News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by dsr_ on Friday June 12, 2015 @10:30AM (#9706073)
If your first thought is that $2M to replace an Amiga is ridiculous, stop.

They wouldn't be replacing the Amiga for $2M. They'll be replacing a 19 site remote HVAC control system, certainly including new radio systems, local controllers, and the central controller. They will want something with a warranty and a service contract for the next 20-30 years.

Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by jokr004 on Friday June 12, 2015 @01:25PM (#9707296)
The radio system made sense back in the 80s before cheap, reliable internet access was widely available, but I feel like IP would be a much more practical communications solution today.. especially considering the fact that the 2-way radios used by the maintenance staff interferes with the existing system.

Though your point is still totally valid, I'm just thinking out loud.

Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by TeMPOraL on Friday June 12, 2015 @03:44PM (#9708117)
> before cheap, reliable internet access was widely available

Cheap and reliable Internet access is still not widely available. You don't want to have your HVAC stop working because ISP botched something up. Frankly, IMO there should be zero reason for any of the HVAC control loop to extend beyond the building. Sending data from your controller to your device next to it through half the world and back is insane, and yet it is what's happening with IoT right now.

Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by nickpsecurity on Friday June 12, 2015 @08:05PM (#9709300)
You couldn't be more right. To this day, I encourage the use of radio, dial-up, closed-circuits, cheap leased lines... anything but the Internet... for mission-critical transmission. Just way too many issues from reliability to security. Using simple lines and protocols with little to no routing let's one use equally simple hardware. If resources are left over, one can use them for boosting manageability, reliability, or security.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by acomjean on Friday June 12, 2015 @04:10PM (#9708232)
This is so true. As someone who worked at a company that did power monitioring and wanted to (and did) expand into thermostat control.

1) Reliable internet isn't everywhere, it cuts out a bit.

2) A lot of internet enabled thermostats are just not that great at reconnecting when the eventually loose their connection.

Though to be fair the thermostats generally will just continue on the normal schedule if they loose connectivity.

The company ended up using on a different wireless protocol to talk from the base station to the thermostats. (z-wave or zigbee fwiw).

Ironically we had a 80s error programmable thermostat in the office, which worked pretty well.

Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by jokr004 on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:00PM (#9708513)
Well as far as the cheap part goes, my thinking was that these buildings definitely already have internet service in the first place, may as well just utilize that.. I supposed you make a point about reliability, but then again they're putting up with the whole 2-way radio interference, seems like the bar is already set low :P

I don't know, again I'm just thinking out loud, I'm no HVAC professional. We do use the internet to manage off site devices in my company and we tend to have more issues with power outages than we do with our ISP uptime, it's been a good solution for us.

Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by tsomctl on Saturday June 13, 2015 @12:44AM (#9709903)
If it is a really critical system, the proper way would be a T1 circuit between the two buildings. The circuit would only go from one building to the local telephone office, back to the other office. They tend to be pretty reliable, but expensive. You could then run a lan over this.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by ChickeNES on Friday June 12, 2015 @02:16PM (#9707620)
Funnily enough it likely is already using TCP/IP: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AMPRNet
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by lbhnact on Friday June 12, 2015 @11:08PM (#9709731)
Man I really hope someone out there has streamed Spotify or NPR over this. Recurs-inception.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by jokr004 on Friday June 12, 2015 @02:20PM (#9707650)
Whoa that is funny! Ha I had no idea
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by monochromatic on Friday June 12, 2015 @11:23AM (#9706426)
What's wrong with just using thermostats in each building? This seems way over-engineered.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by da_chicken on Friday June 12, 2015 @11:52AM (#9706635)
The same reason you don't put a space heater and window AC in every room. Because it's inefficient, ineffective, and archaic.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by protomyth on Friday June 12, 2015 @12:01PM (#9706705)
Yep, you want the whole thing to act like a system not a bunch of parts. Energy savings and a comfortable environment really depends on this. A poorly setup system can be a nightmare for the maintenance staff.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by seanp2k2 on Friday June 12, 2015 @02:30PM (#9707701)
And so this is why, in our office with a thermostat and ducts in every room, it's typically freezing in 1/3rd of the conference rooms, another 1/3 are way too hot, and there is zero meaningful control using the thermostats in the rooms over this?

Not saying it's not a good idea, just saying that in reality I've seen these systems work very poorly together in most office environments I've been in.

Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by protomyth on Friday June 12, 2015 @03:49PM (#9708140)
Well, if you have thermostats in every room, I would imagine that it would be impossible to get a consistent temperature. All the commands and one system to sort it out and move air cannot be good.

If I ever teach a CompSci again, I would think about making a climate controller a problem set. My first choice is a storage building controller, but this would be interesting.

Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by biftek on Friday June 12, 2015 @04:40PM (#9708392)
That sounds like bad air balancing, but that the control system is "working".
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by ohitsdom on Friday June 12, 2015 @12:19PM (#9706842)
A big reason is cost-savings. This prevents each building occupant from setting the AC too cold, or forgetting to turn it up/off when they leave at the end of the day and for breaks.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by mrits on Friday June 12, 2015 @11:41AM (#9706555)
The best way to set the temperature at a comfortable level is guessing every 30 years what you want each building to feel like.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by matthewowen on Friday June 12, 2015 @02:10PM (#9707584)
Do you expect that over the next 30 years our idea of what a comfortable temperature is will change?
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by mrits on Friday June 12, 2015 @04:36PM (#9708354)
Temperatures are set based off things like use of the room and season. Both of these change and usually only one is somewhat predictable.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by maxerickson on Saturday June 13, 2015 @09:16AM (#9710906)
Are we sure that the current system doesn't have that?

Even if they do install local controls, a central monitoring system makes some sense for buildings that go unoccupied for days at a time.

Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by dmritard96 on Friday June 12, 2015 @12:41PM (#9707000)
I dunno. You could find plenty of people that would make it their full time job to just turn on and off systems for 2M over 20 or maybe 30 years. :)
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by spc476 on Friday June 12, 2015 @08:34PM (#9709370)
At 20 years, $2m means you can hire 3 people for $33k a year to do the job. At 30 years, you can only hire 2 people for $33k/year. That figure does not include benefits. That may or may not be viable for 19 schools (depending on how far apart they are, etc).
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by ryanwatkins on Friday June 12, 2015 @09:12PM (#9709466)
The $2 million doesn't have to sit around for 20 years in a non-interest bearing checking account. Put $1.5million in a 5 year CD and get another ~$50k/year. Give them other maintenance work to do while they are at the school turning on and off the heat, and it becomes more viable.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by bliti on Friday June 12, 2015 @02:07PM (#9707566)
It would mostly be all the contractor and subcontractor costs. I'd say they need at least a couple of electricians, which are usually unionized and charge plenty (I have no issues with unions, it just costs more). The plumbers, because you can't hack into a wall without hitting a water pipe. Then the HVAC people, who have different sub specialties. Then the people who do the cement/wood/boarding. Not including the inspectors...
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by whatusername on Saturday June 13, 2015 @12:13AM (#9709837)
Here was an $88M project to replace a system of similar vintage: http://www.smh.com.au/technology/technology-news/30yearold-r...
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by bechampion on Friday June 12, 2015 @10:35AM (#9706117)
thanks for the clarification , the article was misleading to the max
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by organsnyder on Friday June 12, 2015 @10:51AM (#9706220)
Welcome to West Michigan local media (though I'm sure this phenomenon isn't unique to this area). While it can probably be explained by bad writing, they've also learned that anything that provokes the ire of tea-partiers is golden for driving pageviews.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by Grazester on Friday June 12, 2015 @12:06PM (#9706749)
I don't see how anyone could have thought that it cost $2 million to replace this computer. It became very clean that it was for a revamp of the entire system.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by lurkinggrue on Friday June 12, 2015 @04:25PM (#9708293)
Yeah as well as coding a new system from scratch. If they wanted to replace the Amiga they can go on Ebay and spend $400.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by JustSomeNobody on Friday June 12, 2015 @10:56AM (#9706256)
And it probably would not function as well as this (even with this setup's many issues).
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by organsnyder on Friday June 12, 2015 @11:01AM (#9706290)
I see no reason for it not to. Keep in mind that this system has also required maintenance over the years (just like any system). The cost savings from improved efficiency (more granular control, reacting to weather & building occupancy, etc.) will also be a huge improvement.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by JustSomeNobody on Friday June 12, 2015 @12:25PM (#9706878)
I tend to be very cynical these days. Far too many things are not designed for longevity. But, I can certainly see where a newer HVAC system would be more efficient.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by protomyth on Friday June 12, 2015 @12:02PM (#9706720)
Modern climate control systems are quite nice if setup correctly and do a very good job. Probably save them quite a bit of money over the 30+ year lifespan of the new system.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by DannoHung on Friday June 12, 2015 @02:03PM (#9707547)
I still don't completely see why it'll be $2M, unless that's the total cost including the service contract for the system's lifetime. I mean, the hardware and installation labor can't be that expensive, right?
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by maxerickson on Saturday June 13, 2015 @09:13AM (#9710899)
The GRPS website says that they operate 67 buildings, which leads me to speculate that the $2 million includes upgrading other parts of the HVAC system at each school.

Not all that much pops out of a few searches, but there are discussions of projects that make me think that $100,000 per building isn't a lot to spend on such a thing.

Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by DannoHung on Sunday June 14, 2015 @06:58PM (#9716626)
Oh, weird, the article said 18 buildings. 67 seems more like 2 million would be appropriate.
Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by maxerickson on Sunday June 14, 2015 @07:37PM (#9716720)
The upgrade would apply to only the 18 buildings.

The point I was trying to make was that they likely already have other systems in the remaining buildings.

Re:1980s computer controls Grand Rapids Public School heat a... by Lorento on Saturday June 13, 2015 @07:43AM (#9710724)
Yes, it doesn't quite add up. For that money, you could hire the guy to turn things on and off by hand for 50 years.