News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Minister No More by mikeyouse on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:04AM (#9837070)
I saw this comparison earlier and was struck by the depth of the Greek recession:

http://i.imgur.com/mHgxQeQ.png

They're in worse shape than the US was at the same time into the Great Depression. Six years after the GFC, and Greece's GDP is still 25% lower than it was pre-crisis.

This is really unprecedented stuff. Hard to blame them for taking extreme positions to end the suffering.

Re:Minister No More by jarcane on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:23AM (#9837373)
And the funny thing is? It wasn't austerity that got the US out of that depression. It was FDR's New Deal, probably still the most left-wing plan ever enacted by a US government.

Rather than 'tightening belts,' FDR responded with Social Security, the TVA, banking reform, relief funds, the housing administration, new tax policies, the list goes on.

Amusingly, even then, those on the right charged him with attacking business and even communism, but unlike the left-wing policies of the last couple of decades, he actually stuck to his guns and rode the goodwill of the people into the first and only third term in the history of the presidency.

About the only case I know of for austerity ever actually leading to anything half-good is Finland, the only country in WWII ever to pay off the full extent of its war debt. But while the eventual result was to turn the country into a proper industrial power, the intervening decades are still remembered as one of significant poverty, of literally making bread flour from tree bark because wheat was too expensive. One even wonders if this was the start of Finland's lingering reputation for depression and alcoholism, from which it is only now starting to recover.

The ugly truth about austerity politics is that it is very much about making a handful of very rich people even richer, and little else. Look at Britain, where the party of some of the richest people in the country are blabbering about tightening belts. You think David Cameron's cutting back at home?

Or hell, look at Germany. The biggest bully for austerity politics in the whole EU is also literally it's richest country. And you can damn sure bet they aren't playing the same game at home.

And oh look, just as last time Europe tried to squeeze a country into bankruptcy for its debts, there's suddenly all these new fascist parties gaining popular support, and an iron-fisted tyrant consolidating power in Russia. It's almost like we've all forgotten the 30s ever happened already ...

Re:Minister No More by claudius on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:47AM (#9837473)
> Or hell, look at Germany. The biggest bully for austerity politics in the whole EU is also literally it's richest country. And you can damn sure bet they aren't playing the same game at home.

Inform yourself which reforms where enacted in Germany in 2004/2005 which lead to a nearly uninterrupted decade of economic growth and a very practically balanced-out federal budget. Maybe cutting spending and increases taxes actually leads to a sensible economic state and a more-or-less working public sector. Unless, of course, austerity always fails!

Re:Minister No More by alextgordon on Monday July 06, 2015 @06:33AM (#9838057)
Finding efficiencies and austerity are not the same thing. Germany has free university tuition, Greece has a failing healthcare system that keeps running out of medicine.

Germany has not implemented austerity, yet it feels the need to lecture other countries on the need to do so.

Greece is part of the single market, that means that people can leave. All the smart, qualified people left Greece a long time ago.

Re:Minister No More by claudius on Monday July 06, 2015 @07:03AM (#9838166)
> Finding efficiencies and austerity are not the same thing. Germany has free university tuition, Greece has a failing healthcare system that keeps running out of medicine.

Germany failed to collect 2.3% of its tax receipts, Greece failed to collect 89.5% [1]. If Greek people want to continue not paying taxes, they’ll have to make cuts elsewhere, yes.

> Germany has not implemented austerity, yet it feels the need to lecture other countries on the need to do so.

Greece has not contributed financially to the bailout programmes, yet it feels the need to lecture other countries on the need to do so.

> Greece is part of the single market, that means that people can leave. All the smart, qualified people left Greece a long time ago.

So? I don’t mind Greeks moving to Germany for jobs, they’re welcome here just as any other person from the EU. What exactly are you trying to say?

[1] https://img.washingtonpost.com/wp-apps/imrs.php?src=https://... fromhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2015/07/03/w...

Re:Minister No More by jarcane on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:14PM (#9840169)
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-07-06/piketty-germany-has...

I should think after WWI, Germans of all people would see the danger in driving a European country to ruin with onerous debts, but maybe everyone there just forgot about that after the little dictator just decided he didn't want to pay them anymore?

Re:Minister No More by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:34AM (#9837415)
> And you can damn sure bet they aren't playing the same game at home.

Harz IV. Kurzarbeit. Eurojobs. Stable currency for decades/no devaluations.

Lo and behold, it actually worked for them (although it was quite unpleasant for many Germans).

Re:Minister No More by kmonsen on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:46AM (#9837469)
Weak currency even with strong export due to sharing it with Portugal, Greece, Spain etc. This is what worked for Germany. If the Euro breaks up Germany is the one in trouble.
Re:Minister No More by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:57AM (#9837508)
West Germany did fine on the DM.

The first decade or so after reunification was in all respects unusual so I'd rather not try to draw any conclusions from that. They /did/ have trouble around 2000 or so and Schröder was brave/dumb enough to make drastic reforms in order to improve things.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hartz_concept

(And it turns out that I don't know how to spell Hartz. Rather embarrasing.)

The way I as an outsider understand the economic history of Germany, Hartz IV was the one that really mattered.

Whether or not you agree that Hartz IV helped or that it was necessary, I think you can at least agree that it hurt :/ -- in which case one can't complain that Germany wants drastic measures to be undertaken in Greece without being willing to taste the same medicine itself.

Re:Minister No More by Joeri on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:27AM (#9837153)
I find it striking that there was a recovery in 2010, after which the austerity measures were implemented, which were then followed by a downward slide. I have never understood why any sane economist is in favor of austerity measures while it has been shown that every time they plunge the economy into recession making it harder to pay back debts.
Re:Minister No More by crdoconnor on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:40AM (#9837207)
>I have never understood why any sane economist is in favor of austerity measures

That can be attributed to the influence of wealthy business lobbies. Austerity puts downward pressure on wages, which in turn creates upward pressure on profits.

Economists, like everybody else, respond to incentives.

Re:Minister No More by chetanahuja on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:26AM (#9837383)
That makes no sense. All businesses suffer along with the rest of the economy when flow of money dries up. It's not just lower wages, it's lower sales, profits and for those business kept afloat by financial leverage, such crisis often mean complete death.
Re:Minister No More by crdoconnor on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:39AM (#9837446)
>All businesses suffer along with the rest of the economy

A) The relative position of the owners still improves.

http://isites.harvard.edu/fs/docs/icb.topic620591.files/Indi...

B) Businesses in the rest of the Eurozone can reap the benefits of suppressed Greek wages (in the form of a more cut-throat labor market), without facing the consequences of lower demand themselves.

Re:Minister No More by noreasonw on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:12AM (#9837325)
Perhaps they should get less tanks and use the better their money? Greek has more tanks than Germany and France together. A huge army for a little country.
Re:Minister No More by Macacity on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:39AM (#9837653)
The Nato is not a friend of this thought and warned Greece not to save on defense. http://panteres.com/2015/06/30/nato-jens-stoltenberg-warns-g...
Re:Minister No More by oblio on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:20AM (#9837363)
France and Germany don't have hostile neighbors. I bet Greece also spends a lot on its Navy and Air Force.
Re:Minister No More by Mikeb85 on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:19AM (#9837356)
It's prudent considering their neighbors...
Re:Minister No More by Natsu on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:13AM (#9837557)
What would you have done? They have tons of problems. I mean, who will give them money now given that they're telling their creditors, "And I shall wear the creditors’ loathing with pride"? There was that kickstarter to donate to them but...
Re:Minister No More by nickonline on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:12AM (#9837108)
But looking at your graph Greece jumps back up ~2 years into their current depression before diving parrallel to the USA 80 years prior.

So I'd say looking at that graph they're in exactly the same place the USA was ~4 years after the 'start', depending on where you measure it from.

Re:Minister No More by mikeyouse on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:20AM (#9837133)
A common way to measure the length of a recession is to start counting as soon as the GDP drops for two quarters in a row, and stop counting when the GDP recovers past that 'zero point'. A slight slowing in the rate of decline after years of recession isn't quite a recovery so you wouldn't start the clock from there. You can see a similar local max. in the Great Depression line when the government stopped the stimulus programs and passed a law to balance the budget.
Re:Minister No More by corin_ on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:24AM (#9837378)
It's still a recession until it hits 'zero' again, even if there is solid growth?

E.g. if a country started with a GDP of 100, dropped to 10 in a single year, and then over the next 90 years grew its GDP by 1 each year, it would be 90 years of economic growth but still a recession?

Re:Minister No More by mikeyouse on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:35AM (#9839833)
Technically the recession is only when GDP drops for at least two consecutive quarters, what follows is the recovery phase. It's just common phrasing to call the whole period the recession or depression. In your example, there'd be a 1-year recession with a 90-year recovery.
Re:Minister No More by digi_owl on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:02PM (#9840956)
Could be what was brought up on BBC during a interview with Steve Keen, where Keen talks about Greek prices falling faster than GDP for a period of time.

http://www.debtdeflation.com/blogs/2015/07/06/discussing-syr...

Somewhere round the 1:00 mark.

Re:Minister No More by cperciva on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:14AM (#9837113)
Is the starting point of that graph accurate, or was it a "liar loan" GDP?
Re:Minister No More by claudius on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:07AM (#9837305)
The Greek economy was and is primarily based on an oversized public sector, which was only made possible by a) devaluing the Drachma at every point possible and b), after joining the Euro, falsifying statistics to facilitate being lent more.

As such, it seems more reasonable to compare the current GDP with a reference in, say, 1990. Back then, Greece’s GDP was at 98,251,934,651, whereas for 2014 you have 299,615,364,238 (USD), or roughly a 305%-growth. In comparison, France stood at 1,275,300,566,196 and is now at 2,829,192,039,171, i.e. 221%.

In other words, Greece borrowed too much and now people are upset that they can’t continue their just-achieved standard of living because people don’t give them any more money. But even now, their cumulative GDP growth over 24 years is still larger than that of France, one of the primary lenders in the ongoing debacle (comparison to Germany is difficult, due to reunification complicating everything).

(Source for all numbers: http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.CD )

Re:Minister No More by x0x0 on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:28AM (#9837388)
Troika forecasts and numbers show a very similar graph, so probably pretty real. See, eg, the first chart here

http://www.bruegel.org/nc/blog/detail/article/1647-is-greece...

Re:Minister No More by sampo on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:03AM (#9837289)
> This is really unprecedented stuff.

Several Eastern European countries took a similar dive after they got rid of their socialist governments in the 90s. Then their economy started to grow a bit later.

Re:Minister No More by oblio on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:22AM (#9837368)
Re:Minister No More by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:28AM (#9837391)
Most of those countries reformed like there was no tomorrow. Greece reformed like there would always be a mañana.
Re:Minister No More by riffraff on Monday July 06, 2015 @06:24AM (#9838036)
AFAIR, most of those countries defaulted on their socialist era debt too. (Except hungary, which was already known as the "happiest barrack in the communist camp")
Re:Minister No More by sampo on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:31AM (#9837400)
Ok, I take my words back. Only Bulgaria is comparable to Greece.
Re:Minister No More by mikeyouse on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:23PM (#9840229)
This is a good example, Bulgaria grew like crazy -- after 35% of their debt was completely forgiven and the remainder was heavily subsidized via very low interest rates.

http://i.imgur.com/7zPvyKo.png

For Greece, an equivalent amount of debt relief (a reduction of 46% on an NPV basis) would equate to something like $150 billion in forgiven loans.

I think they'd be much more competitive, don't you?

Re:Minister No More by sampo on Monday July 06, 2015 @08:19PM (#9842929)
> For Greece, an equivalent amount of debt relief (a reduction of 46% on an NPV basis) would equate to something like $150 billion in forgiven loans.

If I understand Wikipedia correctly, Greece was indeed given a 106.5 + 48.2 = 154.7 billion haircut in 2012:

"The haircut alone lowered the government debt pile by €106.5bn (equal to a debt-to-GDP ratio decline of 55.0 percentage points), but as Greek banks at the same time were holding almost one third of the restructured debt, this also created the need for the Troika and Greek government to pay for a €48.2bn bank recapitalisation in 2012"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_government-debt_crisis

Re:Minister No More by mikeyouse on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @01:05AM (#9843735)
Kind of, but not exactly.. They exchanged many of the short term loans with longer term ones, with conditions that demanded heavy austerity. The private banks took a big haircut after years of negotiation but the private loans were a small total portion compared to the public ones. The IMF readily admits how flawed their troika bailout was;

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/06/05/i...