News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by PaulHoule on Monday October 26, 2015 @06:36PM (#10454988)
When you consider that a nuclear plant costs billions of USD and that billions of USD of damage has been done, the $500,000 upgrade to the generators is a slam dunk. Also based on recent projections, the probability of a tsunami event of that severity was 80% for the next few decades, so it is a no brainer -- particularly when you consider that the nuclear industry worldwide has been set back 20 or 40 years at least by this incident.

The NRC has had modernization plans at U.S. reactors that have spent much more than this. For instance the hydrogen bubble formation in that kind of BWR was well known here and reactors in the U.S. have had features added (dependent on a power source) that would get rid of it.

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by nickff on Monday October 26, 2015 @07:23PM (#10455199)
You are still falling into the same trap.

cost of preventing low probability events in the future >> cost of preventing events in hindsight

The problem is that you do not know which events will occur, so you will inevitably spend not only on implementing that $300000 upgrade on one plant which will need it, but on many $500000 upgrades on many plants (most of which will never be necessary or related to tsunamis). The cost/benefit ratio of preventing low probability events in the future should be studied, and only after looking at such studies can we decide whether any one change should be made. For example, the US government rejects any highway improvement which costs more than $3MM per life saved, as there are many lower-cost measures that save lives, and spending on less cost-effective measures is "statistical murder".

Re:The Fukushima accident was preventable by PaulHoule on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @04:10PM (#10467030)
I can just say with that attitude there is going to be no public acceptance of nuclear power.