News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Minister No More by socceroos on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:05AM (#9837074)
I'm having trouble reading between the lines here. Was he given a push by being excluded from the recent meetings? Is the suggestion that he was actually a hindrance to Greece progressing? Is he saying he supports the move or that he 'has to'?
Re:Minister No More by toyg on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:11AM (#9837103)
As the most competent economist in the room in any negotiating meeting, he clearly made the mostly-incompetent politicians insecure. I mean, Schauble studied law and was an average accountant, Djesslbloem studied agricultural policies, Lagarde is a lawyer. When he suggested advanced financial instruments of policies, most of them could not understand what he was saying, hence the accusations of gambling and so on.

In that sense, yes, he's better gone: he leaves while on top, having been vindicated by both economists (IMF report) and the public. I fear this might mean Greece will still have to swallow a bitter pill though.

Re:Minister No More by Svip on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:27AM (#9837152)
I think you are leaving out that he wasn't exactly a decent diplomat or politician, calling the creditors "terrorists" and publicly offended the German finance minister. In fact, I'd consider this the biggest reason he has come in disfavour with the other ministers.
Re:Minister No More by adnzzzzZ on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:32AM (#9837170)
He didn't call them terrorists, that was a translation error that inflammatory media outlets didn't bother to correct.
Re:Minister No More by speakeron on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:37AM (#9837437)
> He didn't call them terrorists, that was a translation error that inflammatory media outlets didn't bother to correct.

Where do you think the mistranslation happened? Here's the text (in Spanish) from the El Mundo interview. My Spanish isn't great, but it seems quite clear:

(El Mundo) Aunque no haya encuestas, en las calles de Atenas lo que se siente es que la gente cada día que pasa tiene más miedo.

(Varoufakis) Sí, así es. Lo que están haciendo con Grecia tiene un nombre: terrorismo

(El Mundo) ¿De verdad piensa que lo que están haciendo con Grecia es terrorismo?

(Varoufakis) Por supuesto que lo pienso: es terrorismo. ¿Por qué nos han forzado a cerrar los bancos? Para insuflar el miedo en la gente. Y cuando se trata de extender el terror, a ese fenómeno se le llama terrorismo. Pero confío en que el miedo no gane.

Re:Minister No More by kilburn on Monday July 06, 2015 @05:22AM (#9837798)
Here's a quick translation:

(El Mundo) Even though there are no polls, what you feel in Athen's streets is that people is more scared every day.

(Varoufakis) Yes, that's it. What they are doing to Greece has a name: terrorism.

(El Mundo) Do you really think that what they are doing to Greece is terrorism?

(Varoufakis) Of course I think so: it is terrorism. Why did they force us to close our banks? (They did so) To instill fear into people. And when the objective is to spread terror, that phenomenon is called terrorism. But I have faith in that fear won't win.

---

My personal stance is that he did indeed call their counterparties terrorists. However, he carefully distinguished them from "violent terriorists" such as ISIS et al. Which kind of terrorists are actually more harmful in the long run... that's a matter for personal opinion.

Re:Minister No More by digi_owl on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:08PM (#9840994)
A couple of other terms that could have been used was "spreading FUD" and racketeering (nice nation you have there, would be sad to see anything bad happen to it...).

But the guy have a penchant for not mincing words...

Re:Minister No More by icebraining on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:32PM (#9841994)
Does Varoufakis speak Spanish, or is that itself a translation? Because El Mundo is also a media outlet.
Re:Minister No More by Svip on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:38AM (#9837200)
I will concede that. However, I doubt he was speaking about the creditors in a nice manner. And regardless, it certainly wasn't his first diplomatic gaffe in his tenure as finance minister.

However, if his words are commonly misrepresented, then he should be more careful when speaking publicly. Part of being a politician, and particularly a minister, means your every word will be scrutinised in every way.

While he definitely had the ability as an economist, he did not when it came to being a politician nor a diplomat. But his resignation seems to confirm that he himself realises this.

Re:Minister No More by socceroos on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:48AM (#9837241)
There's something to be said for not pussy-footing around imbeciles.
Re:Minister No More by Natsu on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:18AM (#9837346)
If one considers their creditors imbeciles (as one might fairly do in this case), it becomes an open question where they plan to get money from in order to continue? Even if they go bankrupt, they have to keep getting money from somewhere.
Re:Minister No More by digi_owl on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:10PM (#9841000)
A sovereign nation do not have to get the money from anywhere, unless one is stuck in thinking in terms of commodity money.
Re:Minister No More by Natsu on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:39PM (#9841662)
You're right, they have to get goods from somewhere. The currency situation is due to the imbalance between what Greece produces on the world market vs. what it consumes.

Their government can certainly print money endlessly, but it's like issuing more stock: it doesn't just make the value of that country go up, it makes the value of its stock (money) go down proportionately.

So the fact remains that Greece won't be able to buy all the things it wants without outside cash. And who is going to give it any now? If you just print money without limit, you'll soon find that there's nothing to buy with that money due to inflation.

Maybe they can copy Argentina, but when their finance minister's exit speech is basically "haha, later suckers!" I don't have high hopes.

Re:Minister No More by digi_owl on Monday July 06, 2015 @05:09PM (#9842202)
There is also the exchange rate aspect.

If their currency were to lose value, their exports would become cheaper in relation to others.

This in turn would drive up exports.

Right now the euro is trading pretty much on par with USD.

Not likely that this is beneficial for the Greek economy, as it seems very dependent on farming and raw material extraction.

Re:Minister No More by craigyk on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:18AM (#9837352)
Or insulting the type of people who would let personal insults dictate their decisions affecting millions.
Re:Minister No More by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:38AM (#9837441)
Their room for manoeuvre is ultimately determined by their voters, most of whom have realized by now what little regard Syriza (and most of Greece) have for them.
Re:Minister No More by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:40AM (#9837448)
Was it now?

Googling the actual Greek word he used brings up page after page of arguments that it meant exactly that: terrorism.

Re:Minister No More by quonn on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:41AM (#9837209)
Actually he has been insulted for five months by German politicians but stayed polite despite this. The real problem was the perception as being arrogant, which was also fueled by the media.
Re:Minister No More by evgen on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:40AM (#9837204)
The idea that any of those leaders would have been intimidated by or felt insecure around Varoufakis is laughable. He was a mildly amusing technocrat given a specific mission by his delusional government, a mission he failed miserably at while mostly working to maintain his own brand. National leaders keep trained monkeys of their own in the room to explain or even negotiate the details, the key issues are in making sure that major points are accepted by both sides. I would not say that is is leaving "while on top", he is just leaving.

This is no longer a negotiation regarding greek debt, it is a determination of the process for greek exit from the Euro.

Re:Minister No More by toyg on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:02AM (#9837285)
You might think that, but it's a fact that he managed to move the debate from "more austerity to repay all" to "the unsustainable debt has to be renounced". Both the IMF and the public agreed with him. The fact that he didn't need "trained monkeys", unlike his counterparts, is exactly why they clearly felt threatened and spent six months name-calling him.

> It is a determination of the process for greek exit from the Euro.

It might well be the determination of the process for Euro dismemberment. It's now clear that a country not useful to the current "enlarged deutschmark" will be just thrown to the wolves, so the clock is ticking for Italy and Spain.

Re:Minister No More by danem on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:32AM (#9837406)
> Both the IMF and the public agreed with him.

From my reading of the IMF report abstract, it seems that they believe the debt is unsustainable given that Greece didn't follow the plan laid out in the 2012 framework. Hardly a change of message, I'd say.

Relevant passage:

> By late summer 2014, with interest rates having declined further, it appeared that no further debt relief would have been needed under the November 2012 framework, if the program were to have been implemented as agreed. But significant changes in policies since then—not least, lower primary surpluses and a weak reform effort that will weigh on growth and privatization—are leading to substantial new financing needs.

http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/cat/longres.aspx?sk=43044.0

Re:Minister No More by toyg on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:38AM (#9837652)
They stopped following austerity because things were getting intolerable for the average person. By the time the medicine could have 'worked', the patient would have been long dead. So the change in policy was inevitable, as it was debt relief. If Merkel and Schauble had agreed to debt relief 6 months ago, accepting that it was a price worth paying for the stability and long term wealth of the eurozone, things today would be looking rosy. Unfortunately, they could not get themselves to reveal to their electorate that the 2012 bailout was for European banks and arms dealers rather than the Greek people (which is now long overdue), and here we are.
Re:Minister No More by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:48AM (#9837478)
> not least, lower primary surpluses and a weak reform effort that will weigh on growth and privatization

Here's a wonderful anecdote about their glacial and incompetent privatization:

http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2015/07/03/the-airbu...

Note the marvelous bit about the hundreds of clients the non-selling of 4 Airbus planes provided jobs for.

[deleted]
Re:Minister No More by evgen on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:17AM (#9837570)
Good for you. I am sure that made you feel a lot better.

For starters, delusional may imply mental illness but its primary definition is to hold false or unrealistic beliefs or opinions. That clearly describes the Syriza government.

Trained monkeys is a figure of speech to imply that economists have little place at the negotiation table until they are called upon to produce a fact or table that is required, often to create such a fact or table even if it is not supported by the data. Whether or not they have the capacity for reasoning is completely superfluous to their role in the discussion, they are window-dressing and nothing more.

It is my _opinion_ that Varoufakis has been primarily interested in making sure that he emerges from this sorid affair as he went in, a 'rebellious rock-star' who can assure himself of at least a decade of speaking gigs and punditry while the rest of his country crumbles. Nice work for a mid-grade academic. I am sure the book describing how none of this is his fault and if only they had listened to him everything would have worked out just fine (and the 'elites' would have gotten what they deserve, etc.) is due to be published any day now.

Re:Minister No More by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:15AM (#9837337)
I think it is counter productive to flag good and reasonable comments.

What is wrong or subjective in "delusional government", "failed", "working to maintain his own brand"?

Is it the "trained monkeys" you object to?

Edit: and I think you are just trying to use appeals to decorum to suppress dissent.

Note: "childish", "defamatory", "bad-faith", "stooping", "vacuous", "insults". Hoisted by your own petard? Projection?

Re:Minister No More by corin_ on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:30AM (#9837396)
What is wrong or subjective? Well we still don't actually know what's going to happen. Maybe all their debts will be forgiven tomorrow. Seems unlikely, but right now we don't know what's going to happen we just have a range of good and bad guesses. Until we know for sure they have failed we can't call them delusional; indeed lots of people think they are right to fight against austerity, not delusional. And working to maintain his own brand... even if their isn't an argument to be made that getting people to like him is beneficial for his party and his job objectives (which surely there is), how many politicians do you know who don't attempt to maintain their own brand? It's the game they're in.

All in all... we get it, you dislike the Greek government, disagree with them entirely, and are confident you know what is going to happen. Your views are subjective.

Re:Minister No More by claudius on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:04AM (#9837532)
> Maybe all their debts will be forgiven tomorrow.

Greece is not the only democracy in Europe and Merkel likes her job too much for that to happen. Sure, if the US/IMF think that the debt should be forgiven, they’re welcome to purchase it and hand it over to Greece, but that’s even more unlikely.

Re:Minister No More by venomsnake on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:51AM (#9837254)
>This is no longer a negotiation regarding greek debt, it is a determination of the process for greek exit from the Euro.

Which was the only possible solution for Greece (outside of 50% debt relief which would have been optimal, but politically impossible due to conservative culture). So in a way he delivered.

Re:Minister No More by evgen on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:08AM (#9837542)
Given that Syriza came to power claiming the could both eliminate austerity conditions and keep Greece in the Euro, I have a hard time believing that this is delivering in any way, shape, or form. Greece is now going to have an unpleasant austerity imposed on it by collapse of their banking system and exit from the Euro. In the long-run this is possibly better, but it is going to be very unpleasant for quite a while.
Re:Minister No More by venomsnake on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:23AM (#9837591)
Having permanent depression is always unpleasant. Anyway Euro is not a big deal. Membership in EU is. They have access to Schengen, EU markets and borders.
Re:Minister No More by jbarham on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:36AM (#9837183)
Hmm, it seems to me that "advanced financial instruments" that helped mask persistent corruption and tax evasion are a big reason why Greece is currently in a no-win financial deadlock.

And it's a bit rich to talk about the "competent" Greek economist vs. his "incompetent" EU counterparts when they're the ones with the money and he isn't.

When it comes to the Greek debt fiasco, Shakespeare said it best 400 years ago: "Neither a borrower nor a lender be, For loan oft loses both itself and friend, And borrowing dulls the edge of husbandry."

Re:Minister No More by imron on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:42AM (#9837217)
Sure, they're the ones with money and he isn't, but that's hardly his fault, and it's a bit rich to suggest that this implies competence, when part of the reason Greece doesn't have any money is thanks to the policies of these EU counterparts (and their predecessors).
Re:Minister No More by gonvaled on Monday July 06, 2015 @05:51AM (#9837900)
> And it's a bit rich to talk about the "competent" Greek economist vs. his "incompetent" EU counterparts when they're the ones with the money and he isn't.

So you mean that all competent economists are in rich countries, and all incompetent in poor ones?

Does the same apply to other disciplines? Like all good mathematicians are in the US and India? All good painters are in the Netherlands? etc

How sad! I now realize that coming from a country with less than average literary achievements, no matter how I try I won't be ever able to write! I thank you for saving me the effort to try!

What a funny world!

Re:Minister No More by jazzyk on Monday July 06, 2015 @09:14AM (#9838839)
It is a bit rich to imply that J.K. Galbraith is a competent economist and Donald Trump is not, when Trump is the one who has money and J.K. isn't.

Right? :-)

Re:Minister No More by dev-da0 on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:29AM (#9837161)
A nice way of saying the Greek govt was mostly Idiocracy (2006) incarnate. Sounds like there might be a leadership vacuum and hard, effective work ethic may not be appreciated (or it was a personality conflict).

One positive note: most organizations are culturally self-selecting. So if it didn't work out, that means he's freed up to land a better gig even if he could have made an larger impact if allowed, it's clear the leadership either blames him, feels they have irreconcilable differences or doesn't want him to succeed. It appears he gave it a good go, but perhaps insiders think otherwise. Reiterating the maxim of never burn bridges and always take the high road when leaving employment (and never gossiping/speak ill of anyone in an exit interview.)

Re:Minister No More by chvid on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:19AM (#9837130)
To me it just seems immature, populist, random, yet he seems to have a huge fanbase?!

As far as I can see it is much harder to reach a deal now that there is a precedence to have the negotiated deal rectified at a referendum.

Re:Minister No More by quonn on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:46AM (#9837235)
It's not like Greece just had to get this one deal and then they would have lived happily ever after. For Greece it's not enough to get _a_ deal. They have been getting those deals for 5 years, and a new one is negotiated every few months. The issue is to get a deal that actually works.
Re:Minister No More by jevgeni on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:05AM (#9837294)
I completely agree. Any valid economic arguments he had, he himself made absolutely unsellable due to his behaviour.
Re:Minister No More by socceroos on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:10AM (#9837318)
Bullshit. People need to sit down and be told they're being stupid. Being able to take it is another thing. Call him harsh, but the more I'm reading the more valid his points seem to be.

If everyone else can't handle the truth then they're being fools. Is that true?

Re:Minister No More by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:19AM (#9837358)
Now imagine a universe, a parallel universe, if you like, in which the Greeks were the stupid ones...

> If everyone else can't handle the truth then they're being fools.

Re:Minister No More by socceroos on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @08:08PM (#9848982)
I assume you're referring to the situation that the Greeks have got themselves into in the first place?

Take a step back, the idiocy of the past is history. There is the idiocy of the now to deal with.

Re:Minister No More by jevgeni on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:50AM (#9837487)
He has some good economic arguments at best and only if you subscribe to the school of economic thought he adheres to. What I've seen of him, he is what the Germans would call a "Fachidiot" (something like "subject idiot" in English), someone who cannot see further than their own subject matter.
Re:Minister No More by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:13AM (#9837554)
As a native Dane with a decentish working knowledge of German, I'd say the Danish word "distanceblænder" ("distance blinder", "distance dazzler") is more fitting:

Someone who (or something which) superficially dazzles with apparent qualities but on closer inspection disappoints utterly.

http://ordnet.dk/ods/ordbog?query=distancebl%C3%A6nder

(I agree completely with your description: some good arguments at best and then only if...)

Re:Minister No More by jevgeni on Monday July 06, 2015 @05:48AM (#9837892)
Awesome. Thank you for the cool word!
Re:Minister No More by mwfunk on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:49AM (#9837245)
Unfortunately those are the traits many people look for in a politician, although to be charitable they're usually confusing them with more noble traits like honesty or integrity. :( Flippancy, tribalism, and reductivism all too often look like bravery and insight from a great distance, at least among people who see politics as a war rather than as an unfortunate side effect of democracy.
Re:Minister No More by ghshephard on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:10AM (#9837098)
He refused to negotiate technical details of Austerity in Bargaining sessions, and continually lectured the Troika on the need to provide debt relief. When he says he wears the creditors loathing with pride, he really means it.
Re:Minister No More by hhandoko on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:07AM (#9837083)
He's content with leaving his position, that Greece now had some leverage to negotiate better terms.

He understands that the last restructuring agreement terms is not acceptable. I would assume that he was probably being very vocal in meetings, thus certain parties would think that his presence might make future negotiations more difficult.

Re:Minister No More by r0naa on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:43AM (#9837219)
> He's content with leaving his position, that Greece now had some leverage to negotiate better terms.

Leverage better terms? I don't think you have any idea how much Tsipras has alienated France and Germany's public opinions. Now that supporting Greece has become synonym of political suicide, I believe that Greece has effectively very little leverage.

After Tsipras' call to vote No, I would be surprised to see any negotiation happen in the near future.

Re:Minister No More by nhaehnle on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:42AM (#9837451)
Maybe German and French politicians really are sufficiently pissed off not to want to negotiate. The referendum did have one important effect though: it smashed any illusions that Syriza is the problem. Heck, the No vote in the referendum was significantly larger than the vote for Syriza in the elections this year!

The problem is that the creditors insist on "squeezing blood from a stone", unwilling to reach an agreement that actually works, and the people of Greece insist that they won't accept that. Now, it's often said and true that in a democracy, the people of one country cannot be allowed to force their will onto the people of 18 other countries. But the facts are on the table; the Greeks have demonstrated that they won't budge. If the creditors won't budge either, it probably means total default and Grexit, something that ostensibly nobody wanted, but that is inevitable given how nobody was willing to make the necessary concessions to avoid it.

In the medium to long term, the Greeks will probably be better off outside a dysfunctional currency union, and the Euro will either get fixed or dissolved after the next few crises.

Re:Minister No More by hhandoko on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:36AM (#9837432)
France and Germany has no option but to negotiate.

If Greece defaults, most likely they will exit the Eurozone and this will be disastrous for Europe (Italy and Spain will be exposed in particular).

Financially, it will send a ripple effect and the Euro will devalue as those debts can't be collected, i.e. written off. Politically, it will be the beginning of the end of the Eurozone.

Re:Minister No More by r0naa on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:14AM (#9837559)
> France and Germany has no option but to negotiate.

Again, basic knowledge of the current public opinions of either countries on the subject strongly indicates the contrary.

I do not have the background required to have an informed opinion about the economical consequences of such situation.

Just stating the obvious from a pure political standpoint IMHO.

Re:Minister No More by hhandoko on Monday July 06, 2015 @05:06AM (#9837745)
I'm not disagreeing with you on the public opinion of either France or Germany on Greece. But it is in their leader's (France and Germany's) best interest to `help` Greece despite the public's opinion, as public opinion does not always align to the needed course of action.

In Greece's situation, the public opinion (by form of referendum) is used to cement their bargaining position, i.e. the people are ready to accept the repercussions of debt default if they don't get a better deal.

Which is why the negotiation is continuing / will continue, otherwise it will be a terrible lose-lose situation for all.

Re:Minister No More by youngtaff on Monday July 06, 2015 @06:06AM (#9837961)
The problem is the German and French public have never been told or refuse to understand that the original bailout of Greece was a bail out of German, French and other banks.

Greece was sacrificed to save the wider euro, and the German and French public should be grateful.

Re:Minister No More by nazgob on Monday July 06, 2015 @07:47AM (#9838360)
And what did Greece do with money it borrowed from German and French banks?
Re:Minister No More by youngtaff on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @08:45AM (#9851156)
Does it matter?

When a bank makes a loan there's always a risk of losing money and that's priced into the load (or should be).

'moral hazard' should limit the amount of money banks are willing to lose and so willing to lend to people / companies / countries etc.

The banks and european politicians seem to have forgotten about the hazard and instead bailed out those who lent money to Greece and left the public to pick up the cost.

Re:Minister No More by nisa on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:53AM (#9839999)
They bought german weapons and gave money to german firms.. e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siemens_Greek_bribery_scandal
Re:Minister No More by nazgob on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @07:39AM (#9844776)
Why they did that? Poor countries should not buy brand new German subs. Where are the subs now? As far as I now they are deployed in Greek Navy and like any sub are quite expensive to operate. Did Greece spend all borrowed money on German weapons?
Re:Minister No More by cperciva on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:18AM (#9837124)
Is the suggestion that he was actually a hindrance to Greece progressing?

Yes. The Troika wanted to negotiate, but Varoufakis didn't have the power to negotiate anything because the Greek prime minister reserved the right to veto anything which came out of the negotiations.

First rule of negotitations: If you're serious about negotiating, you send someone who has the power to negotiate.

Re:Minister No More by nhaehnle on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:46AM (#9837467)
And yet, it is one of the most common and powerful negotiation strategies, and hence frequently suggested also on this site, to be able to say "sounds interesting, but I need to check that with my spouse/family/boss/prime minister".
Re:Minister No More by cperciva on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:08AM (#9837541)
Yes. Pretending to negotiate while not in fact negotiating is a very effective negotiation tactic.
Re:Minister No More by danieldk on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:07AM (#9837085)
Good question. Another possibility: he knows there is nothing to win.
Re:Minister No More by _ak on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:15AM (#9837116)
My theory is that this was his endgame: the eurogroup is now forced to make a move, unless Merkel and her entourage want to go down in history as those that broke up the Euro by moralizing demands of having to pay back debts but could have prevented it. And Greece will use exactly this smugness as leverage for further negotiations.
Re:Minister No More by jevgeni on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:56AM (#9837274)
The demands are not moralizing, but consistent. If other countries went through austerity, why should Greece be exempt? Imagine what will happen if everybody suddenly thought, that if they act aggressively and recklessly enough, everybody else would pay?

It's a race to the bottom.

Re:Minister No More by _ak on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:05AM (#9837297)
Because, in history, other countries were forgiven their debts, as well, especially so Germany. If Germany gets their debts forgiven after waging war over Europe, then why not Greece after living beyond their means? That would be consistent, as well. And helpful if it means it keeps the Euro zone together and relatively stable.

And let's not forget how much of the help for Greece wasn't actual help, it was a bailout by proxy for German and French banks. How would the political climate in Europe be if these banks had needed an explicit bailout?

Re:Minister No More by jevgeni on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:58AM (#9837517)
You are talking about historical consistency. What the European establishment needs is political consistency. The Baltic states, as well as Spain, Portugal, and Ireland did go through varying degrees of austerity. If you start treating one member differently, right after other members went through difficult reforms, why should other members then play ball? And that is false reasoning: does this mean that any country can wage war and racial extermination and then be forgiven, because Germany already was?

Regarding the bailout thing. A bailout is, per definition, paying off the creditors (banks in this case). The reason people do it at all is to keep the confidence of the money market. Greece wouldn't need a bailout if they were planning to stop taking on any debt at all. But they aren't.

To answer your question, if the banks would take the hit, then it would hurt private households. People think of banks as some super dodgy prop hedge funds, that use their own money to reap super profits. They don't. Banks invest the money of their clients and bag any difference between the interest rate they've offered and the interest rate they've earned. So again, the hit would go to pension funds and possibly depositors. Now, what kind of political climate would be in Europe, if say a German pensioner suddenly got less, because the Greeks couldn't pay back?

Re:Minister No More by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:18AM (#9837574)
> If you start treating one member differently, right after other members went through difficult reforms, why should other members then play ball?

Yep.

We are talking iterated games and rational expectations here. Something you'd expect an expert in game theory to understand -- which he of course does, leading to the conclusion that he has been very dishonest the whole way through.

(I agree with the rest as well.)

Re:Minister No More by isoos on Monday July 06, 2015 @06:36AM (#9838069)
Maybe austerity is a really bad idea. It has its place in the general monetary toolbox [1], but history shows that it is really not worth to use only that (Mark Blyth: Austerity - The History of a Dangerous Idea [2]). Also, even the IMF has studies where the positive effects of austerity are questioned [3].

    [1] http://www.economicprinciples.org/
    [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQuHSQXxsjM
    [3] http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2011/wp11158.pdf
Also, the EU needs much more wealth redistribution than it is currently happening, and austerity acts contrary to that: https://plus.google.com/+JeanBaptisteQueru/posts/CPB9bwHqsfn
Re:Minister No More by WhoIsSatoshi on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:28AM (#9837154)
Maybe that wasn't his plan, but he can now see the very situation you depicted. I believe he was too proactive for a government that bases a lot on pretense (read - paperwork). Old world vs. New World.
Re:Minister No More by nisa on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:24AM (#9837145)
There was an article in the NYT that sheds some light into the issue: http://mobile.nytimes.com/2015/07/03/business/dealbook/hopef...
Re:Minister No More by socceroos on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:43AM (#9837220)
The article seems to contain a fair amount of hearsay, but you're right; it was enlightening. Thank you.
Re:Minister No More by shin_lao on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:23AM (#9837139)
He called the creditors "terrorists", I'm pretty sure it didn't help.
Re:Minister No More by socceroos on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:53AM (#9837261)
I believe that was a translation error?
Re:Minister No More by strictnein on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:23AM (#9837141)
Maybe I'm being a little too snarky for these parts, but it's amazing how many Greek economics experts are hanging out on HN tonight.
Re:Minister No More by meric on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:39AM (#9837203)
[terrorism]'s original meaning, given in the Oxford English Dictionary as "government by intimidation".[1]

On Thursday, Schulz told German daily Handelsblatt that the elected Syriza government should be replaced by “technocrat” government until stability is restored.

“We should appoint governments of technocrats,” Martin Schulz told Handelsblatt. [2]

[1] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2001/may/07/terrorism

[2] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/11718296/EU-war...

Re:Minister No More by prawn on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:43AM (#9837454)
I think it's brilliant that so many people here take an interest in news beyond the mundane, read what they can and trade opinions in a predominantly reasonable fashion. As someone really late to the party, I appreciate being able to gain snippets of info from my peers plus a few distilled links for when I have time to delve further.