News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor... by dragonwriter on Friday August 28, 2015 @02:00PM (#10136932)
> Are the judges blind to all the media releases in the past two years, or just pretending to be?

Judges are supposed to act on the law and the information presented in the cases before them, not on their biases formed from consumption of outside sources like the popular media.

> Where does it say in the 4th amendment that it's okay to seize and search all the documents without a warrant, as long as there's "no harm"?!

Injury of the type necessary to establish standing is a concrete, particularized violation of a legally-protected interest. Actually having one's own documents searched or seized in violation of the Fourth Amendment is such an injury, whether or not it results in additional harms. The problem here is that the court found that the plaintiff had not done enough to demonstrate that their data was seized.

Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor... by joe_the_user on Friday August 28, 2015 @04:21PM (#10137641)
[A crude simplification to make a point]

Judge: "I can't tell the cops to stop secretly spying on everyone because I don't know who they've been spying on"

Plantiff: "Then make them tell us who they've been spying on"

Judge: "I'm sorry you have no standing because you can't prove they've been spying on you, so you can't demand anything"

Yes, I understand this kind of argument is correct in the legal system but it seems to make a mockery of "higher" notions of justice (which I think sometimes the courts take into account and sometimes they don't).

Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor... by pdabbadabba on Friday August 28, 2015 @06:30PM (#10138184)
It isn't! In fact, in this very case they are being given the opportunity to obtain evidence from the government to establish standing. Of course, you're right that these efforts may fail, but if they do it will (probably) be because the government invokes the state secrets privilege to refuse to hand over the evidence, not the more kafkaesque problem of being unable to demonstrate standing because you lack standing.
Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor... by btilly on Friday August 28, 2015 @07:39PM (#10138366)
No, actually it is correct in the court system. And therefore the government will make this argument whenever they can. Because if they win on standing, their life becomes easier.

In fact this is what the government won on for https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clapper_v._Amnesty_Internation....

That said, if you meet the standing bar, you still have an uphill battle through the inevitable invocation of the state secrets privilege to avoid giving you access to the facts that would be required to actually have a chance to win the court case...

Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor... by joe_the_user on Saturday August 29, 2015 @01:40AM (#10139194)
..invokes the state secrets privilege to refuse to hand over the evidence, not the more kafkaesque problem of being unable to demonstrate standing because you lack standing

Your claim that the either approach is less "kafkaesque" or less Orwellian seems without merit and deplorable.

Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor... by btilly on Friday August 28, 2015 @07:44PM (#10138385)
Injury of the type necessary to establish standing is a concrete, particularized violation of a legally-protected interest. Actually having one's own documents searched or seized in violation of the Fourth Amendment is such an injury, whether or not it results in additional harms. The problem here is that the court found that the plaintiff had not done enough to demonstrate that their data was seized.

I understand the legal theory. But given routine violations of the intent of the Constitutional protection from things like civil forfeiture, it seems to me to be merely one piece of a Kafkaesque system that is designed to provide the illusion of rights without any reality to them.

For those who don't know what civil forfeiture is, the government both can and regularly does seize people's property through the polite fiction of suing the property. The person who owned the property then gets to find out that since they are not a party of the lawsuit, they don't have legal standing to complain that THEIR stuff was taken.

(This practice is quite profitable for law enforcement agencies. There are significant civil rights concerns about the unequal way in which they implement the practice against different people...)