- one of the three judges said that the plaintiff didn't have standing because there wasn't explicit evidence that the government was collecting data from Verizon Wireless. [In a followup post, Marcy notes that a recent IG report (obtained by Charlie Savage of the NY Times via a FOIA suit) does explicitly include Verizon Wireless in a list; but this information probably wasn't known in time to include it in arguments in this suit.]
- another judge said that there wasn't any evidence the plaintiff had suffered any harm from the data collection
- and the third said that the plaintiffs "barely fulfilled the requirements for standing at this threshold stage, Plaintiffs fall short of meeting the higher burden of proof required for a preliminary injunction"
https://www.emptywheel.net/2015/08/28/dc-circuit-reverses-ju...
https://www.emptywheel.net/2015/08/28/government-recently-re...
so you have to prove you've suffered harm from the removal of your rights? They're called rights and the country was founded on protecting them because they're both intrinsically valuable and completely invaluable!
No, you have to be able to establish that you have had your rights violated. The standard that gets referred to as "harm" is more formally "concrete, particularized injury" where "injury" is defined as a violation of a legally-protected interest.
You don't have to prove, e.g., damages from the violation of your rights, but you can't just allege that an action is a violation of people's rights generally, and further that, as a person, you may have been impacted, so therefore you have standing to challenge the action. To have standing to sue, you have to allege with sufficient evidentiary basis that an action actually violated your rights in a concrete way.
Until YOU can prove that YOU have been harmed, YOU don't have standing.
This is precedent set by the supreme court in http://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/clapper-v-amnesty...
Courts do not decide cases based on speculative future injury.
"To establish Article III standing, an injury must be "concrete, particularized, and actual or imminent; fairly traceable to the challenged action; and redressable by a favorable ruling." "
> - another judge said that there wasn't any evidence the plaintiff had suffered any harm from the data collection
Ugh. Where does it say in the 4th amendment that it's okay to seize and search all the documents without a warrant, as long as there's "no harm"?!
Judges are supposed to act on the law and the information presented in the cases before them, not on their biases formed from consumption of outside sources like the popular media.
> Where does it say in the 4th amendment that it's okay to seize and search all the documents without a warrant, as long as there's "no harm"?!
Injury of the type necessary to establish standing is a concrete, particularized violation of a legally-protected interest. Actually having one's own documents searched or seized in violation of the Fourth Amendment is such an injury, whether or not it results in additional harms. The problem here is that the court found that the plaintiff had not done enough to demonstrate that their data was seized.
Judge: "I can't tell the cops to stop secretly spying on everyone because I don't know who they've been spying on"
Plantiff: "Then make them tell us who they've been spying on"
Judge: "I'm sorry you have no standing because you can't prove they've been spying on you, so you can't demand anything"
Yes, I understand this kind of argument is correct in the legal system but it seems to make a mockery of "higher" notions of justice (which I think sometimes the courts take into account and sometimes they don't).
In fact this is what the government won on for https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clapper_v._Amnesty_Internation....
That said, if you meet the standing bar, you still have an uphill battle through the inevitable invocation of the state secrets privilege to avoid giving you access to the facts that would be required to actually have a chance to win the court case...
Your claim that the either approach is less "kafkaesque" or less Orwellian seems without merit and deplorable.
I understand the legal theory. But given routine violations of the intent of the Constitutional protection from things like civil forfeiture, it seems to me to be merely one piece of a Kafkaesque system that is designed to provide the illusion of rights without any reality to them.
For those who don't know what civil forfeiture is, the government both can and regularly does seize people's property through the polite fiction of suing the property. The person who owned the property then gets to find out that since they are not a party of the lawsuit, they don't have legal standing to complain that THEIR stuff was taken.
(This practice is quite profitable for law enforcement agencies. There are significant civil rights concerns about the unequal way in which they implement the practice against different people...)
That is not what they're saying. It is understood that, if it can be shown the plaintiffs' documents were "[unreasonably] seized or searched", there would be an injury. What has not been shown (at least not clearly enough for a preliminary injunction) is that these plaintiffs' documents were searched/seized.
Does the 2nd say 'except for criminals'?
We've long ago tossed out the Constitution and have since just been playing pretend.
If we're playing the literal interpetation game, then the 4th amendment says nothing more than that the government needs a warrant to do what would for a private person amount to trespass to land or chattels. None of this mosaic theory malarkey.
My point was of the exact opposite. That the rights it clearly does list are still ignored and have holes punched in them until they look like Swiss cheese (just look at all the different sorts of gun bans in different areas).
Who decides what rights exist?
History also doesn't do much to support an argument that the 9th hides a right to "privacy". The original drafts of the 9th Amendment weren't about unenumerated rights, but about state and local rights versus the power of the federal government. The language was bickered over, but apparently much of the jurisprudence of the 9th that happened anywhere close to the time of the founders was about devolution of state and local power.
See for instance Hugo Black's dissent in Griswold:
[The Ninth] Amendment was passed, not to
broaden the powers of this Court or any
other department of the [Federal
Government], but as every student of
history knows, to assure the people that
the Constitution . ..was intended to
limit the Federal Government to the
powers granted expressly or by necessary
implication. If any broad, unlimited
power to hold laws unconstitutional
because they offend what this Court
conceives to be the "[collective]
conscience of our people" is vested in
this Court by the Ninth Amendment
. . . , it was not given by the Framers,
but rather has been bestowed on th[is]
Court by th[is] Court.7Are you able to demonstrate the breaching of the 4th Amendment ? Or there just has to be some sustained injury presented before the courts?
So let's see.. Because a person can't prove to the government that the government is violating its own rules, the government decides that the person doesn't actually have a case, even though everyone knows the government is spying on everyone, and thus violating its own rules.
Rright. So even if the government decided the case against itself, i.e. forbade itself from spying on everyone, why would anyone think they'd actually curtail their spying activities?
If a wolf had been eating sheep left and right, and suddenly declared he'll stop doing that because eating sheep is Ba-a-a-ad, would the sheep have reason to believe he'd actually stop?
Eating sheep is in the wolf's nature, and he's never had a problem with it before, so why would he stop? It would serve the wolf's interests to distract/placate the sheep though, so that they'd be easier to eat!
[EDIT:] Apparently this is not clear to everyone, but there is a logical difference between the proposition that two sets differ in some salient respect (e.g. that only those in the NSA may "illegally" spy on other Americans, with impunity), and the proposition that they differ in every respect. A careful reading of the previous paragraph will reveal that I have claimed the former.
What a terribly silly thing to say.
"there is a difference between people who work at X and the average American."
You are claiming that every single employee that works at NSA can in no way, shape, or form be considered an average American. All 30-50k or however many of them there are, they just can't be average Americans?
I mean, I totally agree. I bet they don't have lives outside of work. Probably none of them have kids. I bet they've never been married, or divorced. I'm sure they all rent under pseudonyms, none of them actually buy a house.
Hobbies, pshaw, all they care about is their job, and breaking the law as often as they can. Every single one, a zealot to the cause, insanely loyal to their employer. They don't have bad days at work, or don't feel like going in, because damn it, they're different than the average American.
I mean, there's no way that they just need to put food on the table, or can't leave the area because they have joint custody of their children. That kind of thing only happens to the average American, not NSA employees. By gosh, the horror of even considering that most of them are in fact average Americans, I'm getting tremors down my spine just thinking about it.
That is, it's compromised in some way, and therefore rules in favor of Deep State type things all the time.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ngpsJKQR_ZE http://spot.colorado.edu/~huemer/Contents.pdf
No seriously. Think about it. It really is as simple as that. Apple doesn't have to force people to buy their devices.
People aren't extorted for their benefit, but the extorter's, even if the extortion is shrouded in brainwashing, propaganda, rituals and so on.
So once you accept that taxation is extortion and politicians are psychopaths, you'll start being able to make sense of the insanity of the world.
This book thoroughly destroys most of the pro-state arguments people have come up with: http://spot.colorado.edu/~huemer/Contents.pdf
Are you uncomfortable with reading that? -Well why might that be? What sense does it make? Keep going anyway.
Let's unpack that a little bit. This is not a final ruling on the merits of the case, and it does not have anything (directly) to do with the 4th Amendment. Plaintiffs had moved for a preliminary injunction before the district court that would have stopped the program well before the ultimate outcome of the case. For obvious reasons, the standard for evaluating such requests is high. One of several factors used for evaluating such a motion is likelihood of ultimate success of the merits.
In order for plaintiffs to ultimately succeed, they have to convince the court that they have actually suffered an injury by having their own call records collected. They need to have been injured in order for the court ultimately to have jurisdiction. At this point, the DC Circuit concluded that they do not have any specific evidence of this (and, in fact, some of the indirect evidence weighs against them). So, the DC Circuit concluded that they were not so likely to ultimately succeed that it should give them the injunction they wanted before the ultimate outcome of the case.
This is not a good sign for a plaintiffs' case, but its important to emphasize that this is an early look at it with, necessarily, the benefit of only a small amount of evidence. The case will continue in the district court which will, among other things, try to determine whether the plaintiffs were actually injured.
Of course, the predictable outcome of that inquiry is that the NSA will invoke various legal privileges against disclosing the evidence necessary to actually make a determination, ultimately rendering plaintiffs' case impossible to maintain.