News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Corporation Says It Will Run for Congress by _pius on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @07:09PM (#1099328)
Your statements aren't backed up by the facts.

Sure they are.

According to opensecrets.org a big ol' scary mega-rich industry such as oil and gas has so many "orders of magnitude" more money to throw around and so many disproportionate connections in Washington compared to, say, teachers and education interests that they managed to overspend said education interests by a whopping... 37% over the last 2 decades.

You're conflating available capital with actual money needed to win. Suppose we're playing cards. If you've got $100 in your pocket and I've got $1000, I can browbeat you out of the game without spending my whole $1000. I only need to spend until you're out of money or, to mix metaphors, until I've bought up all the TV time and drowned out your contributions with the relevant congress members.

Re:Corporation Says It Will Run for Congress by _pius on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @07:35PM (#1099374)
Hard to believe that people actually think that unions have the same amount of money to get their message out as corporate interests.

If you believe that, please do downvote me and add a comment letting me know how you've come to that conclusion.

Re:Corporation Says It Will Run for Congress by InclinedPlane on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @07:48PM (#1099406)
Please rank the following organizations based on their total political contributions (federal and state) in 2008:

National Education Association, PG&E Corp, Service Employees International Union, AT&T Inc., Bank of America, American Federation of State/County/Municipal Employees, Microsoft Corp, Chevron Corp

Bonus points for providing actual donation values.

* Spoilers: http://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/list_stfed.php?order=A

Re:Corporation Says It Will Run for Congress by akgerber on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @09:29PM (#1099592)
1. Most of those large donors are groups with earnings directly tied to government decisions. 2. Those unions represent an entire class of workers nationwide, while a corporation represents a subset of the market; the contributions of all corporations in an industry combined represent a more relevant number.
Re:Corporation Says It Will Run for Congress by InclinedPlane on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @10:04PM (#1099640)
Check upthread a few posts for just such numbers (opensecrets.org also has that data). The idea that corporations have excessively more influence due to campaign contributions than, say, unions just isn't supported by the available data.

Also note that publicly held corporations represent a large number of individual shareholders as well.

The problem, in my view, isn't that there is too much money in politics, that's merely a symptom. The underlying problem is that government has too much control and influence over everything anybody does. That makes it not only attractive but often necessary to maintain influence with and access to government representatives in order to get along.

Re:Corporation Says It Will Run for Congress by InclinedPlane on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @07:36PM (#1099377)
A concrete real-world example rather than abstract hypotheticals would be very helpful to your point here. Considering the extensive time period before McCain-Feingold took effect there should be many such examples. Do you have any?
Re:Corporation Says It Will Run for Congress by _pius on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @07:46PM (#1099401)
Ironically enough, I'd been planning on citing OpenSecrets, and I respect the fact that you did. I'll find something and post tomorrow.