News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:18PM (#1062566)
the disincentive to work is very real, it is not a bogeyman of the free market advocates. that said, it's also a common mistake of free marketers to think of a work disincentive as inherently bad. people would do well to remember that economic statements in themselves are value free: If you do X, Y will happen. it says nothing about whether Y is good or bad. That is up to the people Y affects to decide for themselves.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by viggity on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:26PM (#1062763)
I'd like to know when you think an increased economic output is a bad thing? The only argument I can see for that is to protect people from themselves, but then again, I really don't like it when the government tries to mettle with people who are doing no outside harm.

I'd rather have a large supply side driving costs down and improving my quality of life than otherwise.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by nostrademons on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:43PM (#1062802)
There're costs to that economic output that are not reflected in its dollar value.

For example, what's the value of having a parent at home full-time? What's the value of having both parents home for dinner? A bunch of studies have shown that one of the best predictors for having successful, well-adapted children is how much time the family spends together. But how do you quantify that? You won't know what the exact payoff is until 10-15 years later, when the kids are well into their own careers and having their own children. And it varies a lot from kid to kid - someone who's performing well academically with a supportive peer group needs a lot less parental involvement than a loner with no friends who's threatening to blow up the school.

Or another example: when I went to college, I believe the fin-aid formula was that the college would take 100% of my assets, based on my age and income. That meant my gap year was revenue neutral - it didn't matter how much I worked or what I worked on, I wouldn't be able to keep any of it. But that gave me the freedom to observe and to try things out, without the stress of trying to make a lot of money, and in the process I found my eventual career.

You don't want to run an economy like this - there needs to be some accountability so that people work on things that are actually useful. But a high school grad who's time-limited to one year of work isn't going to accomplish anything actually useful anyway - instead, that gap year is an investment in perspective, a way to understand more of the world before you commit to four years in college.

The same thing often comes up in research - a short-sighted focus on increased economic output leads you to miss opportunities that have no obvious dollar value attached, but can be big economy-changers in the long run. How long did it take GMail to become profitable, and would it have existed had Google had the same quarterly bottom-line orientation that most public companies do? How about Google itself? If Larry and Sergey had done the economically rational thing in 1995, would we still be searching on AltaVista? Is Twitter making money yet?

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by viggity on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:52PM (#1062827)
"There're costs to that economic output that are not reflected in its dollar value."

I agree, but I'd rather put that decision in the hands of each individual and not a bunch of central planning bureaucrats. You're assuming that people aren't capable of weighing all the costs (dollars or otherwise).

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by nostrademons on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @02:07PM (#1062874)
Well, the tax/finaid structures here also place the decision in the hands of each individual, they just tilt the incentives.

I'm very much in favor of finaid working the way it does, because it also opens up the possibility of bright children from backgrounds who simply would not be able to afford it going to elite colleges. That's supposed to be the point of education - level the playing field, so that even if you're born to garment-worker immigrants, you can make it big in your own lifetime. If it means that middle class families have some skewed incentives, I don't care.

I'm less sure about the tax issues. I'd like to see the tax code simplified in general, if only because tax preparation is so inefficient now. And I think disincentives in tax rates may cause more harm than the revenue collected from them does good.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by randallsquared on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @02:25PM (#1062914)
Well, the tax/finaid structures here also place the decision in the hands of each individual, they just tilt the incentives.

So does a mugger's threat, somewhat more starkly.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by fexl on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @07:13PM (#1063666)
Here's an interesting video about the history of financial aid for education:

http://schiffforsenate.com/?q=media/how-government-programs-...

Synopsis:

In 1918, a factory worker at Ford Motor Company earned $5 per day and kept all of it. In 32 days he would earn $160, enough to cover the annual tuition at Yale University.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by ZachPruckowski on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @11:51AM (#1065117)
Real (inflation-adjusted) wages have declined or stayed static since the 1970s. Even if college tuition only increased at the rate of inflation, it would still be harder to afford today than it was in the past.

Also, Ford workers at that time were making above-average salaries. They weren't the lower-middle-class to middle-class auto workers of today, they were solidly upper-middle-class. And 32 days is like 12% of his salary, so it wasn't exactly cheap for him (though far better than the 30-40% we see now).

Finally, it's disingenuous to compare 1918 colleges to 2008 colleges. Two major events really shook up the post-high-school landscape in those 90 years: the GI Bill and Vietnam. The GI Bill sent like 5 million people to college in the 40s-50s who otherwise couldn't have afforded it. Then Vietnam made college compulsory for middle-class or upper-middle-class men looking to avoid military service. Throw in desegregation, affirmative action, and co-education, and it's pretty clear that college went from being the domain of the brilliant and affluent to being open to the majority of Americans who finish high school. This total structural shift and basic re-definition of college makes pre-70s tuitions irrelevant to today's system.

If you want, you can also toss in the degree to which the job market has changed to requiring skilled workers with some form of post-secondary education. While some of this is likely a result of the education levels of the labor-supply, at least part of it is due to our changing industrial and commercial landscape.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by fburnaby on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @09:02PM (#1066402)
No bureaucrats are making any decisions in either of your hypothetical scenarios. In one case, there's an unchanging legislative environment incentivizing more work, while in the other case the legislative environment is incentivizing other potentially valuable things. No decisions made.

As long as the tax code isn't too complicated and it doesn't change constantly, then how is the government meddling? There are just free people making their own decisions; their decisions just have slightly altered outcomes depending on the environment they're made in.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by petercooper on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @04:06AM (#1064407)
You're assuming that people aren't capable of weighing all the costs (dollars or otherwise).

Which is a reasonable assumption. We wouldn't need laws if people could rationally weigh up the costs and benefits of their actions.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by j_baker on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:03PM (#1063008)
Remember, there are more important things in life than increased economic output. Like happiness, health, etc. Chances are good you can get increased economic output at the expense of those two things.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @02:54PM (#1062981)
there are multiple economies: dollars, political status, social status, personal happiness etc. people often trade benefits in one for benefits in another. myself and other free market advocates tend to think things should be worked out in dollars (explicit contracts) because it is the most transparent. but we can't lose sight of the fact that everything is a means to an end. that end being personal welfare followed by overall welfare.

I agree with almost everything that anarcho-capitalists say...but many of them don't seem to realize that under such a diaspora many (most) people will continue to live within semi-coercive organizations, because not everyone has the same preference for personal freedoms that they do. so yes, some will actively choose decreased economic output in favor of other things that they desire.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by ZachPruckowski on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @11:19AM (#1065031)
Well, if that large supply side is driving costs down, it's causing deflation, which can screw debtors hard (and most americans are debtors). Further, as costs fall, profits fall, and people see wage cuts or down-sizings to compensate.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by viggity on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:32PM (#1062776)
Its important to note that not only do they mention the disincentive to work, but the disincentive to save and the disincentive to pay your debts.

How is discouraging people to save and pay their debts good for anyone or society as a whole?

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:50PM (#1062825)
this is veering into monetary policy. the government inflates the dollar to pay for things without raising unpopular taxes (80% of treasury bonds purchased by the fed last year). constant inflation causes several things

A) a disincentive to pay debts since they will be cheaper in the future

B) a disincentive to save since your money will have less purchasing power in the future

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by harshavr on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @12:12AM (#1064114)
B) should be disincentive to save using money, not a general disincentive to save itself. One could make investments in any other commodity whose value relative to other commodities stays constant or increases.

It is a somewhat unusual tax, in that your tax rate is based on what proportion of your assets are in dollars. Does someone know what the rate per year on dollar assets is and how to calculate it? You would need to know how much money the Fed prints in a year. Do they publish it or was that what auditing the fed was about?

Also for A), banks probably factor in inflation while setting the interest rate for a loan. So, the relevant variable, i guess, is unexpected inflation rather than the value of inflation itself. The debtor benefits only when the loan market makes low estimates.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by nostrademons on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:48PM (#1062818)
I dunno, but the credit card companies seem to be doing a pretty good job of it. Same with the Federal Reserve. Would you get rid of them as well? ;-)

(It's a semi-serious question. Credit card companies encourage people to buy things they can't afford and then carry the balance - it's how they make money. And the Federal Reserve attempts to cause continual low-level inflation, such that savings are worth less and debts are easier to pay back the longer you carry them. I don't really support either practice, but there are lots of things America is doing to discourage savings and encourage debt.)

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by zzzmarcus on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @05:35PM (#1063459)
Yes, I'd get rid of the Federal Reserve.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by eru on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:29PM (#1063073)
Credit card companies are also making money on fees when you buy stuff.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by ZachPruckowski on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @11:17AM (#1065022)
> How is discouraging people to save and pay their debts good for anyone or society as a whole?

In a time of economic slowness, it benefits the society as a whole more if you increase your marginal spending (spend more cents of every dollar), because that keeps money flowing through the system. Of course, that means we'd want to create incentives to pay debts off and save when the economy's going well (which also has the benefit of controlling growth).

In America, we've become more and more dependent on consumer spending as the engine of our economy, so we keep incentivizing it beyond reason, even in boom times. That's what's causing the personal debt levels we're seeing.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by fexl on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @06:40PM (#1063601)
The disincentive to work is very real indeed, I can assure you. I am making the best money of my life and I aim to make less. That extra money is costing me time spent on more rewarding pursuits such as writing interesting code, or even just taking a long walk -- and that opportunity cost rises as I grow older.

To be clear, if I can make 40% more money with at most 10% more effort, I might consider it. But after a point the extra after-tax income is not worth the time and quality of life I forfeit. The whole point of earning extra money, beyond the ability to buy "things," is to buy more time and an enhanced quality of life. If it does not accomplish that, then the extra money has negative value.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by aprime on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:19PM (#1062745)
"that said, it's also a common mistake of free marketers to think of a work disincentive as inherently bad"

The article points to work disincentives created as unintended consequences of (a combination of) other apparently unrelated policies. Are you suggesting that since work disincentives are not bad, its okay for them to be created this way?

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:52PM (#1062829)
uh...my point was that goodness/badness is a product of interaction between circumstance and people's aggregate preferences.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by joe_the_user on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @10:53PM (#1064009)
Hmm,

I'm not sure it's disincentive to work as such.

It seem more like a disincentive to make more than $60K/year if you're not going to make $200K.

There's still an incentive to work to avoid homelessness.

Perhaps it could be called a disincentive to work hard.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by access_denied on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:25PM (#1062581)
Good comment.

Going to "work" is not the only way an individual can be beneficial to society.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by watmough on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:38PM (#1062640)
If you're dis-incented to work, that may allow you to lead a better life on less, say one partner earning instead of both, whilst someone who needs a primary income will take that higher paying job.

Don't underestimate the beneficial effect of one person being able to stay home, look after a house, cook fresh food, save on childcare, consume less fuel etc etc.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by CWuestefeld on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:29PM (#1062770)
That sounds like the broken window fallacy to me.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by nostrademons on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:49PM (#1062823)
Having a parent at home is a broken window?
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by CWuestefeld on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @02:12PM (#1062885)
See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window

In a nutshell, it's the story of kids playing baseball and accidentally hitting a ball through someone's window. The fallacy is that by breaking the window, they've helped out the economy. The homeowner will now pay the glazier to fix it, whose wife will now have money to buy a new dress, etc.

It's a fallacy because it ignores the productivity that the money would have resulted in had it been used for its original intent. Perhaps his car needs new tires, or whatever -- but there was something that the homeowner would have preferred but for the necessity created by the ball.

By analogy, perhaps the hypothetical second parent, who is now staying home, might instead be a doctor helping people, or a teacher, or even a garbage collector. Whatever, it's something that we would have gotten had it not been for this disruption.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by nostrademons on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @05:10PM (#1063391)
I'm familiar with the broken window fallacy, I just question its applicability here.

The broken window fallacy is usually used to highlight the importance of opportunity cost and unintended consequences. In the parable, the broken window results in some very visible benefits - the glazier has money, his wife has a new dress. But it's a fallacy because we don't know what the glazier would be doing otherwise. Perhaps he would've created a beautiful stain glass window, which causes his business to spike up afterwards as his skills increase, which means his wife can afford a series of socialite parties, which bring together people who would never have met, etc.

As Retric points out, I think the fallacy is more likely to work in the other direction here. The benefits of working are very obvious - you get more income, you can afford to buy more things, you live more comfortably. The opportunity costs are more subtle - perhaps your kid grows up hating you, perhaps they fall in with a bad crowd and start doing drugs, perhaps they never make it over the mathematical hump that prevents them from being a famous physicist. It's different for every kid, and you won't know for years.

Good economists admit that there are things that count that can't be counted, and recognize the limits of their models.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by sokoloff on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:11PM (#1063029)
And if they do that, then they aren't working as a full-time child-care provider, cook, cleaner, errand runner, concierge, etc.

The broken window fallacy says that purely destructive actions don't actually stimulate the economy in a useful way. In no way is one adult staying home to perform "home work" logically equivalent (at least, not in my opinion).

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by CWuestefeld on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:45PM (#1063111)
I think that everyone is missing the point of the broken window fallacy.

It's not that something is destructive. It's also not that something involves monetary transactions or not.

The point is that some external agent forces someone to change their plans, foregoing what they originally intended. (Economics deals with making choices between the available alternatives; money is only the tip of that iceberg)

In the parable as I outlined it, the employment of the glazier is presented as a positive outcome, while ignoring that the homeowner is now unable to buy his new tires, and thus the homeowner has lost the tires and the garage has lost that business.

In the stay-at-home-parent scenario, there's a visible gain of a parent giving the child a close bond and (presumably) good upbringing. But the fallacy hides the fact that had someone else not meddled, that parent would be doing something else that also has a positive outcome (else an employer wouldn't be willing to pay for it).

We can see that in both examples, the person whose behavior was forced now must be satisfied with a plan that is inferior to their initial intent. And assuming that all are rational actors (as economists generally do), then we can conclude that the total utility thus delivered (over the entire economy) is lower than that of the initial intent.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by codexon on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @05:15PM (#1063410)
One point that you are missing here is that some people have stockpiled wealth and power, and have no intentions of using it to stimulate liquidity in the markets.

How much money does a billionaire need to live from day to day? The same as any other normal person. Yes, they are likely to consume more luxury goods, but in the end, it does not cover the fact that the more money you have, the easier it is to get even more.

For examples of this you need to look no further than your local bank and see what premium rates they offer for people with high balances. Index funds offer ultra low expense rates for people with a lot of money. With a large proportion of money, it becomes possible for you to manipulate the markets by buying out competition, and becoming a monopoly: which is arguably the equilibrium state for any free-market. The monopoly is the most profitable situation for any business, and this is at odds with society.

So the more money you acrue, the higher your money/work rate becomes. This is a perverse incentive for the large corporation owners to not work as hard; and also to lay off workers during recessions. What sane company would be hiring when workers/consumers have less money to spend?

And the less work that is put into the economy, the worse off the economy is. This cruel cycle is why the economy was in a deflationary spiral and why "Helicopter" Ben is printing money as fast as he can.

This has a communist vibe, but in the end there is simply no argument that it is much better for the country to utilize the resources and wealth to stimulate the economy as a whole than letting a few people sit on it so they can get richer by doing nothing with it.

The poor and middle class can't just create their own wealth because they don't own "the means of production" or the intellectual property horded by megacorps and protected by megacorp lawyers and lobbyists.

It is analogous to not letting DeBeers sit on a stockpile of diamonds, except instead of diamonds, it is money, food, gas, homes, etc...

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by CWuestefeld on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @05:38PM (#1063468)
I was going to ignore this as a "who cares" until I got to:

in the end there is simply no argument that it is much better for the country to utilize the resources and wealth to stimulate the economy as a whole than letting a few people sit on it so they can get richer by doing nothing with it.

Not only is it false that there's "no argument", but your statement is completely wrong.

If there were no argument, you wouldn't be seeing arguments from prominent economists like Greg Mankiw, Bryan Caplan, and Tyler Cowen. And indeed, they've got good arguments. The idea that burning through money to stimulate the economy comes from the Keynesian tradition -- but we know from the 70's double-shot of inflation and unemployment that the Keynesian model is wrong (the question is, "just how wrong?").

But your statement that they're sitting on their wealth doing nothing with it is the biggest demonstration that you're off base. As far as I know, nobody rich is doing this. If they're stashing it under their mattress, I don't think they'd have gotten rich in the first place. If they've got it invested in stocks or bonds or even banks, then it's not idle and doing nothing. It's helping other people finance their businesses, buy houses, whatever. But it's definitely doing something useful. In fact, it's doing something so useful that the people using the money are willing to rent it from them.

Contrast this to government spending, which according to Keynesian theory could be used by paying people to dig holes and fill them back in, so long as the government is doing this. In the Keynesian model (that Obama and the rest of the government is using), the money does not get used productively. When the rich guy rents his money to someone willing to pay for it, it's much more likely to find good use.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by ajross on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @09:01PM (#1063839)
but we know from the 70's double-shot of inflation and unemployment that the Keynesian model is wrong (the question is, "just how wrong?").

Whoa: way, way, way oversold. Your making a blanket argument on a very complicated subject from a single data point. What about the sustained growth in the 40's through 60's due to New Deal, WWII, and Great Society spending? Economics is hard, and poorly suited to ideological statements like that.

Anyone sane would look at the evidence and say that Keynesian stimulus works sometimes, and not others, and that the details matter a lot. Only political partisans would make a statement like yours.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by CWuestefeld on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @09:14PM (#1063849)
Anyone sane would look at the evidence and say that Keynesian stimulus works sometimes, and not others

Sure, and you quoted my qualifier, too. I did say that the question is, "just how wrong?" (Not that there isn't an ideology I favor, but I don't think I was whitewashing to sell it)

You'll note that some of the credit in the early 60s has to be given to anti-Keynesians. Kennedy's tax cuts broke from the Keynesian model, and were successful. And if you'll buy into Hayek a little, I'll assert that the WWII boom (no pun intended) can't be credited to following any particular school, but is simply because the economic question is easy when you can get the whole society on the same page, working toward the same goal.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by ajross on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @10:42PM (#1063991)
Indeed, and the same qualifier would give a blanket "wrong" to supply-side theory too. After all, it failed in the '28-'32 period. Just how wrong is the question. That logic doesn't work, sorry. Keyensian thought isn't "proved" wrong in anything but the ideological fantasies of Wall Street Journal editorialists.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by codexon on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @06:12PM (#1063551)
If they're stashing it under their mattress, I don't think they'd have gotten rich in the first place. If they've got it invested in stocks or bonds or even banks, then it's not idle and doing nothing. It's helping other people finance their businesses, buy houses, whatever. But it's definitely doing something useful. In fact, it's doing something so useful that the people using the money are willing to rent it from them.

You are absolutely incorrect. They aren't doing this. They are pulling out of the US economy and putting them in Euros, gold, or Chinese factories. Did you somehow forget the complaints of a credit crunch that banks weren't lending any money?

Do you really think they are dumb enough to keep investing in the US when dollars are being printed non-stop? If so you are way off base.

If there were no argument, you wouldn't be seeing arguments from prominent economists like Greg Mankiw, Bryan Caplan, and Tyler Cowen. And indeed, they've got good arguments. The idea that burning through money to stimulate the economy comes from the Keynesian tradition -- but we know from the 70's double-shot of inflation and unemployment that the Keynesian model is wrong (the question is, "just how wrong?").

Then why aren't they the ones making the decisions if they are so correct? And the government doesn't simply just spend money for the sake of spending it. It usually (not always of course) goes into projects that benefit the public for decades such as better roads, power, and homes.

And Keynesian model being wrong because of the 70's? That is simply naive. Inflation was due to fears of Opec increasing oil prices and moving off the gold standard. Inflation was already rising when Nixon implemented his limits on wage/price increases. US Debt as a fraction of the GDP was even decreasing during this period.

http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/askville/4889596_...

Describing this as Keynesian is absolutely inane.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by CWuestefeld on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @10:27PM (#1063964)
Inflation was due to fears of Opec increasing oil prices

That would depend on your understanding of inflation. The monetarist views, which it seems to me have proven themselves out most successfully in the real world, say that nothing of the sort can happen. Inflation is caused by one thing, and that's an increase in the money supply. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation#Monetarist_view

and moving off the gold standard

Well, yes, but that's precisely the point. The end of Bretton Woods was already a done deal by the time we're talking about. We were well into the era that the Keynesians though they could play games "stimulating" the economy by injecting money, bringing down unemployment by so doing. The fact that this didn't achieve their goals is exactly what I was talking about, and one of the reasons you should be listening more to the Monetarists like Friedman, rather than to Keynes.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by codexon on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @10:59PM (#1064015)
Inflation is caused by one thing, and that's an increase in the money supply.

That is plain wrong.

Think about what would happen if the scarcity of crucial goods like food and shelter increased by 1000%. Would there be inflation? I'd put my money on it!

Well, yes, but that's precisely the point.

No, it is not precisely the point. The economy was already declining when Nixon moved off the gold standard. Why do you think he wanted to do it in the first place?

And if your theory was correct, then why did the economy recover? Last time I checked, we didn't move back to gold in 1980.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by nostrademons on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @01:52AM (#1064224)
Check your assumptions. From the article you linked:

"Velocity of money is often assumed to be constant, and the real value of output is determined in the long run by the productive capacity of the economy. Under these assumptions, the primary driver of the change in the general price level is changes in the quantity of money."

Monetarists never claim that inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomena unless they're dumbing things down for the press. They claim that in the long run it's a monetary phenomena. There's still room in the monetarist model for short-term supply spikes like the OPEC oil crises of 1973 and 1979 that the grandparent poster alludes to.

I'd also take issue with your statement that "you should be listening more to the Monetarists like Friedman, rather than to Keynes." They are not diametrically opposed. Friedman accepted Keynes; in fact, one of the reasons that monetarism was successful was because Friedman was one of the first people to accept Keynes on his own terms and then point out situations where Keynesian economics was unable to explain the observed data. Monetarism should be viewed as a refinement of Keynesianism, not a replacement.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @04:34PM (#1063279)
separating preferences from their environmental context is also a fallacy. there are no ideal preferences that would exist if only some outside agent hadn't interfered. life is a long series of outside agents and our response to them.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by timwiseman on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @05:10PM (#1063393)
This is true in the general sense, you cannot remove all outside agents and still say anything meaningful.

But it is not true when dealing with any one particular agent. You can often say what would have happened but for one particular agent.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by Retric on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:03PM (#1063010)
I suspect the broken window fallacy takes place, but in the other direction. If a parent stays home and takes care of their children there is zero apparent economic activity, or less if the stay at home parent cooks. No childcare, less eating out, no maid services etc. However, the stay at home parent is doing that work which benefits the family and is probably also doing a better job of it than low cost help.

PS: This also depends on how much the primary income is, how much time it takes, and how old the children are. If a family with three young children is supplementing a 140k primary income with a full time job that pays less than 50k it’s probably of little net benefit. If on the other hand it’s 40k and 40k and the children are in school it’s probably a significant net gain. Time is also a factor; one of the better and more common setups for families with school age children is a teacher parent. They share the same breaks, and the added stability can be a huge help.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by Psyonic on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:06PM (#1063017)
Or maybe a daycare worker, taking care of someone else's children, instead of her own...? You think that taking care of and raising your child is inherently unproductive?
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by billybob on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:51PM (#1063133)
Choosing parenting over work is great. But it doesn't mean we should devalue work in order to get it.

Better to have people choose between two good options than to make one option lousy.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by ewanmcteagle on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:05PM (#1062710)
Yes, we're taking your stuff. Don't worry it's for your own good. If it's not then it's at least good for society. Look, we're taking your stuff here's a list of excuses just pick one.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by pyre on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:29PM (#1063072)
So we would all be better off in a society with no policies to increase the education of the poor/working class? Lower literacy rates are a boon to society? Or just a boon to you because you are literate and have money so screw everyone else?
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by randallsquared on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @05:38PM (#1063467)
So we would all be better off in a society with no policies to increase the education of the poor/working class? Lower literacy rates are a boon to society?

It's not obvious that policies intended to do X actually help X very much. In fact, there are so many counter-examples (I'm sure you can think of many yourself) that suggesting that the absence of government policy to do X would result in X not being done falls flat. Most of the time, people overall are better off without a government policy concerning them.

Anyway, I think it's pretty obvious that most people are better off if more (other) people are literate.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by pyre on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @06:52PM (#1063624)
He's not railing against any particular policies. He's railing against all government interaction.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by randallsquared on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @08:17PM (#1063756)
Yeah, that's why I generalized the argument to X. Government intervention is generally a bad thing, not only a bad thing in a few very limited cases.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by pyre on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @08:30PM (#1063777)
Wouldn't it then be better to rail against specific policies that are either not proven or proven to be bad than to just say, "screw it all, we'll do nothing?"
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by randallsquared on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @08:57PM (#1063833)
It might be more effective, but it's unclear: I don't know of any strategy that's likely to actually help significantly in rolling back the scope of government, by any metric. (I'm not saying there isn't any, only that I don't know what it would be).

Note, though, that even people who want the government to do less aren't saying "we'll do nothing", they're saying "we want to choose which things to do ourselves". No one needs a law or regulation to spend their own money, it's only required when you want someone else's money spent without having to convince them they should.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by sp332 on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @03:57PM (#1063148)
Yes. If I care about improving the lot of poorer people, I'll do it with my own money and probably with less beaurocracy. If not, get your hand out of my wallet.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by Locke1689 on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @05:42PM (#1063478)
... he says as society crumbles around him and the unfortunate kill him for his stuff...
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by sp332 on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @06:58PM (#1063635)
The only reason a society would tax itself and give the money to the poor, is if (at least) some individuals in that society wanted to give their money to the poor. If no one in the society wants to give their money to the poor, then the society as a whole wouldn't tax itself for that reason, either.

As a believer in personal property rights, I think that those individuals who care about the poor should be free to give their money to the poor. But I don't think that their moral high horse gives them a right to use other people's money.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by gjm11 on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @10:11PM (#1063942)
The argument that I think you're making in your first paragraph is fallacious. In particular, it can happen that (1) everyone wants to give some money to the poor but (2) if they all have to do it individually (rather than a universal tax) no one will do it. This will happen, for instance, if everyone strongly dislikes being worse off than their neighbours, but weakly prefers that the poor be helped. (This is the same idea as in the familiar situations of "prisoners' dilemma" and "tragedy of the commons". It's also why some sports have officially-enforced requirements for safety measures: everyone's better off if everyone's protected, but if it's optional then that's at best an unstable equilibrium because a player or team that chooses to forgo the protection may get an advantage over those who don't. But once no one is protected, all those competitive advantages go away and everyone's worse off than if everyone had been protected.)

Now, if (as your second paragraph suggests) you really believe that taxation is so fundamentally evil that it cannot be justified whatever its good consequences, then of course the above will leave you entirely unmoved. But if you are prepared to consider trading off harms against benefits, then I don't think you're entitled to dismiss the possibility that some redistributive taxation is a good thing overall; in particular, you can't just say "if people want to give money to the poor then let them do so" unless you have good reason to think that the sort of situation I described above doesn't obtain.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by fexl on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @11:54PM (#1066657)
I consider it evil to initiate force against another individual. Therefore, specifically, I consider it evil to incarcerate someone for not paying money into a giant pool to be spent by other people.

I consider it good for individuals to engage with each other in purely voluntary ways. That is the source of happiness, wealth, health, and life. All else is a waste of my limited time on earth.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by AlisdairO on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @03:57AM (#1064396)
How do you feel about progressive taxation?
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by araneae on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @01:30PM (#1062772)
It's true. For instance, raising children is imperative for the preservation of society.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by ShabbyDoo on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @02:51PM (#1062970)
Perhaps more direct incentives might be in order then. Estonia pays mommies a stipend to say home for a year or so, and the amount is based somewhat proportionally on the woman's income pre-baby.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by run4yourlives on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @07:26PM (#1063690)
Estonia?

Canada pays 55% of a salary for a year in the form of Employment Insurance for maternity leaves that can be 1 year for a mother and up to six months for a father.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by gnosis on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @03:25AM (#1064355)
It's not just Estonia. I've heard that in England the mother gets 1 year (fully) paid leave. Same with Sweden and Germany. In Sweden it might even be two years (but my memory is failing me).

I would be willing to bet that at least a full year of paid maternity leave is quite standard in northern Europe.

Some countries (the Netherlands, for instance) even pay their citizens to have children.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by run4yourlives on Friday January 22, 2010 @12:12PM (#1070046)
1 year maternity leave is pretty much the standard globally for established countries, just like state run healthcare.

It's the US that is different here.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by ShabbyDoo on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @03:48PM (#1065745)
Estonia came to mind because of an Economist article a couple of years ago.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by thejake on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @12:49PM (#1062674)
Who deems what is benefical to society?