News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor... by Lawtonfogle on Friday August 28, 2015 @03:39PM (#10137452)
One of the objections to even adding the Bill of Rights was that it would be taken to limit rights to only those listed. The Bill of Rights and later amendments do not encompass all rights, thus things like privacy do not need to explicitly be listed to count as a right.

My point was of the exact opposite. That the rights it clearly does list are still ignored and have holes punched in them until they look like Swiss cheese (just look at all the different sorts of gun bans in different areas).

Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor... by rayiner on Friday August 28, 2015 @05:25PM (#10137927)
> The Bill of Rights and later amendments do not encompass all rights, thus things like privacy do not need to explicitly be listed to count as a right.

Who decides what rights exist?

Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor... by FesterCluck on Friday August 28, 2015 @11:35PM (#10138967)
Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor... by tptacek on Saturday August 29, 2015 @09:51AM (#10139972)
The 9th Amendment was infamously vestigial for most of US history. There were until the New Deal very few SCOTUS cases that even mentioned it, let alone turned on it. In the few cases in which appellants hoped to rely on a notion of "unenumerated yet extant rights", SCOTUS rejected the interpretation.

History also doesn't do much to support an argument that the 9th hides a right to "privacy". The original drafts of the 9th Amendment weren't about unenumerated rights, but about state and local rights versus the power of the federal government. The language was bickered over, but apparently much of the jurisprudence of the 9th that happened anywhere close to the time of the founders was about devolution of state and local power.

See for instance Hugo Black's dissent in Griswold:

    [The Ninth] Amendment was passed, not to
    broaden the powers of this Court or any
    other department of the [Federal
    Government], but as every student of
    history knows, to assure the people that
    the Constitution . ..was intended to
    limit the Federal Government to the
    powers granted expressly or by necessary
    implication. If any broad, unlimited
    power to hold laws unconstitutional
    because they offend what this Court
    conceives to be the "[collective]
    conscience of our people" is vested in
    this Court by the Ninth Amendment
    . . . , it was not given by the Framers,
    but rather has been bestowed on th[is]
    Court by th[is] Court.7
Re:DC appeals court lifts injunction against NSA phone recor... by harryh on Friday August 28, 2015 @07:02PM (#10138267)
John Locke obviously! ;-)