News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Patrick_Devine on Friday July 10, 2015 @05:39PM (#9866900)
As an occasional user of reddit, this whole ordeal has confirmed the reason why I prefer not to hang out in its forums. I have no idea whether Ellen was a capable CEO, but the vitriol which I kept seeing peripherally (through other news articles and here on HN) was absolutely appalling.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by WalterBright on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:51PM (#9867434)
I'd rather have appalling speech than censored speech. The idea is to not confuse supporting a person's free speech with endorsing his views.

Also, reddit is a private company and so is not obliged to provide a platform for anyone's free speech, that also is a facet of freedom.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dmfdmf on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:55PM (#9867973)
At last, a voice of reason in hundreds of pointless comments.

Free speech is a principle and people should be free to say whatever they want no matter how disgusting or distasteful to the majority or mainstream. This is the ideal of a free society and people who can't make the distinction between supporting the principle and yet rejecting the advocates of idiocy are implicitly advocating some form of government censorship.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by agumonkey on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:28PM (#9868237)
What about duty of thinking ?

I'm often weirded by the freedom of speech argument in non critical contexts. These persons life aren't at risk because they can't express opinions, isn't that what is meant by FoS ? not just a free card to be able to let yourself loose in public.

I have no solution, but far too often FoS ends up a noisy non-discussions.

ps: I'll add that I was somehow afraid to express my views on Freedom of Speech. Funny.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by ryanmonroe on Friday July 10, 2015 @11:48PM (#9868448)
>These persons life aren't at risk because they can't express opinions, isn't that what is meant by FoS ?

No

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by rustynails77 on Saturday July 11, 2015 @02:46AM (#9868819)
This thread is very interesting and I deeply appreciate the comments people are making, including FoS, fear to comment on FoS, etc.

I personally respect freedom of speech, except hate. For example, HN strongly discourages attacking another member personally (eg. calling someone else idiot). I consider this a reasonable limit on freedom of speech, but concepts and opinions should be fully open for discussion (eg. pro/anti evolution etc). If the discussions are respectful, then anything should be allowed.

I believe Political Correctness has done more harm than it does good. It has created an unhealthy focus on skin colour, reproductive organs, etc to the point of lunacy. Many people struggle to look past superficial features and seem to lost the ability to make reasoned judgements. Any criticism of a woman gets you labelled a misogynist, regardless of how incapable she is. This continues to undermine the credibility of women that are truly capable in their own right. I'm currently managing a team of women. They all got there on their own merit. I would not hire a woman for the sake of political correctness or because I was bullied by a feminist journalist (as is quite common these days). The women in my team were not selected based on their gender - they were selected based on their talents and attitudes. They were available and capable.

This whole Ellen Pao incident made me think about the validity of comments on sexism and racism that are floating around the net. Compare the attitudes towards the criticisms of Steve Ballmer vs Ellen Pao. One of these individuals contributed to the significant growth of Microsoft, the other didn't manage to achieve much that stands out. Both developed a bad reputation as leaders. Yet, one of these people is being defended and the other is not. The major difference (other than Ballmer's financial track record for Microsoft) is their genders. Political Correctness has driven the need to blindly defend women, no matter how incompetent they may be. The hope is that this behaviour will help "women's rights". I view it as doing the exact opposite ... "jobs for the girls".

It saddens me that we seem to be more sexist, less tolerant and more willing to defend incompetence an an attempt to promote rights for selected members of society.

On a side note, I dislike the term "women's rights". Is it so hard to represent "people's rights"? I believe one of these reflects a destructive, prejudiced mindset and creates a bad attitude of entitlement and encourages sexism. If society said we'd defend the rights of everyone equally based on merit, the world would be a much better place.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by zmb_ on Saturday July 11, 2015 @04:23AM (#9869032)
> I personally respect freedom of speech, except hate.

The problem is that as soon as you draw such a line, you need to appoint a censor to determine what qualifies as "hate". As Christopher Hitchens asked: "To whom would you want to delegate the task to decide for you what you could read? To relieve you of the responsibility of hearing what you might have to hear?"

Typically this job falls to the public prosecutors. Who will make mistakes, misapply and pervert the laws. Sometimes with good intentions, sometimes with malice.

It is not just an abstract argument, it has very real consequences. Here in Finland we had a case [1] where an MP (now MEP) was convicted of hate speech for making a point about freedom of speech by asking a question along the lines of: 'Why is it ok to write that Finns might be culturally and genetically predisposed to get drunk and kill people, but not ok to write that Somalis might be culturally and genetically predisposed to rob people and live on welfare?'

These types of laws have very real chilling effects on public discourse. People are unwilling to engage in certain topics, which should be discussed, due to the fear of being prosecuted. In democracies trying to suppress or censor an idea or argument will just end up elevating them. In this case, the party to which the convicted MP belongs ended up becoming the second largest party and are now in the government. They no longer have to argue their case, they can simply implement it (and their immigration program was written by the MP in question).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jussi_Halla-aho#Criminal_charg...

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by arrrg on Saturday July 11, 2015 @05:04AM (#9869132)
Counterpoint: Censorship is awesome. It creates and shapes places that are just great and pleasant all around. Being an excellent censor is a great ability and there are sadly way too few out there who can give a clear voice (not in the sense of being one voice, necessarily, though that can also be great!) to something and be really excellently opinionated about their censorship.

I want more great censorship, not less. If it’s done by people and organisations, at least. Because that’s what we are talking about here, right? Reddit, not governments?

Censors are just editors and that job is not some inscrutable thing. It can be done and it can be done excellently.

I mean, to me this only gets tricky when we are talking about basic infrastructure, i.e. should a paper mill be allowed to refuse to sell their paper to Neo Nazis because of ideological reasons? Should a web hoster be allowed to refuse to sell to Neo Nazis?

But Reddit? That’s easy and I don’t really get what the fuss is about. Nothing would be lost at all if the admins were much, much, much more ban happy and much more pro-censorship. They should be, 100%.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by growupkids on Saturday July 11, 2015 @06:55AM (#9869312)
Perhaps I'm missing something. How would you know if someone is an excellent censor (I.e. They only censor "bad" speech, and not "good" speech) if then intent is to shield you from the "bad" speech. Wouldn't you then not know what they censored?

Specifically, it seems to me that if you're shielded from seeing that they censored, then they could also be censoring "good" speech too. So the only way it seems you could ensure they weren't do this poorly or deliberately would be to allow everyone access to what they've censored. Which inversely seems to defeat the purpose of having a good censor. Now essentially nothing in censored.

Again, perhaps I'm missing something but if I'm not then I don't understand how you resolve this conundrum.

Edit: Unless you're referring to ex post facto censorship, where everyone sees the "bad" speech, and the speaker is banned for violating "community standards" To pre-emptively ban future speech. But this too still allows "bad" speech, and I suppose you also have the problem of deleting the bad speech. If it's gone, then what substantiates the ban/censorship? Because again, what if the action was either done in error, or maliciously to ban "good" but unpopular speech/speakers how would you know?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by arrrg on Saturday July 11, 2015 @09:50AM (#9869757)
I don’t. I just accept that sometimes I just cannot know the absolute truth and that’s that.

But I do have the ability to trust people and I know when I enjoy something.

So, this all might sound very abstract, but I do know that I like the censors (they call themselves editors) working for certain newspapers I like. I trust them to make good decisions, partly just because I don’t have time to make those decisions myself.

And that’s obviously not perfect – but this whole nerd dream of provable correctness and absolute, guaranteed access to the truth all the time … it’s all unachievable bullshit anyway. Sometime you just don’t know. Sometimes you just have to live with that. I live with it and I like it.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by camelite on Saturday July 11, 2015 @11:36AM (#9870135)
> Sometime you just don’t know. Sometimes you just have to live with that. I live with it and I like it.

Honestly, this comes across as "He loved Big Brother"-level creepy.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by arrrg on Saturday July 11, 2015 @01:54PM (#9870821)
Big brother?

Do you have some sort of trust issues? I mean, sometimes I’m willing to trust other people, that’s all. I don’t have to believe that everyone is evil and out to get me. So when I read a newspaper I like I have a general trust that the editors (censors) have done their job … because what else can I do? What else can you do?

I don’t have the time to sit around 24 hours by the newswire … and even then, the people writing that and reporting that … how do I know I can trust those absolutely? I can’t. That’s all.

We humans are forever doomed to not know the truth always all the time. And no one is an island and sometimes you just have to trust other people. And that’s healthy and that’s ok.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by camelite on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @05:35PM (#9894227)
Basically, there are better sources to place your trust in than journalists. Journalists, in general, really suck.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by camelite on Saturday July 11, 2015 @11:34AM (#9870128)
> Counterpoint: Censorship is awesome.

Well it's crucial that the censors are people who like you. If they didn't like you, you probably wouldn't be such a fan of censorship. That is to say, the only reason you're in favour of censorship on reddit is that you're reasonably that the censors will be people like you, which really is no more than sophisticated tribalism.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by arrrg on Saturday July 11, 2015 @01:56PM (#9870838)
Hm … well I don’t like the censors at (insert certain newspaper I dislike here). But I don’t argue that they shouldn’t censor (edit their newspaper), I argue that they shouldn’t lie and write so much bullshit.

If I didn’t like the censors at Reddit I would do the same thing. I think that’s normal and healthy.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by agumonkey on Saturday July 11, 2015 @05:35AM (#9869172)
It's interesting. Instead of censorships I'm fond of the idea (though experiment so far) of shaping the place with costs and plateaus. Make sensitive things possible but with a bit of effort, so only people needing and meaning it will go the distance. The other will `naturally` fall back to their comfort zone.

reddit does that actually, until you're a well known user, you cannot submit more than a few per minute, after that delays kick in, if it really was something you wanted to share, you'll come back. No censor involved.

That's just an idea, but you get the point.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by JohnBooty on Saturday July 11, 2015 @11:01PM (#9872448)

   > The problem is that as soon as you draw such a line
The line needs to be drawn, though. As the saying goes, "Your freedoms end where my freedoms begin."

At some point, hate speech most definitely infringes upon the reader's rights. The canonical example is yelling "FIRE! FIRE!" in a crowded movie theater and causing a stampede; your right to free speech doesn't trump everybody else's right to be safe.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dredmorbius on Sunday July 12, 2015 @05:20AM (#9872995)
I'd very strongly suggest you read the circumstances of * Schenck v. United States. While I also find the issue of fraudulently harmful speech a reasonable bar, the case itself concerned something rather different.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States

[A] United States Supreme Court decision concerning enforcement of the Espionage Act of 1917 during World War I. A unanimous Supreme Court, in a famous opinion by Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr., concluded that defendants who distributed leaflets to draft-age men, urging resistance to induction, could be convicted of an attempt to obstruct the draft, a criminal offense.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by intopieces on Saturday July 11, 2015 @06:41AM (#9869290)
>On a side note, I dislike the term "women's rights". Is it so hard to represent "people's rights"?

I want to pull this quote out and address it directly, because it's a valid concern with a real answer. The reason we don't represent "people's rights" is because all people do not need their rights defended. To use an analogy, think of our system for measuring the level of endangered for animals, from "Critically Endangered" to "Least Concern." Is it sensible to say, 'Well, aren't all species important to the ecosystem? Why do we seek to protect Garrulax courtoisi but not Megascops watsonii?' This is because the former is nearly extinct, while the latter is ubiquitous. The cause of "social justice" -- the oft-derided 'warriors' of anti-sexism, anti-homophobia, etc -- is to correct years of disadvantage. It's not accurate to call, say, attempts to further women in technology as 'sexist'. In fact, that's co-opting the term to obfuscate the original issue.

Overall, your heart is in the right place -- it does seem like our attempts to further minorities comes off as patronizing (like affirmative action). But, in the end, the good that is done outweighs the bad so long as we adequately train the individuals we put forward through these initiatives such that no one believes they only 'got it because of their gender' (which to me is no different than 'got here through someone she knows' -- this is how most business seems to be done in the world!)

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by __Joker on Saturday July 11, 2015 @06:26AM (#9869265)
Thoughtful comments.

I have thought much on these as common person, neither in an academic setting nor who has to deal with these issue frequently.

Lot of time I would argue with myself why can't we have everybody have equal rights ? Why we need to specially fight for rights of women and be feminists or to project the issue to broader sense, where we talk or act about any group. Personally I believe that while the ideal case as it should be is equal rights for everybody, the problem is the inequality created by negative discrimination over the ages. It is more like we are trying to correct the wrong doing over the ages by believing that a positive discrimination for the groups would offset the historical prejudice.

These are personal thoughts. Please feel free to correct.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by thelamest on Saturday July 11, 2015 @05:21AM (#9869155)
For some reason there is still lots of inequality in education, work and culture so some sort of change is still needed. And I really don't think you get seriously labeled a bigot just for any criticism of a minority member.

> Both developed a bad reputation as leaders. Yet, one of these people is being defended and the other is not.

You mean Ballmer?

We know nothing specific and substantial about internal Reddit politics, so the cause for seeing all this hateful scapegoating can only be some kind of mass stupidity.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday July 11, 2015 @12:39PM (#9870436)
>I personally respect freedom of speech, except hate.

How far are you willing to take that? You could potentially prohibit satire.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by benihana on Saturday July 11, 2015 @05:35AM (#9869174)
>> I personally respect freedom of speech, except hate.

I'm sorry. You don't respect freedom of speech then. Drawing an arbitrary line on what you (or anyone else) considers acceptable isn't free speech.

Put it this way: Things that were unacceptable in the 1950s are completely banal and uninteresting now. Things that were considered in poor taste in the past are horribly offensive now (look at Andy Rooney in Breakfast at Tiffany's). Are you going to be some society guardian, constantly updating what is and isn't acceptable to say as our values shift with the times

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by JohnBooty on Saturday July 11, 2015 @11:05PM (#9872452)
This argument is pretty easy to deflate: a defender of "absolute free speech" most certainly would not be okay with people walking up to them in the street, following them home and verbally threatening them. So, everybody has an arbitrary line.... somewhere.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by ddw on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:11PM (#9871142)
> ps: I'll add that I was somehow afraid to express my views on Freedom of Speech. Funny.

Hah yeah because speaking up against these mobs can lead to getting DOXed. What an insane world we live in.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by benihana on Saturday July 11, 2015 @05:29AM (#9869165)
> These persons life aren't at risk because they can't express opinions, isn't that what is meant by FoS ?

No. That's the exact opposite of free speech. Free speech is meant to protect the most disgusting, heinous, pointless, hateful, ignorant, foolish speech.

That's the whole freaking point - nobody wants to silence unoffensive opinions.

>ps: I'll add that I was somehow afraid to express my views on Freedom of Speech. Funny.

It is funny. Because it's the people who want silence others' free speech who repeat the "freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences" meme as justification for their horrible actions.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by vacri on Saturday July 11, 2015 @07:31AM (#9869383)
> Free speech is meant to protect the most disgusting, heinous, pointless, hateful, ignorant, foolish speech.

No it's not. It's meant to protect speech which the politically powerful find objectionable. It's not about protecting abuse, but protecting ideas. Rebellious and revolutionary ideas, for example.

This is all a canard anyway - Reddit is not the (US) government. They get to set the rules for communication in their playground. If you don't let them do that, then you are infringing on their freedom of expression. Reddit can only say 'no' on their own systems; they don't stop you spreading whatever disgusting, heinous, pointless, hateful, ignorant, or foolish speech in other forums.

If you want free speech the way you describe it, then you need to go to an unmoderated forum. Incidentally, on the front page of HN at the moment is a request for help in removing child porn from a web service, because the owner doesn't have enough resources to moderate it. If you ever wanted a clear example of where free speech is not meant to protect disgusting material, that's got to be it

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by rndn on Saturday July 11, 2015 @08:24AM (#9869494)
I wished the ideal of free speech would include the ideal of being open to discussion (perhaps even the scientific method). I think many movements fail in that regard, for example it was pretty much impossible to have reasonable discussions with FPH subscribers. You were immediately downvoted when you tried to argue against it. If people are completely ignorant towards alternative, consistent points of view, they don't deserve to be listened to.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Veedrac on Saturday July 11, 2015 @11:36PM (#9872495)
Forcing people to listen, act in certain ways or to follow specific practices is basically the opposite of freedom.

Saying that people should be open to your arguments privileges those ideas you yourself hold. How do you tell which arguments get such treatment?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by rndn on Sunday July 12, 2015 @11:00AM (#9873667)
It wouldn't be the opposite of freedom (that would be suppression), but definitely a limit to the freedom we currently have in certain regards. However, we already have formal and informal rules that restrict the actions of people and forces them to follow specific practices, so it wouldn't be entirely new. In fact it would probably improve the situations at both extremes: on the one hand some taboos would be revoked (as that's also a way to avoid discussion), and you could exclude crazy and confused people who don't partake in any actual discourse.

I didn't say at all people should be open to my particular arguments, but to arguments in general.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Veedrac on Sunday July 12, 2015 @01:59PM (#9874285)
> I didn't say at all people should be open to my particular arguments, but to arguments in general.

If it's arguments in general,

* you can't hang up on salesmen,

* you can't kick 911 conspirators off your unrelated forum,

* you can't remove most trolls,

* you can't ban homeopathy threads from /r/science,

* etc.

In general, you lose the ability to moderate conversations in spaces you own, or decide what you spend your time doing. This is, to be honest, a pretty extreme idea if taken literally.

Or you could deem salesmen, 911 conspirators, trolls and homeopathy proponents as "crazy and confused", but who decides that? How is that any more unwanted than posting critical meta commentary to /r/fatpeoplehate?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by rndn on Sunday July 12, 2015 @03:21PM (#9874570)
You are confusing an implication for an equivalence. I've said that those who are not open to arguments should not have a voice. From that it doesn't follow that those who argue should always be listened to.

I imagine a concrete implementation of this idea as a meme that people themselves would recognize this as a good rule and that they would consider it as a decision aid whether or not to participate in a certain group.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Veedrac on Monday July 20, 2015 @06:21PM (#9919498)
You're effectively just juggling the same argument. If I'm to hang up on salesmen, then I'm not open to arguments. Thus you claim I should not have a voice.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by rndn on Thursday July 23, 2015 @02:04PM (#9937422)
Oh, you mean it that way. Anyway, I’ve already said that it should rather applied to large movements instead of interactions of individuals. The current ideal of free speech can’t possibly realized to its fullest extent either/anyway.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by spinlock on Monday July 13, 2015 @04:14PM (#9880737)
It's really not uncommon for hateful children to have thin skin.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dropit_sphere on Saturday July 11, 2015 @11:03AM (#9869989)
>It's meant to protect speech which the politically powerful find objectionable. It's not about protecting abuse, but protecting ideas.

The loophole, then, is to define ideas the politically powerful find objectionable as abuse.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Veedrac on Saturday July 11, 2015 @11:33PM (#9872492)
I think the point is that protecting abuse is a necessary but unwanted side-effect, not that it shouldn't be protected. This matters because it helps distinguish when such freedoms need to be applied (eg. in government, not my back yard) and how it should be applied.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Sideloader on Saturday July 11, 2015 @01:45PM (#9870772)
It's interesting to me how many reddit free speech defenders say stuff like "Free speech is meant to protect the most disgusting, heinous, pointless, hateful, ignorant, foolish speech."

While I agree that pointless, hateful etc. speech deserves protection one word I almost never see in the reddit free speech wars is *dissent. As in "free speech is meant to protect speech that opposes or challenges orthodox opinion and conventional wisdom."

It's almost like the most vocal part of reddit gets off on being offensive for its own sake and is more concerned about the right to call fat people names rather than defending free speech generally. It does seems like they are flying the free speech flag purely out of narrow self-interest.

How many of them actually give a crap about free speech outside of their "community"? How many of them regularly downvote opinions they don't agree with, I wonder?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Merovius on Saturday July 11, 2015 @07:48AM (#9869415)
> It is funny. Because it's the people who want silence others' free speech who repeat the "freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences" meme as justification for their horrible actions.

Ugh. "horrible actions" as a description for calling people out who threaten, belittle, insult and harass other people and claim that is "protected speech".

By the way, even in a context, where the term "freedom of speech" is really adequate (so, when talking laws and government actions, for example), freedom stops where you infringe the rights of others. That's the whole point of states: To balance the natural freedoms of one person with the rights of other people, thus providing stability. Which is why you can't steal, for example. That's a freedom that had to be balanced against the rights of other people.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by jarfil on Friday July 10, 2015 @09:24PM (#9868061)
Freedom of speech != freedom to force anyone to listen to you.

As long as you are free to create your own community where you can say whatever you want, there is no need for any other community to listen to you.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by nindalf on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:12PM (#9868187)
Nor was anyone forced to listen. I find the default subs pretty low quality, so I stopped subscribing to them years ago. So the only things I read about were the books, video games and programming languages I like. If you had a different experience, then I sympathise with you, but don't go reading a thread filled with utter crap and then claim that someone forced you to listen.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by mirimir on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:14PM (#9868198)
As I've said in another subthread, Reddit is not a single community, but rather numerous communities. All users are free to listen to what they like, and to not listen (or even block) what they don't like. It's rather like Usenet, with a Reddit account being equivalent to a news server account.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Natsu on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:29PM (#9868243)
As I understand it, the founding fathers cast it more as "freedom to listen" rather than freedom of speech.

And it's certainly understandable that Reddit has no wish to be associated with certain speech, but that comes with troubling implications as well. For example, do they not then appear to support whatever they do not ban if we know that whatever sufficiently offends them gets the ban hammer?

For another example, take Google removing Confederate flags. I personally hate that damned flag and would be perfectly happy to join others in burning one to express my feelings about it, but I'm loathe to go around removing them. Please understand that I'm perfectly happy if a few get taken down where they appear that some governmental branch was endorsing it.

But at the same time, that's not quite the same as when Google goes about removing them. Sure, they are free to do as they wish, I have to wonder why Google doesn't do the same for Nazi symbols? Surely they don't support Nazis, but it's hard to make a case for not giving the Nazis the same treatment. They're at least as evil, right? So what explanations are left to us for the disparity? That Nazis don't offend googlers as much? That doesn't seem like a likely reason, but just what's left?

And in the end, where does that leave us? The problem is, I don't think that train of thought has an end, and that's what makes me uneasy. After we remove everything offensive, what's left? It's not like we'll have things that don't offend anybody, so at some point it becomes a matter of choosing which people are okay to offend and which people are not okay to offend.

In the end, I just want to get along with everyone. I don't like the thought of living in a society where everything becomes a matter of whether you are one of Us or one of Them and that's where we appear to be heading.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by lmartel on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:46PM (#9868286)
Didn't Google just remove the confederate flag from Shopping Express and ads, not from search results?

They don't sell Nazi flags in their store or (afaik) let people advertise using them, so this doesn't seem as inconsistent to me as you make it sound.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Natsu on Friday July 10, 2015 @11:01PM (#9868328)
Yes, and Google is happy to sell you all manner of Nazi items:

https://www.google.com/search?q=nazi+swastica&ie=utf-8&oe=ut...

Not to mention copies of the Mein Kampf, etc.

Thankfully, the various non-Nazi uses of the swastika appear to be the most popular, but you can find plenty of Nazi items. I dislike the meaning of both symbols, so I have a hard time imagining any logic where it's okay to sell one of them but not the other.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by SixSigma on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:00AM (#9868848)
9front, a fork of plan9, includes Mein Kampf in the distribution as a kind of trolling canary.

We only burn the bad books, right?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by lmartel on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:26PM (#9876032)
Oh, then you're right, this is definitely less okay. I was under the impression that they just stopped delivering them from Walmart (or wherever) via Shopping Express, rather than special-casing the search results.

I guess the argument one could make is that the confederate flag is more dangerous and relevant today, but I don't really buy that.

Occam's razor suggests this is just an easy PR grab. They get a few headlines in mainstream tech press for free, and very minor backlash from "free speech nutjubs" as the only downside.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by tomjen3 on Saturday July 11, 2015 @07:49AM (#9869417)
They probably also sell the soviet flag, copies of Das Capital etc. Equally horrible but for the other side.

Also side note: reading Mein Kampf doesn't make you a nazi, indeed if more people had read it back in the day somebody might have stooped that little corporal.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by maxlybbert on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:44PM (#9868280)
Reddit is legally allowed to censor all they want. Some people, especially people younger than me, like a version of the world where somebody smoothes off the rough edges and hides unsightly things. I think it feels too much like Disneyland.

Reddit spent years building a freewheeling culture. Pao decided to impose standards on that, and her guiding principles weren't well articulated. In the end, it was a really bad copy of Disneyland, and the fact that the effort failed was no surprise.

I'm not sure the company really knows what happened, given that they think they've given their users what they asked for, but they're also telling their users that they're spoiled kids.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by jeo1234 on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:50AM (#9868951)
> Pao decided to impose standards on that, and her guiding principles weren't well articulated.

I think you nailed it there. I'm not a Reddit user, but from what I have read there never seemed to be clear set of guidelines that were evenly enforced by the Reddit staff.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Veedrac on Friday July 10, 2015 @09:11PM (#9868018)
If your version of free speech means allowing anything to be said anywhere, I don't want it. The principle of free speech I subscribe to is allowing anyone a place such that those who want to listen, can. In essence, to prevent one party silencing a communication between two other parties. Reddit need not be that place.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by geomark on Saturday July 11, 2015 @02:49AM (#9868825)
That's a good definition. But even that approach will fail when those with power define the "place such that those who want to listen, can" to be so small that nobody can find it. An example is the so-called free speech zones at some colleges that are small designated spots far from earshot of the entire campus population.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by ketralnis on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:45AM (#9868944)
> that approach will fail when those with power define the "place such that those who want to listen, can" to be so small that nobody can find it

Okay. But reddit isn't "those with power". reddit isn't making it illegal to do it elsewhere.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by geomark on Saturday July 11, 2015 @07:25AM (#9869367)
Agree. I was speaking more in general rather than specifically about reddit.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by crdoconnor on Saturday July 11, 2015 @04:27AM (#9869040)
>Reddit need not be that place.

Nope, but then again, being that place is what made it grow so large in the first place.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dmfdmf on Friday July 10, 2015 @09:19PM (#9868044)
Can you elaborate? Its not clear to me where we disagree, if at all.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by lewisl9029 on Saturday July 11, 2015 @09:30AM (#9869688)
Sure, but people should also be free to refuse to listen to things they find distasteful, and to refuse access to people who post things they find distasteful on platforms they operate.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday July 11, 2015 @12:13PM (#9870311)
>...and to refuse access to people who post things they find distasteful on platforms they operate.

I tend to agree with what I think you're saying but I wonder if you realize what a controversial opinion that can be to some people. Consider the reaction to Rand Paul's criticism of the Civil Rights Act. Should one be able to operate a restaurant/business/country club that won't serve [blacks, LGBT, Muslims, whites, hispanics, cops, etc]?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by JakeAl on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:10AM (#9868870)
The obvious solution to the problem that I don't see on any of these message board sites is simply to allow users to have their own personal blacklists for blocking/filtering users whose comments they don't want to see. Personal differences aside the paid troll farms boosting the noise has really gotten unbearable on the interwebs.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by tsotha on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:08PM (#9871131)
That was one thing Digg had that I missed when I moved to reddit. I suspect it's a pretty resource-intensive function compared to what exists today, though.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by intopieces on Saturday July 11, 2015 @06:28AM (#9869267)
But as the comment you're replying to said:

>Reddit is a private company and so is not obliged to provide a platform for anyone's free speech, that also is a facet of freedom.

We must be careful not to confuse commercial viability with government censorship. At some point, advertisers will leave a website that continues to foster vitriol/hate speech/illegal content because they do not want their brand associated with it. This is freedom of speech in action.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by raz32dust on Saturday July 11, 2015 @09:43AM (#9869731)
This is very idealistic, though. A society works on give and take. Courtesy keeps the society stable. There ought to be some negative consequences for billowing hatred.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by ketralnis on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:44AM (#9868941)
> I'd rather have appalling speech than censored speech

If we were talking about what's legal to publish in your own newspaper, I agree.

If we're talking about what's appropriate to force others to view by brigading with a small number of people to take over a website to use it as its own platform to harass its CEO, I disagree.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Eupolemos on Saturday July 11, 2015 @04:10AM (#9868994)
I absolutely agree with you. Free Speech is not a thing on private boards or sites on the internet. Moderation is a good thing if you want a healthy online environment and conversation.

That said, I think the moderation Pao symbolised on Reddit as a whole was a very wrong move. The Community certainly did. All the subreddits are individually moderated and the subreddits are opt-in; there's very little need for an overarching moderation of Reddit major.

Combine this with the rules for moderation being so vague everyone was asking what they actually were, and the reason given was "safety". Safety?

To me, "Safety" is a red-cloth term. It smells of the agenda used to rule the masses by fear and security, and to me Reddit is the exact opposite. But in reality, it was probably just an honest answer to Reddit's Community and investors both, that they wanted Reddit to be a safe product.

Well, nobody joined Reddit because it was "safe". It's the wild west of the interwebs, subreddits progressively darker as you find more weird stuff and you have to tell yourself "no - I don't need that" (who hasn't ventured to r/aww - darkness comes in many shades).

tl;dr Reddit is set up as a wild west with moderated towns, it is counter-productive to clamp down on everything with "safety" as the rallying cry.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Laforet on Saturday July 11, 2015 @09:07AM (#9869623)
>That said, I think the moderation Pao symbolised on Reddit as a whole was a very wrong move. The Community certainly did. All the subreddits are individually moderated and the subreddits are opt-in; there's very little need for an overarching moderation of Reddit major.

They stepped in because moderators of a banned sub was found to encourage and even directly participate in harassment of other people. And they only caved in after a. incessant complaints from the public and b. some personal threats against imgur employees who took down some images the abusers uploaded.

More info: https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/39bzdf/why_wa...

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by thelamest on Saturday July 11, 2015 @05:49AM (#9869204)
> the agenda used to rule the masses by fear and security > the wild west of the interwebs > clamp down on everything

This is, joking or not, way out of proportion to what happened, which is, a single harassment-focused group was disbanded.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by sangnoir on Saturday July 11, 2015 @08:44AM (#9869550)
> which is, a single harassment-focused group was disbanded.

That wasn't the only event that transpired. I'd venture to say things got really intense after Victoria was let go and sub-reddits accounting for 33% of visits were shut down in protest of how the affair was handled (poor communication, no transition planning). I think the disconnect between the mods and Reddit's leadership is what got Pao fired; not the shutting down of FPH.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by nathanvanfleet on Saturday July 11, 2015 @09:30AM (#9869690)
Free speech is between you and the government. If a company that runs a forum says it bans people for abusive comments there's nothing to do with free speech. We see with Reddit that the ugliest users are the ones that are the loudest and drown out everyone else.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by wingless on Saturday July 11, 2015 @11:54AM (#9870208)
>Free speech is between you and the government.

No. Free speech is a principle that any party can choose to respect. Free speech has been one of the very core values of Reddit right from the beginning, in the form of the ability to create and manage a subreddit with very minimal restrictions.

Being a platform of free speech was the single biggest reason Reddit grew to be the giant community that it is today.

Then Pao comes along and repeatedly shows that she doesn't respect free speech at all. What do you expect the users to do, other than revolt?

It's easy to brush off these incidents as the doings of "the ugliest users", but remember that beauty is in the eye of the beholder. History books are filled with people being silenced due to their expression of uncomfortable ideas.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by om2 on Saturday July 11, 2015 @04:59PM (#9871544)
I see this glib line often (that free speech is only about the government), but I don't think it's right. It's true that the First Amendment specifically requires the US government to respect free speech. But that doesn't mean the general principle applies only to the government.

For example, John Stuart Mill's utilitarian defense of free speech in On Liberty is equally applicable to private parties and specifically says society and individual people should be open to expression of views they find abhorrent. He specifically covers widespread social ostracism as well as government laws. According to Mill, free speech is definitely not just about freedom from government restrictions.

I doubt you understand the principles of free speech better than John Stuart Mill. Or if you understand his argument in On Liberty and disagree, please explain why.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by keedot on Saturday July 11, 2015 @09:46AM (#9869741)
You're correct, it's an ignorant argument, and I see it posted all over the place. I wish America had a better education system, because it drowns out the real conversations that should be happening around free speech.

You have the right to say whatever you want, you do not have the right to say it in my home. I'm curious as to whether or not these individuals understand this, or are just another level of troll trying to stir the pot.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by PavlovsCat on Saturday July 11, 2015 @11:01AM (#9869982)
> you do not have the right to say it in my home.

Furthermore, I do have the right to say it "in public".

But, where is that "public" on the internet? I can make a website - a home - and invite other people to come visit me and listen to me ramble, or respond etc. But there is no public space, is there? And if not, should there be?

Most people don't own the homes they live in. Yet the landlord still doesn't get to tell them what to talk about over the dinner table. That's great, but imagine the government sold all sidewalks and public places to private interests, which dictated how you should dress and walk if you want to get out of your home, or to work. Should that be allowed?

Imagine getting thrown out of a mall because someone overheard and disapproved of your conversation there. Does that ever happen? I know there there is no clear line, but that there is one; e.g. if you trail other people and talk to yourself or a friend about them (especially if it's nasty and aggressive) in earshot, that's not exactly cool. But what, other than sanity, would stop all mall owners to agree that anyone e.g. declaring to like the color green should be kicked out, and to hire staff to enforce it? Would that be legal? If it was, should it be? And if it wouldn't be legal, why is that? In what ways, if at all, could or should this applied to the internet?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by keedot on Sunday July 12, 2015 @12:15AM (#9872562)
There are indeed public spaces on the internet, many governments and government bodies have sites that are public where you can file a petition or voice a concern.

Most people (63%) own their homes in America, and there are protections in place for people who rent. Your landlord cannot monitor you.

When it comes to the mall though, it's more a matter of scope and scale. Overhearing something in a mall affects a handful of individuals and the intent was not to broadcast. If you stand up on a table in the cafeteria and start spouting hate speech, you can and will be escorted out by security.

The internet is different, because you cannot accidentally overhear a conversation. Said anywhere on the internet, especial a place like reddit of HN, it is viewable by the entirety of internet users. So direct comparisons to the physical world will always fall short.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by smsm42 on Sunday July 12, 2015 @03:45AM (#9872842)
If you're looking for fair discussion about free speech, the US education establishment is the last place you want to look. They are completely overrun by PC moral panic, and not only real dissent and vigorous discussion representing diverse points is not welcomed, be it about free speech or any other topic, even mild critique from the friendly side or discomfort with exposure to unsettling thoughts is intolerable. E.g. see: http://www.vox.com/2015/6/3/8706323/college-professor-afraid
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by DanBC on Saturday July 11, 2015 @10:29AM (#9869878)
...and Reddit isn't even banning vile human beings - there are a bunch of subs for hating fat people and other worse subs.

Reddit is only banning subs that brigade.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by KVFinn on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:44PM (#9867950)
>As an occasional user of reddit, this whole ordeal has confirmed the reason why I prefer not to hang out in its forums.

It's really been awful and hard to avoid. I saw more racism on reddit in a couple few weeks (while the police shootings were in the news) than I've seen in the rest of my life combined. That and the increasingly popular /fatpeoplehate and I was pretty close to never visiting even the small well-moderated subs, the leakage was too strong.

And this recent thing, where there have been days where 5 of the top 10 highest voted stories across the entire site were literally titled: "Ellen Pao is a cunt"

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by aneil on Friday July 10, 2015 @09:47PM (#9868139)
I'm a pretty regular user, but have unsubscribed from a number of the default subreddits. Still, there is often a feeding frenzy mentality that takes over there. The racism during Ferguson was appalling. I saw a Pao subthread where people were discussing how sexually unappealing she is. It degenerated from there. Pretty awful stuff.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by bsder on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:18PM (#9868208)
> I saw more racism on reddit in a couple few weeks (while the police shootings were in the news) than I've seen in the rest of my life combined.

Welcome to reality outside the Silicon Valley distortion bubble--Reddit's userbase is not confined to the Mandarins of technology.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by pauleastlund on Saturday July 11, 2015 @04:18AM (#9869015)
Silicon Valley might not be representative of the nation or the world, but (thankfully!) anonymous internet forums aren't, either.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by philwelch on Saturday July 11, 2015 @05:03PM (#9871562)
If they were, we'd be in the final years of the Ron Paul administration.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by BorisMelnik on Saturday July 11, 2015 @12:41AM (#9868552)
one of the craziest things about all the racism is that much of it is trolling from non-racist or not normally racist people looking to get a rise out of people. I see the same thing on YouTube and Reddit all of these troll parody accounts created by ant-social 20-somethings in an attempt to get a reaction or "shock" people.

Reddit can be a great place. Subs like /r/webdev and many, many others are very informative and a great way to meet people. I don't think I've ever seen any kind of racism / hate on the subs I frequent because none of them are main line.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by agildehaus on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:47PM (#9868293)
I doubt your last sentence, as I regularly use Reddit and never saw anything like the story you mention. Certainly there were bad comments in more sanely named threads, but no highly upvoted threads with that title like you mention here.

Mind linking it?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by etherealG on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:32AM (#9868922)
Can I suggest not browsing all
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by DennisP on Friday July 10, 2015 @05:42PM (#9866927)
It depends on the subreddits. With my subscriptions I barely noticed the whole thing.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by geofft on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:49PM (#9867425)
As I mentioned last time this was on HN, me three.

I think there's an interesting cultural weirdness about Reddit here. Part of the problem with brigading is that if you link to another post in another subreddit, you're already logged in and have exactly as much power to upvote and downvote and comment as you did on the subreddit where you came from. There's the entire "no participation" community-by-obscurity trick, where subreddit CSS hides voting links if the hostname is np.reddit.com (this is supposed to be used for translations into the hypothetical "NP" ISO-631 language), but the fact that it's a CSS trick points to underlying discontent.

On the other hand, Reddit is a great platform for small communities precisely because you're already logged in. I've never created a Lambda the Ultimate account and only think about it maybe once every six months, but I'm subbed to /r/types, so anything that flies by gets onto my Reddit home page.

I'm not sure how to reconcile these two problems. A client-side aggregator would solve the issue of visiting each independent site, but the shared login mechanism is also crucial, and is both a blessing and a curse.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by danielweber on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:14PM (#9867839)
There are many technical solutions here.

First is realizing that there are technical solutions. Some people say "you don't want technical solutions to social problems" but the fact that subreddits have no protection against brigading at all is a serious design flaw with reddit[1].

Second is some way to require subscription for some period of time for votes to appear or to count. The CSS-hack stuff was silly, and as someone who has been on reddit since its first year, I have never seen the CSS-side of reddit because I never turned it on.

One of the big complaints from the blackout was the complete lack of tool support and this is an example. Reddit tried to paper over the technical shortcoming with rules and social hacks but once different reddit communities who didn't like each other realized there was a way to attack each other they did so.

[1] to be fair I wouldn't have realized it either if I was in charge of the subreddit design

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by ljk on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:00PM (#9867096)
Only sub'd in smaller subreddits; didn't know everything was happening until I saw it on hn
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by comrh on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:56PM (#9868314)
The problem is some of the worst parts of reddit love to leak into the innocent, fun sections. My first experience with /r/fatpeoplehate was because one of the trolls started harassing a poster in /r/adventuretime who just wanted to show off an awesome hat she made.

It was disgusting and made me take a break from reddit immediately.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by colinbartlett on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:39PM (#9867358)
I've been a heavy reddit user for 8 years and I did not know about this until I read about it in the New York Times. It's really a small subset of the reddits that were touched by the entire ordeal.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by city41 on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:59PM (#9867478)
It completely and totally dominated /r/all for days, even weeks. /r/all is an aggregate of the most popular posts for the entire site, so I disagree only a small subset were affected. Maybe in number of subreddits, but the subreddits that were affected are absolutely gigantic.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by geofft on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:33PM (#9868255)
I'm not subscribed to any of the default subreddits; I imagine very many long-time users are the same way. I never read /r/all precisely because it's an aggregate of posts on subreddits I don't care about.

In particular, I'm subscribed to no general-purpose or wide-purpose subreddits. A few city/geographic subreddits mentioned it in passing, but, like, /r/programming or /r/nycbike or /r/radicalchristianity are going to treat any post about it as off-topic. You can't just post an advice animal about it, or request IAmAs from everyone involved, or say that today you learned whatever-it-may-be about Ellen Pao, or what have you. Nor can you do this about any other topic, which is why I bother to read these subreddits.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by wvenable on Saturday July 11, 2015 @01:42AM (#9868686)
I browse /r/all occasionally to get out of the bubble of the subs I'm subscribed to. And sometimes there is a popular post in an obscure subreddit that I've never heard of before and get that gets me to subscribe.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by bluecalm on Saturday July 11, 2015 @06:34AM (#9869280)
They could add something like sub-reddit tags: NSFW, offensive, video games, sports, technical etc.

Then on r/all NSW/offensive are disabled by default (the same way NSFW is rigth now - you need to change your account settings).

Problem solved, FPH will never make it to people who don't want to see offensive staff.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by geofft on Saturday July 11, 2015 @01:08PM (#9870577)
I think you're misunderstanding what the commenters in this subthread are saying. It's not simply that I don't want to see FPH. I also don't want to see advice animals, documentaries, creepypasta, or jokes. I have nothing against these as forms of content, it's just not what I visit Reddit for.

And even among technology, I have no interest in seeing things about Ruby or Go. Again, it's not that I dislike the languages, it's that they're not professionally relevant to me at the moment so it's not what I visit Reddit for.

So what we need is some way for subreddits to be tagged with their own content: /r/rust about Rust, /r/python about Python, /r/sandersforpresident about Bernie, etc., and some /r/all equivalent that just matches what I'm interested in -- which is exactly what https://reddit.com is for me, right now. I don't need /r/all to be fixed; I have no interest in even seeing "all technology" or "all religion" or "all presidential candidates".

FPH being or not being on /r/all is irrelevant.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by danielweber on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:15PM (#9867843)
Most people are completely unaware of /r/all
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by danieldk on Saturday July 11, 2015 @04:22AM (#9869028)
Isn't that what you get when going to the site while not being logged in?

(I echo the comments that say that Reddit has great subreddits like /r/Haskell and it's easy to mis all of this when you are just subscribed to a few subreddits.)

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by tomjen3 on Saturday July 11, 2015 @08:00AM (#9869439)
No, you get a restricted set of /all with posts from some subreddits: https://www.reddit.com/r/defaults/comments/2ycn0x/list_of_de... is the current list.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by colinbartlett on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:19PM (#9868213)
Certainly not unaware just definitely not interested.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Nemcue on Saturday July 11, 2015 @10:15AM (#9869834)
You say this with certainty? Do you know this to be true?

Because I seriously doubt it.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by sbilstein on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:23PM (#9867279)
Honestly I'm so disappointed that Reddit's management allowed such a crappy culture to evolve in their forums for so long. I remember signing on in 2010 and just feeling really uncomfortable browsing any of the major subreddits. Why did it take so long to deal with characters like violentacrez?
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by nostrademons on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:40PM (#9867363)
The Reddit founders had very strong ideas about censorship and freedom of speech, and so as a matter of principle, they refused to censor subreddits unless the latter were breaking the law. As far as growth goes, this was probably the right choice, as a lot of Reddit's userbase came from previously marginalized groups who now had a forum for their interests on the Internet.

Note that Hacker News made the opposite choice: it has a variety of mechanisms (slow-banning, hell-banning, quarantine, explicit moderation) that makes it very clear to certain users that they are not welcome here. And it gets shit for it too: if you browse the New page with showdead turned on, you'll see pretty frequent posts from people who are hellbanned complaining about the fascist moderators of this site.

Ultimately, the problem is that for any given slice of humanity, there are significant other slices of humanity that the former find repugnant. And usually vice versa. As a community grows bigger, there's no way to avoid running into the bad apples. I actually think the subreddit system is about as good as it can currently get for a public, open forum.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by nopenopeyep on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:05PM (#9867794)
a variety of mechanisms (slow-banning, hell-banning, quarantine, explicit moderation) that makes it very clear to certain users that they are not welcome here.

Are you kidding? None of those make it the least bit clear to the users. HN is the most passive-aggressively moderated site I've ever seen. Also, hell-banning non-spammers is about the most cruel thing you can do. By extension of holding Pao responsible for all actions taken under her charge, I declare PG to be sociopathic, if not outright evil.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by ThomPete on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:17PM (#9868204)
But the moderation is part of what keeps it a fairly enjoyable experience still IMO.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by nopenopeyep on Saturday July 11, 2015 @12:15AM (#9868496)
That's irrelevant to my comment. However, I don't think you have any evidence to support your assumption.

As I expected: downvoted for pointing out the truth. HN is terrible.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by DanBC on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:28AM (#9868909)
> By extension of holding Pao responsible for all actions taken under her charge, I declare PG to be sociopathic, if not outright evil.

You don't think the downvotes are for this hyperbolic insult?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dvanduzer on Saturday July 11, 2015 @06:25AM (#9869263)
As a long time enthusiast of HN, and not a total shithead based on karma, I don't think there was anything hyperbolic in the original comment.

What is even slightly out of sorts about comparing Ellen Pao to Paul Graham?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by DanBC on Saturday July 11, 2015 @08:44AM (#9869547)
You don't think calling PG sociopathic or downright evil is hyperbolic?
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dvanduzer on Saturday July 11, 2015 @02:01PM (#9870861)
That wasn't what was said, though. It wasn't particularly coherent, but it was a comparison between two prominent figures in two prominent online forums.

I don't think it's hyperbolic to say that both sites have an element of sociopathic and downright evil people influencing the culture. And reasonable people can still disagree about the level of accountability for the actions and inactions of Pao and Graham.

There are plenty of details that don't line up well when making that comparison, but I read the comment as intending to illustrate all the hyperbole around Ellen Pao. There are a lot of people on the Internet talking past each other this week.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by remarkEon on Saturday July 11, 2015 @01:10AM (#9868612)
Haven't been around here long, but this place seems to me to be much better than reddit for what I'm looking for. To each his/her own, I guess, but so much of reddit was such utter and total shit for so long that the enjoyment evaporated.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by ThomPete on Saturday July 11, 2015 @01:36AM (#9868674)
How can I have evidence for an opinion other than expressing it?
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Zuider on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:48PM (#9867416)
>Why did it take so long to deal with characters like violentacrez?

He wasn't dealt with. He deleted his account in a frantic and futile attempt to avoid exposure.

Violentacres/Violentacrez (had to block him twice) set himself up as king of the reddit underworld. The admins cast a blind eye to his antics, and in return he prevented the raw sewage from gushing onto the clean streets of the reddit front page.

He was a troll from the start, and deliberately so, even in his choice of username which he had stolen from a popular blogger at the time. This illustrates the kind of brinkmanship that was his trademark - it is not quite impersonation to steal someone else's anonymous handle, but it is not quite ethical either.

His one good point was that he kept the other reddit trolls busy via interminable (literally) troll-fights.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by nailer on Saturday July 11, 2015 @05:17AM (#9869152)
> He wasn't dealt with. He deleted his account in a frantic and futile attempt to avoid exposure.

Doxxing is doxxing. It doesn't become 'exposure' when people you like do it.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Zuider on Saturday July 11, 2015 @06:57AM (#9869314)
>Doxxing is doxxing.

I meant that the reddit admins didn't 'deal with' Violentacrez. Chen doxxed him, destroying his career, despite the full knowledge that Violentacrez had innocent dependants who would also be hurt badly. If Violentacrez deserved to be 'punished', then whatever punishment was meted out should have fallen exclusively on him.

>It doesn't become 'exposure'.

Bad choice of words. I intended the term in a literal sense, not a judgemental one. It was revolting how Chen made Violentacrez crawl in the false hope he could salvage some part of his livelihood.

>...when people you like do it.

I dislike the people who doxxed Violentacrez very much. I disagree with the use of doxxing as a tactic.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by vehementi on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:42PM (#9867943)
Wait, who is right, you or danielweber above?
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Excavator on Friday July 10, 2015 @09:48PM (#9868144)
In so far as I can remember he had good relations with many on the staff and even ended up with a special icon next to his username.

The /r/SubredditDrama posts in regards to the incident are correct as I remember it:

Part I - violentacrez: https://archive.is/7ygdr

Part II - CreepShots: https://archive.is/8AVd8

Part 2 above ends with a link to VAs alleged last comments with an alt:

http://i.imgur.com/E8fCA.png

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by jsmthrowaway on Saturday July 11, 2015 @06:10AM (#9869243)
The special icon was subreddit CSS added most likely by himself. Give me five minutes and a subreddit and I'll make your username 72px. The admins didn't bless him with a flag at any time.

It's a common meme that violentacrez was "special," had some kind of sway with the admins beyond any other moderator, received instruction from the admins that was unique and not the usual ban threats that many subs get in modmail, and so on. Most people who say these things heard it from someone else, because the actual story is that he was barely tolerated. He even says so himself in your linked thread.

I don't get the elevation of violentacrez to something special. I see it a lot (friendly with the admins! The admins asked him to help with creepshots! it's all over this thread) and I don't get it. He was a power mod. So are hundreds of others. There are a bunch of Reddit yarns that put the Kubrick lunar landing to shame; some of them are making an appearance in this thread.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by remarkEon on Saturday July 11, 2015 @01:27AM (#9868643)
Wow, guess I somehow missed this dramafest.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by danielweber on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:17PM (#9867849)
> Why did it take so long to deal with characters like violentacrez?

The admins asked violentacrez to help with the /r/creepshots. Later history got rewritten to say that he had created it, maybe to throw him under the bus.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by golergka on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:42PM (#9867382)
> feeling really uncomfortable browsing any of the major subreddits

Genuinely curious: why?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by sbilstein on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:58PM (#9867467)
Hard to explain objectively; I think the things that turned me off to reddit back then (now it's more mainstream) were people's willingness to assume tons of knowledge of topics they didn't really know about, the general white, upper middle class male from the burbs tastes of things like r/music and other cultural subreddits. It felt like walking into a videogame fraternity and realizing I didn't belong there.

That's a highly subjective opinion...but it's how I felt. r/shitredditsays probably captures a bit of what made me uncomfortable.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by golergka on Friday July 10, 2015 @07:03PM (#9867501)
There's certainly a white fraternity feel in a lot of reddits, so I can imagine how people can feel disconnect to it. But /r/shitredditsays, well... I was subscribed to it for some time, and the posts themselves do a good job at noticing really bad behaviour on reddit sometimes — but then I discovered the comments there, and I must say, it feels like half of the users of this sub are trolls who pretend to be THE worst strawmen feminists/SJW (I hate this term, but since we're talking about strawmen, I think it fits) ever. Just saying.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by morbius on Friday July 10, 2015 @09:48PM (#9868141)
The SRS sidebar makes it pretty clear that the whole SJW façade is exactly that: a façade. They obviously have legitimate complaints but hyperbolise everything to poke fun at it.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Jimmy on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:15PM (#9868201)
They don't accept the "it's just a joke" excuse from their targets, why should we accept it from them?
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by asddubs on Saturday July 11, 2015 @08:35AM (#9869525)
the idea is to expose people to a "taste of their own medicine", for what that's worth.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by vehementi on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:25PM (#9868230)
> targets

> we

> them

Gah.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by morbius on Friday July 10, 2015 @11:58PM (#9868470)
Because there's no object to their jokes. It's just exaggerated humor not at the expense of anyone.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Nemcue on Saturday July 11, 2015 @10:17AM (#9869838)
Except it is at the expense of people, so that's not true at all.

SRS are notorious for brigading and messing with peoples lives.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by golergka on Saturday July 11, 2015 @05:48AM (#9869201)
That doesn't make it any better.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by ryanlol on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:43PM (#9867393)
Why should the reddit administration interfere with communities ran by third parties?

IRC networks are still running just fine with minimal intervention.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by chinpokomon on Friday July 10, 2015 @09:23PM (#9868059)
Or for that matter newsgroups. I guess since newsgroups are subscribed by the carrier, IRC might still be the better example.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by zardeh on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:12PM (#9868189)
there is no /r/all for irc or newsgroups.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by thelamest on Saturday July 11, 2015 @05:45AM (#9869193)
On IRC plenty of people who cry about getting a ban or K-line are ridiculed and told to go elsewhere. There is drama there as well, but it's a smaller and less exposed thing.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by ryanlol on Wednesday July 15, 2015 @04:45PM (#9893971)
IRC is mostly drama, but for whatever reason nobody thinks it's a big deal. (Compared to reddit.)
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by multinglets on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:13PM (#9868194)
> really uncomfortable

I know what you mean. I logged into /r/funny one day and someone had used the "b" word. I was just really concerned and uncomfortable with how things were going. What did you end up doing?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by jodah on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:40PM (#9867370)
> the vitriol which I kept seeing peripherally... was absolutely appalling.

I'm not a Reddit user, but the vitriol seemed pretty commensurate with what motivated it, which among other things included the despicable (and possibly illegal) firing of an employee for having leukemia (more or less).

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by KVFinn on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:20AM (#9868887)
>I'm not a Reddit user, but the vitriol seemed pretty commensurate with what motivated it, which among other things included the despicable (and possibly illegal) firing of an employee for having leukemia (more or less).

That employee got cancer in 2012. He got a salary for almost two years while too sick to work, of the total three years he was at the company. Four months of that salary undo Pao. Then he got an additional full year of health coverage when they finally couldn't wait any longer to fill his position. He was never well enough to even move to the Reddit officers, which was the plan when they hired him in 2012.

That's not just not despicable, it's laudable, and it's better than how you'd be treated at 99% of companies in the US. And somehow this became twisted by the furious mob into a story about a vicious CEO firing someone for having cancer?

(Legally in the US you are guaranteed three months of unpaid leave for getting sick. Although ironically in this case this employee didn't even qualify for that since he got sick before he was at the company for 12 months.)

That this became the battle-flag for everyone to pitchfork is appalling. Seriously appalling.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by jodah on Saturday July 11, 2015 @12:30PM (#9870391)
A few things:

> somehow this became twisted by the furious mob

There's no mob here. If anything, most people seem unfamiliar with this episode.

> Legally in the US you are guaranteed three months of unpaid leave for getting sick

Except where one qualifies for protection under the ADA [1].

> That's not just not despicable, it's laudable

There are two things here. That Reddit maintained the employee for nearly two years, as you say, is clearly laudable, though this decision predated Pao. My overall view of the situation, and likely this goes for others, is in how it was ultimately handled, where Pao said one thing to the employee then did another, more than once. I can see a situation where this could have been handled openly and candidly, with humanity, but that's not what happened.

Maybe in the end he would have relapsed again, and maybe his doctor would have determined that he was too sick to perform his duties, and maybe firing him for that actually would have been legal (without knowing his ADA status we can't know), but that's quite a few 'ifs'. Not knowing what would have happened, Pao could have addressed the uncertainly in an honest way, but instead she chose to lie to and then fire the employee. I'm not a one man mob, and I respect your difference of opinion, but that to me is despicable.

[1] http://www.cancer.org/treatment/findingandpayingfortreatment...

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by KVFinn on Saturday July 11, 2015 @01:50PM (#9870806)
>There's no mob here. If anything, most people seem unfamiliar with this episode.

Top post on multiple reddits, various random threads upvoted to /all, brought up in this thread by multiple people as a reason the CEO was despicable.

>There are two things here. That Reddit maintained the employee for nearly two years, as you say, is clearly laudable, though this decision predated Pao.

While she was CEO he got 4 months of the almost two years of paid time while he was unable to work. Also under he he got an extra year of medical insurance.

>Maybe in the end he would have relapsed again, and maybe his doctor would have determined that he was too sick to perform his duties, and maybe firing him for that actually would have been legal (without knowing his ADA status we can't know), but that's quite a few 'ifs'.

He was supposed to move to the office in 2012. He was never well enough to do so. At the time he was finally let go, he still didn't have a move scheduled. He was still 2 to 3 months away from being able to to start the job. Note his woolly timelines, especially in his followup comments, where 5 months later he was still not ready for full time work.

Changed your mind is not lying, "Sorry, we actually need to someone to start this job immediately, we can't keep waiting."

All this is giving him the most charitable reading of his posts, a post he made at the height of rage at the CEO filled with obvious dog meat like: "Does anyone know of any Reddit alternatives?" "I don't know anything about why Victoria was fired, but he's some speculation as to why she was fired." Etc.

So yeah, I find it despicable that people find this despicable, that comments all across the internet are calling her 'human garbage' and whatnot for treating an employee better than 99% of other companies would have. It's absurd. The story should have been, "Wow, reddit treats employees amazingly!"

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by otterley on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:43PM (#9867392)
Do you have a primary source for this information?
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by jodah on Friday July 10, 2015 @07:12PM (#9867552)
Not sure what the downvoting is all about - let's hope you never get cancer. The source is the employee himself who did an AMA that was partially censored by Reddit:

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/3c0idl/i_am_dacvak_fo...

It was on HN a while back.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by SloopJon on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:01PM (#9868171)
> The source is the employee himself who did an AMA that was partially censored by Reddit

It looks like Dacvak deleted his own posts: "Edit: I've removed this post. All future discussions regarding this subject will be between me and reddit."

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by jodah on Saturday July 11, 2015 @12:46AM (#9868560)
I think he just deleted that one post. The rest were deleted by Reddit, as was the entire conversation for a while, before being restored.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by LordHumungous on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:46PM (#9867956)
Hanging out on Reddit has made me understand and appreciate Linus Torvald's style of community management.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by InclinedPlane on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:54PM (#9867446)
This is the best description of reddit I've found so far: https://twitter.com/waxpancake/status/619625808403894272
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by eli on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:24PM (#9867872)
As an aside, I think it's notable how Metafilter has maintained a high-quality link aggregation/discussion forum over many years through the use of community norms and relatively aggressive moderation.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by glass- on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:37AM (#9868929)
That analogy doesn't account for what happens when a submission gets posted to both a "pinot" subreddit and a "sewage" subreddit, and subscribers in the sewage subreddit see the post in the pinot subreddit from the other discussions tab and "invade" the other subreddit.

Subreddits and their communities are not neatly contained in clearly labelled bottles.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by kbatten on Saturday July 11, 2015 @08:22AM (#9869487)
If you are only an occasional user why are you even commenting? I'm only picking on you because you are an easy target, but I have seen a number of HN posts from people who first state that they barely use reddit, then go on to blast all reddit users as vitriol spitting losers. What do you gain from getting on this bandwagon?
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by sidcool on Saturday July 11, 2015 @12:59AM (#9868590)
People behind internet coffers are quite nasty, even cruel at times. I guess that's what human nature is. Power corrupts anyone and everyone.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by lewisl9029 on Saturday July 11, 2015 @07:27AM (#9869373)
Agreed.

Some of the things I see people say on the internet makes me wonder what kind of social lives those people can possibly lead while being so hopelessly devoid of any empathy.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dorfsmay on Saturday July 11, 2015 @10:25AM (#9869862)
If you follows only subreddits focussed on interrests you have, reddit is a good source of information, not unlike Usenet 20 years ago.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dimino on Friday July 10, 2015 @05:57PM (#9867059)
I came this close to not even knowing about this, until someone posted something in /r/dataisbeautiful about Ellen Pao's comment karma over time.

Just like Facebook, it's almost entirely related to what you subscribe to/follow. /r/chess was entirely mum on the situation, for example.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Nadya on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:02PM (#9867114)
This? https://i.imgur.com/nrYiK5M.png

I find it telling it was negative a majority of the time. Usually "mods" get +1'd just for being mods (common on many forums). It shows, to me at least, that what she said rarely was supported by the community.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by benaiah on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:25PM (#9867876)
Note that this is a chart of per-comment karma, not a trend of her total karma. Thus explaining the sheer cliff between a largely-downvoted comment and a largely-upvoted one.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dimino on Friday July 10, 2015 @07:21PM (#9867595)
I completely and utterly disagree with this opinion, and furthermore find it dangerous for what it suggests - specifically, the idea that a large group of anonymous people can do anything but fall prey to their collective impulse.

I would argue that decisions of large bodies of anonymous people are historically and demonstrably inaccurate, misleading, nearsighted, and wholly terrible for not only the decision they're making, but also the good of the body itself.

Groups of people, at a sufficient capacity, are simply some of the worst, most base, and utterly abhorrent things to exist on this planet, and claiming that the disapproval displayed by the group calling itself "Reddit" is "telling" would be, to say the least, a misstep.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Nadya on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:03PM (#9867780)
I'm confused how having a negative karma on Reddit is not a sign that people on Reddit find you disagreeable. It's a metric designed to showcase one's agreeability or disagreeability. If more people agree with you than disagree with you: karma will largely reflect that. If it's consistently negative, people consistently disagree with you.

Having a trend over time allows for a better judgement as karma is a metric that can change drastically over time. A generally disagreeable person can have a huge spike in positive karma but that doesn't mean they're liked overall. So it helps that the chart shows as far back as 2013.

A slow overall increase with several downward trends means you're generally agreeable but have a controversial opinion (opposed to the "collective group mentality"). A slow overall decrease with an upward trend now and then means you're generally disagreeable and occasionally say something the community agrees with.

Her karma over time tells me that she's generally disagreeable with a few moments that brought her from "negative" to "neutral" and that before the subreddit bans her popularity was spiraling downwards, hit a full catalyst, and the apology was rather well received.

If her karma was overall positive and only trended negatively in light of the subreddit ban and the Victoria mishap - it'd be telling of a very different story. The fact that it's been consistently negative is telling of the larger picture.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by magicalist on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:08PM (#9867809)
> I'm confused how having a negative karma on Reddit is not a sign that people on Reddit find you disagreeable

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sampling_bias

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dimino on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:07PM (#9871127)
There are reasons other than "I disagree with your specific comment" that a person might be downvoted.

And do you know something about Victoria's firing that everyone else doesn't? Do you know why she was fired?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Nadya on Sunday July 12, 2015 @06:47PM (#9875327)
>There are reasons other than "I disagree with your specific comment" that a person might be downvoted.

Including, but not limited to, "I hate this person so will downvote everything and anything they say."

Which makes you a disagreeable person if enough people hate you enough to downvote anything you say.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dimino on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:05PM (#9878962)
No, it quite simply does not.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by seanflyon on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:27PM (#9867886)
Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all the others. We have decided that no one is more trustworthy to pick our leaders than large bodies of anonymous people.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Zuider on Saturday July 11, 2015 @09:42AM (#9869730)
Democracy works not because it provides a means of putting people into power, but because it provides a bloodless means of removing them.

In the past, factions went to war in order to take absolute power. When they achieved it they would destroy all rivals and enforce strict conformity. They would try to avoid the necessity of constant fighting to hold on to their position by employing various means to cement their legitimacy in the minds of the ruled. One of these was the idea of an aristocracy which had an inherent right to rule. Another was harnessing religion to declare that the rulers held power by divine right, making rebellion a sin. Regime change would only come about through violence.

In a democracy the competing factions can bide their time in the anticipation that they can get into power again. Because of that, they do not feel compelled to use violence to seize power, and by the same token, violence does not have to be used to suppress them.

An interesting side effect of democracy was the relaxation of the need for absolute conformity. This facilitated social mobility, commerce and the flourishing of literature and scientific exploration, all of which would have been seen as subversive and dangerous to the status quo in the older way of doing things, and consequently, rigorously suppressed.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dredmorbius on Sunday July 12, 2015 @05:15AM (#9872989)
Is it, really? I mean, beyond Winston's quip, what empirical evidence do you have to support that?

Democracies have been known for only a few brief periods of human existence. They emerged for a few hundred years, in a very limited sense, in one city-state within Greece, 2500 years ago. And then disappeared until just over 200 years ago, with some spread since.

Fewer than half the people on Earth today live in democracies (though it's close: 48%), only 12.5% live in full democracies. Far more live in autocratic regimes than any other of the forms measured by the Democracy Index: 37.6%.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index

The fastest growing economy in the world is solidly autocratic: China. Despite the claims of the benefits of both democracy and capitalism, many critical advances have come from countries which lacked one or both institutions: Nazi Germany developed jet aircraft and missiles, Communist Russia was the first to orbit satellites and put man in space.

I'm not opposed to democracy. But it seems it's got a few challenges as well.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by seanflyon on Sunday July 12, 2015 @03:54PM (#9874697)
Yes democracy has its problems as well, that's the entire point of that famous quip. Which countries would you most want to live in and how many of them are democracies Nazi Germany accomplished some impressive things, but they were the exact opposite of good government. A clear majority of countries are either actual democracies or pretend to be, because of a near worldwide consensus that democracy is the best option we have.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dredmorbius on Sunday July 12, 2015 @10:00PM (#9875956)
So: when did "democracy" become an overt policy goal? And how?

(There's a story there. It's interesting.)

There are numerous states that have functioned quite well that _weren't_ (or aren't) democracies.

Nazi Germany was, in fact, a democracy. Hitler stood for election in Germany's presidential elections of 1932. While he didn't win a majority of the July vote (none of the _six_ candidates did), he was appointed chancellor following a series of inconclusive elections.

A concern of mine is whether democracy brings wealth, or wealth democracy. Causality's arrow is sticky.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by tomjen3 on Saturday July 11, 2015 @08:10AM (#9869460)
Actually we ended up proving that democracies are pretty sticky - it is hard to go from a genuine democracy to a dictatorship, both because people don't like to lose power but also because if a significant group becomes unhappy with the way things are going they will get enough political power to change things within the current system.

In fact I don't know of a true democracy (defined here as a democracy where no group is excluded, where votes are counted fairly and where each person who wishes to do so can vote for whatever he wants) that has since transitioned into anything else.

None of this, of course, means that democracy is a good system, merely that it is sticky.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dimino on Monday July 13, 2015 @12:09PM (#9878983)
Two points -- what you're describing is a republic moreso than a democracy, and those are pretty sticky indeed.

Reddit is also not a democracy -- it's a series of benevolent dictatorships, where the content is decided on by anarchistic vote, but can be controlled ultimately through a supreme leader, empowered by the virtue of their age (the oldest member of the subreddit gets to decide the content of that subreddit).

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by Nullabillity on Saturday July 11, 2015 @05:40AM (#9869184)
Reddit doesn't flag your admin/modship next to your post unless you explicitly opt in for that post.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by j_lev on Friday July 10, 2015 @07:12PM (#9867553)
Wow.

Am I the only one that sees this as possibly the greatest potential "turnaround" story ever created?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by jellicle on Friday July 10, 2015 @07:48PM (#9867716)
It shows to me that she was dogged by misogynists and MRAs excited by the discrimination lawsuit, from the start of her Reddit tenure through to the end.

In a similar fashion, if Barack Obama posted something like "Mom and apple pie are both great.", it would be downvoted by his political foes and upvoted by his political allies. That should not be taken as an indication that "the community" opposes or disagrees with his viewpoints on Mom and apple pie.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by nindalf on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:31PM (#9868248)
I see a lot of comments like yours claiming that the hate was only because she's a minority. I get the feeling such people find it unacceptable to dislike a woman or a black/Asian person regardless of what they did.

I disliked her for

* Firing Victoria, who took AMAs to the next level. I enjoyed them a ton.

* Firing an employee for having leukemia - http://redd.it/3c0idl

* Using corporate weasel words instead of having the guts to be honest - "We're banning behaviour, not ideas"

* Treating the community with disdain and contempt, while not understanding how reddit works at all. She derided her detractors as being a very tiny minority without realising that the most active people are the ones creating and moderating the content that helps reddit thrive. If these people are unhappy with her and leave, then the passive majority (such as myself) will follow them to wherever they go.

But no, I'm probably a misogynist and a racist who hates Ellen Pao because she lost a gender discrimination lawsuit, amirite?

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by KVFinn on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:40AM (#9868934)
>Firing Victoria, who took AMAs to the next level. I enjoyed them a ton.

The Victoria specific AMAs tended to be short, done on the phone where she types responses, and oriented around'My new movie is out Friday don't miss it' instead of a conversation. I prefer the raw format myself.

>Firing an employee for having leukemia - http://redd.it/3c0idl

That this became the battle-flag for everyone to pitchfork is seriously appalling:https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9868887

>Using corporate weasel words instead of having the guts to be honest - "We're banning behaviour, not ideas"

I'm personally only familiar with the banning of /neofags because I know people who were targeted and harassed by that reddit. It was clearly banned for the behavior of the mods in the reddit, and not for content, as evidenced by other reddits with much worse content not being banned at the same time.

>She derided her detractors as being a very tiny minority without realising that the most active people are the ones creating and moderating the content that helps reddit thrive.

What does this even mean, all her detractors were also the ones creating the content? Most of the reddits complained about wanting more powerful mod tools, not less control: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/3cuw90/megathrea...

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by nindalf on Saturday July 11, 2015 @12:36PM (#9870419)
> oriented around'My new movie...

Incorrect. She did some of the best ones. The ones with Bill Murray and Sean Bean really stick out in my mind as being really great. You couldn't see either of them, but thanks to her you could make out inflections, emphasis and character. It was like hearing them talk, rather than having them type. Either way, regardless of what you think I loved the AMAs that Victoria assisted with, and so did a whole lot of other people. Pao took that away from us, and you're saying that we shouldn't criticise her for that?

> That this became the battle-flag to pitch-fork

He was almost recovered. He would have rejoined work in a month, but she rejected that. That reddit was so benevolent to him was thanks to hueypriest and Yishan Wong. She reversed this policy. Now you're saying its appalling that people are criticising Pao because Yishan and hueypriest were so nice.

> What does this even mean?

It means that the people most engaged with the site (top submitters and moderators) were unhappy with her. The site depends on these people for quality content This was written in really simple English, I don't see what your trouble with understanding it was.

I feel like you were in the flow of a "point-by-point takedown" and had to say something about the last line, but that left you looking pretty silly by the end.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by KVFinn on Saturday July 11, 2015 @01:36PM (#9870733)
>He was almost recovered. He would have rejoined work in a month, but she rejected that. That reddit was so benevolent to him was thanks to hueypriest and Yishan Wong. She reversed this policy. Now you're saying its appalling that people are criticising Pao because Yishan and hueypriest were so nice.

While she was CEO he got 4 months of the almost two years being paid while too sick to work. He got an extra full year of insurance.

He never had a move date scheduled. He was "2-3 months away" and in his AMA when asked where he was working today? He said he still wasn't feeling well enough for full time work - this was 5 months later. "Sorry, we can't keep waiting, we need someone who can do the job immediately."

So yes it is appalling that this became the reason to be furious, while treating an employee better than he would be treated at 99% of other companies in the US. In a reasonable universe the story would have been: "Wow, reddit treats employees amazingly."

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by dimino on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:10PM (#9871134)
I'm curious about your first two points -- are you privvy to information about those firings that the general public is not privy to? Because the general public, for legal reasons, is not privy to most of the information surrounding those firings, and it strikes me as interesting that you have an opinion related to them despite not having any information.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by nindalf on Sunday July 12, 2015 @04:22AM (#9872900)
To clarify those two points

* I resented that she fired Victoria, because I liked Victoria and what she brought to reddit. I didn't speculate on why she was fired at all. But let me speculate a little now - it wasn't for performance reasons judging by what every single person who has worked with Victoria says.

* I relayed what the employee in question said about it on reddit. If its a question of trusting what he says or what Pao says, I'll err on the side of the former, because of the duplicity that Pao has exhibited in recent months.

I hope that clears it up.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by mirimir on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:39PM (#9868267)
Some griefers did key on that. But overall, she was perceived as opposing free speech, which is a core value for numerous (maybe even most) Reddit users.
Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by justizin on Saturday July 11, 2015 @10:11AM (#9869823)
FWIW, harassment isn't free speech, even when you're talking about the government, and aside from basic decency, the company could be responsible, esp if it facilitated people actually following through with threats.

It is unreasonably acceptable for death, rape, and other threats to be used as a form of outspoken criticism online, and as an outspoken critic, I don't appreciate being lumped in.

Re:Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief by throwaway999666 on Friday July 10, 2015 @06:02PM (#9867115)
That sounds reasonable; only observe one side of the conflict and none of what might have provoked it and base your whole opinion on that.