Speaking as a huge fan of the Newton MP 2000 (which I kept using for years after the Newton was cancelled):
1) You can search your meeting notes. I had four or five years of meeting notes that could be instantly (well, by late 90s standards of "instantly") searched.
2) You could point it at any IRDA printer and just print stuff. (I was astonished by this when I discovered it worked, because the first IRDA printer I got was made long after the Newton was cancelled.)
In contrast to this, most of my paper notes (and I've gone back to paper) end up being lost, and those that aren't lost are horribly disorganized. Generally, the half life of paper notes -- for me -- is perhaps a month.
I agree that this happens, but it is your own decision. Until the 20th century, scientists had to maintain notes of everything they did in notebooks. They kept them organized and accessible, despite having to use handwritten notes.
Why use word processors? Quill and ink has served us for generations.
I never face this issue, very simply because after you use a real notebook for a while, you learn to organize information. Indexing information by date, topic etc is common for seasoned notebook users.
Conversely, I've had lots of PDAs through the years, and any notes I took on them were lost long ago.
Search - How do you grep or Ctrl-F your notebook to find out that one command you ran three weeks ago to fix your dev environment?
Copy/Paste - If I ask you for a copy of your notes, you have to retype it out. I can yank and paste into my e-mail client.
In addition, I have to quibble with expandability. Yes, I can buy additional notebooks, but I have finite desk and drawer space. Moreover, the cost of searching increases nonlinearly as the number of notebooks increases. Meanwile, grep runs approximately as quickly on 1kb of notes as it does on 100kb of notes.
I can't do that
There is almost never one tool to use in every situation. Fluidity is key: Use the right tool for the job. Solo and need to take quick notes you can search on? Newton. Love a keyboard? PC/Mac w/ Evernote or OneNote. Want to stand up in front of a bunch of people and show them an idea in real-time? A white board.
I personally have a notebook I write in when taking notes on a computer would be just plain rude (in front of prospects and clients) and at other times, I organize my thoughts in Workflowy. Some of my meeting notes go directly into our CRM. The right tool, for the right job, at the right time.
At the end of the day it's whatever works for that particular person at a particular time. I wouldn't say that people shouldn't try different things for a week just to see how it works, because you don't know what you don't know, and don't know you don't know it until you see a blog post like this, but there is no one-size-fits all solution to transferring info from your brain to a medium.
This feature doesn't work for me so often...
It's not compatible with blind people or people who don't speak the language of the notebook.
One of the wonderful things that computers have done is to vastly improve the ability of people with disabilities and speakers of any language to access vastly more information than they could before.
;-)
Good luck fitting a dozen three ring binders into a single pocket.
Photographs of handwriting are good enough, millions of students use such method. It is so good that even Google Books uses it, no?
Sometimes a canvas is better than text, and sometimes text is better than a canvas. Paper is cheap, but it's not inherently better at these tasks. A computer can much more effectively organize your notes while being as compact as the situation calls for.
Battery life - infinite
Handwriting recognition - I can recognize my own handwriting.
Document centric workflow - The document is definitely front and center.
Share Everything - in the paper notebook, everything is shareable, and shared in the same way. Either take a picture of the pages, type them in somewhere else (and edit while you do so), or make a photocopy. Optical Character Recognition may be possible but would arguably be adding unnecessary complexity.
Expandability - either purchase more notebooks, or use the 3-Ring Binder (tm) model to expand the capacity of your existing device.
Community - the paper notebook is no wonder device. The spiral notebook was patented in 1935 and has a large community of nearly all of western civilization.