As the saying goes, those who sacrifice liberty for safety deserve (and receive) neither. In the same manner those who sacrifice liberty toward reducing corruption in government deserve (and receive) neither.
[citation needed]. People have always been able to speak out in favor of their preferred candidates - that's what free speech is about. AFAIUI, the recent SCOTUS decision concerned:
1. What happens when there was an exchange of money for political speech on behalf of a third party, eg. paying someone for advertisements.
2. What happens when the "person" paying that money is not a person, but a corporation.
There's a big difference between somebody speaking out on their own and somebody paying for advertisement. There's a further difference between somebody paying for advertisement and something paying for advertisement.
I'll elaborate if you wish, but I'd assume this should be fairly clear to most people...
http://blogs.wsj.com/law/2009/03/25/could-hillary-movie-case...
So your fundamental objection is to political organization.
Consider your last question, though: What do you mean by influence?
Multi-nationals based in the US and elsewhere already had plenty of influence in various forms before this decision. Now...they can pay for commercials. They can now make blatant, public statements of support in front of American customers, roughly 40% of whom will take some degree of umbrage or offense to this no matter who they support.
How does this hurt democracy?
It is a legal accident that corporate personhood was established in the first place. http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/2469/how-can-a-corp...
While corporations are not flesh and blood people, we as humans can certainly define intangible entities into existence. They are still made up of people, but that does not diminish the realness of an entity created only by our civilization's power of words and ideas.
I think people should have rights; not inanimate entities. I think corporate personhood is one of the most egregious mistakes ever committed by humanity as it has allowed living people to no longer be accountable for their crimes. I also think it's too late to fix -- if the USA eliminated corporate personhood, the stock market would crash and there would be a mass exodus of corporations to more business friendly countries.
It's not a hopeless situation though; there will continue to be restrictions on the rights of corporations. I'm optimistic that Congress is going to overturn this most recent Supreme Court decision.
We could be doing more. As an important first step, I suggest a drastically increased use of the corporate death penalty, starting with multiple-time convicted felon (and statistical mass-murderer) Pfizer. If Pfizer was a flesh and blood person, it would be spending a very long time in prison. Instead, it has only paid some of the largest criminal settlements in DoJ history. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pfizer
Blackstone's Commentaries (11th edition, 1791), volume 1, p. 467 (ch. 18, "Of Corporations"):
"We have hitherto considered persons in their natural capacities, and have treated of their rights and duties. But, as all personal rights die with the person; and, as the necessary forms of investing a series of individuals, one after another, with the same identical rights, would be very inconvenient, if not impracticable; it has been found necessary, when it is for the advantage of the public to have any particular rights kept on foot and continued, to constitute artificial persons, who may maintain a perpetual succession, and enjoy a kind of legal immortality.
These artificial persons are called bodies politic, bodies corporate, . . . or corporations: of which there is a great variety subsisting, for the advancement of religion, of learning, and of commerce; in order to preserve entire and for ever those rights and immunities, which, if they were granted only to those individuals of which the body corporate is composed, would upon their death be utterly lost and extinct." (my emphasis)
I cite Blackstone, no small figure in either legal history or the law undergirding the U.S. constitution, to emphasize that he regarded it as central to the idea of what constitutes a corporation that it was to be treated as a legal "person." This is found in my 1791 edition of this work.
Thus, this doctrine is hardly new or radical and certainly no one felt the need to mock it over the 200+ years during which it has been in effect by suggesting that a corporation exercise rights of a citizen by running for office.
All that said, I understand your point about its being claimed that this doctrine was accidentally incorporated into the Court's constitutional analysis but the core doctrine runs much, much deeper than the particular case cited in your linked article and (as reflected in the Blackstone quote) is and always has been fundamental to understanding the legal idea of a corporation.
I think you need to look more deeply into the history of human mistakes.
I'm not sure how to further answer you and similarly-concerned people in the larger sense, though. Of all the legal and political problems in the US, I consider the issue of corporate personhood to be deeply trivial, and I'm dismayed and angered that people would restrict the free speech of actual human beings out of fear of a legal fiction.
The way our particular laws have been written and interpreted by the Supreme Court, then yes, these things are indeed tied together. But there's no particular reason why one could not have a legal system with one and not the other. That's the entire point of the OP.
Why exactly is unrestricted freedom of speech a necessary condition for corporate immunity? Assume you are building a constitution from scratch: Can you construct an argument for why you can't have corporate immunity without corporate freedom of speech, without referring to existing US case law?
Yes, but if it's a matter of "a corporation should have some rights a human has, but not other rights", we're already there. The idea that corporation has all human rights is already transparently false. For one thing, anything that requires a "citizen" is going to be something they can't do.
Anyone who thinks that we've transitioned from "corporations have some of the rights of humans" to "corporations have all of the rights of humans" is emoting, not thinking. We've gone from one subset of rights, to another, to yet a third.
And they still have responsibilities, and in fact have some responsibilities that normal citizens don't have. The casual presumption, for those that are so presuming, that this particular transition is some sort of unique disaster or major shift in the balance of rights v. responsibilities is not justified.
The OP is talking about an election in the US, not about some ex nihilo society.
I find your questions rather confused; you may wish to research the issue further.
But "corporate immunity and corporate free speech come from the same legal doctrine" is a lot different from saying "you can't have corporate immunity without corporate free speech". The latter is what you said, but your argument supports the former. Are you sure I'm the one who is confused?
I'm not actually saying that, despite your misunderstanding.
Beyond that, I'm not interested in discussing built-from-scratch legal systems.
Your last sentence surprised me, though. Clean-slate thought experiments are useful to figure out whether you're doing something because it's the best way to do it, or just because of legacy. That goes for both code and law.
In particular, some of the other critics of the Citizens United decision, including ones who are a little more serious and a little less playful than the OP, are talking about a long-term campaign for a constitutional amendment to address this issue (I'm in particular talking about Larry Lessig and Change Congress, but there are others). Such efforts might be political longshots, but how do you engage in discussions with them if you don't want to consider all the ways the law could be radically different, or could have evolved entirely differently?
Human political freedom in the US is something I'm interested in, and I'm not actually interested in wandering off the topic. I would hope someone engaging me in discussion on the issue wouldn't try to pull off into other directions - that would be disengaging.
Also, you're right.
Try googling +ussc "supreme court". It's a less-used, but real initialism.
Deep down, I think this is the issue that many have a problem with: Shareholders aren't responsible for the actions of this entity.
I would love to see some more work done on attaching the legal liability of corporations to individuals that are subject to full and proper citizenship. Yes I realize what I'm saying, I think it's ultimately unethical to suggest otherwise though.
This is already the case for most small businesses. (sole proprietors)
This is not to say that your conclusion must be invalid, just that this line of reasoning is suspect.
Corporations most certainly did exist, and without a doubt engaged in political activity. While the doctrine of corporate personhood and the equivalence between money and speech are later inventions, it's not clear that the founders would have supported a reading of the Constitution that allows bans on corporate (or any other) political speech. Especially since it was common practice at the time, and continued to be a practice after the ratification of the Constitution.
Corporations are businesses. They are not sentient. They do not have their own opinions. They do not require free speech.
Better not to give government that power at all. It may leave room for people you don't like to do things you don't like but freedom is messy.
Constitution preamble: "We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America."
And so...?
Both of your claims can't be true.
EDIT: Sorry, down-voters, they can't both be true. Either corporations speak on behalf of actual human beings, or they're sentient financial entities.
Not that this is any different from anything a company does. No matter how much freedom each employee has, they have no freedom to act against the interest of their employer.
I wish people would honestly make that argument instead of resorting to the prior ridiculous rhetoric.
"Not that this is any different from anything a company does."
Or any organization.
Let's take Exxon. http://www.google.com/finance?q=exxon
Which humans does this corporation speak on behalf of? Are they all American citizens, for example? Do you think that matters if, say, Exxon decides to run for a seat in Congress?
Those same people "it" (or in reality, the people within it) acts on behalf of.
"Do you think that matters if, say, Exxon decides to run for a seat in Congress?"
Why do you dive on this red herring instead of trying to address whatever your real concern is?
1) You mention "Those same people "it" (or in reality, the people within it) acts on behalf of."
a) 'the people within it' --> a company does emphatically not speak for the people within it. This is in stark contrast with a political party or other groups joined by individuals for political purposes
b) you could argue for the shareholders --> but, the major shareholders are mostly pension funds etc. Membership to these funds is mandated by employers, with little choice by employees (i.e. most voters).
2) And your 2nd comment: "Why do you dive on this red herring instead of trying to address whatever your real concern is?"
The United States Constitution preamble: "We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America."
If a corporations can run for a seat in Congress, and, if they are the voice of shareholders, and these shareholders can be foreign, where does that leave our democracy?
I did not say it necessarily did, though it's certainly speaking for its leadership, who answers to the human shareholders and is voluntarily associated with the other people in the company.
"This is in stark contrast with a political party or other groups joined by individuals for political purposes"
Indeed. It's a group created for other purposes. Political involvement is a valid avenue for pursuing those purposes, as the political system affects the group.
"If a corporations can run for a seat in Congress, and, if they are the voice of shareholders, and these shareholders can be foreign, where does that leave our democracy?"
That's not a concern, that's open-ended rhetoric based on a publicity stunt. EDIT: One based on a facile misreading of legal principles intended to confuse the uninformed.
Uhm, huh? Let's say Exxon runs for a seat. During its term, 20% of Exxon is purchased by PetroChina. So now the seat is no longer under American control. The person who was elected to Congress is no longer the same person; legally it is still Exxon, but in reality it is a different person since the new shareholder, who is a foreigner, exerts significant influence.
Or is my reasoning bogus?
You - and many other people in this discussion - are confusing different legal concepts of "person" as well as "citizen". People like those in the linked story are working to encourage that confusion.
However, I am assuming the company in the article is thinking it stands a chance, as evidenced by it spending dollars to test how far it can go. Otherwise they're pretty stupid, which they may very well be.
OK, but your scenario requires that confusion.
The people in the article are engaging in a stunt. They don't expect or intend to win, and they probably won't spend much or long on the campaign.
If the board does not fire them, the shareholders can fire the board.
As for the minority shareholders, they agreed that their property (their portion of the company) would be bound by the decision of the majority subject to the restrictions of the corporate charter.
This was my choice. If I disliked this, I could have made no contribution to the fund, or even quit my job.
[1] I oversimplify. They try to maximize an objective function which penalizes volatility, particularly volatility at the end of the life of the fund.
"The human beings are free to do that on their own. They don't need to speak through the corporations"
This argument can be made as reasonably for every organization and the very act of political organization, from political parties on down to rallies and petitions.
Right, and it takes about half a second of thought to figure out why. And no it's not because of the "liberal media"; it's because unions don't typically have billions of dollars they can use to further their agenda.
Drops in the bucket compared to what their corporate issue adversaries take in. For instance, the minimum revenues of any Fortune 500 company right now is measured in the billions (profits at around half a billion).
Currently unions are prohibited from contributing directly to candidates due to being tax exempt entities, but that doesn't stop them from spending tens of millions of dollars during election campaigns to support the candidates they favor.
And you can say the exact same thing about corporate interests (both individual corporations and their "unions" of trade associations). The only difference is that corporate interests have literally orders of magnitude more money available to pursue their agenda, as well as a disproportionate set of connections in Washington.
Your statements aren't backed up by the facts. According to opensecrets.org a big ol' scary mega-rich industry such as oil and gas has so many "orders of magnitude" more money to throw around and so many disproportionate connections in Washington compared to, say, teachers and education interests that they managed to overspend said education interests by a whopping... 37% over the last 2 decades. Indeed, donations from education interests just barely exceeded those from the entire pharmaceutical industry during that same period (note that this includes soft-money contributions as well). The situation does not appear to be quite as unbalanced as you would suggest.
Sure they are.
According to opensecrets.org a big ol' scary mega-rich industry such as oil and gas has so many "orders of magnitude" more money to throw around and so many disproportionate connections in Washington compared to, say, teachers and education interests that they managed to overspend said education interests by a whopping... 37% over the last 2 decades.
You're conflating available capital with actual money needed to win. Suppose we're playing cards. If you've got $100 in your pocket and I've got $1000, I can browbeat you out of the game without spending my whole $1000. I only need to spend until you're out of money or, to mix metaphors, until I've bought up all the TV time and drowned out your contributions with the relevant congress members.
If you believe that, please do downvote me and add a comment letting me know how you've come to that conclusion.
National Education Association, PG&E Corp, Service Employees International Union, AT&T Inc., Bank of America, American Federation of State/County/Municipal Employees, Microsoft Corp, Chevron Corp
Bonus points for providing actual donation values.
* Spoilers: http://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/list_stfed.php?order=A
Also note that publicly held corporations represent a large number of individual shareholders as well.
The problem, in my view, isn't that there is too much money in politics, that's merely a symptom. The underlying problem is that government has too much control and influence over everything anybody does. That makes it not only attractive but often necessary to maintain influence with and access to government representatives in order to get along.
Well, yes - many of the people pushing this argument around the country really like labor unions.
"unions don't typically have billions of dollars they can use to further their agenda"
Interestingly, neither do most corporations. Even the biggest aren't going to throw away their profits and alienate ~40% of US consumers (no matter who they pick) by running billion-dollar political ad campaigns.
That's just a variation of the "liberal media" argument I already pre-empted.
Interestingly, neither do most corporations.
Yes they do. At least, the Fortune 100 does.
Corporations and their unions (trade organizations) spend exactly what they need to in order to effectively promote their political interests. If unions had more money to spend, you'd start seeing billion dollar corporate campaigns.
What does the "liberal media" have to do with this? Are you discussing a point or running a partisan script?
In point of fact, "most corporations" are not "the Fortune 100" by definition.
Also, you continue to overestimate the available disposable income they have to spend on enormous political campaigns.
Actually, I was going to ask you the same thing. The general argument that "most of the population likes unions, which is why you don't hear this conservative point of view" and "the media is liberal, which is why you don't hear this conservative point of view" are both variations on the same tired theme.
In point of fact, "most corporations" are not "the Fortune 100" by definition.
Obviously. But talking about "most corporations" in some general sense is so broad as to be practically meaningless for the purposes of this conversation.
Also, you continue to overestimate the available disposable income they have to spend on enormous political campaigns.
You're asserting that without proof. My argument (which, to be honest, should be obvious) is that corporate interests generally have far more money available to them than union interests.
Without proof, you're making the remarkable claim that the Fortune 100 companies each have billions of dollars they're ready to throw at political races.
'The general argument that "most of the population likes unions, which is why you don't hear this conservative point of view" and "the media is liberal, which is why you don't hear this conservative point of view" are both variations on the same tired theme.'
As I didn't say either thing, I must assume you are running a purely partisan script. You won't need my further involvement then, I trust.
This is not some crazy new doctrine the USSC shat out this year, this is a legal premise that has existed for over a century. Otherwise, you couldn't sue a company for damages.
The issue is about political speech for actual human beings in organizations, including corporations and labor unions (and yet oddly, you don't hear much bewailing of "union citizenship").
Crying out "ZOMG giving corporations rights!" is nothing more than trying to short-circuit others' thinking.