Better not to give government that power at all. It may leave room for people you don't like to do things you don't like but freedom is messy.
Constitution preamble: "We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America."
And so...?
Both of your claims can't be true.
EDIT: Sorry, down-voters, they can't both be true. Either corporations speak on behalf of actual human beings, or they're sentient financial entities.
Not that this is any different from anything a company does. No matter how much freedom each employee has, they have no freedom to act against the interest of their employer.
I wish people would honestly make that argument instead of resorting to the prior ridiculous rhetoric.
"Not that this is any different from anything a company does."
Or any organization.
Let's take Exxon. http://www.google.com/finance?q=exxon
Which humans does this corporation speak on behalf of? Are they all American citizens, for example? Do you think that matters if, say, Exxon decides to run for a seat in Congress?
Those same people "it" (or in reality, the people within it) acts on behalf of.
"Do you think that matters if, say, Exxon decides to run for a seat in Congress?"
Why do you dive on this red herring instead of trying to address whatever your real concern is?
1) You mention "Those same people "it" (or in reality, the people within it) acts on behalf of."
a) 'the people within it' --> a company does emphatically not speak for the people within it. This is in stark contrast with a political party or other groups joined by individuals for political purposes
b) you could argue for the shareholders --> but, the major shareholders are mostly pension funds etc. Membership to these funds is mandated by employers, with little choice by employees (i.e. most voters).
2) And your 2nd comment: "Why do you dive on this red herring instead of trying to address whatever your real concern is?"
The United States Constitution preamble: "We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America."
If a corporations can run for a seat in Congress, and, if they are the voice of shareholders, and these shareholders can be foreign, where does that leave our democracy?
I did not say it necessarily did, though it's certainly speaking for its leadership, who answers to the human shareholders and is voluntarily associated with the other people in the company.
"This is in stark contrast with a political party or other groups joined by individuals for political purposes"
Indeed. It's a group created for other purposes. Political involvement is a valid avenue for pursuing those purposes, as the political system affects the group.
"If a corporations can run for a seat in Congress, and, if they are the voice of shareholders, and these shareholders can be foreign, where does that leave our democracy?"
That's not a concern, that's open-ended rhetoric based on a publicity stunt. EDIT: One based on a facile misreading of legal principles intended to confuse the uninformed.
Uhm, huh? Let's say Exxon runs for a seat. During its term, 20% of Exxon is purchased by PetroChina. So now the seat is no longer under American control. The person who was elected to Congress is no longer the same person; legally it is still Exxon, but in reality it is a different person since the new shareholder, who is a foreigner, exerts significant influence.
Or is my reasoning bogus?
You - and many other people in this discussion - are confusing different legal concepts of "person" as well as "citizen". People like those in the linked story are working to encourage that confusion.
However, I am assuming the company in the article is thinking it stands a chance, as evidenced by it spending dollars to test how far it can go. Otherwise they're pretty stupid, which they may very well be.
OK, but your scenario requires that confusion.
The people in the article are engaging in a stunt. They don't expect or intend to win, and they probably won't spend much or long on the campaign.
If the board does not fire them, the shareholders can fire the board.
As for the minority shareholders, they agreed that their property (their portion of the company) would be bound by the decision of the majority subject to the restrictions of the corporate charter.
This was my choice. If I disliked this, I could have made no contribution to the fund, or even quit my job.
[1] I oversimplify. They try to maximize an objective function which penalizes volatility, particularly volatility at the end of the life of the fund.
"The human beings are free to do that on their own. They don't need to speak through the corporations"
This argument can be made as reasonably for every organization and the very act of political organization, from political parties on down to rallies and petitions.
Corporations are businesses. They are not sentient. They do not have their own opinions. They do not require free speech.