Re:Corporation Says It Will Run for Congress
by Semiapies on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @08:17PM
(#1099469)
Yes, the reasoning is bogus because Exxon can't take public office. Full stop.
You - and many other people in this discussion - are confusing different legal concepts of "person" as well as "citizen". People like those in the linked story are working to encourage that confusion.
Re:Corporation Says It Will Run for Congress
by joubert on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @09:05PM
(#1099556)
I don't confuse citizenship with legal person at all.
However, I am assuming the company in the article is thinking it stands a chance, as evidenced by it spending dollars to test how far it can go. Otherwise they're pretty stupid, which they may very well be.
Re:Corporation Says It Will Run for Congress
by Semiapies on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @09:12PM
(#1099569)
"I don't confuse citizenship with legal person at all."
OK, but your scenario requires that confusion.
The people in the article are engaging in a stunt. They don't expect or intend to win, and they probably won't spend much or long on the campaign.
Uhm, huh? Let's say Exxon runs for a seat. During its term, 20% of Exxon is purchased by PetroChina. So now the seat is no longer under American control. The person who was elected to Congress is no longer the same person; legally it is still Exxon, but in reality it is a different person since the new shareholder, who is a foreigner, exerts significant influence.
Or is my reasoning bogus?