas a growth rate of 9% would value it at $1 billion. Almost 10x as much. That is why growth is so important to finance people.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by dharmon on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:57PM (#11077210)
This formula (the Gordon growth model), doesn't really apply here, cause the g is for perpetual growth. For example, if you plugged in FB's current growth rate, it would blow up to something ridiculously large. The rule of thumb is that it should never be larger than GDP (since that company would quickly come to dominate the national economy). Tracking inflation is safe if the company can at least raise prices to match inflation.

If you don't want to set up a full DCF, the Benjamin Graham formula gives a quick intrinsic value estimate:

V = E * (8.5 + 2g) * 1.1,

E is earnings (FCF, or a modified form like owner's earnings would work also), but here, g is the growth rate for the next 7-10 years.

This still wouldn't work for TWTR, since negative earnings always give you a negative value, so you would have to project out the next few years until twitter has positive earnings (or positive FCF), then you could use the Graham formula and discount it back to present value. But at that point you might as well just do a full DCF.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by mistermann on Thursday February 11, 2016 @12:15AM (#11078366)
You wouldn't happen to know of a book or website where one could learn some of these theories and formulas in a very condensed/quick way?
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by kgwgk on Thursday February 11, 2016 @02:13AM (#11078676)
The Little Boook of Valuation, by Aswath Damodaran, is nice. You can find lot of things at his website, including a draft version of the book. http://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/ http://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/pdfiles/papers/littlebo...
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by dharmon on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:44AM (#11088463)
If you literally just want the technical stuff, then anything by Damodaran is good. His Valuations book is awesome, but does not qualify as "condensed / quick". You can also watch his valuation course on YouTube.

I have not read it, but if his "Little Book" is indeed a condensed version of his main book, then its a good start. I think he also gives out a PDF for free on his website.

I would advise against blindly applying DCFs, or at least making real investment decisions from blindly running one. When I first got started I looked for some grand "insert and crank" method of valuation, but now I am convinced there is no shortcut aside of thoroughly understanding a business and its financials.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by leroy_masochist on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:12PM (#11078002)
While your post is technically correct in terms of how a DCF works, it is also emblematic of a pervasive misunderstanding within SV about how valuation works and especially how institutional investors (the people who control most of the money in the stock market) approach valuation.

Financial models, especially DCFs, are useful as a framework for comparing similar assets against each other -- whether it's two software companies or two oil refiners.

On the other hand, using DCFs as a tool to derive the "true" value of a company's equity is a mistake. Similarly, imputing truths about the drivers of a given company's DCF valuation -- e.g., g in the Gordon growth model -- based on the value of that company's equity in the financial markets is also a mistake.

The recent explosion (last 5 years or so) in private company valuations is more a function of a global thirst for yield than investor expectations that any given company will be producing free cash flow of a in year x or b in year z.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by samfisher83 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:49PM (#11078300)
You project for as long as you can, but eventually you have use the growth model at the very end. Even before you get to that point you have project a growth model. So year 1 is 1.2A year 2 is 1.2^2A etc. So the growth rate is pretty important in creating valuation.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by leroy_masochist on Thursday February 11, 2016 @01:01AM (#11078484)
You're missing my point altogether. I'm aware of how DCFs work and you describe their mechanics accurately.

My point is that the drop in Twitter's stock price has nothing to do with DCFs and more broadly, that DCF models are useful (and used) primarily as a means of comparing similar companies rather than as a "true measure" of a company's value.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by akg_67 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:12PM (#11077287)
If you are interested in valuing Internet/Tech companies, look into Aswath Damodaran's blog http://aswathdamodaran.blogspot.com/?m=1 In the past he had valued AAPL, FB, Uber etc. His Investment Valuation course at NYU Stern is also available online.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by joakleaf on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:16PM (#11076548)
Perhaps because they think lack of growth is a precursor to implosion.

Investors also always think about the immediate obvious future. Twitter may have many monetization opportunities, but without implementing or demonstrating any, you have know way of knowing where they are going or if they'll succeed as an investor.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by Riod on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:32PM (#11076686)
Quite possible too. They compete with FB for ad revenue. Social networks tend to be winner take all/most. If Twitter continues to be small, then it has to have a small valuation
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by jusben1369 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:38PM (#11076721)
There are a lot of reasons why. Just one example is advertisers. The largest advertisers need to work with properties at a certain scale. TV has that. Google has that. Facebook now has that because it grew to be huge. Pinterest doesn't. Twitter doesn't and more importantly now looks like it never will. So if your service's primary revenue stream is advertising but you're unappealing to the largest advertisers it's a big problem.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by bpicolo on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:02PM (#11076912)
Seems like a poor example. Twitter is way higher scale than a single TV network. 320M MAU.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by smm2000 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:21PM (#11077013)
Twitter requires custom creatives - this is a huge cost. Every TV network can run standard 30s slot.

Average American spends 4h on TV every single day. Twitter has nothing on that.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by Riod on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @08:15PM (#11077583)
Actually the worst part of twitter is that things disappear so quickly (till recently). 320MM MAU doesn't mean everyone sees that. A TV ad can 1) be sent to any station, 2) has a good chance of being seen by a large % of people tuned into that station at that particular time.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by jusben1369 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:42PM (#11077437)
Yes. You can't deploy the same ad on FB and Twitter and Pinterest the way you can do a TV spot and deploy it on any channel large or small.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by briantmaurer on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:34PM (#11077094)
If there are two companies A and B, and you are convinced that A will yield a better ROI than B, you will sell B and buy A – even if there is room for B to yield a positive ROI.

Growth in users/usage/engagement in a social network almost always yields a better ROI than no/low/negative growth in users/usage/engagement.

Twitter does not necessarily have a monetization problem, people just want to invest their money where there is more potential.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by Riod on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:37PM (#11077403)
No. Really depends on the price of B. If you could buy all of twitter for $1 now, you wouldn't?
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by briantmaurer on Thursday February 11, 2016 @11:59AM (#11081347)
From an investor perspective, prices in the stock market are basically meaningless.[1] As an investor you can purchases multiples or fractions of a stock which allows you to choose your price. Percent change in price is all that matters for your ROI.

e.x. A $1 increase on a $1 stock purchase yields a 100% increase, a $1 increase on a $100 stock price only yields a 1% increase. In this example, you should have purchased $100 worth of the $1 stock.

e.x. On the other hand, if have some $x less than $100, but you think the $100 stock is going to increase at a faster rate than the $1 stock, you should purchase x/100th of a share of the $100 stock.

[1] A stock's price is meaningful for two reasons. The sum of value of all shares defines the market capitalization for a company. Also, price can be used to exclude buyers in a socioeconomic way. This is rare, most companies will split the stock every so often to keep the price affordable. An example of an exclusionary stock is Berkshire A, which is currently priced around $180,000. Nonetheless, at the end of the day, as an investor, the only thing that matters is your expectation for the percent change in price.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by Riod on Thursday February 11, 2016 @01:35PM (#11081979)
? The whole company = the enterprise value of the company. Maybe you didn't understand what buying all of twitter meant. My point is if you bought twitter for $1 and with their XBN revenue, all you'd have to do to earn a 100% return on capital is make sure you get back a $2 after tax dividend. This illustrates why price matters in investing. But I'd suggest reading Seth Klarman and Buffett for further reading on the relationship between price and value.

Another way to think of it is, forget about speculating and expected price changes. Think about at what price you would be comfortable buying the whole company and taking it private and harvesting cash flows from it. At $1 for an XBN revenue company that's a no brainer. I'd earn a 1000% return in a year just by cutting some costs and making sure capital is allocated in a manner that generates a return.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by briantmaurer on Thursday February 11, 2016 @07:39PM (#11084546)
I was referring to just buying some shares as an individual investor, not the whole company. Then yes, obviously total value matters.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by Riod on Thursday February 11, 2016 @08:09PM (#11084656)
Roger that. Cheers.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by altonzheng on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:49PM (#11077472)
Well, yes, because then your ROI would be huge for the money you're putting in.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by Riod on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:50PM (#11077478)
Neat, me too.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by perseusprime11 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @09:53PM (#11077947)
Facebook trained the wall street to think in terms of MAUs.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by hkmurakami on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:23PM (#11076616)
Companies are compared to peer group companies by the banks. For example, small cap semiconductor companies are compared to each other on the basis of P/E, revenue growth, margins, etc.

What are Twitter's peer companies? Well Facebook is certainly one such company that is publicly traded and its metrics widely available. So Facebook's numbers, and in particular the numbers that Wall Street analysts decide are relevant, become the benchmark stats that Twitter is judged on, even if Twitter actually should not be put into the same basket as Facebook.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by randyfandal on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:11PM (#11077284)
Because there are other things that DO grow. So if twitter doesn't grow, then you go invest your money somewhere else that does grow. Which means you sell twitter.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by HappyTypist on Thursday February 11, 2016 @02:57AM (#11078845)
Because monetisation is logarithmic, while growth is supposed to be exponential for a while.

You can go from $1 / user to $1.40 / user or $1.60 / user, but you can't go to $3 / user or $10 / user without some fundamental shifts that'll lose you users.

You CAN go from 100 million users to 300 million to 1 billion.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by Xyik on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:29PM (#11077066)
An ads business is based on impressions. Growing users is one way of increasing impressions in which you can sell to advertisers.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by rb808 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:31PM (#11077072)
Wall Street isn't so hung up on user growth. The article is on techcrunch. OK it is an issue but there are lots of others. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-02-10/twitter-us...
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by spangry on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:09PM (#11077269)
Sorry if it's bad form to re-post, but it seems relevant. Here's the counter-argument:

My very controversial view is that Twitter will never achieve profitability (of the level that justifies their market cap). Like Facebook, Twitter is in a two-sided market. Unlike Facebook, it's unclear what the other side of that market is, or how it could be sufficiently monetised:

       User         -->  Facebook <-- Advertiser
    (Stalking)      -->  (Profit) <-- (Eyeballs)
   (Socialising)    -->  (Profit) <-- (Targeting)
  
       User         -->  Twitter  <--    ? 
  (Free expression) --> (Profit?) <--    ?
  (Public broadcast)--> (Profit?) <--    ?
There are probably a bunch of other market participants on the right side (e.g. developers) for both companies. But I think these are the primary profit engines (and main benefits listed under the participants). Here's the interesting part. Let's assume the right side participant for Twitter is also 'advertisers'. In both cases, advertising creates a 'negative cross-side network effect': it subtracts from the user's benefit. But Facebook has a number of advantages over Twitter:

- Because of the structured data they hold, it's far easier for them to target advertising at finely grained demographics. This is beneficial because it reduces or eliminates the 'user value subtraction' from advertising, and increases the value of placing an ad for advertisers (so Facebook can charge more for it). Twitter have far less scope to do this, as they can only make general inferences about their user based on sentiment and relationship-network analysis. Also, because the data is public, advertisers can analyse and target (via company/brand accounts) for free.

- Facebook enjoy increasing returns to scale. On the user side, if more people use facebook there are more people to stalk or socialise with. On the advertiser side, more users means more eyeballs, more targeting data and more advertising niches. For Twitter, users gain far less from increased scale (as user-base size is not related to 'free expression', and only weakly related to 'public broadcasting', given non-twitter users can read twitter walls). Even worse, because Twitter data is public, they can't charge advertisers for the (less structured) data they generate.

- Although an ill-defined concept, Facebook has increasing returns to scope. That is, as they acquire new types of data on their users, they can offer even better targeting and find more granular marketing niches. For example: imagine if Facebook acquired LinkedIn. It's fairly easy for them to link Facebook and LinkedIn users, as most use their real names on both. So now, in addition to knowing someone is a single 28 year old white guy who enjoys scotch, they now also know he earns a high income. This means that where they used to target him with generic scotch ads, they can now target high-end and expensive scotch ads at him. Twitter's users, on the other hand, mostly interact behind unlinkable pseudonyms.

As heretical as these sound, I think there are only three ways for Twitter to generate significant profits (and they all carry significant drawbacks):

- start charging for API calls above some threshold (i.e. charge for market research) - start charging commercial entities based on number of followers (or volume of tweets) - use adsense (better user data linkability)

tl;dr - Twitter creates significant value. But it's difficult for them to capture at least some of that value as profit (unlike Facebook).

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by sergiotapia on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:16PM (#11077310)
Because if you ain't first, you're last! WOOO GIT SOME!!!!!!
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by sosuke on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:10PM (#11076495)
These are the investors that want quick cash now. They want to put all their eggs in one basket and cash out before everyone else does.
Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by oldmanjay on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:13PM (#11076527)
Or equally plausibly, they are investors worried about the long-term strength of the company since they are in the same market as several other very strong companies who look to the long term.

That's less convenient for the narrative of hatred for Wall Street, of course, but it does seem within the bounds of reason.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by revelation on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:23PM (#11076607)
Investing in stable, boring companies (or markets) is a suckers game reserved for pension funds.

Or to put it differently, why invest in a company that isn't growing? How do you make money if you pay $X and don't expect the company to go beyond $X?

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by hodder on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:45PM (#11077454)
This is some of the worst investing advice I've ever heard. High valuation glamour investing in the way you describe has been widely discredited by academics as leading to poor returns. You can in fact slice the market into valuation deciles, and your returns on 5-10 yr rolling averages will increase as you step down to cheaper deciles.

Further, high valuation stocks are subject to much greater crashes while annual best deciles upside is spread across valuation deciles. Meaning High value stocks tend to be a poor bet.

Re:Twitter’s User Growth Goes Nowhere as It Meets Revenue Ex... by saryant on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:06PM (#11076947)
Dividends.