Judges are supposed to act on the law and the information presented in the cases before them, not on their biases formed from consumption of outside sources like the popular media.
> Where does it say in the 4th amendment that it's okay to seize and search all the documents without a warrant, as long as there's "no harm"?!
Injury of the type necessary to establish standing is a concrete, particularized violation of a legally-protected interest. Actually having one's own documents searched or seized in violation of the Fourth Amendment is such an injury, whether or not it results in additional harms. The problem here is that the court found that the plaintiff had not done enough to demonstrate that their data was seized.
Judge: "I can't tell the cops to stop secretly spying on everyone because I don't know who they've been spying on"
Plantiff: "Then make them tell us who they've been spying on"
Judge: "I'm sorry you have no standing because you can't prove they've been spying on you, so you can't demand anything"
Yes, I understand this kind of argument is correct in the legal system but it seems to make a mockery of "higher" notions of justice (which I think sometimes the courts take into account and sometimes they don't).
In fact this is what the government won on for https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clapper_v._Amnesty_Internation....
That said, if you meet the standing bar, you still have an uphill battle through the inevitable invocation of the state secrets privilege to avoid giving you access to the facts that would be required to actually have a chance to win the court case...
Your claim that the either approach is less "kafkaesque" or less Orwellian seems without merit and deplorable.
I understand the legal theory. But given routine violations of the intent of the Constitutional protection from things like civil forfeiture, it seems to me to be merely one piece of a Kafkaesque system that is designed to provide the illusion of rights without any reality to them.
For those who don't know what civil forfeiture is, the government both can and regularly does seize people's property through the polite fiction of suing the property. The person who owned the property then gets to find out that since they are not a party of the lawsuit, they don't have legal standing to complain that THEIR stuff was taken.
(This practice is quite profitable for law enforcement agencies. There are significant civil rights concerns about the unequal way in which they implement the practice against different people...)
That is not what they're saying. It is understood that, if it can be shown the plaintiffs' documents were "[unreasonably] seized or searched", there would be an injury. What has not been shown (at least not clearly enough for a preliminary injunction) is that these plaintiffs' documents were searched/seized.
Does the 2nd say 'except for criminals'?
We've long ago tossed out the Constitution and have since just been playing pretend.
If we're playing the literal interpetation game, then the 4th amendment says nothing more than that the government needs a warrant to do what would for a private person amount to trespass to land or chattels. None of this mosaic theory malarkey.
My point was of the exact opposite. That the rights it clearly does list are still ignored and have holes punched in them until they look like Swiss cheese (just look at all the different sorts of gun bans in different areas).
Who decides what rights exist?
History also doesn't do much to support an argument that the 9th hides a right to "privacy". The original drafts of the 9th Amendment weren't about unenumerated rights, but about state and local rights versus the power of the federal government. The language was bickered over, but apparently much of the jurisprudence of the 9th that happened anywhere close to the time of the founders was about devolution of state and local power.
See for instance Hugo Black's dissent in Griswold:
[The Ninth] Amendment was passed, not to
broaden the powers of this Court or any
other department of the [Federal
Government], but as every student of
history knows, to assure the people that
the Constitution . ..was intended to
limit the Federal Government to the
powers granted expressly or by necessary
implication. If any broad, unlimited
power to hold laws unconstitutional
because they offend what this Court
conceives to be the "[collective]
conscience of our people" is vested in
this Court by the Ninth Amendment
. . . , it was not given by the Framers,
but rather has been bestowed on th[is]
Court by th[is] Court.7
> - another judge said that there wasn't any evidence the plaintiff had suffered any harm from the data collection
Ugh. Where does it say in the 4th amendment that it's okay to seize and search all the documents without a warrant, as long as there's "no harm"?!