News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by nickff on Monday October 26, 2015 @01:51PM (#10453027)
As I understand it, the Fukushima plant was never designed or rated to sustain such a large earthquake or tsunami. If this understanding is correct, we should not have expected it to survive the damage, and the problems were not with the design, but perhaps with the specification (depending on whether you think this should have been foreseen).

It seems to be a common thread with all tragedies and disasters that people suffer from hindsight bias, and believe that this specific case should have been foreseen. It is not clear what the cost of building everything to sustain all similar low-probability events would be, and whether doing so would be statistical murder.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by maxerickson on Monday October 26, 2015 @02:04PM (#10453129)
Here's a key phrase from the abstract that suggests more than hindsight bias is involved in the report:

The Fukushima accident was preventable, if international best practices and standards had been followed, if there had been international reviews, and had common sense prevailed in the interpretation of pre-existing geological and hydrodynamic findings.

Another one:

Three, the hazard analysis to calculate the maximum probable tsunami at Dai-ichi appeared to have had methodological mistakes, which almost nobody experienced in tsunami engineering would have made.

So there is sense in which they are pretty strongly pointing at regulatory failure.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by ChuckMcM on Monday October 26, 2015 @02:39PM (#10453451)
I'm not sure if you agree that the findings are unsustainable or not. Two things that the IAEA had established were that

1) Fukishima survived the earthquake as designed, and was in the process of shutting down when the tsunami hit.

2) The tsunami disabled primary and backup power to the cooling systems which was the proximate cause of the failure.

Further, at the time of its commissioning, the tsunami it experienced was accepted by the best engineering data at the time to be impossible.

You can make the argument that over time as more data became available the regulatory agency should have required additional upgrades to cover the larger tsunami risk. There have been plenty of stories about regulatory capture between TEPCO and the regulators which prevented best practices from being followed.

A lot of retrofits had been installed over time and that no doubt contributed to its survival of the earthquake.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by msandford on Monday October 26, 2015 @11:59PM (#10456241)
> 2) The tsunami disabled primary and backup power to the cooling systems which was the proximate cause of the failure.

What I find really disgusting is that they had backup BACKUP generators trucked in and they couldn't use them because the plugs didn't match up. IT'S A FREAKING NUCLEAR POWER PLANT! DO YOUR JOB, CUT THE CONNECTORS OFF AND MAKE A CONNECTION! Literally EVERY ONE of the people who worked there are directly involved in the power generation business and they couldn't make a wonky connection work? If that's not in the top 10 completely preventable disasters of the century I don't know what is.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by spronkey on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @05:55AM (#10457059)
I'd go one step back and say what on earth were backup generators doing in a basement in the first place.

This just completely blows my mind. It is literally the worst vertical level they could have put them!

I guess they took defence in depth a bit too literally...

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by msandford on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @06:12PM (#10461542)
I'll give them a pass on that, personally. Tsunamis are rare and the sea wall was supposed to protect them against just about any "realistic" tsunami threat.

But what's inexcusable is allowing a reactor to melt down because you don't know how to cut connectors off of cables and do makeshift splices.

How many people will end up dying because someone wasn't willing to take a little risk? I mean, what's the worst that could happen? It'd work for a while and then fall apart? It'd blow up your generators? The worst-case scenario is that the nuclear reactor melts down which is what happens if you don't create a makeshift splice. So you have nothing to lose.

I'm obviously armchair quarterbacking this, but I can't see the argument against just trying something and hoping it works.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by maxerickson on Monday October 26, 2015 @02:42PM (#10453475)
This report directly disagrees with Further, at the time of its commissioning, the tsunami it experienced was accepted by the best engineering data at the time to be impossible. Directly.

This part uses scare quotes to describe the 'quality' of the work:

Its initial application was based on the 3.122 m measurement local tsunami height (above Onahama Peil (O.P.) reference sea level), observed during the 1960 Great Chilean tsunami at or close to Fukushima [32]. The flooding estimate was provided to the nearest millimetre, underscoring a false sense of accuracy in the safety assessment that is impossible even today. With hindsight, it also underscores the ‘quality’ of the engineering work and of its review.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by dredmorbius on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:03PM (#10453629)
British use of quotes is typically distinguished from American, in that where emphasis using language from the original document is intended, those words are typically quoted. You'll see this extensively in BBC headlines.

They're not "scare quotes", to quote you. They're direct quotations, for emphasis.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by _delirium on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:27PM (#10453795)
I've definitely noticed that. I often misread BBC headlines as scare-quotes at first, which is sometimes funny. Two on there right now: Ministers 'in listening mode' on tax credits; 'Autonomy' plan for Scottish Labour.
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by maxerickson on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:08PM (#10453667)
Those quote marks are in the report to indicate sarcasm.
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by dredmorbius on Monday October 26, 2015 @05:53PM (#10454748)
Useage elsewhere doesn't support your comment. E.g., in the introduction:

Interestingly, while the Onagawa NPP was also hit by a tsunami of approximately the same height as Dai-ichi, it survived the event ‘remarkably undamaged’.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by ChuckMcM on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:30PM (#10453814)
I believe I misquoted the IAEA, but I did find the actual report [1] which talked about the Tsunami hazard. As reported it was "Fukishima's tsnumani vulnerability has been regularly updated with the latest accepted methodology." (and I relayed that as meeting the standards of the time) but the actual report also concludes that the methodology was insufficient because it did not consider beyond the most recent few hundred years.

But perhaps more importantly this is a great example of how complex these things can be. The "accepted methodology" and by that they mean the one the regulators hold them to, failed to consider a more geologically relevant time span (thousands of years versus hundreds of years).

My understanding of the situation was that the regulators said "Tell us you have accounted for tsunamis" and TEPCO said "We have, using the accepted methodology, here are the results."

So when did we know the methodology was wrong or insufficient? A lot of people had access to what TEPCO filed and their rationale over the 40+ years of operation. I'm interested if there was a concerted effort, pre-disaster, to get the methodology changed.

[1] "While the tsunami hazard assessment ha d been periodically updated at the Fukushima nuclear power plant taking into account the latest accepted methodology in Japan, the magnitude of the tsunami hazard was underestimated because it was based solely on historical data on relatively recent events (occurring within the past few hundred years). " -- https://www.iaea.org/sites/default/files/protection040912.pd...

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by zurn on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @02:49AM (#10456646)
The article talks about the Soloviev & Go catalogue how it wasn't taken into account: "Presumably on the basis of these studies, [Soloviev & Go] assigned it a tsunami intensity I=4, which is one of their highest values for Japan tsunamis. Yet, in the aftermath of the Fukushima accident, it has been argued repeatedly that the Jōgan tsunami had not been documented until 2001 [17], well after the design of the NPP"

Also, the 2007 journal paper that found insufficient protections at Fukushima: "The senior author of [46] was then a TEPCO scientist, while another two co-authors are two of the most senior tsunami engineers in Japan. We wonder how disappointed they must have been on 26 November 2010, when, in the symposium organized by JNES, they found out that TEPCO did not appear to have heeded their recommendations [46] in its re-assessment of Fukushima Dai-ichi"

I haven't read the whole report, these are just 2 that I picked up.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by maxerickson on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:33PM (#10459140)
The article cites the safety culture at the company that runs the compared reactor and discusses how they went about deciding what sort of events they needed to plan for. They apparently knew what they were doing in 1968 and did not lean on passing the regulatory minimum (the reports cites later studies of how the plant is situated and the relative lack of damage from the 2011 tsunami).
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by seanflyon on Monday October 26, 2015 @04:31PM (#10454247)
> the tsunami it experienced was accepted by the best engineering data at the time to be impossible.

I find that hard to believe. It was the 4th largest earthquake in the last century and doesn't make the Wikipedia list of "Megatsunamis". It was more a question of how long between such extreme events than if such an extreme event could occur.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by abduhl on Monday October 26, 2015 @06:47PM (#10455038)
Megatsunamis are caused by large volumetric displacements of water resulting from massive amounts of earth entering the water. The tsunami that caused the Fukushima disaster was not a megatsunami - it was caused by thrust faulting resulting in underwater displacement rather than the megatsunami mechanism discussed above.

The analogy here is splashing your hand into water (megatsunami) versus moving your hand underwater.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by Shivetya on Monday October 26, 2015 @02:16PM (#10453241)
When it was built or after? This plant was built in the early eighties. The article doesn't state if it violated the ideals of then or more recent knowledge.
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by maxerickson on Monday October 26, 2015 @02:26PM (#10453338)
The comparison to Onagawa makes it clear enough that they are talking about when it was built. They wouldn't have had so much more experience in 1968 than when they did the early design work for Fukushima Dai-ichi.
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by samstave on Monday October 26, 2015 @02:30PM (#10453373)
Fukushima was built in 1967... and was based on an even slightly older GE plant design.

Or were you talking about the other plant?

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by logicallee on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:19PM (#10453742)
The next nuclear accident that will occur in the world is 100% preventable, and without any hindsight bias I will tell you exactly how... after it occurs.

/s

(seriously, if you want me to take a claim seriously that accidents are preventable, talk about what we are doing wrong today, not in the past.)

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by makomk on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:27PM (#10453799)
Engineers at TEPCO did tell them what they were doing wrong at Fukushima Daiichi. They were ignored:

"In 2008, TEPCO did two sets of calculations, one based on the Headquarters for Earthquake Research Promotion (HERP) fault models which suggested tsunami height estimates of 8.4–10.2 m relative to the reference sea level. Another one based on Satake et al. [47] produced 8.7–9.2 m tsunami height estimates which were also apparently dismissed [32]. TEPCO ignored them, claiming there was ‘no wave source model’ for the former, and it required a tsunami deposit investigation for the latter [32]. In 2009, new estimates using updated bathymetry and tidal data yielded a 6.1 m tsunami height [12,32]. This was not followed-up and was only reported to Japan's Nuclear and Industrial Safety Agency (NISA) on 7 March 2011 [48]. A post-event study [48] asserts that ‘a senior NISA official has confirmed to us that NISA neither ‘commissioned nor reviewed’ numerical studies of tsunami run-up at Fukushima Daiichi’."

The reason you only hear about these issues after an accident occurs is not because they could only be predicted in hindsight, but because no-one cared about the predictions until after the accident.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by logicallee on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:40PM (#10453889)
if our title read "Nuclear power plants are still being run recklessly, and the next Fukushima-like accident is likely 100% preventable today" it would get my attention, and I would read what the claims that we need to be doing are.

small statistical disagreements about experts on the other hand, are hard to take as seriously.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by btilly on Monday October 26, 2015 @08:03PM (#10455335)
The thing is that those are not small statistical disagreements.

The maximum tsunami+tide they designed for was 5m. Design parameters said that you should have a wall 2x what you think you need so they built a 10m (about 30 foot) wall.

Two independent teams came up with realistic tsunamis near that 10m wall (one over and one under), so they should have changed their wall requirement up substantially. But they argued themselves into believing that 6m was a realistic maximum then did nothing.

Their estimates were also out of line with actual tsunamis experienced elsewhere. Tsunamis in recent decades from earthquakes similar to the ones that they knew could hit the area have ranged from 3-30m. Even a 7.0 earthquake managed to create a 12m tsunami in New Guinea.

The actual tsunami was 13m.

The most telling point is how the response afterwards has shown lessons not learned. For example The United States National Research Council of the National Academies had a 21 person panel conduct 18 months of interviews with a wide variety of technical experts on how the disaster could be prevented here. NOT ONE of the members of the panel or the people interviewed was an expert on tsunamis. The author's of the paper clearly believe that if you're studying the aftermath of a tsunami, you should at least talk to someone who studies tsunamis...

If the paper is correct, it is a question of time until somewhere in the world we have another entirely preventable major disaster because local officials underestimate tsunami threats that current knowledge is more than sufficient to predict. Of course enough things can go wrong that the next big disaster won't be that. But that preventable disaster is coming...

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by maxerickson on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:26PM (#10453789)
http://www.nrc.gov/reactors/operating/ops-experience.html

The point of that link being, there are people that are thinking about what the problems are and working to fix them, so it is sort of glib to demand that such things be done.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by PaulHoule on Monday October 26, 2015 @02:37PM (#10453426)
If you read closely you see that the accident was so bad because of one simple problem.

If a nuclear reactor has a cooling failure, the fuel will eventually heat up and then melt down. To prevent this you have to keep water circulating around the reactor core. It doesn't take a huge amount of energy to do this, but it does take some. If the power goes out at the station and they can't get emergency power, the outcome is very bad.

If they had spent maybe $300k or so they could have moved the emergency generators a little bit higher up. With that investment there still would have been serious damage to the plant but only a very limited release of radioactivity because the fuel integrity and the coarse integrity of the plant would have been protected.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by nickff on Monday October 26, 2015 @02:43PM (#10453482)
I have read that many times, and it makes some sense. The issue with this line of reasoning is that the move would be a design change which is not required by the specification (as I have read and understood it), which would have been seen as unnecessary waste at the time.

A study which I would find more important and useful than the one here would be a cost/benefit analysis of increasing all specifications relating to all (similar) low probability events. In other words, if you had been a designer of the plant looking to spend an extra $500000 to make the plant safer, would you have spent it on moving the generators? How many other contingencies would have been higher priorities than this one (if any)? What would be the total cost/benefit of applying this heightened standard to all new facilities? Would this be statistical murder?

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by alricb on Monday October 26, 2015 @10:27PM (#10455893)
It's very hard to estimate the probability of very rare events like tsunamis and earthquakes, so you kind of have to use heuristics to get a reasonable "design basis" event. Then you design your system to survive said event. The argument the authors make is that the event was improperly chosen (too low). A proper choice of event would have led TEPCo to conclude that they had to mitigate the danger posed by a higher flood line, by, for instance, moving the generators.
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by nickff on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @02:02AM (#10456529)
This thinking is using hindsight bias.

If you had been more cautious with respect to this one type of event at this one plant, you would have prevented this problem at a low cost. The problem is that only really tells you that 'if you know what's going to happen, you can do a really good job planning for it', which is rather obvious and completely useless.

My point is that if you were to have been more cautious in the overall specification for the plant (because, again, the plant was never designed to survive the type of event it was subjected to,) it is not clear whether the generators would have been moved (as that may not have been a high priority compared to other improvements), or even if they had, what the cost/benefit ratio would be. You have to remember that there may be many other events which may have appeared more likely than large earthquakes and tsunamis, and those would probably have been seen as more cost-effective safety enhancements, and would have been waste. In addition, this heightened standard would be applied to all the power plants subject to similar regulation, which would have been further waste.

The important question is not what the cost/benefit ratio for moving generators at Fukuhima before the tsunami would have been, but what the cost/benefit ratio for taking precautions against all events of similar likelihood and impact in would be for all power plants (or even all infrastructure) would be.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by alricb on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:37PM (#10461963)
The value used to determine the Design Basis Flood is a 10000 year recurrence. Over a 100 year lifespan, there is around a 1% chance of that flood happening. The consequences of loss of all power including backups is the loss of the plant + huge evacuation costs and possible loss of life. $1M is very cheap to protect a multi-billion plant in this context.
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by PaulHoule on Monday October 26, 2015 @06:36PM (#10454988)
When you consider that a nuclear plant costs billions of USD and that billions of USD of damage has been done, the $500,000 upgrade to the generators is a slam dunk. Also based on recent projections, the probability of a tsunami event of that severity was 80% for the next few decades, so it is a no brainer -- particularly when you consider that the nuclear industry worldwide has been set back 20 or 40 years at least by this incident.

The NRC has had modernization plans at U.S. reactors that have spent much more than this. For instance the hydrogen bubble formation in that kind of BWR was well known here and reactors in the U.S. have had features added (dependent on a power source) that would get rid of it.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by nickff on Monday October 26, 2015 @07:23PM (#10455199)
You are still falling into the same trap.

cost of preventing low probability events in the future >> cost of preventing events in hindsight

The problem is that you do not know which events will occur, so you will inevitably spend not only on implementing that $300000 upgrade on one plant which will need it, but on many $500000 upgrades on many plants (most of which will never be necessary or related to tsunamis). The cost/benefit ratio of preventing low probability events in the future should be studied, and only after looking at such studies can we decide whether any one change should be made. For example, the US government rejects any highway improvement which costs more than $3MM per life saved, as there are many lower-cost measures that save lives, and spending on less cost-effective measures is "statistical murder".

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by PaulHoule on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @04:10PM (#10467030)
I can just say with that attitude there is going to be no public acceptance of nuclear power.
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by ansible on Monday October 26, 2015 @02:53PM (#10453549)
If a nuclear reactor has a cooling failure, the fuel will eventually heat up and then melt down. To prevent this you have to keep water circulating around the reactor core.

This is the one simple problem.

There are now reactor designs that are passively fail-safe. So that even if all the pumps and everything stop, it will still not result in an explosion or otherwise serious release of radioactive material.

I don't know how much those sorts of designs were developed at the time Fukushima was commissioned though.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by guscost on Monday October 26, 2015 @06:52PM (#10455065)
BWR reactors like Fukushima are all passive-safe in at least one way, since water moderates the neurons coming off the critical materials, slowing them enough to continue the reaction. If the water boils away, sure the thing will almost certainly melt but there won't be a runaway prompt-critical event like Chernobyl, and if the concrete "bathtub" around the core holds, there won't be much radioactive material released into the groundwater either.

From what I heard the concern at Fukushima was that the earthquake had compromised the integrity of the containment structure, so allowing the core to melt down was judged as too risky (I'm not sure if I agree with that decision, but of course my opinion in hindsight is not relevant). In fact the majority of radioactive material that was released in the incident might have leaked from the spent fuel storage, which was also damaged in the earthquake:

http://web.mit.edu/nse/pdf/news/2011/Fukushima_Lessons_Learn...

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by jandrese on Monday October 26, 2015 @03:58PM (#10454008)
In fact Fukushima had a passive cooling system, but the valve to it was mostly closed when the power was lost and nobody knew how to open it or even check its state.
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by nickff on Monday October 26, 2015 @02:58PM (#10453587)
This all misses the point of my first post.

You could have a much safer design available, but if the 'less safe' design is more cost effective, and meets all specifications, it would still be the preferred design. This means that the any problem is with the specifications/requirements. The next question is whether the standard of safety which would require choosing the 'failsafe' (or at least failsafer) design would cause statistical murder.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by InclinedPlane on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @12:40AM (#10456346)
Molten salt reactors have the ability to avoid such disasters, as a built-in design criterion. In such a reactor there's no issue if the fuel melts down, it's normally molten anyway. If there's a loss of coolant then the core melts through a frozen salt plug and then sits in a catch area. Because the core isn't under high pressures there's vastly less risk of any radioactive bits escaping the confines of the reactor.
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by vesinisa on Monday October 26, 2015 @05:49PM (#10454725)
The authors argue that there were very serious and repeated shortcomings in the methodology used to estimate the highest possible flooding caused by a tsunami.

The plant was designed for 6-meter tsunami from an M=7.5 earthquake, but what actually hit them was a 13-meter tsunami from an M=9.0 quake. I understood it's international standard practice to consider worst-case events from historical record spanning thousands of years in nuclear plant risk analysis, and it is known that almost as strong earthquakes hit Japan in 1933 (M=8.5) and 869 (M=8.6), for example. A plant by a different company just 100 km north of Dai-ichi was built for a 13-meter tsunami, so there was little consistency in what preparations the tsunami analysis actually induced, and the regulator seems to have been indifferent to these disparities. Further, there were for some reason no mandatory "safety margins" in tsunami level precautions to offset modelling inaccuracies, unlike in precautions for the earthquake ground shock – eventhough computational models for tsunami levels were and remain much less accurate than the ground shock models.

Although by 2000s the shortcomings of tsunami analysis like the one done for Dai-ichi were already well-known, a methodologically-flawed further analysis by TEPCO in 2010 failed to introduce any new recommendations – against the published opinions of their own scientists. The cost of relocating the diesel generators higher up in the building would have been just in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, rather than millions.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by BurningFrog on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @08:42AM (#10464058)
Remember that this was the biggest earthquake to hit Japan in over 1000 years of known quake history.

It hit in a pretty ideal spot to generate a big tsunami at the reactor site.

Maybe the reactors "should" have been engineered to handle this situation anyway, but keep in mind that this event is an extreme outlier.