News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by steckerbrett on Sunday January 31, 2016 @08:47PM (#11009129)
> 50% OF US LIVE NEAR THE COAST. WHY DOESN'T OUR DATA?

It's corrosive, expensive to get things to and from it for replacement, leaks destroy the hardware, it's not close to power generation, internet access needs cables because RF doesn't penetrate water, everything is going need watercooling which is rather expensive.

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by hobs on Sunday January 31, 2016 @09:10PM (#11009213)
Imagining they completely solve the problem of sea water, leaks, etc, it still is amazing to think that you would want to do your server maint by pulling a data center out of the ocean on a boat and replacing hard drives and the like.

The only way this makes sense to me is if there is the ability to create something akin to the cargo container as a building block of a data center, where you can have arbitrary compute and storage plug into a greater complex.

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by BinaryIdiot on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:53PM (#11009652)
Sounds like that's exactly what they want to do: they would only pull them out of the water every 5 years to do computer replacements / maintenance. If some components fail then who cares. They wouldn't do a full rebuild for 20 years.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by winfred on Sunday January 31, 2016 @11:46PM (#11009827)
I worked in large data centers before and I just don't see how this can be done practically. Data centers require quite a bit of physical maintenance.

Every computer design has some element that will render a large part of the design inoperable in case of failure. Either it is a SAN head (even if you have two, the fail over can malfunction), or a switch setup.

Then there are things like failures of simultaneously purchased components (hard drives purchased at the same time, that are worked the same load will roughly fail at the time).

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by andrewvc on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:47AM (#11011653)
Cloud datacenters are not complex heterogeneous mixes of components. There's no SAN head. It's one thing multiplied + some networking gear. Even if a top of rack switch fails they're still not going to yank the box yet because the TCO will be lowered by too much maintenance at this scale. They wait for their maint interval and fix everything at once (or just upgrade the hardware).
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by acveilleux on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:51AM (#11011996)
Think of a farm of small data center pods with cloud apps. When failure in a pod exceed useful threshold, apps are migrated out to other pods and the pod is retrieved, serviced and returned to its place.

A custom made barge with dynamic positioning gear and a grabbing/coupling system to detach the pod from the subsea grid, lift it, and then re-attach it would make the servicing relatively efficient.

I could see the roundtrip time for a full hardware replacement of a pod being under an hour, conceivably under 10-15 minutes.

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by kbenson on Monday February 01, 2016 @01:43AM (#11010194)
> The only way this makes sense to me is if there is the ability to create something akin to the cargo container as a building block of a data center

Which is something Google already did[1].

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Modular_Data_Center

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by cm2187 on Monday February 01, 2016 @03:15AM (#11010477)
And if it is just cooling, why aren't datacenters built on the coast pumping sea water for cooling?
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by anonymfus on Monday February 01, 2016 @04:57AM (#11010806)
High cost of the land on the coasts?
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by cm2187 on Monday February 01, 2016 @05:38AM (#11010967)
And I guess you wouldn't even need to use sea water as a primary cooler, just as a secondary cooler. I.e. the primary cooler flows through your datacenter and the secondary cooler cools that primary cooler. So fewer pipes are exposed to sea salt.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by creshal on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:07AM (#11011501)
So, same procedure as power plants.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by cm2187 on Monday February 01, 2016 @08:34AM (#11011602)
Yeah. Instead of trying to protect the environment from what's inside (radioactivity), you are trying to protect what's inside from the environment (sea salt)!
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by foota on Sunday January 31, 2016 @11:26PM (#11009771)
I think they should be able to handle most of those issues, for example they may be able to use wave power for power generation. Furthermore, I don't see how RF opacity is an issue, seeing as anyone running a data center over RF is criminally insane.

edit: I can't grammar

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by nickpsecurity on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:07AM (#11009893)
You run management connections from separate computers over RF as a backup and for fail-over in event everything else fails. I mentioned that in a recent comment related to Github outage and preventing those:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10996442

Can help with certain security situations, too. Not sure how much that applies if it's underwater, though. Most infiltrations would probably turn into a denial-of-service attack effectively haha.

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by foota on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:44AM (#11010012)
Fair enough. It doesn't get much more literally out of band, eh?
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by nickpsecurity on Monday February 01, 2016 @01:44PM (#11014161)
I tried to get it further by proposing a neutrino-based communication system. Can just send the signals straight through the planet itself to a datacenter very far away. I was told there would be both implementation problems and cost overruns with that project. Went back to default recommendations for wireless.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by tzs on Sunday January 31, 2016 @09:18PM (#11009253)
> everything is going need watercooling which is rather expensive

Why would everything need water cooling? I'd expect that something using water would be used to keep the air inside the unit cool, and then the cooling for the servers themselves would be ordinary air cooling.

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by BinaryIdiot on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:49PM (#11009636)
Assuming they have ways around some of those issues this could work out rather well. The important thing is that it's only a research project. Microsoft's research turns out some really awesome stuff but plenty of it failed or is cut. Who knows what'll happen to this but it's a really interesting proposition!
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by tdicola on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:07PM (#11009429)
For power you could use a small nuclear reactor, just like submarines and aircraft carriers. I've always thought it would be a fun exercise to take a decommissioned nuclear submarine and turn it into a floating datacenter.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by nradov on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:43PM (#11009603)
When nuclear vessels are decommissioned they remove the reactors. Operating a naval reactor requires a constant watch by multiple highly-paid experts. They are not cost effective for electrical power generation.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by ihsw on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:49PM (#11009634)
The staffing required to operate a nuclear submarine is astronomical, so it would set the person:server node ratio back decades.

It might be fun but there are better things you can do with $700M.

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by andromeduck on Sunday January 31, 2016 @11:21PM (#11009754)
Yeah but we only need the reactor, not the whole submarine.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by Bjartr on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:42PM (#11009597)
Do you want the raft? Because that's how you get the raft.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by sandworm101 on Monday February 01, 2016 @12:16AM (#11009919)
Because 50% of us live near the coast, not past it. Maintaining anything in close association with an ocean is painful. Everything rusts. Even the stuff they say doesn't does. Anything that moves ages at an accelerated rate. As soon as the slightest waves start, little salt crystals appear on every surface.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by driverdan on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:09PM (#11009432)
> everything is going need watercooling which is rather expensive

Water cooling significantly reduces running costs which is why many DCs are switching to it. Over the long term you save money.

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by riddlemethat on Sunday January 31, 2016 @09:12PM (#11009228)
I've read that ancient Roman concrete was manufactured in a way that is seemingly lost to time. It's also practically impervious to the elements.

http://www.romanconcrete.com/docs/spillway/spillway.htm

If we want to find a way to build beneath the sea that's a good place to start.

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by mintplant on Sunday January 31, 2016 @09:30PM (#11009295)
According to this article, a 2013 study successfully reverse-engineered the recipe for Roman concrete:

http://www.ancient-origins.net/news-history-archaeology/rese...

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by ChuckMcM on Sunday January 31, 2016 @11:24PM (#11009759)
That is an awesome link. Thanks for that.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by dingo_bat on Sunday January 31, 2016 @08:56PM (#11009164)
Do data centers ever rely on RF for connectivity?
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by steckerbrett on Sunday January 31, 2016 @08:58PM (#11009176)
No, but it's a harder proposition to have fibre runs to a server which is in the ocean. You can throw a normal server somewhere silly and connect to it wirelessly, this is just the one remarkable exception.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by toast0 on Sunday January 31, 2016 @09:07PM (#11009203)
What if you hook up to some of the undersea fiber that's already there? (I still think this is a bad idea)
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by steckerbrett on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:15PM (#11009464)
I don't think that's possible, it would be sheathed in extremely thick steel and not something you can just splice onto.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by haimez on Sunday January 31, 2016 @11:00PM (#11009675)
The NSA disagrees.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by ksec on Sunday January 31, 2016 @09:53PM (#11009382)
Same question in my head, how do they prevent corrosition?

And why "everything is going need watercooling which is rather expensive" ?? If i remember correctly every OVH DC Server are using it.

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by steckerbrett on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:09PM (#11009434)
For marine gear you either use a material which won't readily corrode, or you use sacrificial anodes which are galvanically consumed rather than something you care about.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by Spooky23 on Sunday January 31, 2016 @08:52PM (#11009151)
Seriously. It's a proposition obviously cooked up by someone who has never spent more than a week's vacation by the sea.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by remarkEon on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:16PM (#11009471)
-> It all started in 2013 when Microsoft employee, Sean James, who served on a US Navy submarine submitted a ThinkWeek Paper.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by cududa on Sunday January 31, 2016 @09:11PM (#11009224)
Well Seattle is right by the sea, so..
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by hueving on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:10PM (#11009437)
Microsoft isn't in Seattle, so...
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by cududa on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:20PM (#11009493)
I'm aware - I worked there. But it's pretty close - certainly not far enough to be oblivious to the ocean
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by cldellow on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:19PM (#11009489)
It's a 20 minute drive from Redmond to Seattle.

It's a 3 hour drive from Seattle to the ocean.

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by remarkEon on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:56PM (#11009663)
I suppose it would depend on what you'd qualify as "the ocean". I lived in Seattle for 4.5 years, and while I don't consider Elliot Bay[1] to be "the ocean" per se, it's pretty close - and you have all the corrosion problems and general exposure to the elements that you'd get, which I think was the original point of the comparison in this thread.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elliott_Bay

Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by nwhybrid on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:28PM (#11009522)
Ok someone has never been to Seattle it seems. It's not a 3 hour drive to the ocean.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by foota on Sunday January 31, 2016 @11:33PM (#11009788)
It's amazing that the drive to the Northern part of the Olympia Peninsula is so long, Bellingham which looks much farther is around a half hour closer.
Re:Project Natick: Microsoft's Underwater Data Center by tiff_seattle on Sunday January 31, 2016 @10:45PM (#11009612)
With minimal traffic, it is: https://tinyurl.com/zbkp89q