News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by ajross on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @09:01PM (#1063839)
but we know from the 70's double-shot of inflation and unemployment that the Keynesian model is wrong (the question is, "just how wrong?").

Whoa: way, way, way oversold. Your making a blanket argument on a very complicated subject from a single data point. What about the sustained growth in the 40's through 60's due to New Deal, WWII, and Great Society spending? Economics is hard, and poorly suited to ideological statements like that.

Anyone sane would look at the evidence and say that Keynesian stimulus works sometimes, and not others, and that the details matter a lot. Only political partisans would make a statement like yours.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by CWuestefeld on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @09:14PM (#1063849)
Anyone sane would look at the evidence and say that Keynesian stimulus works sometimes, and not others

Sure, and you quoted my qualifier, too. I did say that the question is, "just how wrong?" (Not that there isn't an ideology I favor, but I don't think I was whitewashing to sell it)

You'll note that some of the credit in the early 60s has to be given to anti-Keynesians. Kennedy's tax cuts broke from the Keynesian model, and were successful. And if you'll buy into Hayek a little, I'll assert that the WWII boom (no pun intended) can't be credited to following any particular school, but is simply because the economic question is easy when you can get the whole society on the same page, working toward the same goal.

Re:When work doesn't pay for the middle class by ajross on Tuesday January 19, 2010 @10:42PM (#1063991)
Indeed, and the same qualifier would give a blanket "wrong" to supply-side theory too. After all, it failed in the '28-'32 period. Just how wrong is the question. That logic doesn't work, sorry. Keyensian thought isn't "proved" wrong in anything but the ideological fantasies of Wall Street Journal editorialists.