News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by yc1010 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @04:58AM (#9856836)
Google adsense has a bigger problem, adblocking

It has gone from hardcore nerds (about 10%) blocking ads which was fine to everyone and their mother blocking ads on desktops/laptops, and I do not blame them. According to my measurements of adblocking (surprisingly easy to detect if ads are being blocked)

I have used adsense since it started in 2003 making close to million euro in that time, but the last few months have been absolutely disastrous (tho my traffic has also fallen in last couple of years unfortunately)

Basically the writing is on the wall and I have concentrated on other projects in last while

There must be alot of worried people now at google wondering if they will still have a job in a few years, yes mobile is helping but for how long?

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by Udo on Thursday July 09, 2015 @05:23AM (#9856907)
I think it became disastrous for Google when they made the decision to serve image ads, and even worse: animated ads. This means as a user you can no longer whitelist Google ads with the expectation they'll stick to unobtrusive text-only ads.

But there's also a deeper problem. In my opinion, when you install an ad blocker, you're already exceptionally unlikely to click an ad on purpose.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by corin_ on Thursday July 09, 2015 @07:33AM (#9857252)
> In my opinion, when you install an ad blocker, you're already exceptionally unlikely to click an ad on purpose.

I don't think that's the case, I think it's just a lie told by people working in ad sales

Nobody installs ad block because they realised they weren't interested in any of the adverts. They're doing it because some adverts are annoying or distracting or browser intensive or privacy violating or...

None of those things make a person less likely to click on an advert if they see one that is both reasonably presented and relevant to their interests.

Of course there are people who detest adverts, and in those people there's obviously a (close to 100% I presume) crossover between "has adblock" and "wouldn't click anyway", but I think those people are a small minority of people blocking ads.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by Udo on Thursday July 09, 2015 @07:54AM (#9857322)
> I don't think that's the case, I think it's just a lie told by people working in ad sales

I don't work in ad sales, and I'm not lying. Yes, ads are beyond annoying and they're making some websites borderline unusable - but the reason why ads don't work lies in the fact that the number of ads I ever clicked on purpose could probably be counted on one hand, over my entire lifetime.

It may well be the case that I'm exceptional, but on the off chance I'm not: advertisers were wasting their dollars on showing me stuff since way before I even knew what an ad blocker was.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by edwintorok on Thursday July 09, 2015 @09:35AM (#9857748)
Ads in emails from webshops that I purchased from in the past sometimes work, as long as: they don't send me such emails too frequently (i.e. not more than once a week), and it is a shop from where I've actually purchased something in the past and not just spam.

Ads on the web (and especially in mobile apps) usually have the reverse effect: it drives me away from using that site or application or to install an adblocker, and the ads I do see I use as a guidance on what NOT to buy.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by agumonkey on Thursday July 09, 2015 @08:02AM (#9857341)
I'm close to your one-handed-click-count 'niche'. I'm really not a commercial target. I kinda despise the actual idea of advertising. It's in your face, takes a lot of resources, distract and also rarely on point.

I don't think I would ever install an adblocker if it was 80% small text ads (like Google off side ads), or a non invasive static image (granted it's not taking more space than the content I was about to read). Could website function with this kind only ?

Also, I really wonder what it looks like for a user to click on an ad...

ps: I didn't count the few times I did click on them voluntarily just to give some prints to a website in need.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by corin_ on Thursday July 09, 2015 @11:24PM (#9862132)
If you read the rest of my comment you'd see that I already mentioned people like you exist. For as long as advertising has existed, the people doing it have understood that not 100% of people seeing it will "convert". Regardless of whether you want someone to click online or if it's a TV ad or whatever, the fact that most views of it are going to be wasted views is known and built into the expectations.

The point is there are lots of people who block adverts because of how obtrusive they often are online, but who if they didn't block them, would be of value to the advertisers. (Keep in mind value doesn't have to be a click, there's also brand awareness, (sub/)conscious retention of information about an advertised product, etc.) Maybe you're not one of those people.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by Udo on Friday July 10, 2015 @02:51AM (#9862630)
> If you read the rest of my comment you'd see that I already mentioned people like you exist.

I do apologize if I misunderstood you, but re-reading your comment and mine I still don't believe that's really the case.

Either people like me are a lie told by the ad industry or we do exist. It's unlikely both of these are true at the same time.

I also object to the rest of your original comment, which literally boils down to "Nobody installs ad block because they realised they weren't interested in any of the adverts", I just didn't address it explicitly because it would have been redundant. But if you are looking for a lie told by people selling ads, that sentence would make a better candidate.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by corin_ on Friday July 10, 2015 @01:48PM (#9865533)
First, you're right that saying nobody was wrong - but I think very few people. Even you, do you really object to advertising, or just the way it's done online? If you get on a train do you hate the fact that there are adverts on there subsidizing the cost of the service? My guess is you don't care as you just ignore them.

But that wasn't actually the point I was trying to make. My response to "when you install an ad blocker, you're already exceptionally unlikely to click an ad on purpose" isn't that nobody exists like that, but that (in my opinion a massive majority) are doing it because of bad adverts, not because they're anti-adverts. And my maning about the lie told by the industry is that when a company spending ad money says "what about all the people on your website we see using adblock?" Mr Ad Sales' answer is often (that I've witnessed) to say that those are people who never would have given your advert the time of day in the first place, so it's irrelevant whether they see it or not. (Of course now days with better tracking and better competition, it's more common to see adblock detected and not charged as an impression.)

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by dazc on Thursday July 09, 2015 @08:57AM (#9857543)
It may well be the case that I'm exceptional

You're not alone. I use adblocker on sites where the number and kind of ads is annoying. On the sites I don't block I have never clicked an ad intentionally.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by qu4z-2 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @08:19PM (#9861606)
The only time I click ads is those google ads at the top of the results, when it's an ad for literally the thing I googled. Otherwise I follow a policy of "If it didn't occur to me that I want it, I don't want it."
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by teddyuk on Thursday July 09, 2015 @08:06AM (#9857355)
i'm like you, the only time I had clicked an ad has been by accident and I have hit back straight away.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by geomark on Thursday July 09, 2015 @09:37AM (#9857758)
Same here. Never clicked an ad intentionally. Not on a website or on Google's search results pages. I guess that's why it seems to me that all the huffing and puffing about the evils of ad blockers is nonsense, because ad blocker or not I'm not going to click an ad. I'm also going to avert my eyes if I see a display ad, so brand building with display ads is also lost on me. And I have never purchased music that includes DRM, except a DVD by accident one time and I returned it for a refund when I discovered it was infected with DRM. I guess I'm just a really terrible consumer and not part of anybody's target market.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by vultour on Thursday July 09, 2015 @10:23AM (#9857973)
I honestly never clicked on any ads, and very probably never will. If I need something I find it in eshops I know, not by clicking on sketchy ads.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by cronjobber on Thursday July 09, 2015 @07:45AM (#9857293)
> you're already exceptionally unlikely to click an ad on purpose.

I hate distracting blinkety-blink and I hate the tracking and spying aspect of the whole sordid business model, so I adblock. But I can't say I'm immune to the ads I do see.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by pjc50 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @05:53AM (#9856988)
I'm considering rooting my Android phone and tablet simply so I can install effective adblockers against three things:

- in-app ads which, without clicking on the ad, bounce me out of the app and into a browser

- browser ads which bounce to the good old "your computer has a virus!" exploitware

- animated web background ads which slow the browser to a crawl

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by DanBC on Thursday July 09, 2015 @06:41AM (#9857122)
> - in-app ads which, without clicking on the ad, bounce me out of the app and into a browser

On iOS there are ads that bounce you out of the browser and into the app store.

I cannot understand how anyone thinks this is a good idea. I am ad tolerant but those ads make me want to use ad block technology.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by falcolas on Thursday July 09, 2015 @07:13AM (#9857203)
Yeah, Imgur would run some of these ads, and I wanted to scream every time I would be browsing reddit and get bounced to the app store with every third click.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by jmngomes on Thursday July 09, 2015 @07:25AM (#9857233)
Deep linking was being touted as the next big thing in mobile advertising, namely by some well known VCs (1) that love to play the predict-the-next-breakthrough lottery, yet it has proven to be more of a nuisance than anything else...

(1) https://twitter.com/cdixon/status/608713213702713344

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by prawn on Thursday July 09, 2015 @07:44AM (#9857287)
I have had this happen on page load, without clicking anything. The ad networks should shamed for letting anything like that through.

I started blocking ads after the day I picked up a virus through an embedded ad on an NBA team site. Just too risky to leave ads running.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by msravi on Thursday July 09, 2015 @07:26AM (#9857236)
I've found rooting my phone and installing AdAway (that blackholes ad-server requests using the /etc/hosts file) to be extremely effective against all sorts of ads - in-browser, in-app, you name it.

AdAway and XPrivacy are the two apps that made rooting my phone worth every second I spent doing it. Cannot recommend it enough!

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by teddyuk on Thursday July 09, 2015 @08:07AM (#9857359)
If you are blocking ads, do you pay for the apps you use or do you want app developers to give you them for free?

Genuine question, I don't like ads in apps and if I use an app I donate or pay for it rather than relying on free

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by msravi on Thursday July 09, 2015 @08:30AM (#9857424)
I buy the ad-free version of apps that I use regularly. But then, there are those that don't give me that option...

[Edit] A good example of one that doesn't allow you to pay, but insists on showing you ads, and if I'm to go by the reviews, video ads, is AppSales, which allows you to track the price of an app on the app-store.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by wernercd on Thursday July 09, 2015 @09:15AM (#9857633)
Seconded. I'll pay a dollar for small apps I use regularly. AdBlock is one of the last reasons I rooted - more important ones were

* remote control apps (security type "wipe phone if requested, resist attempts to remove from phone") * backup apps (Backup EVERYTHING... some apps try to block that) * Junk removal (No I don't need a racing game that I can't remove on my samsung - switch it from system app to normal app please kthxbye) * Host adblock

I'm less militant about in-app adds than I am about in-browser, personally.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by blfr on Thursday July 09, 2015 @06:34AM (#9857100)
You can have a regular in-browser AdBlock in mobile Firefox without rooting the phone. It doesn't stop the in-apps ads of course.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by soylentcola on Thursday July 09, 2015 @01:37PM (#9859429)
Browser-based ads are fairly easy to block on Android with Firefox using the same addons you'd expect on the desktop (AdBlock Plus/Edge/etc).

But yeah, for a while I just made a point of unlocking the bootloader and installing supersu on any new device just so I could run AdFree (simple hosts file/blacklist solution) to block the ads in apps.

Still, I recently got a replacement for a broken phone and while I unlocked the bootloader immediately (kind of a pain once you've set your phone up) I haven't gotten around to installing AdFree. Turns out most of the apps I use anymore don't include those sorts of ads. Of the ones that do show an ad window inside the main part of the app (and not just in a settings window or something), it really did remind me that I ought to plunk down the $1-2 for the ad-free version. They're apps I use often enough and with Adfree I didn't even realize there were ads in the app.

For the handful that I don't care about or use shitty intrusive ads, I just uninstall them once I notice it. I feel a lot better about it because I'm supporting the non-shitty developers and uninstalling the ones I'd rather not support.

But for browsing...oh hell yes I use an Adblock extension in mobile Firefox. The ads that show up on mobile sites are 10x worse than what I see on the desktop, they take up more screen space, they waste data when my plan is capped at 5GB monthly, and they're easily dealt with via the addon.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by flavor8 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @06:56AM (#9857158)
Ghostery has a repackaged chrome in the play store, which has ad blocking built it. I got tired of sites that _pop up_ ads on mobile with a tiny X button.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by anc84 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @09:25AM (#9857686)
You can also install a firewall (AFWall+) to block apps from sending any data. This and ad-blocking is why I root. The disregard to privacy is crazy nowadays.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by raverbashing on Thursday July 09, 2015 @06:37AM (#9857110)
Really, displaying exploitware should be reason to ban completely those who use it (from the app stores)
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by HappyTypist on Thursday July 09, 2015 @05:39AM (#9856956)
Google is reportedly paying 30% of ad revenue to the company behind Adblock Plus to get on the "acceptable ads" whitelist for Google search. I find this a despicable pracrice and encourage my friends to use another ad blocker. If you use ABP, you are funding Eyeo.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by cbr on Thursday July 09, 2015 @09:23AM (#9857669)
https://adblockplus.org/acceptable-ads

    No applicant will be favored or treated differently,
    and no one can buy their way onto the whitelist.
    Everyone has tocomply with the criteria and everyone
    has to go through the same process before the ads
    qualify as "acceptable."
https://adblockplus.org/en/acceptable-ads-agreements

    Do companies pay you for being added to the list?

    Whitelisting is free for all small- and medium
    websites and blogs. However, managing this list
    requires significant effort on our side and this
    task cannot be completely taken over by volunteers
    as it happens with common filter lists. That's why
    we are being paid by some larger properties that
    serve non-intrusive advertisements that want to
    participate in the Acceptable Ads initiative.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by fridek on Thursday July 09, 2015 @08:26AM (#9857419)
That would be $20 billion, making it one of the top 1000 companies by revenue globally. I'll leave it to you to decide if it looks like a true information.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by philjohn on Thursday July 09, 2015 @06:03AM (#9857024)
Like it or not, ads pay for much of the content you consume online.

I don't mind unobtrusive ads, and the google adsense ads tend to fall into that camp.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by blfr on Thursday July 09, 2015 @06:32AM (#9857095)
You only need to untick one box in ABP and it stops letting through the whitelisted ads.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by golergka on Thursday July 09, 2015 @05:59AM (#9857007)
> reportedly

Can you please provide a source?

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by jmngomes on Thursday July 09, 2015 @07:29AM (#9857242)
Also curious...I'd be surprised if they are still paying 30% to the publishers.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by vultour on Thursday July 09, 2015 @10:28AM (#9858005)
Yet they still allow you to block them easily. Good for them
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by tobico on Thursday July 09, 2015 @08:53AM (#9857523)
I use ad blockers for distracting image and popup ads, but I fairly frequently click on Google text ads in search results. When there's a product category that's very crowded, if a company is willing to pony up some money to get my attention, that's often one indicator that a particular product might be worth my time to investigate.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by kps on Thursday July 09, 2015 @10:23AM (#9857974)
These are about the only ads I deliberately use, and yet, it happens again and again that I am interested in buying XYZ, search for XYZ, click an ad that explicitly mentions XYZ — and find that the advertiser doesn't offer XYZ. What is it about marketeers that has them ceaselessly shitting upstream from where people drink?
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by amelius on Thursday July 09, 2015 @08:37AM (#9857461)
> Google adsense has a bigger problem, adblocking

Also, one day Congress will figure out that it could be a good idea to introduce a tax on ads.

Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by honest_joe on Thursday July 09, 2015 @06:02AM (#9857019)
Can that be "fixed" by dynamically CSS generated ads ?
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by ExpiredLink on Thursday July 09, 2015 @06:34AM (#9857102)
Google could easily circumvent ad-blocking by making ads indistinguishable from content. I hope they will not do it, the internet would become a bustling nightmare.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by thescrewdriver on Thursday July 09, 2015 @07:42AM (#9857281)
The background color of ads section in search results seems to get closer and closer to the regular page background each year, or maybe it's just my eyes.
Re:Google’s Ad System Has Become Too Big to Control by cbr on Thursday July 09, 2015 @09:28AM (#9857705)
They've switched from coloring the background to adding a yellow "Ad" marker on each ad: https://www.google.com/search?q=credit+cards