Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class
by nostrademons on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @05:10PM
(#1063391)
I'm familiar with the broken window fallacy, I just question its applicability here.
The broken window fallacy is usually used to highlight the importance of opportunity cost and unintended consequences. In the parable, the broken window results in some very visible benefits - the glazier has money, his wife has a new dress. But it's a fallacy because we don't know what the glazier would be doing otherwise. Perhaps he would've created a beautiful stain glass window, which causes his business to spike up afterwards as his skills increase, which means his wife can afford a series of socialite parties, which bring together people who would never have met, etc.
As Retric points out, I think the fallacy is more likely to work in the other direction here. The benefits of working are very obvious - you get more income, you can afford to buy more things, you live more comfortably. The opportunity costs are more subtle - perhaps your kid grows up hating you, perhaps they fall in with a bad crowd and start doing drugs, perhaps they never make it over the mathematical hump that prevents them from being a famous physicist. It's different for every kid, and you won't know for years.
Good economists admit that there are things that count that can't be counted, and recognize the limits of their models.
The broken window fallacy is usually used to highlight the importance of opportunity cost and unintended consequences. In the parable, the broken window results in some very visible benefits - the glazier has money, his wife has a new dress. But it's a fallacy because we don't know what the glazier would be doing otherwise. Perhaps he would've created a beautiful stain glass window, which causes his business to spike up afterwards as his skills increase, which means his wife can afford a series of socialite parties, which bring together people who would never have met, etc.
As Retric points out, I think the fallacy is more likely to work in the other direction here. The benefits of working are very obvious - you get more income, you can afford to buy more things, you live more comfortably. The opportunity costs are more subtle - perhaps your kid grows up hating you, perhaps they fall in with a bad crowd and start doing drugs, perhaps they never make it over the mathematical hump that prevents them from being a famous physicist. It's different for every kid, and you won't know for years.
Good economists admit that there are things that count that can't be counted, and recognize the limits of their models.