Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor...
by beambot on Friday August 28, 2015 @06:46PM
(#10138225)
So if rights are violated, but the violations are kept secret (eg. secret court gag order, national security, etc)... then you haven't been legally harmed?
Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor...
by NickNameNick on Friday August 28, 2015 @07:14PM
(#10138299)
Someone may have been harmed, but
Until YOU can prove that YOU have been harmed, YOU don't have standing.
Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor...
by ekianjo on Saturday August 29, 2015 @02:47AM
(#10139311)
Why doesn't this process lead to an investigation whether data was collected or not about the plaintiff?
Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor...
by dragonwriter on Saturday August 29, 2015 @11:29AM
(#10140304)
In civil lawsuits, investigation to gather facts necessary to meet threshold requirements like standing is the responsibility of the plaintiff before filing suit.
No, you have to be able to establish that you have had your rights violated. The standard that gets referred to as "harm" is more formally "concrete, particularized injury" where "injury" is defined as a violation of a legally-protected interest.
You don't have to prove, e.g., damages from the violation of your rights, but you can't just allege that an action is a violation of people's rights generally, and further that, as a person, you may have been impacted, so therefore you have standing to challenge the action. To have standing to sue, you have to allege with sufficient evidentiary basis that an action actually violated your rights in a concrete way.