Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class
by fexl on Wednesday January 20, 2010 @11:54PM
(#1066657)
I consider it evil to initiate force against another individual. Therefore, specifically, I consider it evil to incarcerate someone for not paying money into a giant pool to be spent by other people.
I consider it good for individuals to engage with each other in purely voluntary ways. That is the source of happiness, wealth, health, and life. All else is a waste of my limited time on earth.
Now, if (as your second paragraph suggests) you really believe that taxation is so fundamentally evil that it cannot be justified whatever its good consequences, then of course the above will leave you entirely unmoved. But if you are prepared to consider trading off harms against benefits, then I don't think you're entitled to dismiss the possibility that some redistributive taxation is a good thing overall; in particular, you can't just say "if people want to give money to the poor then let them do so" unless you have good reason to think that the sort of situation I described above doesn't obtain.